POV

Breathtaking. Inspiring.

by thanh
September 8, 2009, 11:28 PM

The English Surgeon

The kind of progam I was always hopeful would be a part of our television experience. Unfortunately it is rare such an inspirational effort is presented. The progam is deserving of the broadest possible showings and perhaps it will inspire some in the US to grasp the true meaning of health care and the need among people of limited income faced with almost impossible choices.

by Bob Flannery from West Palm Beach, Florida
September 8, 2009, 11:35 PM

Touching and inspiring surgeon and his medical ethics

It is simply inpiring,It is motivating. It is a documentary it must be watched for every medical student.

What is the worth of life.

by sedat ulkatan from New York, NY
September 8, 2009, 11:36 PM

the english surgeon

The film is thoughtful, poignant, beautifully photographed and ultimately makes you aspire to be a better person.

by helaine bernard from Queens, New York
September 8, 2009, 11:37 PM

The English Surgeon

A kaleidescope of emotions - poignant, inspirational, sad, hopeful, human. What a terrific film! A powerful expose of healthcare in the Ukraine.

by Al Waite from Belton, Texas
September 8, 2009, 11:38 PM

The English Surgeon in Ukraine

This program absolutely captured my attention. Feelings of hope, despair, happiness, sadness all were within me while watching Dr. Marsh and Dr. Igor while they were trying to provide some kind of care in a country where people are so poor and yet the Ukrainian people are so humble and greatful. I want to so much give some help and yet I feel so helpless because I truly don't know how I can help. I have such deep compassion and feelings for people who are so much less fortunate than myself as far as being able to obtain the care they so need.

I thank channel 13 for allowing this documentary to be shown because it hits the most inner core of a human being.

Thank you and I hope to see more of these kinds of programs so that we in America could appreciate how truly lucky we are to be here and all that is available to us as compared to other parts of the world.

God bless you and again thank you.

by Daria Witiuk from Fishkill, NY
September 8, 2009, 11:40 PM

The English Surgeon

Wow .... It was so amazing to watch the two doctors do what they knew needed to do and the extreamly hard decisions and they had to make. Out of the goodness of their hearts and with vurtually nothing to work with the two doctors gave it their all. Thank goodness that the English Surgeon was able to go to that area and provide surgery and medical expertise to aid the Ukrain doctor who is clearly overwhelmed with all the cases that come before him. Thank you to both of you for caring so much about helping people.

by Cheryl from Biddeford, 04005
September 8, 2009, 11:41 PM

Superb documentary

I was extremely impressed with the film and tne neurosurgeon from England. He seems to be a very caring and loving person who deeply cares about his patients and helping them receive the appropriate treatment plans. I am married to a neurosurgeon, so I know how difficult the field is. It is astonishing how the Ukraine does not offer patients much of anything and their healthcare system is so weak. What makes me even more upset is to see young people dying and going blind from benign brain tumors, where here in New York they would have surgery or the Gamma Knife or radiation and in most cases these people would survive. My husband treats brain tumors every day and most of his patients do extremely well.

I would like to do more to help these people in the Ukraine get better care.

Thank you for the show.

by Maddy Brisman from Roslyn, New York
September 8, 2009, 11:47 PM

the english surgeon

I was touched by the commitment these two doctors have for their patients.The struggle between false hope and yet some comfort. I was also struck by the lack of all the material trappings we would assume a brain surgeon to have (limo, Rolex etc.) Extremely inspiring and the best of PBS. Thank you.

by kate from naples, fl
September 8, 2009, 11:53 PM

This film could not have been aired at a better time. It should make every single person appreciate the freedom of choice. The diversity that creates competition that motivates the competitors to strive to come up with bigger and better solutions.

by d from Staten Island, NY
September 8, 2009, 11:56 PM

A true doctor

What a emotional roller coaster of a documentary. Very well done. It will last a long time on the mind and the soul. Note: Have your kleenex close by.

by Carolyn from Omaha, NE
September 8, 2009, 11:59 PM

Thank you for sharing this wonderful story of an inspiring man and his life.

by Gloria Florida
September 9, 2009, 12:32 AM

True Compassion

I was seeking something meaningful to watch and saw this documentary coming on as I passed through the channels. I did not intend to watch it, but ended up never turning away from it. This documentary was truly inspiring and puts so many things into perspective. My prayers go out to those who are burdened with illness in Ukraine and my prayers and thoughts of appreciation go out to everyone who is involved with this greater purpose. Thank you!

by Suzann from Dallas, TX
September 9, 2009, 12:44 AM

The English Surgeon

A beautiful film, the compassion and the deep concern DR. Marsh has for the patients, his own inner struggle between giving false hope and at times a hopeless diagnosis. A true physician so rare today. Thank you for this film. Please keep up these extrodinary presentations.

by Baerbel Merrill from Gillette, Wyoming
September 9, 2009, 12:46 AM

The English Surgeon

I feel very sad about the reality of poor access to healthcare in the Ukraine and throughout the world. I am grateful for the opportunity to see these two wonderful physicians working together.

