NOVA investigates the story of cannabis from the criminalization that has disproportionately harmed communities of color to the latest medical understanding of the plant. What risks does cannabis pose to the developing brain? How much do we know about its potential medical benefits? As cannabis becomes socially accepted, scientists are exploring its long-term health consequences. (Premiered September 29, 2021)
Check out a previously recorded panel discussion and audience Q&A featuring experts and producers from "The Cannabis Question" here.
More Ways to Watch
The Cannabis Question
PBS Airdate: September 29, 2021
NARRATOR: Cannabis: a multi-billion-dollar industry is moving from the illicit market into our daily lives, creating a stark divide.
KASSANDRA FREDRIQUE (Drug Policy Alliance): In a country where people are talking about its medical use, someone gets arrested for cannabis every 58 seconds.
NARRATOR: A plant, demonized to arrest millions, now marketed as a medicine.
EVELYN NUSSENBAUM: My son had a devastating form of epilepsy, and a cannabis compound gave him a life.
NARRATOR: How does the vast array of chemicals in cannabis engage a mysterious system in our bodies?
YASMIN HURD (Addiction Institute of Mount Sinai): The cannabinoid receptor, is the most abundant receptor in the brain.
MATTHEW HILL (University of Calgary): How a single system can influence so many biological processes is surprising.
NARRATOR: Will regular, even daily use cure us or hurt us?
PAUL DEBASSIO (Cannabis User): If someone were to tell me that I was dependent on marijuana, I would have said, “No way, absolutely not.”
NARRATOR: Smoked, dabbed, vaped and eaten, today’s cannabis is hyper-potent and far from understood.
ZIVA COOPER (UCLA Cannabis Research Initiative): These products are coming online much faster than we can actually research them.
NARRATOR: As federal law blocks science, an unintended public health experiment is underway.
CHINAZO CUNNINGHAM (Albert Einstein College of Medicine): Really, the questions are, “for what conditions is it beneficial?” and “for what conditions is it harmful?” It’s not black and white, and it’s complicated.
NARRATOR: What’s the right dose? Who should use cannabis? Who shouldn’t?
STACI GRUBER (McLean Hospital): It’s a highly contentious subject, but it’s not about your personal thoughts or feelings. What does the data tell us? What does the science tell us? Truth through science. We should know the answers.
NARRATOR: The Cannabis Question, right now, on NOVA.
More than 80 years after America ended one type of prohibition, it’s ending another. The majority of people now live in a state where cannabis is legal. As a multi-billion-dollar industry rises, our country is at a crossroads.
MATTHEW HILL: Cannabis is genuinely one of the most fascinating discussion topics I’ve ever seen, because of how emotionally polarizing it is amongst people. And it’s very strange, because the entire field of cannabis science is very poorly developed. There’s not been a lot of research, and there’s a lot of things that we don’t understand. And yet, what we have in society is groups of people that very fervently believe it is this panacea that can cure any disease that exists or it’s the “devil’s grass,” and it’s going to cause the downfall of society, not recognizing that the reality of cannabis is somewhere in the middle.
NARRATOR: Americans everywhere are turning to cannabis, seeking relief from a wide range of ailments, including veterans, like Sean Worsley, who uses cannabis to treat his post-traumatic stress disorder, caused by combat in Iraq.
SEAN WORSLEY (Medical cannabis user): Our sole purpose was to clear the routes for supply convoys that came through, looking for roadside bombs that were on the route. I was on a mission, and we rode over a hole that was in the center of the road, and unfortunately it was an I.E.D. that went off, knocking me unconscious. And when I woke up, a medic was in my face, asking me, was I okay, could I hear him.
NARRATOR: After his tour, Sean struggled with a traumatic brain injury and disturbing symptoms caused by P.T.S.D.
SEAN WORSLEY: For me it’s paranoia, insomnia, seeing things that aren’t necessarily there—shadow people, as they call them—night terrors, dreams. But these nightmares were very realistic. If I was shot in the dream, I would wake up grabbing my chest, because I felt the pain.
NARRATOR: Sean’s medications for P.T.S.D. had troubling side effects, so he got a medical cannabis card.
RYAN VANDREY (Johns Hopkins University): Cannabis, at a low dose, can help reduce anxiety, relax someone. And individuals who have P.T.S.D. that newly initiate cannabis use report it being life-changing. So, “I can sleep for the first time in two years,” and “I can go to the grocery store without being so intense and on edge.” That’s why individuals with P.T.S.D. heavily gravitate towards cannabis use.
NARRATOR: For thousands of years, humans have cultivated cannabis for its fiber, seeds, and medicinal properties. Ancient Hindu texts claim it was brought by the god Shiva for the pleasure of humanity. The plant contains over 400 chemicals, including cannabinoids, which are most abundant in the resin glands of budding female plants.
In the 1960s, Israeli scientist Raphael Mechoulam isolated T.H.C., the psychoactive cannabinoid that makes users feel high. The discovery launched a new chapter in neuroscience.
