Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
Citizens Respond to Hate Talk About it Get Involved About Us
Newark CA
Sacramento CA
Redding CA
Anderson CA
Los Altos CA
Illinois
Missoula MT
Olympia WA
More Stories

On July 1, 1999 -- less than two weeks after the firebombing of three Sacramento-area synagogues -- Gary Matson, and his partner Winfield Scott Mowder were shot to death Matson and Mowder in their home near Redding, CA. Four days later, brothers Benjamin Matthew Williams and James Tyler Willliams, who were under investigation in the arson attacks, were arrested on suspicion of murder. The brothers had ties to white supremacist groups, and had espoused anti-Semitic and anti-gay beliefs.

A popular and prominent couple, the slayings shocked and horrified the community of Redding. But they also prompted people of divergent faiths and backgrounds to hold a first-ever unity rally. The community joined together to not only express their sorrow over the loss of two beloved and esteemed friends, but also to send a clear message that hate has no home in Redding, California.

Two Pillars of the Community Slain
Gary Matson and Winfield Scott Mowder lived in veritable paradise on their lush farm in Happy Valley, on the outskirts of Redding. Matson helped start the Redding Farmers Market, a community garden to feed the hungry, an arboretum and Carter House, a natural science museum for schoolchildren. Mowder became a loving parent to Matson's daughter Clea, and he spoke at local high schools about what it was like to be gay. Their murders were a dramatic loss for the community, who found inspiration in the two men.
[Watch the Video 56k | 200k]

A Victim's Daughter Speaks Out
Gary Matson's college-aged daughter Clea wondered why it mattered to people that Scott and Gary were gay. "I wish now I had told people about my family Gary Matson's daughter Clea but when I was little," she said. "I knew they wouldn't understand. My friends in school have always been religious. It's just a very religious community. Now I wish I'd told them, because they were my friends. If I'd let them get to know Dad and Scott, they would have learned something."
[Watch the Video 56k | 200k]

Read and participate in a conversation with relatives of hate crime victims.

A Community Remembers
Two weeks after the slayings, the community held a memorial rally for Matson and Mowder, the likes of which had never been seen before in Redding. Four Community rally hundred people gathered to protest hate and intolerance. Four dozen religious leaders from different faiths joined onstage to lead a public mourning for the loss of two good friends, and to open a dialogue about tolerance for gays and lesbians in a community that belongs to all of its citizens. Gay activists, spiritual leaders and local conservative politicians all expressed outrage over the murders, and publicly took a stand against hate crimes of every kind.
[Watch the Video 56k | 200k]

Find out how you can get involved.

Update
Five days after the killing of Gary Matson and Winfield Mowder, two brothers, Benjamin Matthew Williams and James Tyler Williams, who had ties to white supremacist groups, were charged with the double homicide. When the Williams brothers' house was later searched, police discovered a cache of weapons and extensive hate literature. Evidence eventually also linked the Williams brothers' to the Sacramento synagogue arsons.

In March 2003, James Tyler Williams was sentenced to at least 33 years in state prison for the 1999 double homicide. He will begin serving the murder sentence after he completes his 21-year sentence in federal prison for the Sacramento synagogue arsons. Williams will be eligible for his first parole hearing in 2053, sometime around his 82nd birthday. On November 17, 2003, Benjamin Matthew Williams was found dead in his cell after committing suicide. He was awaiting trail for the murders of Matson and Mowder.

On the fifth anniversary of the Redding gay couple's death, loved ones and families attended an emotional Shabbat service at Congregation B'nai Israel in Sacramento. Rabbi Brad Bloom dedicated the service to the memory of the gay couple and wanted to unite the communities of Redding and Sacramento who were both victimized by the Williams' brothers.

"I really appreciate Rabbi Bloom's efforts, and the fact that he is willing to reach out toward gays and lesbians and toward the issue of intolerance," says Brian Matson, Gary Matson' brother. "Gary would certainly appreciate that very much." Ten family members of the Redding gay couple attended the healing ceremony, along with local elected officials, members of the police and FBI.

Back to top>>


Pillars of the Community Video
56k - 220k
Community Reaction Video
56k - 220k
Victims Daughter Video
56k - 220k
Williams Bros. News Chronology
To purchase a tape or DVD, visit theworkinggroup.org