by Janet Atkins from San Antonio, Texas
September 9, 2009, 12:51 AM

The English Surgeon

I think this was a wonderfull Program.
I enjoyed watching. It Reminded me of my own surgeries Of Cancer of the larynx,which was totaly removed. By My surgeon Here in Pittssburgh Dr. David Demarino. A wonderfull surgeon who saved my life. Thank You!

by Paul Kehren Sr. from Pittsburgh, Pa.
September 9, 2009, 12:55 AM

THE ENGLISH SURGEON

Very touching and inspirational. It reminds us all to be truly grateful for what we have as many others in the world are really suffering and are in desperate need of help. Dr.Marsh and Dr. Igor are truly great men and may they be blessed for their selfless acts of kindness and steadfast committment to helping those who are truly in need. Well Mr. Smith. Well done PBS. Keep up the Good work.

by Maurice from Port of Spain, Trinidad and Tobago W.I.
September 9, 2009, 1:03 AM

Oh my goodness I am so touched by this film.I have 2 Brain Aneurysm's and would give anything to have a brillant surgeon like that operate on me.Thank you for a touching story

by Lori Bowser from Enid, Ok
September 9, 2009, 1:08 AM

Inspiring Film

This inspiring, relevant film added something precious to the end of my day.
Thank you.

by marina from new york, new york
September 9, 2009, 1:12 AM

The best of television and storytelling

I was riveted and extremely moved by Mr. Smith's film. Both doctors are true heroes...the kind that really deserve all the accolades yet never get them. I pray they continue to do what they do and help the countless people in the Ukraine who so desperately need their skills and talents.

by Sonya Bell from Oklahoma City, OK
September 9, 2009, 1:32 AM

As good as it gets!

A very moving, emotional and fascinating journey in the life of the imminent English neurosurgeon and humanitarian, Dr. Henry Marsh as only PBS could bring us! It is especially timely to see this when the US healthcare system presently is under the microscope and being pulled in so many different directions by so many interests. Whatever whining I was doing inside about our healthcare system "shortcomings" has been deafened by the poor, sub-standard woeful conditions people face around the world as this wonderful and poignant film reveals. I am forever grateful to the filmmakers, PBS and all the participants, especially Dr. Marsh for impacting my life and inspiring me to be more considerate of others' predicaments and to give more.

by Michael Zuckerman from Atlanta, GA
September 9, 2009, 1:32 AM

The English Surgeon

The English Surgeon is a real tear jerker that should open our eyes to how we should help our fellow man.

by Brent from Huntington Beach, CA
September 9, 2009, 2:09 AM

Soul Reaching

I've been watching PBS for many, many years and, along the way, a precious few make it to the top for me. Frontline's presentation of "A killer at Thorston High" and "Brother's Keeper" are at my top but, tonight, I just added another one.

I like the fact that this did not feel like another "documentary" although it was in a way. But it was so well done that it didn't seem so. It wasn't about surgery but about life decisions that we all have to make if we have any ability to help others.

I have my own load right now, helping another that needs it badly. It's not an easy choice in life. Thank you for the handshake doctor. I'm ready to carry on now.

by Rich from Orange, California
September 9, 2009, 2:12 AM

Time for Tears for a Moment

Great television. Thank you.

by Ted Michael Morgan from Baton Rouge , Louisiana
September 9, 2009, 2:24 AM

Depressing

I watched this program with a sense of frustration with Dr. Marsh. Obviously he is an educated man and provides a good service to society. However, he appears to be quite arrogant at times. He so easily falls into the role of "life saver" and "god like". It's unbecoming. He descends into the poorly equipped and uneducated "wilds" of Ukraine... He practically brags about the resources of the UK and how wasteful he and his colleagues can be. I hope that he puts his money and celebrity toward the real cause of poor health care in the world--namely, the capitalization of health care services... Those agencies and people who are associate with health care services are among the highest paid in the world! In fact, it's the lack of money and resources that makes this story so upsetting to me. Serious conditions that have resulted from the lack of services in the area because all of the really good providers rush away to practice in the highly paid West... It's very frustrating.

by Tom from San Francisco, California
September 9, 2009, 2:31 AM

The English Surgeon

The English surgeon was a moving and dramatic viewing experience. The film maker captured the full effect of a man who deals with decisions that are real and life changing for those he examines.

In addition to the effect of the reality of the scenarios, the film was thought inspiring and provoking.

The film is inspiring and challenging. After viewing this extrodinary film, I will personally choose to behave in a manner that will, in some manner, benefit my fellow man.

Thank you for bringing this film to PBS.
Theresa Brown

by Theresa Brown from Scottsdale, AZ
September 9, 2009, 2:35 AM

When I saw the advertisement for this, I knew I wanted to watch it, but as someone recovering from a craniotomy to remove a malignant tumor, I wasn’t sure how well I would be able to deal with it. I’m so glad I decided to watch, though I admit I couldn’t watch it all.

It wasn’t the graphic scene in the operating room that disturbed me, in fact that was fascinating and gave me a better understanding of what happened to me. What disturbed me was the long line of hopefuls, many of whom were fellow brain tumor patients, looking to the renowned surgeon from England to help them, only to be told that there was nothing that could be done. It was a powerful part of the film, but for me it was too “There but for the grace of God…” It was heartbreaking to see good people lose their last hope.