DANIELE PIOMELLI (University of California, Irvine): Cannabis opened a window into the functioning of our body, completely unexpected window, because what was discovered was that T.H.C. binds to receptors in the brain and outside the brain, and when it does so, when it binds to these receptors, the cells now behave differently.
NARRATOR: Cannabinoid receptors, named after cannabis, are found on nearly every organ in the body. They bind with our own cannabis-like molecules, called endocannabinoids, which regulate functions like sleep, cognition, memory and mood. Unlike other brain chemicals, they travel backwards across the synapse, where they control the release of most neurotransmitters.
STACI GRUBER: One of the most amazing things that happened was the discovery of the endocannabinoid system. Every mammal has one. And this is a system of chemicals and receptors throughout the brain and body. And really, the primary goal of the endocannabinoid system is homeostasis, keeping things in balance.
NARRATOR: At Mount Sinai Hospital, neuroscientist Yasmin Hurd remembers the first time she looked for cannabinoid receptors in the human brain, seen here in vivid red, orange and yellow colors.
YASMIN HURD: The cannabinoid receptor is the most abundant receptor in the brain. When we looked at where these receptors were expressed, they’re expressed in brain regions relevant for motor coordination, cognition, memory, emotional regulation, reward. All of these brain areas are key to so many normal behaviors, obviously, but also psychiatric disorders as well.
NARRATOR: A key role of the endocannabinoid system is to manage stress. In fact, the first endocannabinoid found in our body was given a Sanskrit name, “anandamide,” meaning “bliss.”
MATTHEW HILL: In response to stress, our body mobilizes an endocannabinoid signal. And so, if something aversive happens to us, and we suddenly see a threat in front of us, our body kind of goes into a high alert mode and we shoot up. Once we’ve been removed from that threat though, our body needs to turn that stress response back off. And what we have learned is that this burst of endocannabinoids that occurs in response to stress is really critical for that recovery phase.
NARRATOR: Scientists suspect this signal goes awry in people with P.T.S.D., and that’s why T.H.C., which mimics our own endocannabinoids, might help.
RYAN VANDREY: And so, when you look at individuals that have P.T.S.D. and use cannabis, in short term trials, you see very beneficial outcomes. But if all they do is use cannabis, and they don’t engage in other behavior therapies to help work through their trauma, they’re not treating the root cause of the disorder. And it’s important to recognize that T.H.C. at higher doses increases anxiety.
CHINAZO CUNNINGHAM (Albert Einstein College of Medicine): Cannabis is not a miracle; nothing is a miracle. And so, really, the questions are, “for what conditions is it beneficial?” and “for what conditions is it harmful?” And, “for whom is it beneficial?” and “for whom is it harmful?” So, it’s shades of gray. It’s not black and white, and it’s complicated.
NARRATOR: In 1996, cannabis was legalized in California for medical use. But federally, it remains a Schedule I drug, like heroin, making research difficult and leaving patients like Elizabeth Pinkham on their own.
To cope with her cancer treatments, Elizabeth has turned to cannabis.
ELIZABETH PINKHAM (Medical cannabis user): When you go through chemotherapy, there are side effects that can be…like nauseousness. You may have loss of appetite. You may have difficulty sleeping. So, I was looking for something that wasn’t another big, heavy duty pharmaceutical.
NARRATOR: On display, one can find cannabis-infused teas, sodas, candies, bath salts, psychoactive body washes, and flower with T.H.C., that can ease nausea when smoked.
ELIZABETH PINKHAM: The effects are pretty immediate. I’ve definitely gotten my appetite back a little bit more. It also helps with neuropathy, which is, like, the numbness in your fingers and your toes.
CANNABIS RETAIL SALES REPRESENTATIVE: This is super medicinal. You see how, like, dark and dense that is? That’s indicating more of the Indica family: good for the body, good for pain.
STEVE D’ANGELO (Founder of Harborside, Inc.): My staff needs to do the best that they can to try and guide people to the products that are going to serve them the best. But my staff, they’re not trained doctors, and really we should have is cannabis medicine being taught at every single medical school across the United States. And that’s not happening now, because of federal law.
YASMIN HURD: It’s really a voter-approved, quote/unquote, medicine. People say, “Oh, there’s medical cannabis that’s approved.” It has not been. It has not gone through F.D.A. rigorous research process, and that’s what’s critical for medicine.
ELIZABETH PINKHAM: I think it would be great if there was a bit more science behind this. But I think, in the meantime, you have to do what works for you, and you have to figure this out as you go.
NARRATOR: But it’s challenging. Scientists aren’t sure whether cannabis sativa, indica and ruderalis are distinct species, but most cultivars grown today are hybrids. They have distinct chemicals, called “terpenes,” which create flavors and smells. And, in addition to T.H.C., the plant contains over 100 other cannabinoids.
One, called C.B.D., is flooding the market.
ZIVA COOPER: One in seven adults in the United States are using C.B.D. You see C.B.D. everywhere. You see it in the pet stores, you see it at Bed Bath and Beyond®, at Whole Foods®. And so, there’s a multi-billion-dollar industry that’s built on this plant and all these different hypotheses of what these different chemicals can do to help us. But these products are coming online much faster than we can actually research them.
