Climate change is contributing to more severe flooding in communities along the Mississippi River. In 2019, the Mississippi crested at its highest-ever recorded level in Davenport, Iowa, causing widespread damage in the city’s downtown and reigniting a debate about how it should protect itself. NewsHour Weekend’s Christopher Booker reports as part of our climate change series, “Peril & Promise.”
>> Sreenivasan: WE CONTINUE OUR
SERIES, "FURTHER DOWN THE
MISSISSIPPI," WHERE, THIS PAST
MAY, THE RIVER CRESTED IN
DAVENPORT, IOWA, AT RECORD
LEVELS, OVERTOPPING FLOOD WALLS
AND INUNDATING PARTS OF
DOWNTOWN.
DAVENPORT, THE LARGEST OF THE
QUAD CITIES WITH ABOUT 100,000
PEOPLE, IS NO STRANGER TO
FLOODING.
THE LATEST ROUND HAS RE-IGNITED
THE DEBATE ABOUT HOW THIS CITY,
THE LARGEST ON THE MISSISSIPPI
WITHOUT A PERMANENT FLOOD WALL
OR LEVEE SYSTEM, SHOULD PROTECT
ITSELF FROM FUTURE RISING
WATERS.
NEWSHOUR WEEKEND'S CHRISTOPHER
BOOKER HAS THE STORY.
>> Reporter: FRONT STREET
BREWERY FIRST OPENED ITS DOORS
IN 1992.
>> DID YOU LIKE THE "RAGING
RIVER"?
>> Reporter: A YEAR LATER, IT
INTRODUCED ITS RAGING RIVER
I.P.A., A FERMENTED REMINDER OF
THE HISTORIC MIDWESTERN FLOODS
OF 1993.
BUT TONIGHT, THIS BEER IS BEING
POURED IN RECOGNITION OF A MORE
RECENT BATTLE WITH THE
MISSISSIPPI RIVER.
>> INSIDE THE MAIN FLOOR OF THE
RESTAURANT BUILDING, WE HAD
ABOUT 18 INCHES TO TWO FEET OF
WATER.
>> Reporter: SO, IN HERE, THERE
WAS TWO FEET?
>> YEAH, WHERE WE'RE SITTING
RIGHT NOW, THERE WAS ABOUT TWO
FEET OF WATER.
>> Reporter: FRONT STREET'S
CO-OWNER, TIM BALDWIN, SAYS THE
WATER CAME IN, IN A MATTER OF
MINUTES WHEN A SECTION OF THE
TEMPORARY FLOOD WALL ASSEMBLED
TO HOLD BACK A SWOLLEN
MISSISSIPPI RIVER SLIPPED.
THE EXACT MOMENT IN LATE APRIL
WAS CAPTURED ON A SECURITY
CAMERA.
>> WE RAN, OF COURSE, GOT SOME
THINGS WE... WE DEEMED
IMPORTANT.
AND BY THE TIME WE WERE DONE
ROUNDING ALL THAT UP, WE FOUND
OURSELVES IN THE BACK OF OUR
BUILDING, IN OUR PARKING LOT,
STANDING IN NEARLY CROTCH-DEEP
WATER.
>> Reporter: IT WAS THAT FAST?
>> IT WAS... IT WAS THAT FAST,
YEAH.
>> Reporter: BY THE TIME THE
MISSISSIPPI CRESTED A FEW DAYS
AFTER THE BREACH, THE RIVER IN
DAVENPORT WAS 22.7 FEET, THE
HIGHEST LEVEL EVER RECORDED AND
MORE THAN FOUR FEETABOVE WHAT
IS CONSIDERED THE LEVEL OF A
MAJOR FLOOD.
AND FRONT STREET BREWERY AND
MORE THAN 30 OTHER BUSINESSES IN
DOWNTOWN DAVENPORT WERE DIRECTLY
AFFECTED.
WERE YOU THINKING, "IT'’S DONE"?
"THE RESTAURANT'’S FINISHED?"
>> NO, I DIDN'T THINK THAT THE
RESTAURANT WAS FINISHED BECAUSE,
YOU KNOW, WE KNOW THE HISTORY OF
THIS PLACE, AND WE KNOW THAT, IN
1993, THE EXACT SAME THING
HAPPENED.
SO, IT WAS, YOU KNOW, "OKAY,
WE'LL JUST HAVE TO DEAL WITH IT
TOMORROW."
