Photo of Bill Moyers Bill Moyers Journal
Bill Moyers Journal
Bill Moyers Journal
Watch & Listen The Blog Archive Transcripts Buy DVDs

« Alberto Gonzales Resigns; Why Now? | Main | Seeds of Change »

More response to My Fellow Texan

Rick Byrne, Director of Communications, BILL MOYERS JOURNAL:

The PBS Ombudsman Michael Getler posted another column this week regarding "My Fellow Texan.” In that column, he includes the letter below from a viewer. For the record, Bill Moyers did ask Karl Rove to come on BILL MOYERS JOURNAL, by fax and by mail.  These requests were made before Chris Wallace responded on-air on Fox News Sunday to Bill Moyers' letter, and we still haven't heard from Karl Rove.

I saw and heard that commentary by Bill Moyers, and of course it was a commentary not intended to be news reporting. I was not aware of the so-called reports of Mr. Rove's comment on his alleged agnosticism, and would agree, after reading Mr. Getler's examination, that Moyers was loose in his characterization. Personally, I did not think that that point, true to whatever degree or not, was the key issue, but rather a sub point that was part of the larger commentary.

In any event, PBS executives are correct in saying that the program clearly is Bill Moyers and his views and his interviews with others. The press in general — including many commentators — was lax in reporting on and analyzing the White House, Congress and the war in the past half-dozen years, and Moyers' strongly worded commentaries are welcome by many. The fawning over Rove by other commentators — not by all, certainly — is hardly dented by Moyers' strong words. (Rove, in fact, was on three Sunday network or cable discussion shows. He more than holds his own all by himself.)

He slipped up, it seems, in not clarifying the agnosticism reference, and really did not need it. But on the whole, his role is clear: He comments on and analyzes events and the people behind them. If the argument is whether PBS needs to present someone with different views (which it has done, if I am not mistaken), fine. Add another voice.
But Moyers is a commentator and a thoughtful analyst who should be taken — and liked or disliked — for what and who he is. Here's an idea: Ask Moyers to ask Rove to be a guest on his program for a free-wheeling discussion. I bet Rove would not do it.

- Dan Hortsch, Portland, OR


TrackBack URL for this entry:


Karl Rove is the anti-christ. We have this pri**k to thank for Bush II, and all the illegal, immoral, anti-american, cronieism. HE SHOULD BE SHOT for treason, as should Bush, Bush II, Cheny, Rumsfeld, Ashcroft, Gonseles, Miller, Rice, Powell, and Powell, and ANYone else who thinks or believes that the Presidency take presedence of the people. NOBODY, EVER, SERVES AT THE PLEASURE OF THE PRESIDENT; THE PRESIDENT SERVES AT THE PLEASURE OF THE PEOPLE.
Bush is not King, even though HE thinks so, and for that alone he is a traitor, and should be treated as such.

And if the country grinds to halt for a time while this goes on, then so be it. You're supposed to grind to halt for a time when have a criminal in the white house, in order to get rid of them, and prosecute them. I t is what you are supposed to do. Read the constitution.

Karl Rove is a scoundrel. Bill Moyers simply pointed that out. What is wrong with that? Bill Moyers is a commentator and a reporter with the guts to state the truth. He is the kind of man sorely lacking in journalism today. If we had more journalists like Bill Moyers we might not be sunk in the morass of an unjust and unwinnable war. We might not have an Executive branch that has absolutely run amok, trampling on the hard-won liberty of every American citizen. If you people who are so upset with what Bill Moyers said about Karl Rove want to hear the other side, simply turn to Fox. You'll hear the party line 24-7 and nary a word of criticism for the worst administration in U.S. History.
Bill, keep on reporting the news, and be assured it's OK to flavor your reporting with your own opinion. Your opinion is of great interest in itself, due the vast experience you have in journalism and your many years of observation of the political life of this country.
And you, Mr. Ombudsman, you should be supporting Bill Moyers. Grow a spine, you wimp!

so karl is a church-going, money-donating episcopalean? he's also married and you can ask jeff gannon how that is going.

Post a comment

THE MOYERS BLOG is our forum for viewers' comments intended for discussing and debating ideas and issues raised on BILL MOYERS JOURNAL. THE MOYERS BLOG invites you to share your thoughts. We are committed to keeping an open discussion; in order to preserve a civil, respectful dialogue, our editors reserve the right to remove or alter any comments that we find unacceptable, for any reason. For more information, please click here.

A Companion Blog to Bill Moyers Journal

Your Comments


THE JOURNAL offers a free podcast and vodcast of all weekly episodes. (help)

Click to subscribe in iTunes

Subscribe with another reader

Get the vodcast (help)

For Educators    About the Series    Bill Moyers on PBS   

© Public Affairs Television 2008    Privacy Policy    DVD/VHS    Terms of Use    FAQ