The film also gave me even more respect for what surgeons do, and sympathy for what they have to deal with. I will never forget Dr.Marsh saying that deciding on surgery was like playing Russian Roulette with two guns.

By the way, those who equate socialized medicine with the mess in the Ukraine should remember that the wonderful Dr. Marsh is from England - where they have socialized medicine.

by Penny from Tulsa, OK
September 9, 2009, 2:46 AM

What are the early signs of a possible brain tumor before it's too late?

by Kristina from Paradise Valley, Arizona
September 9, 2009, 3:23 AM

Each in his own way

Dramatic medical dramas such as this program always grab our attention. But we who are not capable of performing medical marvels must understand that our diligent though modest efforts to help others count for a lot.

by Lemastre from Dallas, TX
September 9, 2009, 5:31 AM

The Heart is Heavy

I was playing on my laptop in a hotel room and left the TV on PBS. My attention was drawn to the PBS show.

When I watch a show like this, I am torn by the lack of health care that is needed in these countries. Ukraine children, if only were caught earlier, might NOT go blind or die. How can I do more to help.

This show draws on so many emotions and compassion. Thank you PBS for the excellence you have portrayed in The English Surgeon. Thank you to both Doctors for helping those that need it most.

by Daren from Tacoma, WA
September 9, 2009, 5:58 AM

brilliant!

I got caught up in this last night and was extremely moved. I work every day in a surgical pathology unit in the US, (where the tumors go) and we see similar cases all the time...this is how it is, even in the United States.

I was angered on behalf of the little girl who will be permanently blinded because there were not the resources to treat her benign tumor in the Ukraine and it was too late. When will people realize that health care is a HUMAN RIGHT, NOT a BUSINESS, NOT a POLITICAL HOT BUTTON, but a right that every person has? We in health care struggle to make that a reality, but there are never enough resources and our technology is still behind our best impulses. I thank God I dont have to deliver dx'es (diagnoses!) to patient like that, I would die.

I could not believe he went shopping for a surgical drill and other equipment in a hardware bazaar. That is wrong! Hopefully the Ukraine doctor will start getting some resources after this. One thing that could be done is remote reading of CAT scans and X-rays--they can do that now. Other specialists could volunteer time remotely in radiology, pathology, and even do consults over streaming video.

In any case, you have to get angry for the patients like those children and the 23-year old with inoperable metastatic brain cancer.

Good for the English Surgeon--I could tell he enjoyed what he did...it was as much for himself as everyone else involved, that he loved being able to help others who were helpless because of a geograpy or a post-Soviet approach to medicine.

More people need to see this film. In the US all the idiots are popping out of the woodwork...people who OBVIOUSLY know nothing about medicine as it is practiced today in the US (ie. "death panels" when DNR's and DNI's are signed and acted on every day in the US often without the brain dead patient's input.....people dont know how we actually die or get care in the US)

In any case, bravo! But healthcare in the Ukraine and other places should not rely on charity and miraculously generous surgeons and doctors. Someone or some entity needs to step in (UN? WHO?) and say this is unacceptable, and perhaps the establishment of some kind of reciprocity between nations who have and nations who dont have has to happen.

Notice the English Surgeon IS English...they have completely NATIONALISED health care. You can have brain surgery there and never see a bill. Here you will see a bill for...I dont know, in the $10,000 range for a single procedure without a catastrophic hospital stay...somewhere around $100 K. Probably more when all is said and done. Incompetent people need to realize that they are in fact incompetent.

Cheers !

This comment has been edited by the moderator for content

by Sarah Partridge from Brooklyn , NY
September 9, 2009, 8:32 AM

Amazing film

As a prepare to start studying medicine as a first year student I am so thankful to see showcases like this and Hopkins that was on ABC last summer. These types of film ignite a passion for medicine in me that is sometimes bogged down. I shudder to think what medicine will turn into if Doctors lose the chance to think and act upon their gut feelings. I hope for health care reform but not how it is currently being proposed. I will never nor could ever turn away a person that was ill solely upon their inability to pay. I was touched seeing the two physicians advocate on behalf of the patient for the lowest possible cost. I was touched to see Dr. Marsh and how deeply impacted he was by a 'mistake' he took on operating on the young child. Surgeons are humans and mistakes are sometimes made, Dr. Marsh is like so many physicians of old that see medicine as a calling rather than a job. Thank you Dr. Marsh and continue the good fight.

To Sarah from Brooklyn, it is sad to see someone like yourself spouting off the same type of rhetoric that the far right spouts off, just from the opposite spectrum. You are both wrong and fail to see the big picture. In this film you see how people are cared for and the careful unbiased decisions that the English Surgeon makes. Physicians should be coming up with ideas for reform we because we are in the profession and we know what works and what doesn't. We don't need politicians that are in cahoots with special interests dictating how we should practice. Whether you are a conservative or liberal, both parties are influenced by special interest groups and don't want to upset the people that bank rolled their campaign. Therefore, let us physicians tell you what works and what doesn't. A special note, did you notice that the English surgeon was not sued for operating on that little girl? Would that be the same situation had it happened to an American girl here in the states? I doubt it. Tort reform should be central to health care reform. Physicians make mistakes and sometimes they are catastrophic for the families of the patients, but you know what medicine is not done, it is practiced. No procedure is fail safe but I can guarantee that every physician tries their hardest and does their best. And if we happen to error sometime, not only do we pay for it monetarily, but that procedure, that patient stays with us for the rest of our life and haunts us.

