An excerpt from Houdini's
n order that the
reader may thoroughly understand my relation to the "Margery" case and the "Scientific American,"
and to make this record as complete and clear as possible, I will first review briefly my connection
with that magazine's investigation of so-called psychic phenomena.
like three years ago I was asked to write a series of articles on Spiritualism for the "Scientific
American" but had to refuse owing pressure of work. Later a Mr. James Black furnished
the magazine with a number of articles which were published, but these were so inaccurate that
they were assailed, and justly so, from all sides.
Having thus stirred up a hornets' nest and not having a sufficient knowledge of Spiritualism
to meet the situation, one of the oldest editors on the "Scientific American," and my friend for
over a quarter of a century, Mr. A.A. Hopkins, wrote me again, urging that I prepare some articles
on Spiritualism for them. The letter was followed very soon by a call from Mr. Hopkins who came
to my office in New York bringing with him a tall man whom he introduced as J. Malcolm Bird, also a
member of the "Scientific American's" editorial staff.
They discussed the Black articles with me and asked why it was that I would not write on
Spiritualism for them. I explained that the research work involved was such that I could not
entrust it to anyone else and that it was impossible for me to spare the time which this and
the writing of the articles would require, but I advised them to form an investigating committee
and said if the other members were honest, reliable, and qualified, I would serve as one without
pay with the stipulation that I was to have the right to reject any person proposed as a member
of the committee with me. My reason for this was, as I explained to them, that while an ordinary
investigator, whether layman, professor, or scientist, could make a mistake and later correct
himself without damage to his standing, I was in a different position, for due to the peculiar
nature of my work my reputation was at stake and I could not run the risk of having it injured.
This was agreed to before they left my office, but sometime, afterwards hearing that they had
selected a committee without consulting me I wrote the following letter to protect myself.
|November 13, 1922.|
Mr. J. Malcolm Bird,|
New Yok City.
Dear Mr. Bird:
I have just been informed by Mr. Hopkins that you have already selected a committee to
serve as investigators for the $5,000.00 offered to the mediums.
So, that there is no mistake in this, I would like to have it understood emphatically,
that when I consented to be one of your committee, it was under the condition that,
- I am to know each and every man selected.
- That all conditions placed before the mediums should be thoroughly gone over with me,
so that there could be no loophole for anyone to misconstrue the conditions of the manifestations
- Another condition is that the selected committee will go to a number of séances for
investigation purposes, so that we could get a line on each other regarding the capability of
actually recording in writing what was seen, as mal-observation is the curse of all description.
It was also stipulated in my condition that we are to hold conferences to see
whether all the committee are agreeable to each other, because we must work in harmony.
I have more at stake than the money you are offering and that is my reputation.
As a psychic investigator, and I, therefore, ask you to give me your full
confidence, as I am giving you mine. I intend to serve you faithfully, and with all
the knowledge I possess, but I ask to be fully protected in this.
May I suggest that it might be advisable for us to get together again before
publicity is given, so as to prevent any mistakes on all our parts. I am keenly and
intensely interested in the subject and will deem it a compliment to be on the committee,
but if any of the above conditions do not meet with your approval, please count me out.
The Committee as finally formed consisted of Dr. William McDougall, af Harvard University; Dr. Daniel F. Comstock, formerly of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology; Dr. Walter Franklin Prince, of the Society for Psychical Research; Hereward Carrington; and Houdini. Mr. Bird acted as Secretary for the Committee and Dr. Austin C. Lescaboura, another editor on the "Scientific American" staff, has assisted in arranging the tests and been present at most of the séances.
Following the "Scientific American's" offer of a sum of money as a prize to any medium
who could successfully pass its tests, several presented themselves and gave sittings
before the Committee. Among them were the Tomsons, Mrs. Josie Stewart, Valentine, and Pecararo.
Bird did not invite me to the major part of the séances, whereas, as Secretary, it was his
duty to do so, therefore, on learning of the Pecararo tests, I traveled from Little Rock,
Arkansas, to New York, to be present at one of the Pecararo séances.
In all these investigations it would seem that Mr. Bird allowed the mediums to believe
that they had practically won the prize and this is mirrored in the press reports given out
by him. Dr. Prince and I strenuously objected to this course.