NARRATOR: Despite C.B.D.’s availability today, it took a group of determined parents to bring it to market. One quest began in Palo Alto, California, when a Stanford neuroscientist, Catherine Jacobson set out to treat her son Ben’s epilepsy.
CATHERINE JACOBSON (Tilray): Watching your child have a seizure is really, really scary. It’s awful, right? It’s awful because you know that brain damage is happening. The kids get scared, they get confused. And with uncontrolled epilepsy, we all live with this fear that they’re going to die.
NARRATOR: About a third of epilepsy patients don’t respond to medications. Catherine knew the longer Ben’s seizures continued, the less likely they’d be controlled. And she was not alone.
In Berkeley, California, her friends, Fred Vogelstein and Evelyn Nussenbaum, also felt powerless to control their son Sam’s epilepsy.
FRED VOGELSTEIN (Sam’s father): I mean, the thing about seizures, that most people don’t realize, is that they’re dozens of different kinds. So, the kind of seizures that most people know about are the grand mal seizures, where you just lie on the ground and, like, start flopping. The other seizure that a lot of people know about are staring spells. Sam had a version of those seizures, because he would go unconscious for like 15 seconds.
EVELYN NUSSENBAUM (Sam’s mother): When anyone has a seizure, you could compare it to an electrical storm or an overtaxed electrical grid. We all have electricity in our brains. And when someone has a seizure, the electricity becomes irregular.
FRED VOGELSTEIN: Every single drug we tried didn’t control the seizures, and some of them had pretty nasty side effects.
EVELYN NUSSENBAUM: One time, he had hallucinations and thought he had holes in his skin and there were bugs crawling out of them. I thought we were going to have to take him to the psych ward.
FRED VOGELSTEIN: And then there were all the medicines that made him a zombie.
NARRATOR: Then, they stumbled across research suggesting cannabis might quell seizures.
CATHERINE JACOBSON: I knew nothing about cannabis, but I did some research, and I found out that, obviously, there are many different chemicals in cannabis. The two most prominent are C.B.D. and T.H.C. We know that T.H.C. makes people high. C.B.D. doesn’t do that. And so, my preference was, of course, to try C.B.D. first.
NARRATOR: C.B.D. doesn’t bind to cannabinoid receptors directly, but its presence seems to reduce the impact of T.H.C. It also increases levels of anandamide, our bliss molecule, and interacts with receptors like serotonin, which affect our mood. Yet in 2011, it was hard to find extracts high in C.B.D.
CATHERINE JACOBSON: And so we would get these vials, and sometimes they would work a little bit and then the next vial wouldn’t work. So, after probably six to eight months of doing this and seeing no benefit to Ben, I just said, “Look, I’m going to make my own.”
EVELYN NUSSENBAUM: When Sam first took Catherine Jacobson’s C.B.D. tincture, it was clear as day, his seizures were going down immediately. Unfortunately, Catherine only had enough for five days. And so, we had this incredible five-day stretch. And then we ran out.
NARRATOR: C.B.D. also helped Catherine’s son Ben, but her next batch of tinctures were too weak to use.
FRED VOGELSTEIN: Drug companies get a lot of abuse for their marketing tactics, but the one thing that they do really, really well, is they make every pill exactly the same.
EVELYN NUSSENBAUM: It’s sanitized, it’s quality controlled. And I wanted that for my son.
NARRATOR: Then, they heard about an English company called GW Pharmaceuticals, with greenhouses full of cannabis and labs that could make chemically pure drugs.
Since C.B.D. was illegal in the U.S., Sam’s family flew to London for treatment, while Ben’s family waited. After four days of taking GW’s C.B.D., Sam’s seizures dropped from 68 to 6 per day. On the eighth day of treatment, he only had three.
EVELYN NUSSENBAUM: It worked, and it worked fast. But the other thing about him improving was that I saw this child that I hadn’t seen since he was four years old and started having seizures, except now he was 11, and he was clever and funny and wanted to ride a zip line over London.
NARRATOR: Sam is now seizure-free. His story led to clinical trials, and, in 2018, F.D.A. approval of the first C.B.D. drug, called Epidiolex®. In certain types of epilepsy, it can reduce seizures by some 40 percent.
Sam is now in college. But since seizures cause brain damage, for Ben, help came too late.
CATHERINE JACOBSON: I have no idea whether Epidiolex, given at six months, would have changed the course of his disease. I feel like it has reduced the severity of the most severe kinds of seizures he has, so, I feel like it helps. But Epidiolex is not a miracle drug. It’s a tool in the toolbox, just like every other anti-seizure drug. You try it. If it doesn’t work, you stop it. If it works, then, you know, it changes your life.
FRED VOGELSTEIN: One of the things that’s, like, super important about a drug like Epidiolex is that, for the first time, you’ve got a drug that’s derived from cannabis that is completely legitimate for mainstream medicine to study. And we’re only beginning to see where that can lead.