Enough with the bickering about American health care, Health care affects all of us and should be fixed by all of us. No party should have the final say solely because they are the majority in both houses, that is unfair and will only further divide the country. Lets all be grown up adults and talk openly without being hyper emotional and get things reformed as to help make health care more accessible and cheaper.

by Luke W. from Salt Lake City, UT
September 9, 2009, 9:29 AM

As GOOD as life gets

The English Surgeon swallowed me whole...my eyes...my mind...my heart.

Drs. Marsh and Kurilets beckon us to a place where, despite the odds (NOT good), their work makes life as GOOD as it ever gets. Congratulations to Geoffrey Smith et al.

An aside: As a cost-conscious Republican, I respected Dr. Marsh's thrift nearly as much as I loved his drift.

by BP from Wdby, CT
September 9, 2009, 10:01 AM

Best I have seen

Thank you for such a wonderful film! Dr. Marsh and Dr. Kurilets inspired me to be the physician I want to be.
More people should watch this documentary, it makes one appreciate what one has and help the other.

by Camila Bahamon from Homestead, Florida
September 9, 2009, 12:23 PM

The English Surgeon

An extremely touching documentary. That two singularly caring Drs.(Marsh and Kurilets) have met each other and work so well together is kismet.

I hope as many people as possible will be able to see this film. It has affected me deeply.

Thank you.

by Lillian from Brooklyn, New York
September 9, 2009, 1:04 PM

My brothers keeper

At the end where Dr. Marsh says "you must help people or your nothing." That is it everyone. You reading this.. are your brothers keeper. Do you understand we are all human and we must take care of each other.

by Christopher from Arlington, Texas
September 9, 2009, 4:34 PM

My wife (who has had three operations on an inoperable brain tumor) found this a fascinating, moving documentary. Both surgeons impressed us with their humanity and with the terrible difficulty they face in delivering bad news to patients.

Incidentally, the correct way to address a member or fellow of The Royal College of Surgeons is to use the title Mr, Miss, Mrs, or Ms (not Dr). This system (which applies only to surgeons, not physicians) has its origins in the 16th century, when surgeons were barber-surgeons and did not have a medical degree (or indeed any formal qualification), unlike physicians, who held a University medical degree.

The documentary honored (honoured?) this usage, and my wife and I honor both physicians. A wonderful film from our favorite television station.

Thank you very much.

by Bob Ross from Franklin Lakes, NJ
September 9, 2009, 5:08 PM

What a wonderful program. I had trouble watch at times but thought the doctor was great guy.
THANKS

by Brian Beaton from Tamarac, Florida
September 9, 2009, 10:44 PM

Iluminating and Extraordinary

Thank you to PBS, Dr. Marsh, Dr. Kurilets, and Mr. Smith for this extraordinarily touching documentary. I cannot shake the images of the 3 year old girl, the pretty young blond woman, the desperation and hope. I cannot forget the beautifully made tombstone of Tanya in the country cemetery. This film made me realize that my own little problems are petty indeed and that there is no greater calling than that of helping others.

by Russell Stroup from McKinney, Texas
September 9, 2009, 10:53 PM

The English Surgeon

I missed it! Any chance it will be broadcast again?

by Lynn Lippincott from Bishop, CA
September 9, 2009, 11:31 PM

The English Surgeon

This is POV and PBS at its best. An excellent production dealing with timeless and timely issues. How lucky we the public are to witness people making a difference through volunteerism and empathy.

by Patrick Cunningham from Twin Lakes, Mn
September 10, 2009, 2:19 AM

Ms

I couldn't take my eyes off the show!
...and I strongly agree (at the end) 'that after all, 'what are we if we do not help one another?...then we are nothing, nothing!'

God Bless You, and all you have touched!
.............?how can I help?
jordanridge333@yahoo.com