So far as I knew there was no other investigation under way when, on picking up a copy of
the "Scientific American" early in 1924, I was surprised to find an announcement of a series of
séances being held by the Committee with a certain "Margery" and judged from the reading
of it that the Committee was on the verge of awarding her the prize. In the next issue of the
magazine I again found mention of the mysterious medium whose identity was being hidden behind
the name of "Margery," but as most all American papers carried stories giving her correct name
and address before I was called into the séances, and as later she gave interviews to
newspaper men, and one in particular in my presence, without denying her name, it would
be ridiculous for me now to do other than call her by her right name also, Mina Crandon,
wife of L.R.G. Crandon, a well-known Boston surgeon.
The "Scientific American" reports, written by Editor Bird, were such as to lead an ordinary
layman to believe that the magazine had found a medium who had successfully passed all its
crucial tests and to all intents and purposes was "genuine." In addition the lay reader,
and the uninitiated reporter as well, were left with the impression that the Committee had
approved this medium, whereas the articles only represented the opinion of Mr. Bird, who,
garbing himself in a mantle of authority, had written whatever he desired, always, however,
being careful to so phrase his material that later, in case the necessity arose, he could claim a certain alibi. A careful reading of the articles makes these subtleties obvious.
These articles, written by Bird, are the worse piffle I ever read, paralleled only by the tommy-rot
written about Mrs. Guppy, who was said to have been floated through the air, plate-glass window, and solid brick. Bird represented the medium as not only doing the ordinary table tilting, lifting and communicating by means of a code of raps common among all mediums, but in addition, such stunts as stopping and starting clocks, tipping over the cabinet, having furniture moved around the room before the observers in full light and with no visible means of accomplishing it. Spirits whistling a tune, using a megaphone, and sending a curtain rod sailing around the room. They also claimed the transportation of a live pigeon through solid matter. They are fulsome, gushing reports of nothing, and to intimate that a live pigeon had been brought into the room from the outside, passing through glass or brick without making or leaving an aperture, is doing something which a magazine with such a reputation for conservativeness and accuracy as the "Scientific American" should avoid, even though the idea is covered.
Shortly after the appearance of the articles, I received the following letter from Mr. Bird:
233 Broadway, New York.
June 18, 1924.
Mr. Harry Houdini,
278 West 113th St.,
New York City.
My Dear Mr. Houdini:
As you will observe when you get your July "Scientific American," we are engaged in the
investigation of another case of mediumship. Our original idea was not to bother you with
it unless, and until, it got to a stage where there seemed serious prospects that it was
either genuine, or a type of fraud which our other Committeemen could not deal with.
Regardless of whether it turns out good or bad, there will be several extremely interesting
stories in it for the "Scientific American" and these will run in the August and following
Mr. Munn feels that the case has taken a turn which makes it desirable for us to
discuss it with you. Won't you run in, at your convenience, to take lunch with one or both of us,
and have a talk with Mr. Munn? Better call me in advance, and make sure that he and I will be in at the time you select.
J. Malcolm Bird,
P.S. Mr. Munn left the office today, to be gone until Monday morning.
I made the appointment requested in the letter and on meeting Mr. O.D. Munn he explained
that he had been anxious to get in touch with me, and in fact had been trying for a week,
but Bird had been sidestepping the matter, and that he thought we should go to Boston together
and sit in at the "Margery" séances. After we had talked the matter over he called Bird
into his office and turning to him I asked point blank:
"Do you believe this medium is genuine?"
I asked him this because, although a raw amateur at investigating, which amounts to a profession in itself, and with no experience with or knowledge of "the production of mysteries" he had nevertheless, given his approval to several mediums and failed to detect their conjuring trick methods. His reply, as near as I can remember, was:
"Why, yes, she is genuine. She does resort to trickery at times, but I believe she is fifty or sixty percent genuine."
"Then you mean that this medium will be entitled to get the "Scientific American "prize?" I asked.
"Mr. Bird," I replied, "you have nothing to lose but your position and very
likely you can readily get another if you are wring, but if I am wrong it will mean the
loss of reputation and as I have been selected to be one of the Committee I do not think
it will be fair for you to give this medium that award unless I am permitted to go up the
Boston and investigate her claims, and from what you tell me I am certain that this medium
is either the most wonderful in the world or else a very clever deceptionist. If she is a
fraudulent medium I will guarantee to expose her and if she is genuine I will come back and
be one of her most strenuous supporters."