NARRATOR: Scores of clinical trials are now underway, including at U.C. San Diego’s Center for Medicinal Cannabis Research.
Fourteen-year-old Braylon has severe autism. His parents are hoping C.B.D. might help.
DORIS TRAUNER (Pediatric Neurology, University of California, San Diego): Braylon is a very sweet boy who has a great personality. He gets extremely anxious if he doesn’t know what’s going to happen. And if something happens that he didn’t expect, he can be very difficult to manage.
KEVIN PULLEY (Braylon’s father): I want you to get up, please.
BRAYLON (Autism patient): No, thank you.
KEVIN PULLEY: And we wanted to see what can be done to try to curb that behavior. He was hitting, being kind of violent.
LETITIA PULLEY (Braylon’s mother): And I’d never forget, one therapist told me, “You want to get a handle on it, because it affects his learning. If you can’t control the behavior, it’s going to be hard for him to focus in class.”
NARRATOR: Children who have autism have different brainwave patterns than children who don’t.
DORIS TRAUNER: There is something different about the way the brain develops that causes children to have tremendous difficulty with social interactions, with social communication. And it appears that one of the problems may be a type of sensory overload.
NARRATOR: To find out if Epidiolex might treat severe autism, Trauner is running a double-blind clinical trial. Over two eight-week sessions, children will take either C.B.D. or a placebo, and researchers will use a battery of tests to see if the drug helps.
To study C.B.D.’s impact on the brain, in another part of the trial, Alysson Muotri will work with human skin cells. That’s because skin cells can be converted back into master builder cells, and then coaxed to develop as brain cells do, forming networks of neurons.
ALYSSON MUOTRI (University of California, San Diego): These brain cells, they will actually self-arrange and form what we call a brain organoid, and as they mature, over time, they start to become more and more electrically active.
NARRATOR: That activity is captured by electrodes placed beneath the cluster of brain cells. When their neurons fire, they create electrical signaling comparable to a developing brain. Next, the brain cells are treated with different doses of C.B.D. to see if the drug has any impact.
ALYSSON MUOTRI: One of the biggest surprises that we see is that by adding C.B.D. in the culture, we actually silence or quiet the activity of these brain cells, over time. This is not permanent. We can wash it out, C.B.D., from the system, and we see that the brain is able to restore electrical activity.
LETITIA PULLEY: So, what are you going to do in the morning?
BRAYLON PULLEY: Wake up.
LETITIA PULLEY: Wake up.
BRAYLON PULLEY: Wash up.
LETITIA PULLEY: Wash up.
NARRATOR: But will C.B.D. calm excess neuronal activity in the brains of children with autism? The study is still blinded, but Braylon’s parents are certain C.B.D. helped him in phase one of the trial.
KEVIN PULLEY: It was dramatic. It was like night and day. So, I could be wrong, but you know we both saw the difference.
LETITIA PULLEY: Having eight weeks of really no hitting, no perseveration and things like that was wonderful.
KEVIN PULLEY: And then, when we went on the second half of the trial, he was back to his normal self. So, I’m hopeful the first round was the C.B.D.
DORIS TRAUNER: What we are hearing from the parents is pretty remarkable. And we don’t know whether they were on placebo or C.B.D. But it’s really important to get good data that demonstrates whether C.B.D. is effective and whether it’s safe, because we’re talking about long-term treatment.
NARRATOR: Treatment that uses hundreds of milligrams of Epidiolex, not the small amounts of C.B.D. you can buy in a dispensary.
MATTHEW HILL: As little as four percent and maybe as great as 20 percent of the C.B.D. that you consume orally actually gets into your body. And so, it seems like you need to take around about a hundred milligrams of C.B.D. oil orally for there to even really be a signal in your bloodstream that you have C.B.D. onboard.
YASMIN HURD: You know, most of the products being sold are like 10 and 20 milligrams. And some people say that they benefit from that. And even if it’s a placebo effect, I’m actually fine with it. But what I’m worried about is that the C.B.D. that they’re taking has other chemicals.
NARRATOR: Generally, only products in legal states that contain T.H.C., not C.B.D., are regulated. Before they can be sold, they must be tested in licensed labs for potency and contaminates, like pesticides, molds and heavy metals.
Using untested cannabis is dangerous.
But when it comes to assessing risks, a key factor is your age, because the endocannabinoid system, which cannabis targets, changes over our lifespan.
DANIELE PIOMELLI: As we grow from being a fetus into becoming an adolescent, and, eventually, an adult and an elderly person, the endocannabinoid system follows us. And at each of these stages of our life serves a slightly different purpose.
NARRATOR: During adolescence, our natural endocannabinoids reach their highest levels, as the brain rapidly changes. It’s also a time when many first try cannabis.
DANIELE PIOMELLI: When one consumes T.H.C., you’re basically indiscriminately activating all your cannabinoid receptors in your entire body and the entire brain.
YASMIN HURD: So, T.H.C., it’s like a hammer on all of these receptors. Our natural endogenous cannabinoids are never these hammers.