by Cindy Jordan from Dothan, AL
September 10, 2009, 3:37 AM

im a nobody but a honest nobody

Im 55 yrs. young, i have a bad memery do to a accedent in 1978 but this is not about me!!.To the English Doctor,You are deffinetly an ensperation.As to my reaction i cryed.To me all life is emporting weather humen or animal.I beleave this so much that i know humanity shoud not have the right to strip our lands for gread. Beleave me all goverments have one thing in mined,to get rich. Money rules,it shoud not be like this.Goverments are the reason for predudes and raceisum.Goverments,gives there people reasons to leave ther countryies too find a better life,and i don't blam them for doing so. The problum is servival hard anywere for lower class people, so when 100rd of 1,000ens of imergrents starts entering others country they feal invaded and that there going to lose what they erned and fought for. My teachen of the U.S.Goverment was that our goverment was created by the people for the people and all man was created equiel so wy don't they live by it? Point being get Rid of Money and you Rid Hunger, Sickness and Hate.Im watching presedent Obama right now in the house of congress about health insurances he sounds realy good mabe you can email him this and mybe he will respone to me and tell me wy my idears won't work and if he can't, mybe he will put my idears too use.He's saying every thing i feal i would love to help him make his talk come true. Dear Mr.English Dr. all these words come becouse of you, becouse i realy wan't to help you,to help the people that you doso much for,help me help the people that can change the world. I dont have the mined or the nohow or the infuances,to embaresh all goverments and milloners to stop buying youghts,privet jets,millons dollar homes,$100,000,00 cars. Were are ther priorites certinly it's not in there peoples best intrest? If it was our world would not be in the mess it's in.It's 4:40 am. im tierd and can't think any more so for my closer let me say PLEASE,Mr.English Dr. help me help all goverments so can help people humanitariens like you to help the unfortunet witch is probly (65 to 80% of the world. PS.Please let me know how you feal, one way or the other.I would be hornerd to hear from you personaly and at eased that you got my letter.GOOD NIGHT AND GOD BLESS Vincent Vaccaro

by vincent r vaccaro from east boston, massachuttes
September 10, 2009, 4:31 AM

the english surgeon

I truly enjoyed the documentary of a doctor trying to help, with limited resources. You need to have strength to be able to see a child blind or the lovely 23 yr old lady and say we cannot do anything!. It really is a tear maker. It is a excellent movie, perhaps it will help send some CAT systems to that part of the world. Especially for a country full of doctors that always needs new technology. Or perhaps our overpaid doctors could do similar charity work!
thank you!

by MG from Livermore, CA
September 10, 2009, 9:24 AM

Superb film; touching, humbling story

This documentary was so many things - moral tale, science, humanitarianism at its best, touching, tragic. It was inspirational to see both what a doctor in an underfunded, limited-resources region like the Ukraine was willing to do for his patients and how he made do with what he had; at the same time, he was so eager to learn more. Dr. Marsh as a personality was equally fascinating - a man of immense experience and talent reaching out to help another colleague, willing and eager to teach, provide some resources, assist with decision-making of risk of surgery vs. benefits while not forgetting the all-important human reaction of patients and family. He also was not arrogant, which is rather unusual to see in many surgeons - I work in allied health in a hospital group and have seen physician arrogance up close and personal. I've also had (spinal) neurosurgery myself, though, and I have to say that my own neurosurgeon was one of the kindest physicians I've ever encountered. I wonder if it's the specialty itself that attracts/demands this of the men and women who choose neurosurgery as their field? Both these doctors gave me a reason to aspire to being more humanitarian in whatever small way I can. They also made me feel pride in the work I do to help patients, even though it is not of the magnitude of neurosurgery. Thank you to the filmmaker, PBS, and especially Dr. Marsh for this thought-provoking, heart-and mind-touching film.

by Joana from Cincinnati, Ohio
September 10, 2009, 12:25 PM

Stunning - thank you

Thank you to everyone involved in this project. My husband was diagnosed with glioblastoma last June and has received excellent care and is doing well. Our experience with the health care system is the polar opposite to the victims of similar terrible diagnoses in the film. I admit at times, I changed channels to avoid seeing what exactly my husband experienced during surgery. The two doctors are brilliant and are to be commended for their strength - morally, physically, emotionally - to fight against the Ukrainian system that appears not to have 'healing' as its guiding principle. I hope you will follow up with a posting as to how can we - as viewers - assist Dr. Marsh in his efforts to bring hope to a few patients. I know that sending supplies or funds directly to the Ukraine would not be possible. My best regards and thanks again, to everyone.

by Pam Spooner from Austin, TX
September 10, 2009, 12:30 PM

the english surgeon

This was a magnificent testimony to the bravery humility and compassion of not only "Mr. Marsh" but the surgeon from Ukraine as well. After spending five
years trying to help a boy with severe life threatening spinal deformities in Belarus, I was completely emphathetic with the frustration that he felt.
I made five trips to Belarus, to no avail.
Sadly, the country of Belarus would not let us help this boy... no one would take personal responsibilty for an orphan. no surgery for him.
Dr. Marsh is a beacon of hope and encouragement.
I will not give up trying to help those in need.
He is a blessing in our troubled world.
He is love.

by susan jones from connelly springs, nc
September 10, 2009, 12:42 PM

I was very moved and inspired by the story of Dr. Henry Marsh and his work in the Ukraine, and am wondering how he might be able to train other young doctors to help and learn from him.

by Elspeth Nickerson from Malibu, California
September 10, 2009, 1:17 PM

Хай благословить вас Бог, доктор.