Then turning to Mr. O.D. Munn, I said:
"If you give this award to a medium without the strictest examination every fraudulent medium in the world will take advantage of it. I will forfeit a thousand dollars if I do not detect her if she resorts to trickery. Of course if she is genuine there is nothing to expose, but if the "Scientific American" by any accident should declare her genuine and she was eventually detected in fraud we would be the laughing stock of the world, and in the meantime hundreds of fraudulent mediums would have taken advantage of the error."
This was the condition of affairs on July 23, 1924, when Mr. O.D. Munn and I
reached Boston, where Bird had preceded us by auto and was the guest of the medium and
her husband, as he had been previously for weeks at a stretch, at times accompanied by Mrs. Bird
and at other times alone. Carrington had also spent a number of weeks in the family, but, although we had dinner with the Crandons, Mr. O.D. Munn and I stopped at a hotel, for I agree fully with Dr. Prince that it is not possible to stop at one's house, break bread with him frequently, then investigate him and render an impartial verdict.
"Well then you and I will go up together and see," he replied.
"All right, I am at your service," I told him.
We were given to understand that this first séance which I attended on the evening of Wednesday, July 23rd, was the forty-eighth in which Mrs. Crandon had been tested, but I learned later from a letter written by her husband that it was nearer the eightieth, and by the time Mr. O.D. Munn and I had finished our fifth séance Dr. Crandon claimed that the total was ninety. All séances were dark.
At this séance Dr. Crandon sat on the medium's right and held her right hand and J. Malcolm Bird, as had been customary in their previous séances, circled with one of his hands the fingers of both the medium and her husband. This left one of Bird's hands free for "exploring purposes" as he said.
I sat on the left of Mrs. Crandon and held her left hand with my right. My right foot was placed against her left foot, pressing against her ankle.
Anticipating the sort of work I would have to do in detecting the movements of her foot I had rolled my right trouser leg up above my knee. All that day I had worn a silk rubber bandage around that leg just below the knee. By night the part of the leg below the bandage had become swollen and painfully tender, thus giving me a much keener sense of feeling and making it easier to notice the slightest sliding of Mrs. Crandon's ankle or flexing of her muscles. She wore silk stockings and during the séance had her skirts pulled well up above her knees.
One of the successful demonstrations which she had been giving and which none of the Committee had been able to expose, involved the use of an electric bell enclosed in a box fourteen inches long by six wide and five deep.
This box was stoutly fastened on all sides except the top which was covered with boards. Inside the box with the bell were dry batteries which rang it whenever a certain pressure at the top of the box completed the circuit. In previous séances when this box had been placed in front of Mrs. Crandon and the sitters supposed they had her perfectly controlled (held hands and feet so they could detect any motion) the bell had been rung repeatedly and the explanation given was that "Walter," the medium's dead brother, had closed the circuit. Not only had the bell been rung but it had been used with a code and answered questions.
On the evening in question the bell-box was placed between my feet with my right foot between it and Mrs. Crandon's left foot. As the séance progressed I could distinctly feel her ankle slowly and spasmodically sliding as it pressed against mine while she gained space to raise her foot off the floor and touch the top of the box. To the ordinary sense of touch the contract would seem the same while this was being done. At times she would say:
"Just press hard against my ankle so you can see that my ankle is there," and as she pressed I could feel her gain another half inch.
When she had finally maneuvered her foot around to a point where she could get at the top of the box the bell ringing began and I positively felt the tendons of her leg flex and tighten as she repeatedly touched the ringing apparatus. There is no question in my mind about it. She did this. Then, when the ringing was over, I plainly felt her leg slide back into its original position with her foot on the floor beside mine.
During the second intermission "Walter" asked for an illuminated plaque to be placed on the lid of the box which held the bell and Bird went to get it. This left the right hand and foot of the medium free. Bird had difficulty in finding the plaque and while he was searching "Walter" suddenly called for "control."
Mrs. Crandon placed her right hand in mine and gave me to understand that I had
both her hands. Bird was requested to stand in the doorway, but without any warning,
before he could obey, the cabinet was thrown over backwards violently. The medium then
gave me her right foot also saying:
"You have now both hands and both feet."
The way she did these two tricks is as follows: when Bird left the room it freed her
right foot and hand. With her right hand she tilted the corner of the cabinet enough
to get her free foot under it, then picking up the megaphone she placed it on her head,
dunce-cap fashion. Then she threw the cabinet over with her right foot. As she did so I
distinctly felt her body give and sway as though she had made a vigorous lunge. As soon
as this was done "Walter" called for "better control" and she gave me her right foot. Then she
simply jerked her head, causing the megaphone to fall at my feet. Of course with the
megaphone on her head it was easy and simple for her to ask me or anyone else to hold both
of her feet and also her hands, and still she could snap the megaphone off her head in
any direction requested. This is the "slickest" ruse I have ever detected, and it has
converted all skeptics.
