New Allegations of Prisoner Abuse at Rikers Island

Share:

May 16, 2012

The Village Voice recently published startling new images of inmate abuse as part of the paper’s ongoing investigation into violence at New York’s Rikers Island jail.

In 2008, the paper first published allegations that Rikers guards were staging a “fight club” for the inmates, some of whom were teenagers. Reporter Graham Rayman writes that in what was known as “the Program”:

… guards were deputizing inmates, often in the teen jail, and pitting them against one another in fights as a way to keep order and extort them for phone, food, and television privileges.

The new photos show gaping wounds to inmates’ faces from knives or beatings, and the Voice reports that “several sources, including current and retired investigators, say that the practice is very much still in place.” The paper also obtained “hundreds of internal Correction Department documents” from 2009 to 2012 that show the influence gangs have on the jail, particularly in the area where the teenagers are housed.

Jail officials say they put new controls in place after “the Program” was initially exposed to prevent it from happening again, including reducing the guard-inmate ratio and assigning officers to staff rooms where inmates spent time during the day, the article said. The Corrections Department strongly denied that “the Program” was still going on, with  Spokeswoman Sharman Stein describing the allegations as “patently false.” Stein acknowledged that bullying occurs at the prison, but said, “This is not a department that is looking the other way.”

According to the Voice, the Justice Department’s civil rights division has been investigating the violence at Rikers and investigators have subpoenaed “more than a year’s worth of incident reports in the effort.”


Sarah Childress

Sarah Childress, Former Series Senior Editor, FRONTLINE

More Stories

Coming This Fall on FRONTLINE
Plus: How you can support our journalism at a critical time for public media. Read a message from FRONTLINE Editor-in-Chief & Executive Producer Raney Aronson-Rath.
October 1, 2025
What the O.J. Verdict & Its Aftermath Revealed About Race in America
On the 30th anniversary of a verdict that shook the U.S., revisit a seminal FRONTLINE documentary on the stark truths and lasting impact of the O.J. Simpson trial, now streaming on YouTube for the first time.
October 1, 2025
Exclusive: Iran Won't Allow Nuclear Inspections if Sanctions Are Reimposed, Says Iran’s Chief Nuclear Negotiator
In an exclusive interview with FRONTLINE, Iran’s chief nuclear negotiator said the country will end its participation in international weapons inspections if sanctions are reimposed.
September 26, 2025