Having been to Ukraine several times myself, I found this very moving and relevent. It gives a good portrayal of life in that country and the struggles that ordinary people face there. I also have come to love Ukraine almost as much as my own country. I salute the Doctor for what he is doing there. "If we don't try to help others, what are we? Nothing ... we are nothing." What he is doing is something great, something good. God bless you for it.

by David Keys from Prairie City, Iowa
September 10, 2009, 3:03 PM

Absolutely Wonderful and Inspiring...Great Man..Mr. Henery Marsh - Thank You for being a most remarkable human being.

by Mrs. Moreau from waterbury, ct
September 10, 2009, 5:57 PM

God bless you both

Moving, touching and humane!!!

by Victoria from Provo, UT
September 10, 2009, 6:30 PM

INSPIRING

I watch the wonderful story of The English Surgeon and cried during the entire movie. It left me spellbound and proud that there are those who have a place in their hearts to help others less fortunate. How blessed we are to be living in the United States. I have never complained about the medical services anywhere, as most medical personnel are doing their best under the circumstances. I know as I retired from this field. This movie should be view by everyone that thinks health care is bad in US. Here these people wait patiently, hour after hour and many times it is too late to have surgery. How sad is that?? I give this a 5 star rating and this beautiful and skillful surgeon deserves the Noble Peace Prize. Ruth Ann in Tulsa, Oklahoma

by RUTH DAVIS from TULSA, OK
September 10, 2009, 6:49 PM

English Surgeon

In a time when politics is distorting our discussion about health care, we need to look at what we have and be thankful. What we have is obscene in it's execution, unfair, costly and cumbersome. But so much better than that forced on the two heroic doctors in the film.

I think we need a bit more of Dr. Marsh's charity and compassion for those who do not have the health care they deserve.

PBS has once more shown what REAL television can be and I applaud all of you who support your local station.

by Richard Diedrich from Shillington, PA
September 10, 2009, 10:48 PM

The English Surgeon

Geoffrey Smith deeply understands the humanitarian side of the medical profession in this story about patients who put their lives in the hands of an English brain surgeon. Touching and heartfelt.

by Darlene Dranda Ohio
September 10, 2009, 11:14 PM

Thank you!

I just finished watching "The English Surgeon" and thought I would write to say thank you to PBS for airing this wonderful documentary/film.

by Gina Moscatelli from Philadelphia, PA
September 10, 2009, 11:38 PM

I AM STRUCK BY THESE BEAUTIFUL, HUMBLE PEOPLE, SO THANKFUL-SO UNAWARE OF THE DEPRIVATION THAT CONSUMES THEIR LIVES. UNFORTUNATELY I SEE SO MANY IN THE US DEMAND MORE AND MORE...NOTHING IS EVER GOOD ENOUGH.
GOD BLESS THESE HEROIC DOCTORS...YOU ARE GIFTS TO HUMANITY!

by LORIE THOMAS from NORMAN, OK
September 11, 2009, 3:54 AM

So Humbled

I could not sleep last night so I happened upon this story of the remarkable physician, I myself work on a daly basis with neurosurgeons I cannot tell you how humbled most of his collegues would be to see the work he has done. His comment that unless we help we are nothing speaks volumes. I am interested in learning more on this true gentle-man who is making a difference. I was privledged to watch this story...Thank-you for sharing with the world...By the way I finally fell asleep

by Jeanne Connolly from Fayetteville, NC
September 11, 2009, 7:17 AM

There are few words that can express how inspiring I found this documentary. Mr. Marsh and Igor Petrovich are today's heroes. God bless them. This documentary exhibits the humanity of medicine and the gentle nature of the Ukranians grateful for so little. Amazing people! Thank you for this film.

by Mary Fron from Niles, MI
September 11, 2009, 12:21 PM

The English Surgeon

I had much the same reaction as many of the other postings. However, my overriding emotion was that of humility. This film will stay with me for a long while. Whenever I begin to indulge in self pity, the memory of the suffering the Ukrainians in this film undergo each and every day will help me to appreciate how privileged we are in this country.
I intend to purchase the video of this episode and show it to my children and grandchildren in order that they might gain a perspective on life that would otherwise be difficult to achieve in our
self-centered environment.

by Jay Henderson from Boise, Idaho
September 11, 2009, 11:34 PM

Thank You

Seeing this film is more than an eye-opening experience: it combines reality with thought-provoking wisdom; dismal conditions of an underfunded health care system in the midst of which two surgeons dedicate themselves to helping others. A powerfully moving depiction of what it really means to dedicate one's efforts--one's life--to better the life of another.

Thank you so very much.

by Sophia Pilipchuk
September 12, 2009, 12:53 AM

The English Surgeon

I can't stop thinking about this film. These two doctors are passionate about medicine, passionate about their art and have found a way to make a difference for so many. They are both realists as well. How fortunate that they have found each other because truly, it seems like the magic is the pairing of the skill and drive of both. I am humbled and inspired by this story and feel invigorated to find ways to make difference myself.

by Shelley Watts from Wallingford, Vermont
September 12, 2009, 12:46 PM

Amazing!

I applaud the filmmakers for creating something, that depicts the Ukrainian medical system so well. Keep in mind that the events of this film take place in Kiev, the capital, it is much worse in other parts of Ukraine.
It was absolutely inspiring to see how dedicated and caring these two doctors are. This film stirred up a lot of emotions, especially in light of the fact that I will be in Kiev in a few weeks.
Thank you!

by Vlad from Calgary, AB
September 12, 2009, 1:10 PM

When is it playing again???????

I was so mad at myself for missing this on TV... I caught it on radio... and forgot to Tevo it on TV... Will it ever replay??