>> Reporter: FLOODING HAS ALWAYS
BEEN A PART OF DAVENPORT, BUT
THINGS HAVE CHANGED.
OF THE CITY'S 15 LARGEST FLOODS,
SEVEN HAVE BEEN SINCE 2008.
THE INCREASED FREQUENCY OF
FLOODS, INCLUDING THIS SPRING'S
BREACH, HAS RE-IGNITED A DEBATE
ABOUT HOW DAVENPORT SHOULD
PROTECT ITSELF FROM THE RIVER.
>> THERE ARE PEOPLE IMMEDIATELY
WHEN IT HAPPENED SAID, "PUT UP A
WALL."
>> Reporter: FRANK KLIPSCH IS
THE MAYOR OF DAVENPORT.
>> WE'VE HAD A LONG-TERM
POSITION IN THE COMMUNITY THAT
WE WANT TO EMBRACE THE RIVER AND
NOT TRY TO FIGHT IT.
>> Reporter: DAVENPORT IS THE
LARGEST CITY ON THE MISSISSIPPI
WITHOUT A PERMANENT FLOOD WALL
OR LEVEE SYSTEM.
RATHER THAN BUILD A PERMANENT
BARRIER, THE CITY INVESTED IN A
TEMPORARY FLOODWALL BUILT FROM
METAL MESH CONTAINERS FILLED
WITH SAND, CALLED HESCOS.
THE CITY HAS ALSO EXPANDED GREEN
SPACE BY BUYING OUT LOW-LYING
PROPERTIES, CREATING A BUFFER
ZONE THAT IS DESIGNED TO FLOOD
AND HOLD WATER AS THE RIVER
RISES.
MAYOR KLIPSCH SAYS IT'S A MODEL
THAT HAS SERVED DAVENPORT WELL.
>> WHEN YOU HAVE A RECORD FLOOD,
IT CHALLENGES YOU.
AND NOW, IT'S A MATTER OF TRYING
TO WORK THROUGH THAT.
AND HOW DO WE, IN FACT,
CONTINUE TO DO A BETTER AND
BETTER JOB DEALING WITH THAT
TEMPORARY NATURE, BUT EMBRACING
THE RIVER OVERALL.
>> Reporter: IN JULY, MAYOR
KLIPSCH FORMED A TASK FORCE TO
STUDY HOW THE CITY SHOULD UPDATE
ITS FLOOD PLAN.
IT HAD REPRESENTATIVES FROM
FEDERAL AGENCIES, INCLUDING THE
ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS AND THE
NATIONAL OCEANIC AND ATMOSPHERIC
ADMINISTRATION, PLUS LOCAL
OFFICIALS AND BUSINESS OWNERS,
INCLUDING TIM BALDWIN.
>> THIS IS DAVENPORT'’S PROBLEM.
>> Reporter: YEAH.
>> THIS IS BETTENDORF'’S PROBLEM.
THEIR PROBLEM IS MITIGATED WITH
THAT WALL.
>> Reporter: DRIVING AROUND THE
REGION, BALDWIN SHOWED ME WHAT
SOME OF DAVENPORT'S OPTIONS MAY
BE.
>> YOU THINK ABOUT WHERE OUR
BUSINESS IS LOCATED ON THE
RIVER, THIS WOULD BE OUR VIEW.
>> Reporter: THE TOWN OF
BETTENDORF SITS RIGHT NEXT TO
DAVENPORT.
IT COMPLETED THIS PERMANENT
LEVEE IN 1987.
IT'S ESTIMATED THAT A SIMILAR
WALL IN DAVENPORT, WHICH IS A
MUCH BIGGER CITY, WOULD COST AT
LEAST $175 MILLION.
BUT, REGARDLESS OF THE COST,
BALDWIN DOESN'T WANT TO SEE ONE
IN DAVENPORT.
>> I CERTAINLY WOULDN'T WANT MY
CUSTOMERS TO CLIMB UP ON A LEVEE
TO... TO BE ABLE TO TAKE
ADVANTAGE OF THE... OF THE RIVER
VIEWS.
SO, SITTING BEHIND A WALL LIKE
THIS JUST DOESN'T HAVE THE SAME
APPEAL.
>> Reporter: BUT DAVENPORT WILL
HAVE TO DO SOMETHING, ESPECIALLY
IF IT WANTS TO PROTECT ITS
LOW-LYING DOWNTOWN.
AND IT'’S NOT ALONE.