NARRATOR: To understand the impact of cannabis, clinical psychologist Joanna Jacobus has scanned over 1,000 teenage brains, to search for differences between those who use the drug and those who don’t.
Today, she is evaluating Angel, who has smoked cannabis at least once a week for the past year and is curious to learn about its impact.
ANGEL FLORES (Teen recreational cannabis user): All I needed to really hear is like, “Hey, you want an MRI of your brain?” Yes! Like that, to me, that’s, like, really cool. I know it’s nerdy, but, the substance you’re doing, you don’t get to see what it does to your brain.
NARRATOR: Using functional magnetic resonance imaging, Jacobus can study brain structures that are critical for healthy development in young adults.
JOANNA JACOBUS (University of California, San Diego): The brain is rapidly changing from infancy through childhood, adolescence, into young adulthood. Two types of tissue are rapidly changing that support cognitive development. So, gray matter contains the cell bodies and makes up the cerebral cortex, so, the outermost lining of the brain. And white matter allows gray matter regions to communicate quickly and efficiently.
NARRATOR: During the teenage years, white matter increases and grey matter diminishes, as weaker neural connections are eliminated and new ones formed to make the brain more efficient. Jacobus has found that teen cannabis users have a thicker cerebral cortex, suggesting that this pruning of synapses has been disrupted.
And it’s not just physical brain changes.
Thousands of cognitive tests reveal that teens who use cannabis regularly struggle more on learning and memory tasks than those who don’t.
ANGEL FLORES: It made me realize that memory is probably the biggest thing that impacts me with cannabis. But definitely, if I stop for a little bit, I have a feeling that it would be easy to remember those things.
NARRATOR: Research shows after a period of abstinence, cognitive performance can bounce back. And the brain changes? Other studies link them to alcohol or genetic and environmental influences.
ARPANA AGRAWAL (Washington University in St. Louis): It is possible that cannabis itself is not the culprit. That these differences that we see in the brain are preexisting and that they come before a child ever picks up their first joint.
NARRATOR: To unravel the role of drugs, genes and the environment, over 11,000 children are being tracked through their teenage years in the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development Study. N.I.H. researchers will evaluate the children’s physical and mental health, academic achievement and drug use, with tests of salvia and hair.
So far, few of the children have tried cannabis, but there is data from surveys about their parents’ use.
RYAN BOGDAN (Washington University in St. Louis): One of the things we are most interested in was prenatal exposures. And we saw that there were a fair number of mothers in this study, just like what we’re seeing in the general population, that used cannabis during their pregnancy.
CYNTHIA ROGERS (Washington University in St. Louis): And we were able to look and see, among those children whose moms used cannabis during pregnancy, did we see any difference in their developmental outcomes?
ARPANA AGRAWAL: And one questionnaire that really stood out to us was the Psychosis-Like Experiences Assessment.
RESEARCHER: And although you couldn’t see anything or anyone, did you suddenly start to feel that an invisible energy, creature or some person was around you?
RESEARCHER: Yeah, okay. And did that bother you?
ARPANA AGRAWAL: And this dataset gave us an opportunity to roll back the tape to a period of time in an individual’s life where they’re being exposed, at a time when their brain is exquisitely vulnerable.
RESEARCHER: Did you start to worry, at times, that your mind is trying to trick you or wasn’t working right?
RYAN BOGDAN: So, among kids who were exposed to cannabis following their mother’s knowledge of their pregnancy, they experienced more psychotic-like experiences, they experienced more depression and anxiety-like behavior, they’re breaking more rules, they have more attentional thought problems.
NARRATOR: Psychotic-like experiences are also associated with an increased risk for mental illnesses like schizophrenia and depression.
CYNTHIA ROGERS: We know that the use of cannabis during pregnancy is increasing. We’ve seen advertisements online, social media, targeting women saying this is something that’s safe for you to use during pregnancy for things like nausea or insomnia. And these women are not trying to harm their babies, they’re just trying to get through what can be a challenging time.
NARRATOR: Rogers and Agrawal are now scanning 250 babies to see if brains exposed to cannabis during pregnancy are different from brains that were not.
CYNTHIA ROGERS: T.H.C. crosses the placenta, so we know the baby’s brain is exposed to it. We also know that the receptors in the brain that T.H.C. binds to develop very early during pregnancy.
YASMIN HURD: The endocannabinoid system is critical for hard wiring of the brain during development. So, if cannabis comes on board while this endocannabinoid system is regulating neural circuits that are laid down, how the cells communicate as they’re being developed, obviously, it can have an impact on that. And that is the thing that is critical for people to understand, cannabis is not a benign drug.
NARRATOR: While scientists worry about the risks, most agree that far greater harm has come from criminalizing cannabis, starting in 1937.
HARRY ANSLINGER (Federal Bureau of Narcotics, 1930–1962/News Reel): The treasury department intends to pursue the despicable, dope pedaling vulture…
NARRATOR: Harry Anslinger, head of the Bureau of Narcotics, stoked racism towards Mexican immigrants by demonizing their word for cannabis, marijuana, and claiming the evil weed corrupted users.