Thanks Nanette Counts,

sikiwi@aol.com

by Nanette Counts from Palm Springs, Ca
September 12, 2009, 8:46 PM

The Way It Is

I have been involved in a medical exchange with talented and dedicated Ukrainian physicians for a few years and I can assure you that the medical system there is as grim as depicted in the film (if not worse). If you step back and look at the medical system there, you would be inclined throw up your hands and say to yourself, "Why bother?". Instead, you do exactly what Dr. Marsh is doing-help one doctor and one patient at a time to make a difference. My compliments to all involvrd in this great film.

by Doug from Waco, Texas
September 12, 2009, 11:35 PM

Ms.

This was a most genuine experience. We all struggle with our mortality and it is difficult to imagine not being anymore. The courage and sensitivity that is portrayed here shows the best of how humans can manage good and bad news. I sat in rapt attention and realized that my departure from this world can be a natural, expected and fitting experience. Sad? Yes, but there is no alternative! A good death is important. Let's not botch this one opportunity.

by Suzanne from Rochester, NY
September 13, 2009, 1:34 PM

The English Surgeon

The film was excellent and gave great insight into the subject. What struck me however was the complete lack of recommendations to seek alternatives to surgery. As a nutritionist, I know of many people who have been told they had inoperable cancers who, after being put on certain supplements and dietary modifications, along with other non-invasive protocols, were able to reverse the growth of their malignancies and restore their health. After viewing this film, I felt moved to assist such people who have been turned away. What whould they have to lose if they have already been turned away as inoperable? I would also like to see a film made about this kind of program, and I would be interested in assisting the realization of such a project, as alternative approaches can offer hope to many who would otherwise be unable to obtain the more expensive operations.

by Fred Pulver from Carbondale, Colorado
September 14, 2009, 3:04 AM

the English Surgeon

In our "Western" civilization, it is refreshing and sobering to reflect on what's really important in life----giving of ourselves to others. The Doctor(s) are truly a credit to the human race. An immense "thank you" for helping (us) self-absorbed humans to put things in their proper perspective. Maledets an Bravo to these brave ment and their efforts.

by M. Galligan from Santee, Ca
September 14, 2009, 3:14 AM

The English Surgeon

I experienced a lot of bittersweet memories as I watched this tender depiction of two friends quietly holding fast against the odds. I have been an English teacher in Odessa, Ukraine. Before that, my wife and I traveled twice to Russia in order to adopt three of our children. We were in the big cities and small towns too, and the thing to remember is that this documentary depicted the desperate condition of the people around the biggest, most privileged city in the country. God help those from the sticks. And God bless the doctors and professionals like Dr. Marsh who continue to make room in the battle to care for people in their home nations to go to Ukraine to share their abilities, for no charge. I know of a 3D ultrasound machine that was donated to a hospital in Russia that stayed under a tarp because the Dr.'s said that even if the machine helped them to diagnose an illness, what good would it be if they could not treat it?
Thank you POV! This is the real power of "boots on the ground," to go and give of yourself. Please show us more.

by Jeff from Columbia, MO
September 14, 2009, 3:55 AM

English Surgeon

A moving film that makes me think of my own place in this world as well as our total resposibility to mankind. It was just wonderfull. Thanks for showing it.

by Lenny Schlein from San Diego, Ca
September 14, 2009, 1:21 PM

The English Surgeon

Thank you for sharing this beautiful, thought-provoking, and very human story.

by Mia Sloan from Newton, MA
September 15, 2009, 10:33 PM

Man

First I must say that your show was a inspiring for me, in that , there is health aids for Ulyana and all of the others waiting in the hallways of the Kiev hospital which had been turned away. I have been there several times and taken some samples for private use by my friends. What I took was not fancy FDA drugs but health aids which attach themselves to the protein which the anaerobic cancer cells and microbes get their oxygen from, resulting in suffication of these cells. Another health aid is quite simple , change the ph level in the body so that the cancer cells cannot live in. Usually the blood ph should be 7.2 and around 5.0 cancer cells and other microbes proliferate. If anyone wants more information on these alternatives for a healthy life e-mail me at davidboucherjop@yahoo.com.I am not asking for business but the information is readily available on the internet , I'll direct you there , you decide.
Would the producers contact me so that I can hand deliver this to Igor, My next trip to Ukraine would be so much more fulfilling.
thanks and keep healthy.
David Alan from Ontario, California.

by David Alan from around Ontario, on the land near California
September 17, 2009, 10:57 PM

The English Surgeon - More Information

The English Surgeon will be available for viewing online until October 8th.

http://video.pbs.org/video/1247097843/program/1154485580

It is beautifully crafted. An exploration of suffering, of the risks and rewards of human life, of the enduring compassion and difficult ethical decisions of those who try to help. And of life in post-Soviet Ukraine. Humbly grateful people living in a broken society, seeking to restore itself.

