|   | 
             
               Yanks for 
                Stalin 
                Interview Transcript
               Abel 
                Aganbegyan    (cont)
              Q.  
              Do we need to thank foreigners, especially Americans, for their 
              role in industrialization? 
              
              A.  
                They played a very important role.  Any developed country 
                plays an enormous role, when its expertise and technology is applied 
                in a less-developed country, independent even of whether the developed 
                country likes it or not.  And we, back then, used Stalin's 
                words to discuss the efficiency of Americans.  We did not 
                hide it, even though we criticized all the while, perhaps a stronger 
                word than criticized, American imperialism.  But we were 
                forced to acknowledge American efficiency.  We learned much 
                from advanced Western expertise, German, British and American.  
                Correspondingly, these countries had a very strong influence.  
                In addition, we invited their specialists to come here, and many 
                of our people went to the West to study and brought back knowledge 
                to be applied here. 
              Q.  
                We were at GAZ and were told how much Americans had helped there. 
              A.  
                I don't see any reason to hide it or cover it up.  The influence 
                is there, without a doubt, but experience is one thing; it's another 
                to put it to practical use.  Unfortunately, it is much more 
                complicated to put experience to practical use than it is to recognize 
                experience.  Knowing and creating are two different processes.  
                But we created all these things, not with the hands of the Americans, 
                and not with their money, but with our own hands, and in spite 
                of the Americans, one could say.  If we look at the big picture, 
                and assess it properly, then the encirclement of capitalist countries 
                interfered with our progress.  There was trade discrimination 
                employed against Russia.  Just like now, by the way.  
                We lose approximately $5 billion per year due to discrimination, 
                because we are not a member of the World Trade Organization.  
                Then it was even more difficult for us to put our goods on Western 
                markets.  We were isolated.  They refused to export 
                strategic goods to us or goods that they believed could have enabled 
                our development.  They did not want our country to develop.  
                The official policy of Western countries was to hinder our development 
                in the postwar period. 
              Q.  
                But individual businessmen helped us? 
              A.  
                Yes.  It wasn't the official policy of Western countries 
                to assist us.  It is thought that Hammer helped us, but he 
                didn't help us.  He was doing business.  He was doing 
                business, and business here was more profitable that it would 
                have been in America at that time.  He got rich in Russia.  
                Of course, he did some good for Russia, but he did better for 
                himself. 
              Q.  
                Did we add to our problems by throwing our ideology in the face 
                of Western nations? 
              A.  
                Of course.  That frightened people away.  In addition, 
                our policies were highly contradictory.  On the one hand, 
                our policy was the ideological rejection and condemnation of capitalist 
                imperialism, as well as the financial support of overseas branches 
                of the Communist Party.  Remember our malevolent glee at 
                the slightest misfortune visited upon the West, how we reveled 
                in the American crisis of 1929-1933.  Remember the slogans:  
                "We complete a Five-Year Plan in four years, while they move 
                backward."  Remember Stalin's first progress report.  
                Of course, this didn't improve our relations with the West.  
                That is why it is such an era of contradictions.  Our policies 
                were not rational and balanced. 
               
                 
                    1 
                  | 2 
                  | 3 
                  | 4 
                  | 5 
                  | 6 
                  | 7 
                  | 8    
                
             |