FILM NARRATOR (Reefer Madness Film Clip): Debauchery, violence, murder, suicide.
KASSANDRA FREDERIQUE: If you look at the way that they talked about marijuana, part of the strategy was to make cannabis something that wasn’t acceptable, make it foreign, and create the hysteria to put laws in place that control a group of people that were not white and push forward a narrative that the government is keeping us safe.
NARRATOR: In the 1970s, Richard Nixon ignored an expert panel recommending decriminalization, and declared a “war on drugs.” Soon drugs would become the key reason for being arrested in the U.S.
POLICE: Do you mind if we search the car?
NARRATOR: Since 2000, over 14-million people have been arrested, and some 40,000 Americans are now behind bars for cannabis, mainly for possession charges.
KASSANDRA FREDERIQUE: Someone gets arrested for cannabis every 58 seconds.
In a country where we are now legalizing cannabis, people are talking about its medical use. In the midst of COVID-19 it is an essential service. Cannabis is one of the driving forces fueling mass incarceration in this country, and it is disproportionately targeting poor people and communities of color…
CHINAZO CUNNINGHAM: In every single state in the United States, whether cannabis is legal or not, black people are arrested for cannabis-related offenses more than white people.
KASSANDRA FREDERIQUE: …despite the fact that all government data shows that usage is equal across races.
NARRATOR: Although many Americans believe the war on cannabis is over, for Black people especially, like Sean and Eboni Worsley, it’s a war that’s still going on.
To manage his post-traumatic stress, Sean had gotten a medical cannabis card in Arizona. But as he and Eboni began a cross-country trip to see family, they would drive through states where cannabis is illegal and racial profiling common.
EBONI WORSLEY (Sean Worsley’s wife): We needed gas. We had no idea, especially in a place where you are not familiar with, when is the next place you will be able to stop for gas.
SEAN WORSLEY: I get out of the car. As I’m walking away, a vehicle pulls in front of my wife’s car, and it is a police vehicle.
EBONI WORSLEY: And all of a sudden, I am approached by an officer. He startled me. When I looked up, he’s, like, you know, “Where are you heading?” And I’m like, “We are heading to North Carolina.” And then he began speaking to my husband. who is outside of the vehicle.
SEAN WORSLEY: He asked me about any weed being in the vehicle, and I just was honest. And I told him, “Sir, you know, I am a medical cannabis patient from Arizona, and I do have my cannabis, but it’s zipped up, and it’s in the trunk.”
At that point, he puts me in handcuffs and proceeds to search the vehicle. I give him my I.D.s., and he said, “Well, you won’t need these where you are going.”
NARRATOR: The officer found a third of an ounce of medical cannabis.
LEAH NELSON (Research Director, Alabama Appleseed Center for Law & Justice): He charged them as severely as he could, with possession for other than personal use. And that was because Sean had with him a grinder, and he had rolling papers, and he had a scale. All of those things were recommended by his doctor.
If you smoke marijuana medically, it’s not uncommon for a doctor to tell you to use a scale, so you know how much you are smoking.
NARRATOR: Eboni and Sean spent six days in jail before getting a hearing. At the Pickens County Courthouse, they were charged with multiple felonies. After struggling to pay a bondsman and impound fees for the car, the couple returned to Arizona.
EBONI WORLSEY: The fines and the fees became astronomical. By the time we made it back to Arizona, we literally couldn’t afford to pay our rent or bills. And we ended up evicted. We were homeless.
NARRATOR: Under stress, Sean had a stroke. Eventually, Eboni’s charges were dropped, but due to prior minor convictions, Sean was sentenced to five years and put on probation.
LEAH NELSON: Probation requires a stable address, it requires you to pay money, and one of the conditions of Sean’s probation is that he needed to get drug treatment. And the V.A. looks at him and says, “You have a medical marijuana card, man. We are not going to treat you. You don’t qualify because you don’t have a drug problem.”
SEAN WORSLEY: Probation and parole, they’re just traps to send you right back, to keep you in their grasp. You want to lock me up for not having a job, you want to lock me up for not having a place to stay? How am I supposed to get these things, if I can’t get a job because you have me labeled as a felon?
NARRATOR: In March 2020, Sean was extradited to Alabama to serve the remainder of his sentence behind bars.
CHINAZO CUNNINGHAM: I see the harms of the war on drugs every single day, in all of my patients’ lives. It is so clear. There’s not a single family that I know that doesn’t have some member who’s been arrested or incarcerated. And what I see is that what happens in society, the arrests, the incarceration, the poverty, dramatically affects people’s health, their lives, their quality of life.
NARRATOR: As criminalization destroys lives, at the same time, the cannabis wellness industry is thriving. One entrepreneur is Eugene Monroe, a former football player who believes cannabis can help address chronic pain.
EUGENE MONROE (Former National Football League Offensive Tackle): Playing in the N.F.L. was a lifelong dream. I loved the sport. That explosive power, to propel my body and essentially flatten people, each time that happens, each time, your brain rattles in your skull. You pay a price.
