Otto Warmbier’s death looms over U.S.-China talks on North Korea
WASHINGTON — Otto Warmbier’s death after returning from North Korean imprisonment is stoking outrage in Washington and threatening to overshadow high-level U.S.-Chinese talks Wednesday.
President Donald Trump has been counting on China to use its economic leverage with Kim Jong Un’s totalitarian government as American concern grows over North Korea’s acceleration toward having a nuclear-tipped missile that can strike the U.S. mainland.
Top U.S. and Chinese diplomats and defense chiefs are meeting in the U.S. capital for security talks, and North Korea will get “top billing,” according to Susan Thornton, the senior U.S. diplomat for East Asia. The two world powers are trying to build on “positive momentum” created when Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping met in Florida in April, she said.
Wednesday’s discussions replace a sprawling strategic and economic dialogue held annually under the Obama administration. It rarely produced significant results. This year’s edition separates out the security aspects, and Secretary of State State Rex Tillerson and Secretary of Defense Jim Mattis are hosting Chinese foreign policy chief Yang Jiechi and Gen. Fang Fenghui, chief of the People’s Liberation Army’s joint staff department.
Thornton said talks would cover the South China Sea, where Beijing’s island-building and construction of possible military facilities have rattled neighbors and caused tension with Washington; U.S.-Chinese military cooperation to reduce risk of conflict; and efforts to defeat the Islamic State group. Divisive trade issues will be tackled separately at a later date.
While Trump has heaped praise on Xi for trying to contain North Korea, which counts on China for some 90 percent of its trade, the effort has delivered few results. Trump appeared to acknowledge as much in a tweet Wednesday, a day after Warmbier’s death.
“While I greatly appreciate the efforts of President Xi & China to help with North Korea, it has not worked out. At least I know China tried!” Trump wrote.
No cause of death has been determined for Warmbier, 22, who was detained for nearly a year-and-a-half in North Korea before being sent home in a coma last week. The University of Virginia student was accused of trying to steal a propaganda banner while visiting with a tour group and was convicted of subversion. His family is blaming North Korea for “awful, torturous mistreatment.”
President Trump condemned the death of 22-year-old American student Otto Warmbier — who was released from North Korean detention in a coma — and seemed to abandon his goal of enlisting China to pressure the regime. How does Warmbier’s tragic end affect the U.S. approach? John Yang explores what’s at stake with Kathleen Stephens, former U.S. ambassador to South Korea.
From Capitol Hill to the White House, pressure is mounting for a tough U.S. response. The Trump administration is considering banning travel by U.S. citizens to North Korea, officials said Tuesday, and Trump declared Warmbier’s treatment a “total disgrace.”
Like past presidents, Trump is finding the U.S. has limited scope for punishing North Korea, particularly over the arrest of U.S. citizens.
A ban on Americans visiting North Korea would only slightly add to Pyongyang’s isolation and loss of revenue. The route to inflicting significant economic pain on Kim’s government remains through China.
Thornton said the U.S. will be seeking “concrete cooperation” with China on getting North Korea to abandon its nuclear and missile programs and return to negotiations. Such talks are a seemingly distant goal since Kim is believed to see his weapons of mass destruction as a guarantee against invasion.
North Korea hasn’t conducted a nuclear test explosion as feared earlier this year — a possible consequence of Chinese pressure — but it has kept up its rapid pace of missile launches, drawing another U.N. Security Council resolution this month and additional sanctions.
Last week, Tillerson told a Senate hearing that China’s efforts on North Korea had been “uneven.” On Tuesday, Thornton cited Chinese restrictions on imports of North Korean coal as “notable” progress. But she said the U.S. wants more action against blacklisted North Korean companies doing business through China.
Washington has one threat it can use with Beijing: The possibility of “secondary” sanctions that go after Chinese companies doing business in North Korea. Such a move risks fraying relations between the world’s two biggest economies.
Beijing, which wants resumed U.S. negotiations with North Korea, is hoping for “positive outcomes” from Wednesday’s dialogue, Chinese foreign ministry spokesman Geng Shuang said.
Associated Press writer Richard Lardner contributed to this report.