Then "Walter" called out:
"The megaphone is in the air. Have Houdini tell me where to throw it."
"Toward me," I replied, and in an instant it fell at my feet.
The next day Mrs. Crandon told us it would be impossible to either kick or push the cabinet over as it was hinged on the inside and would double up in the middle, but that afternoon Mr. O.D. Munn and I went upstairs alone and while sitting in the medium's chair I put my right foot under the right-hand corner of the cabinet and easily tilted it so that the slightest movement caused it to fall over.
The second séance of Mrs. Crandon's which I attended was on the
evening of July 24th, at Professor Comstock's hotel. At this time I discovered
without question that she used her head and shoulders to push back the table. Her great
asset in disguising the muscular movements which she uses in doing this is the arm chair
in which she sits. As she is unusually strong and has an athletic body she can press her wrists so firmly on the arms of the chair that she can move her body and sway it at will without the sitters, who have hold of her hands, detecting the movement.
That evening I was in charge of her left hand which rested lightly on the palm of my right. With my index finger I could feel her pulse. In fact I used the secret system of the "touch and tactics" of the mind or muscle performer, (I had given performances or tests in this field of mystery) who is guided by the slightest muscular indication in finding a hidden article. I was able to detect almost every time she made a move. Frequently she stretched out her arms to rest them and once I caught her using this motion as a subterfuge, leaving only her elbow on the chair while she pushed the table with her head.
"Walter," her guide and aide, is very autocratic, seldom asking anything but usually directing, and this evening he ordered everyone to move back from the table around which we were sitting so that he might gather force. This was simply another ruse on the medium's part, for when all the rest moved back she moved back also and this gave her room enough to bend her head and push the table up and over. I caught her doing this twice.
Before going to the séance Mr. O.D. Munn and I had determined to explore things to our satisfaction and had arranged a code of signals. At the séance he sat at my left in the circle, I holding his right hand. At the first movement of the table I pushed his hand under it and let go and began groping around with my left hand. As I did so I felt Mrs. Crandon's head at the edge of the table pushing it up and forward until the box with the bell had slipped off to the floor. I reached over and whispered to Mr. O.D. Munn what I had detected. Then to check up and assure myself of the deception I reached out again into the dark and she ran her head directly against my outstretched fingers. I do not think she was more surprised than I. She then said something about losing hairpins and after the séance her hair was loosened. This was done for effect and to offset my discovery.
While I knew she was still using her head, I pulled Mr. O.D. Munn's ear to my lips again and whispered:
"Will I denounce and expose her now?"
After this demonstration the bell-ringing test was gone through again. The box was placed between my feet with her ankle against my right foot like the night before. I had rolled my trousers up as on the previous evening. She began with exactly the same tactics, but nothing happened. Finally she said to me:
"You had better wait a while," he replied.
"Now is the time," I urged.
"No, better not for a while," he answered.
"You have garters on, haven't you?"
"Yes," I replied.
"Well, the buckle hurts me," she said.
I reached down to undo the garter and found that the buckle had caught her stocking so fast that it prevented her from sliding her ankle enough to get room to tap the bell. After I took the garter off she was able to reach the bell as she had the previous night. When the spirit asked Mr. O.D. Munn how many times he wanted the bell rung and Mr. Munn said "five," she made so bold a sliding movement with her ankle to reach the box that I think she was under the impression that I was badly fooled or was going to help her like others. After the five taps on the bell she slid her foot back into position on the floor beside mine.
When the séance was over Mrs. Crandon left the room to dress for the street. I had Mr. O.D. Munn call the Committee into a room by themselves and I explained the trickery which I had discovered and there was a discussion as to whether I should expose the medium then or after our return to New York. The Committee finally decided that we should return to New York first; that Mrs. Crandon was not to be informed that I had detected her, and I was to make an affidavit for the Committee covering the details of my discoveries. Bird opposed my demands to have her exposed as quickly as possible, but I called his attention to the rapid exposure he had given the others and he replied:
"We will do it different this time."
I strongly suspected his motives and told Mr. O.D. Munn so after we had left.