Climbing without O's
by John B. West, M.D., Ph.D.
The successful ascent of Everest without supplementary oxygen is one of
the great sagas of the 20th century. In addition to being a triumph of
the human spirit, it raises some of the most intriguing questions in
Ever since I was invited by Sir Edmund Hillary to take part in the Himalayan
Scientific and Mountaineering Expedition of 1960-1961 I have had a special
interest in the critical factors that allow climbers to reach extreme altitudes—particularly the summit of Everest—without supplementary oxygen. Back in
1960, Messner and Habeler had yet
to make their ascent of Everest without
supplemental oxygen, and many believed that it was physiologically impossible.
Over the course of our scientific expedition more than three decades ago, a
group of physiologists spent about five months at an altitude of 5800 m (19,000
ft) on a glacier about 10 miles south of Mt. Everest. We lived in a
prefabricated hut known as the "Silver Hut" because of its color. The
scientific leader was Dr. Griffith Pugh and we made an extensive study of the
process of acclimatization to this very high altitude.
In the spring, we were joined by a climbing party who attempted
(unsuccessfully) to reach the summit of Makalu (8481 m) without supplementary
oxygen. A bicycle ergometer (which measures the amount of work done by the
exercising subject) was assembled on the Makalu Col just east of Everest and we
made measurements of maximal work capacity at an altitude of 7440 m (24,400
ft). These remain the highest measurements of work capacity ever made on a
When the line relating maximal oxygen consumption to altitude was
extrapolated all the way to the summit of Mt. Everest, it looked as though the
mountain could not be climbed without supplementary oxygen. The same conclusion
had been reached by other physiologists in the 1930s.
Therefore when Messner and Habeler finally made their "oxygenless" ascent in
1978, we naturally wondered how they did it.
When we planned the 1981 American Medical Research Expedition to
Everest, we ambitiously decided to try to make a few measurements on
the summit to try to answer that question. We identified three critical
measurements. The first was the atmospheric pressure, because it was clear that the amount of work that a
climber could do was extremely sensitive to this; atmospheric pressure
determines how much oxygen is in the air, and the lower the pressure, the lower
the amount of oxygen. Furthermore, some physiologists had previously predicted
the pressure on the summit from the so-called Standard Atmosphere and we knew
that this was far too low based on measurements made at lower altitudes on
In any case, the first direct measurement of atmospheric pressure on the summit
was made on our expedition by Dr. Christopher Pizzo, and the figure of 253 mmHg
was rather higher than even we expected—suggesting that there was more
oxygen at the summit of Everest than you would predict from theory.
This year, David Breashears was able to take another measurement on the
summit. As soon as we are able to check the calibration of the instrument we will know more
about this critically important variable—and therefore have a better sense
of how much oxygen is actually available at the tallest point on earth.
The second critical variable was the extent to which the climbers increased
their ventilation, because this process maintains the oxygen
level in the alveoli in the depths of the lung at a viable level. Pizzo
measured his ventilation by taking samples of air from the depths of
his lung while sitting on the Everest summit. The results showed that
he had increased his ventilation about five to six-fold, which was much more
than we expected.
The third critical measurement was the maximal oxygen consumption on
the summit. Previous predictions were that this was insufficient for a climber
to reach the summit without supplementary oxygen. It was not possible to put a
bicycle ergometer on the top of Mt. Everest; there is a limit to what can be
done in the field! However we had extremely well-acclimatized climbers breathe
14% oxygen (normal air has 21%) in our laboratory at 6300 m (21,000 ft). The
low inspired oxygen mixture gave them the same oxygen pressure as on the
Everest summit. We found that the maximal oxygen consumption was about one
liter per minute. This is a miserable value, equivalent to that of someone
walking slowly on level ground. However it is just sufficient to allow a
climber to reach the summit without supplementary oxygen. A simulated climb of
Everest carried out in a low-pressure chamber four years later (Operation
Everest II) found almost exactly the same maximal oxygen consumption.
Although we now have a much clearer idea of how a climber can make an
"oxygenless" ascent of Mt. Everest, a number of areas of ignorance remain. One
is the degree to which the blood becomes alkaline
as a result of the extreme increase in ventilation. Pizzo's measurements
suggested a very severe degree of alkalinity which interestingly enough helps
to load oxygen onto the blood in the lung. However some people have challenged
this finding and we badly need more data.
Another area of ignorance is whether the body produces lactate—a normal
byproduct of exercise—under these conditions of extreme oxygen deprivation.
Making lactate allows the muscles to do work in the absence of oxygen.
Exercising muscles normally produce large amounts of lactate when they are
starved of oxygen. Paradoxically, this does not seem to be the case in
acclimatized people at extreme altitude. Indeed, predictions based on
measurements at somewhat lower altitudes suggest that no lactate at all is
produced near the summit of Mt. Everest.
John West is Professor of Medicine and Physiology in the School of Medicine,
University of California San Diego. He was a physiologist on Sir Edmund
Hillary's Silver Hut expedition in 1960-1961, and led the 1981 American Medical
Research Expedition to Everest.
Photos: (1,2) Liesl Clark; (3) David Breashears; (4) Ed Viesturs; (5) J. West.
Lost on Everest |
High Exposure |
History & Culture |
Earth, Wind, & Ice
Previous Expeditions |
Site Map |
Editor's Picks |
Previous Sites |
Join Us/E-mail |
About NOVA |
Site Map |
PBS Online |
NOVA Online |
© | Updated November 2000