tehranbureau An independent source of news on Iran and the Iranian diaspora

Grand Ayatollah Rejects Election Results

18 Jun 2009 13:314 Comments

Girls holding posters of Ayatollahs Beheshti, Khomeini and Montazeri at a rally in Tehran, circa 1980. Photo/ J. Javid

Grand Ayatollah Hossein Ali Montazeri Rejects the Results of the Election


TEHRAN BUREAU | As I described in a previous article, Mir Hossein Mousavi, the main reformist candidate, wrote a letter to important clerics, asking them to declare their opinion about the results of Iran's presidential election of June 12.

A very important development in this respect has been a response to that letter from Grand Ayatollah Hossein Ali Montazeri, the most important and senior ayatollah living in Iran. He was one of the leaders of the 1979 Revolution, and a strong critic of the hard-liners. He has issued a statement rejecting the results of the presidential elections of June 12, and has warned the nation that they should not provide any excuse to those who intend to create an atmosphere of fear and repression in the country by setting fire on people's property and creating chaos. The following is a translation of that statement begins by saying,

"Over the last several days I have been witnessing the glowing presence and the lively and sacrificial efforts of my dear and dignified sisters and brothers, old and young, in the campaign for the 10th presidential elections. Our youth also demonstrated their presence in the political scene with hope and good spirit, in order to achieve their rightful demands. They waited patiently night and day. This was an excellent occasion for the government's officials to take advantage of and establish religious, emotional and nationalistic bonds with our youth and the rest of our people.

"Unfortunately, however, this opportunity was wasted in the worst possible way. Such election results were declared that no wise person in their right mind can believe; results based on credible evidence and witnesses has been altered extensively, and after strong protests by the people against such acts -- the same people who have carried the heavy weight and burden of the Revolution during eight years of war and resisted the tanks of the imperial government [of the Shah] and those of the enemy [Iraq] -- they attacked the children of the same people and nation right in front of the domestic and foreign reporters, and used astonishing violence against defenseless men and women and the dear [university] students, injuring and arresting them. And, now, they are trying to purge activists, intellectuals, and political opponents by arresting a large number of them, some of whom have even held high positions in the government of the Islamic Republic."

The statement then describes what the Ayatollah describes as his religious and national duty, based on a Quran's Surah.

The letter continues:

"A characteristic of a strong and legitimate government -- Islamic or not -- is that it is capable of respecting all opinions, whether they support it or oppose it. This is necessary for any political system, in order to embrace all social classes and encourage them to participate in the affairs of their nation, and not dismiss and repulse them and, therefore, increase their numbers [the opponents'] every day. I am afraid that because the regime is considered a religious government, such acts of its officials will lead to the loss of people's faith in their religion, and will hurt Islam.

"The present circumstances and problems that have been created after the elections have astounded the people and made them pessimistic [about their government]. They expect the officials, based on their moral and religious teachings, to be neutral and demonstrate their honesty by protecting people's rights, particularly about such an important issue [the elections]. It is expected of the government to find an acceptable and reasonable response to people's demands, and by using the right approach eliminate people's pessimism and doubts. Otherwise, people will lose their trust in the government, and the government's legitimacy will become questionable. I have said repeatedly that the nation's votes are valuable popular and Godly assets, and any government that is based on altering them has no legitimacy.

"I ask everybody, particularly our dear youth, to continue claiming their demands with patience and to be careful and alert about keeping the peace and the nation's security, by avoiding any kind of violence, in order not to provide any excuse to the thugs who wish to distort their lawful demands, thugs that are embedded among the people and by setting fire on people's property and creating chaos and destruction wish to create a besieged atmosphere in the country. It is necessary to have an informed presence in the political arena, so as to allow those candidates whose rights have been denied to pursue the legal path.

"I remind all officials and security and military personnel that they should preserve their religion and not sell it out for the sake of others, and be aware that the excuse that they have been ordered [to act unlawfully] will never be accepted by the great God. They should consider people's protesting children like their own, and avoid any irresponsible and inhumane confrontation [with them], and by learning from the past be aware that sooner or later those who commit unjust acts against people will be punished both in this world and the next. It is not possible in this era to hide the truth from the people by censorship and cutting off telecommunication communications between them.

"I end by wishing success for everyone in serving Islam and Muslims, and pray for the honor and greatness of the Iranian nation."

Given the wide popularity of Ayatollah Montazeri among the people, his impeccable reputation for honesty and piety, and his courage for standing up to Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini in 1988 for executing thousands of political prisoners, the statement will provide a religious moral basis for those protesting the official results of the election, and will do much to deflate from the propaganda of the hard-liners who are calling the protesters thugs and agents of foreign governments, and acting against Islam.

Two other important ayatollahs, Ayatollah Abdolkarim Mousavi Ardabili, a close aid to Ayatollah Khomeini and the Chief Justice when he was living, and Ayatollah Asadollah Bayaat Zanjani, also issued statements in support of Mr. Mousavi, the main reformist candidate; they have rejected and harshly criticized the official results.

Copyright (c) 2009 Tehran Bureau

SHAREtwitterfacebookSTUMBLEUPONbalatarin reddit digg del.icio.us


If every demonstrator were to carry just one little white pebble, about 3cm in circumference to Tehran's Freedom Square, and then leave it there in the middle of the square, then the accumulated pile of small white pebbles would make a huge statement. Imagine 144,000 pebbles, one for each of 144,000 demonstrators, in one public pile? It would be, if my caclulations are correct, a pile of white pebbles 3 meters by 3 meters by 3 meters.

What could be wrong with carrying a white pebble? That's how the ancients voted -- by various colored stones. The significance would be overwhelming!

DR. G / June 18, 2009 11:59 AM


carpus / June 20, 2009 3:55 PM

The supreme leader is a jackoff

Tim / June 20, 2009 4:21 PM


Obama is not a chicken! The president of the USA is a genius and he knows what he is doing! The Green Wave Revolution is thirty years in to the making. It is a political chess game and President Obama is well aware of what is at stake. He knows how to play this political chess game.

We are with the Iranian people! If I was there, I would be doing exactly what they are doing. Fighting for the right to Democracy. I am a minority in the USA and I know what they are going through and my heart goes out to them. They are doing exactly what they want to do. It reminds me of the South Koreans. Go to youtube.com and look up the South Korean students and you will know what I mean. There is also the Orange Revolution who recently did what was unthinkable. But, remember, these people were reformist opposed to the USSR and the situation in Iran is different. So, those of you in Iran, may ALLAH be with you! It is smarter to work collectively than to waste you time on one person...

chillingaz / June 24, 2009 3:54 AM