ARCHIVED CONVERSATION
Read through archived FRONTLINE/World
conversations around this story below, including responses
from the reporters.
Hai Tiet - Lawrenceville, Georgia
After watching the segment of Frontline/World on Vietnam,
I started to have mixed feelings about the show and Vietnam.
Being a Vietnamese- American teenager, I have been plagued
with images of Vietnam as a "poor" country in need of help.
Watching and reading Nguyen Qui Duc's story shined a new
light to my conditioned memories. I have visited Vietnam,
but I have to say that the film did not portray an accurate
image of this country. I was excited to see Vietnam in such
great shape, but I knew better. With the stats on the PBS
website, I feel that this film shows too much of the "rich"
side of Vietnam. Of course the segment was only so long,
I feel like Mr. Nguyen Qui Duc could have done a better
job as a journalist and storyteller. Vietnam, as any communist
country, is slowing turning their wings to a new light and
with that brings many problems. The problem was that this
film's target audience was to the Western world. In my eyes,
I feel that the film shows Vietnam as a prosperous country
with what it seemed to be minimal problems. Yes, Nguyen
Qui Duc did highlight Vietnam's many problems, but I believe
too much of "rich" side was shown (i.e. the go-go girls
and drugged teenagers/ the problems of a nation becoming
capitalist). In light of that, many Westerners might have
mixed images of Vietnam as a country. I do commend Mr. Nguyen
for showing the audience a new side of Vietnam, but what
about the people of Vietnam? I feel as a journalist one
has a duty to carefully represent all the facts without
any bias. Yes, the film is about Mr. Nguyen's life, but
as a journalist, one represents the voice of the people
of which Vietnam does not have. As I recall, there were
one or two stories about the poor conditions of Vietnam,
which plague and counts as a large percentage of the nation.
Somehow, I feel like my memories of Vietnam have been cheated.
The voices of the unheard are not heard and the tears of
the tearless cannot be shed. Despite my disappointments,
I do thank Nguyen Qui Duc for the special and do commend
him with feverous applauds and hope he continues his works
for years to come.
Gregory Rutchik - San Francisco,
California
Amazing; Touching; Insightful;
Human. Such a well done piece. Struggling to reconnect to
his past and to his father, the author tells a story that
even I, a second generation Jew living in San Francisco,
can relate to. Your homeland is beautiful and your father
would be proud that you returned. But most of all, I hope
that you continue to tell your story and the story of Vietnam
so that we can learn more of our own insulation and of our
similarity.
George Reid - Marquette, Michigan
I thought it was very sad that this generation of Vietnamese
has no clue about the strife, devastation, turmoil and upheaval
of the Vietnam War (conflict?) period. I can't help but
wonder if it's due to apathy, as here in the States, or
government control and manipulation of the media and educational
content.
Anonymous - Gurnee, Illinois
I was not surprised at
the teenager's reaction to the question about the war. However,
I might have been had I not just returned from a trip to
Vietnam, Cambodia and Laos a few months ago. I was 20 years
old when Saigon fell and was very much against the war.
I wanted to go to Vietnam since our history is so intertwined
with theirs. I had heard that now that the country is at
peace and most Vietnamese were not born at the time of the
war, that Americans are welcomed in Vietnam. We had a guide
accompany us from the United States, along with local Vietnamese
guides from both the north and south. Our guide from the
south was my age and our guide from the north was in his
20's. The facts of the war were discussed with our older
guide from the south (but not our younger guide from the
North), however, the politics of the war were not discussed,
except with our U.S. guide in our hotel rooms. I think for
most of the Vietnamese the American War (as they refer to
it) is a thing of the distant past. We Americans seem to
have a harder time dealing with the aftermath of our role
in the war. I loved the time I spent in Vietnam and was
treated warmly by everyone I met. I hope to go back in the
future.
Anonymous - Rock Springs, Wyoming
You can find a teenager in any country who 'doesn't
have a clue'