The job creates a need for pain relief, inherently, so I was given a lot of opioid drugs, which would let you go into a game with acute injuries and perform, because you don’t feel bad. I was taking my oxycodone, just as prescribed, and saw my daughter walking down the hallway and didn’t recognize her. And I realized that they were causing a serious issue, and I stopped taking them. And that’s the point where I decided that cannabis is a better option.
Cannabis didn’t just allow me to cut back on opioids. It allowed me to eliminate all pharmaceutical drugs. It hasn’t cured my injuries, but what it did for me was alleviate my pain, so I felt motivated to go to the gym and work out and take care of my body.
CHINAZO CUNNINGHAM: We know that cannabis leads to less pain, and it alters people’s ability to tolerate the pain. It affects the immune system and reduces inflammation. It’s certainly safer than other medications that we’ve been using for decades.
NARRATOR: Monroe is now a partner and consultant for one of the nation’s largest cannabis companies.
Yet, while many praise the benefits of cannabis, some scientists warn there are risks, especially for those who use it daily. About nine percent of users will develop a cannabis addiction.
One is Paul.
PAUL DEBASSIO: So, I was in my junior year of high school, and it was a 400-freestyle relay, and so the last leg of the race always, you go just as hard as humanly possible. And as I came up from the flip turn and I snapped my head up, I just felt this, this twinge, just right in between my shoulder blades, and it just, it killed me.
But it wasn’t until I went into college that it became a recurring detrimental thing. And I started using cannabis to alleviate a lot of the pain and to help me sleep at night, ’cause I could never get a full night’s rest.
NARRATOR: Cannabis seemed to cure Paul’s insomnia.
PAUL DEBASSIO: I loved how calming it was. I’d have the best night of sleep that I ever had in my life. And I said, “This is amazing.”
NORA VOLKOW (Director, National Institute on Drug Abuse): It would be fantastic if we have a drug that would actually calm you when you need it, that makes you feel groovy, more social and there’s no negative consequences. That would be extraordinary. But that’s not the case. Biology basically adapts to stimuli that you give.
NARRATOR: Cannabis is less addictive and safer than tobacco, heroin, cocaine and alcohol, which kill hundreds of thousands each year. But, you can take too much.
NORA VOLKOW: We’re seeing an increase in the number of people that end up in emergency departments with a full-blown psychosis because of the high content T.H.C.
NARRATOR: Dependence can impair memory, mood and motivation. Paul didn’t know he had a problem, until he needed a drug test for a job.
PAUL DEBASSIO: And so I quit, cold turkey. And almost immediately, I noticed a big change in my mood.
DEEPAK CYRIL D’SOUZA (Professor, Yale University): They get irritable, they get aggressive, and they can feel depressed.
PAUL DEBASSIO: There were stretches of weeks that I slept for maybe two to three hours a night, every night. And that was all I could get.
DEEPAK CYRIL D’SOUZA: We looked at sleep architecture, and what we found was that when people quit using marijuana, slow wave sleep, which is the kind of sleep that makes you feel rested the next morning, was significantly disrupted.
Okay. Hi, Paul. How are you?
PAUL DEBASSIO: Good morning.
NARRATOR: In a new clinical trial, Deepak D’Souza hopes to harness the endocannabinoid system to prevent cannabis withdrawal.
DEEPAK CYRIL D’SOUZA: I need to observe you take the study medication, so let’s just go through that.
NARRATOR: When the brain is repeatedly flooded with T.H.C., it reduces the number of cannabinoid receptors. Once a person is dependent on cannabis, abruptly quitting triggers withdrawal. To replace T.H.C., D’Souza is testing a drug that increases our own cannabis-like molecule, anandamide.
PAUL DEBASSIO: There was a two-week period where I was taking either the placebo or the study medication and still smoking, at the same time, and then, I had to quit cold turkey. And the day that I quit, I thought that there was no way I was going to sleep that night.
I had no issues, it was very, very easy. I’ll never forget that first night that I was able to sleep after not smoking. I woke up the next day in absolute shock and awe.
NARRATOR: Paul doesn’t know yet if he got the study drug, but an earlier trial showed that it helped people quit. And PET scans reveal that after cannabis is stopped, the brain’s own cannabinoid receptors come back.
YASMIN HURD: Our endocannabinoid system is really powerful. And that’s why we shouldn’t really play with it that much. A drug may be fine for one person, but it isn’t for everyone. Dose matters. When you take it, during development, matters. We need to really understand what these drugs do to the brain, even if they will, and I do believe, have some medicinal benefits.
NARRATOR: So, what does the future hold for cannabis as a medicine?
STACI GRUBER: Moving on to the Skywalker OG: why are you using it?
NARRATOR: To find out, Staci Gruber is following adults who buy cannabis from dispensaries to treat a range of ailments.
STACI GRUBER: Chronic pain is the number one condition. Anxiety is probably number two, P.T.S.D., difficulties with sleep. And we have patients who come to us and say, you know, “I use these types of products for this problem.” And then we go, “Hmm, we should look at that?”
How’s the anxiety? In all honesty, how is it?