Here is an article about the film from the Kiev English language newspaper.

http://www.kyivpost.com/nation/47267

Da Svedanya,
Terry

by Terry Gustafson from Green Valley, Arizona
September 20, 2009, 4:37 PM

Mr

I thought the film of Dr Marsh & his brilliant humanity for the people of Ukraine was a remarkable film. I felt every emotion, the hope for patient's to get a good prognosis, & a tremendous sorrow to see many were destined to die, because tumour's were seen too late. & it hurt to see so many young children with same & not to have an effective health system in Ukraine to help them. I shall never again complain about the "Health Service" in Ireland (unless it’s really bad) because after seeing this film, we with fairly good health services have no reason to. I was so happy to see that the young man in the film has recovered from both his tumour & epilepsy. He was so brave during that operation; I would have probably jumped off the bed & run for the hills.

I am going to write to Ireland's national TV station; "RTE" to screen this film as soon as possible, for I feel is should be shown as many places as possible. Now reading about & commenting about "Health Reform" in the US will by me at least, be more measured, what is there to complain about, really?

Thank you, for allowing me to watch same, & keep up the good work.

by v.gerrard from Dublin, Ireland, Doesn't apply
September 20, 2009, 10:36 PM

Mr

Would the producers contact me so that I can hand deliver this to Igor, My next trip to Ukraine would be so much more fulfilling.
thanks and keep healthy.
David Alan from Ontario, California.

I am sure Dr Marsh & Dr Igor would use health aids if that all that was needed...but he is a surgeon & knows when a brain tumour is beyond treating. Also, your health aids I am sure cost money & the people in Ukraine are not very well off people in the majority. Also, their government are on the brink of bankruptcy compared to say Russia/Poland Czechoslovakia etc & couldn't afford to put that cost in to their budget's...especially when they can't afford ordinary operating theatre equipment & drugs & the like. So let Dr Marsh & Dr Igor the professionals in their field say, when their patient's have hope or not, as it's even worse giving these beautiful people another "False Hope"!

by v.gerrard from Dublin, Ireland, Doesn't apply
September 20, 2009, 10:54 PM

To the makers of "The English Surgeon:,
I just finished watching "The English Surgeon" on WHYY and to me this superb presentation surpasses mere filmmaking and enters the realm of something like a state of grace. I am not a religious person, but watching this film felt like a deeply spiritual experience to me. My utmost praise to the creator of this amazing work of art, thank you for revealing the goodness that human beings are capable of.
Dr Marsh and his Ukrainian colleague are truly heroes for our time.
Sincerely,
John Thornton

by John Thornton from Ocean City, NJ
September 25, 2009, 1:32 PM

The English Surgeon

It was a deep, introspective and emotionally provocative story. Dr. Marsh says "what are we if we don't try to help others, we're nothing," I admire Dr. Marsh for having a full sense of the value of his life and what he wants to do with it. Well done. I believe we don't necessary have to be a surgion to help others. Let us start from where we are and what we have.

by Masami Endo from San Francisco, CA
September 26, 2009, 1:33 AM

the english surgeon

is this the rated g virsion?where the action..pbs has changed so much through the years..no visual..there isnt any operating,pbs is just not fun anymore.the english sergeon should be called the english documentery..seems like almost all the people where inoperable..i dont think i'll watch again..very dissapointed..

by regina haskell from plymouth , massachusetts
September 27, 2009, 10:39 AM

viewer

Superb film. Exquisite film . Given how much witless junk is on TV, I wonder why I bother with "the box" at all. Programs like the English Surgeon are why; I stumbled on this gem while channel surfing. It made me want to go out and be a hero the next day.
I do not generally subscribe to the idea that some persons are angels, and now, I sort of, do. I am not sure whether the filmmaker, or the surgeon, is the angel. Either way, the film took me to the other side of the street.

by Hollie Smith from Santa Rosa, Ca
October 9, 2009, 2:11 AM

The purpose of living

There aren't suitable words to describe this move. It is inspiring, not only for me who are going to be doctor, but for every human being. I would like to be more men like Dr Marsh. We can all give our small contribution to those who are needed help. We mustn't forget there is always something that we can do, whatever we be and wherever we live.

Thank you for this wonderful move. It doesn't change my life, but just remind me who I am and what is the purpose of living. It will do for everyone!

by Tijana from Nis, Serbia
November 4, 2009, 8:29 AM

Time Saver

I finished looking the movie just now. It is beautiful and horrible at the same time. Those beautiful man save lifetime!

Andreas Czech, Hamburg, Germany

by Andreas Czech from Hamburg, Germany
November 18, 2009, 7:27 PM

Großartig!

Ein großartiger Arzt und eine wunderbarer Mensch dazu der Herr Marsh!! Meine Hochachtung und Respekt was Henry Marsh für diese armen Menschen tut und empfindet. Das ist gerade in der heutigen Zeit kaum noch zu sehen wo alle nur nach Geld und Macht gieren auch die meisten deutschen Ärzte! Alle bekommen den Hals nicht voll aber Herr Marsh opfert seine Zeit um ganz armen und kranken Menschen zu helfen. Manchmal aussichtslos aber oft erfolgreich. Er versucht es und das ist das wichtigste...ja dieser Mann sollte Vorbild für andere sein!
Diese Dokumentation hatte alles auch für nicht Mediziner, ein absolutes Muss für eine überheblich dekadente Gesellschaft wie die unserige sich sowas mal anzuschauen!!

by Dieter from Stadtlohn, Deutschland
November 18, 2009, 9:38 PM