INCREASED FLOODING IS AN ISSUE
THAT COMMUNITIES UP AND DOWN THE
MISSISSIPPI ARE DEALING WITH.
IS CLIMATE CHANGE CONTRIBUTING
TO AN INCREASED NUMBER OF
FLOODS?
>> ABSOLUTELY.
>> Reporter: DEFINITIVELY?
>> DEFINITIVELY.
>> Reporter: LARRY WEBER IS AN
ENGINEERING PROFESSOR AT THE
UNIVERSITY OF IOWA AND THE
CO-FOUNDER OF THE IOWA FLOOD
CENTER.
IT'S AN ACADEMIC CENTER CREATED
TO HELP THE STATE PREPARE AND
PROTECT ITSELF FROM FLOODS.
>> WE GET A LOT OF RAINFALL IN
IOWA.
AS CLIMATE CHANGE HAS IMPACTED
OUR WEATHER IN IOWA, WE DON'T
GET THE RIGHT AMOUNT AT THE
RIGHT TIME AS MUCH ANYMORE.
YOU KNOW, WE HAVE THIS
INTENSIFICATION OF RAINFALL.
YOU KNOW, IT'S THE RAINFALL
EVENT WHERE WE HAD EIGHT INCHES
OF RAIN, AND THEN WE GET ANOTHER
SIX-INCH RAIN, AND THEN ANOTHER
TEN-INCH RAIN, AND THEN NO RAIN
FOR SEVERAL WEEKS OR MONTHS.
>> Reporter: SO, FLOOD, DROUGHT,
FLOOD, FLOOD, DROUGHT.
>> YEAH, YEAH, THAT'’S RIGHT.
>> Reporter: HE SAYS THE
INCREASE HAS BEEN NOTICEABLE FOR
IOWANS OVER THE LAST QUARTER
CENTURY.
>> IN 1993, THE GENERAL SENSE
AMONGST MANY PEOPLE THROUGHOUT
THE MISSISSIPPI RIVER WAS, WE
HAD JUST EXPERIENCED THE FLOOD
OF A LIFETIME.
YOU KNOW, WE EXPERIENCED THE
"500-YEAR FLOOD."
AND SO, WE WOULDN'T EXPECT TO
SEE AN EVENT LIKE THAT AGAIN.
>> Reporter: LO AND BEHOLD,
THOUGH, WE'VE SEEN MANY MORE
500-YEAR FLOODS.
>> YEAH.
IN 2008, PEOPLE WERE SURPRISED
WHEN THE IOWA AND CEDAR RIVER
BASINS FLOODED AGAIN AT LEVELS
THAT WERE EQUAL TO OR MUCH
GREATER THAN 1993.
>> Reporter: IN JUNE OF 2008,
IOWA EXPERIENCED THE LARGEST
NATURAL DISASTER IN ITS HISTORY
WHEN THE CEDAR RIVER FLOODED
CEDAR RAPIDS, CAUSING AN
ESTIMATED $5.4 BILLION IN
DAMAGES.
MORE THAN 11 YEARS LATER, THE
CITY IS STILL RECOVERING AS IT
IMPLEMENTS A $550 MILLION FLOOD
PROTECTION PLAN.
FUNDED WITH FEDERAL, STATE, CITY
AND PRIVATE MONEY, THE PLAN
INCLUDES LEVEES, WALLS AND
ENTIRE NEIGHBORHOODS THAT WERE
BOUGHT OUT AND RETURNED TO GREEN
SPACE.
THE COST AND TIMELINE OF CEDAR
RAPIDS' RECOVERY IS NOT LOST ON
OFFICIALS IN DAVENPORT.
>> IT TAKES THAT LONG TO PLAN,
AND IT TAKES THAT LONG TO GET
THE PROPER FUNDING IN PLACE.
SO, IT'S NOT A... A QUICK
PROPOSITION, UNFORTUNATELY.
>> Reporter: NICOLE GLEASON IS
DAVENPORT'S DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC
WORKS.
SHE'S RESPONSIBLE FOR
IMPLEMENTING THE CITY'S FLOOD
PLAN, INCLUDING THE PLACEMENT OF
TEMPORARY BARRIERS.
IS IT POSSIBLE TO BALANCE THESE
TWO IDEAS, THE IDEA THAT YOU
WANT TO HAVE AN ACCESSIBLE
RIVERFRONT AND YOU ALSO WANT TO
HAVE A DRY DAVENPORT?