ERIN ROSENBERG (Cannabis user): Things are going really good. I’m really busy.
NARRATOR: Gruber’s study has yet to be peer reviewed, but two years of clinical and psychological tests show patients improving.
STACI GRUBER: Wow, so that’s a decided change.
ERIN ROSENBERG: Yes.
STACI GRUBER: “Reduced symptoms of pain, reduced anxiety, improved sleep and improvements across the board on a number of different cognitive tasks that require executive function.” The question is why? It may very well be that the restorative sleep that people are starting to get once they find something that works for them is the key to the improvement.
LEAH NELSON: I think this was the most important document. This was the letter from V.A. Mental Health.
NARRATOR: Back in Alabama, Leah Nelson is working with Eboni Worsley to get her husband Sean paroled.
LEAH NELSON: Alabama’s war on cannabis has failed. People like Sean, particularly Black men, are paying this horrific price for doing something that is already legal in states where half of Americans live.
NARRATOR: In November, 2020, Sean was released from prison and placed on parole.
SEAN WORSLEY: It was scary being inside. It rocked me to the core. It was probably one of the most difficult things I’ve had to do. I would pick going back to war before going back to prison, most definitely.
EBONI WORSLEY: It set us back so far. It’s supposed to help rehabilitate individuals. Instead, it’s putting us in positions where we need so much more mental help, we need much more financial help, we need so much more than we needed before.
KASSANDRA FREDERIQUE: It is past time for us to end the war on drugs. We need to legalize cannabis. We need to be pumping money into research to actually learn more about this substance. So, this moment is about building new responses to drugs that are based in science and that are based in the rights of people.
NARRATOR: There are still many questions to answer: Should cannabis be marketed as candy? Should the T.H.C. potency of products have limits? From reducing harms to expunging convictions and ensuring equity, getting legalization right is as complicated as the plant itself.
STACI GRUBER: Cannabis is not one thing. Our recreational consumers have a different goal for using cannabis than our medical patients. Our medical patients say, “I’m not looking necessarily to change how I feel. I just want to address this set of symptoms.” But we have frighteningly little data on the long-term effects of medical cannabis use. The plant is comprised of over 400 compounds, 400. If people turn to it, we should know the answers.
Devin E. Haqq
WRITTEN, PRODUCED, AND DIRECTED BY
Rosa Amanda Tuiran
DIRECTOR OF PHOTOGRAPHY
R. Lorraine Collins
Chloe Jennifer Jordan
Humberto ‘Beto’ Cabral
CAMERA ASSISTANTS & GRIPS
Christopher J. Mullen
T. Brendan Feeney
ONLINE EDITOR & COLORIST
Heart Punch Studio
Universal Production Music US
Melissa M. Pollard
American Civil Liberties Union
The CONUS Archive
Jace B. King
University of Utah
Susan F. Talpert
University of Mississippi
John, Gavin & Sandra Lee
Jenny Le Coq
Jacqueline-Marie N. Ferland
Yale School of Medicine
University of California, San Diego
Ben and Julia Feldman
NOVA SERIES GRAPHICS
yU + co.
NOVA THEME MUSIC
ADDITIONAL NOVA THEME MUSIC
CAPTIONING AND AUDIO DESCRIPTION
Media Access Group at GBH
POST PRODUCTION ONLINE EDITOR
Lindsey Rundell Denault
SENIOR DIGITAL PRODUCER
DIGITAL MANAGING PRODUCER
DIRECTOR OF EDUCATION AND OUTREACH
PROGRAM MANAGER, NOVA SCIENCE STUDIO
DIGITAL EDITOR, EDUCATION
DIRECTOR OF AUDIENCE DEVELOPMENT
DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC RELATIONS
SENIOR DIGITAL EDITOR
DKC Public Relations
DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL AUDIENCE RESEARCH
PROJECT MANAGER, SCIENCE AND SOCIETY
LEGAL AND BUSINESS AFFAIRS
SENIOR SUPERVISING PRODUCER
SENIOR PROMOTIONS PRODUCER AND EDITOR
Michael H. Amundson
POST PRODUCTION ASSOCIATE PRODUCER
SENIOR EXECUTIVE PRODUCER, EMERITA
Paula S. Apsell
SENIOR SCIENCE EDITOR
SENIOR DEVELOPMENT PRODUCER
SENIOR SERIES PRODUCER
DIRECTOR, BUSINESS OPERATIONS & FINANCE
Julia Cort Chris Schmidt
A NOVA Production by Holt Productions LLC for GBH Boston.
© 2021 WGBH Educational Foundation
All rights reserved
This program was produced by WGBH, which is solely responsible for its content. Some funders of NOVA also fund basic science research. Experts featured in this film may have received support from funders of this program.
The Cannabis Question is made possible (in part) by the Corporation for Public Broadcasting. Additional funding is provided by the George D. Smith Fund, Inc.
NOVA original production funding was provided by 20th Century Studios, a subsidiary of The Walt Disney Company, the David H. Koch Fund for Science, the NOVA Science Trust and the Corporation for Public Broadcasting.
Image credit (smoke)