Comments on: Watch the Full Episode

By: Linda Collison

Linda Collison — Sun, 24 May 2009 18:54:06 +0000

rita and debra g, you have to look at everything in its historical context. “The Floating Brothel” upon which Voyage of the Courtesans was based, was one of the many books I read while researching Star-Crossed (Knopf, 2006), the story of an 18th-century orphaned British teen who narrowly avoided becoming one of these women.

By: Sarah Thorn

Sarah Thorn — Sun, 17 May 2009 18:13:39 +0000

While prostitution is by no means a career that a parent would wish upon their child, I feel that this was the safest option available to these women. Had they not agreed to prostitution they probably would have been raped and overall abused. Many of these women would have died on the journey to Australia. By becoming prostitutes these women allowed themselves to become in charge of their situation as much as they could. I know that this goes against a lot of people’s basic beliefs and morals, but I think that we need to ask ourselves what we would have done in the same situation. I think that we can all remember the news story of the man who chopped his own arm off when it became wedged in a crack away from the beaten trail. We can’t judge these women fairly, I believe, until we have been in a similar situation.
I also think that the overall story off how Australia was a penal colony is inspiring in itself. What was once a place where no ‘respectable’ person would go is now as much of a part of the ‘respectable’ world as any other country. When we think of Australia today we think of surfing, kangaroos, Crocodile Dundee, and the 2000 Olympics not convicts. I feel that this story of settlement makes Australia all the more unique.

By: edwina o'donnell

edwina o'donnell — Tue, 05 May 2009 20:18:05 +0000

I wonder how many countries and areas have been settled by women such as these. Times were hard, life was hideous in England then and it is the oldest trade in the world which many men were users. Excellent history lesson (I have so often wondered about Australia and its strange beginnings with the castoffs of society. Hope this is shown again, as I missed the episode.

By: rita

rita — Wed, 29 Apr 2009 13:35:13 +0000

While this story is interesting it is hardly encouraging. I use no feminist or religious beliefs to guide my opinion. These women were selling sex and its expected that we should look upon them honorably? Them and the men who sought their services should have been lynched.

By: debra g

debra g — Sun, 26 Apr 2009 22:22:35 +0000

Terry Wambolt.I would like to ask this person what century are you from?Because woman are not here just to serve man.Woman can do any thing a man can do work wise I say.Not just to bear children and keep a household.I just wish men could go through what us women do.But theses days in the 20th&21 century we have done alot.And as far as the Courtesans they must have been very strong woman and have alot of guts to surive the voyage all the way to Australian.And to make a new life for them selfs.We were once called the weaker sex.But were never were the weaker sex.We are strong and can do what needs done no matter what.As someone said along time ago a mans work is from sun to sun a womans work is never done.And I’m so looking forward to watching thei programe this week .TY

By: darrel armstrong

darrel armstrong — Sun, 19 Apr 2009 19:21:30 +0000

For those of you interested in a more balanced view of the American frontier, I strongly recommend looking into the contributions made by these women’s counterparts here…American history and historical archaeology have told a very different story than bluenosed ‘official’ versions. In the late 19th century our town had within the space of a few city blocks a fairly conventional old boy’s club city hall, at least two red light districts that served it, and the nation’s first Congresswoman. There’s much more to the social changes of the ‘civilizing’ of the West than ranch wives, spinster school marms and church women. Let’s tell all the tales. A community without women has no roots.
all

By: lynda

lynda — Sat, 18 Apr 2009 21:03:03 +0000

Terry,
There’s a difference?

By: Christina

Christina — Thu, 26 Mar 2009 17:01:36 +0000

I just caught this episode last night, happened to be flipping channels. I am always intrigued by events & situations that start out in wretchedness and, ultimately, prove victorious. I am today doing more research on both Sydney and these women, and posting an article about them on my website,God, History and You

By: alan eggleston

alan eggleston — Sun, 26 Oct 2008 01:07:08 +0000

interesting story; it should be remembered that a key factor in establishing the penal colony at Sydney Cove 1n 1778 was that the American Declaration of Independence in 1776 meant that convicts could no longer be transported to the American Colonies and the Colony of New South Wales was established in part to relieve the overcrowding in Jails

By: Cindy Warner

Cindy Warner — Tue, 07 Oct 2008 21:41:50 +0000

Having played a courtesan in Rigoletto at a Carnival party I have to wonder why operas continually feature courtesans only to punish them. Is this an Italian thing, the morality play punishing self serving women by having them die alone? Or at least have their party ruined by an outraged count putting a curse on the whole shebang since his daughter was ravaged and his family name besmirched? Killjoy. Actually he gets punished too as we see him led off to the dungeon. So being good is subjective, it’s a trial by fire. If you succeed, then good for you to be so clever. Indeed in Rigoletto the duke is a rake and he gets away with it all, singing blissfully about how women are so fickle they are like feathers in the breeze . . . always lying even when they are smiling. Keep smiling girls.