>> I THINK IT IS, BUT I THINK
THAT IT'S GOING TO HAVE TO BE A
BALANCE OF FIGURING OUT CRITICAL
INFRASTRUCTURE, CRITICAL ASSETS
AND MAYBE LOOKING AT PROTECTING
THOSE SPECIFICALLY; AND THEN
LOOKING AT OTHER WAYS TO TURN
THOSE AREAS THAT ARE MORE
DIFFICULT TO PROTECT OR DON'T
MAKE AS MUCH SENSE AND TO
PROTECT INTO MORE... MORE
PARKLAND, MORE WETLANDS, THINGS
LIKE THAT.
>> Reporter: BUT FIGURING OUT
HOW TO BALANCE PROTECTING
DIFFERENT PARTS OF DAVENPORT'S
NINE-MILE RIVERFRONT, AND WHO
SHOULD BEAR THE COST, COULD BE A
CONTENTIOUS PROCESS WITH SO MANY
STAKEHOLDERS.
>> YOU START THIS BATTLE BETWEEN
DOWNTOWN BUSINESS OWNERS OR
THOSE THAT LIVE ALONG THE RIVER,
AND THE REST OF THE TAXPAYERS IN
THE CITY OF DAVENPORT SAYING,
"YOU'RE THE DUMMIES THAT BUILT
DOWN THERE, OR OPERATE
BUSINESSES DOWN THERE, OR LIVE
DOWN THERE, WHY SHOULD WE PAY
FOR THIS?"
AND ON THE SURFACE, YOU KNOW,
THAT'S PROBABLY A NATURAL
REACTION, AND PROBABLY WITH SOME
ACCURACY THERE.
BUT, YOU KNOW, WHAT PEOPLE DON'T
THINK ABOUT IS THAT THIS FLOOD
MITIGATION IS A PROBLEM FOR THE
ENTIRE CITY.
>> Reporter: AND BALDWIN
CONCEDES THAT PERMANENT FLOOD
PROTECTION FOR DAVENPORT MIGHT
MEAN RETREATING FROM THE RIVER.
>> YOU KNOW, IF... IF THE CITY
AND FEMA CAME IN AND SAID, "THIS
IS WHAT WE NEED TO DO," WE
WOULDN'T HAVE HAD A LOT OF
PUSHBACK.
>> Reporter: IF THEY SAID, "WE
NEED TO BUY YOUR BUILDINGS AND
TEAR THEM DOWN"?
>> TO TEAR THEM DOWN.
I MEAN, CERTAINLY, WE'D WANT TO
BE COMPENSATED APPROPRIATELY,
BUT, NO, WE WOULDN'T HAVE PUSHED
BACK ON THAT BECAUSE IT SEEMED
TO BE THE RIGHT THING TO DO.
THERE'S OTHER PLACES WE CAN
OPERATE FROM, RIGHT?
>> Reporter: BUT, FOR NOW, THIS
PUB REMAINS ON THE RIVERFRONT,
CELEBRATING A GRAND-REOPENING
SEVEN MONTHS AFTER IT WAS
FLOODED.
(GAVEL BANGS )
>> I WOULD LIKE TO CALL THIS
SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL MEETING...
>> Reporter: MEANWHILE, FRANK
KLIPSCH'S TERM AS MAYOR JUST
ENDED, BUT HE SAYS THAT THE
CITY'S FLOOD TASK FORCE HAS
IDENTIFIED SEVERAL SHORT-TERM
PRIORITIES, INCLUDING
COMMISSIONING A COMPREHENSIVE
ENGINEERING STUDY.
HAS THIS CHANGED THE WAY THAT
YOU THINK ABOUT CLIMATE CHANGE?
>> I THINK THE REALITY OF IT IS
THERE'S STILL... I HAVE FOUND
THERE'S SOME PEOPLE THAT WANT NO
TALK OF... OF HOW IT'S
HAPPENING, BUT EVERYONE CAN
UNDERSTAND THERE'S A NEW NORMAL
NOW, AND WE'VE GOT TO DEAL WITH
IT.
>> Reporter: AND OFFICIALS NOTE
THAT THIS PAST FALL WAS WETTER
THAN 2018, NOT A GOOD SIGN FOR
KEEPING DAVENPORT DRY THIS YEAR
AS THE WINTER SNOW MELTS AND THE
SPRING RAINS COME.