|
What do the numbers really mean?
If you've seen ANTIQUES ROADSHOW UK, you may have wondered before
exactly how the experts assign values to objects they examine on the
show... and what those numbers mean.
Though it may seem a bit flip at first, in many ways the only correct
answer to the question "What's this worth?" is "It depends." There are
so many variables: age, initial quality, and condition of the object
itself; changes in the market; even geographysomething may be worth
more in London than New York, or more in Texas than in Boston.
Then there's the context of the value an expert places on an object. We
encourage viewers to listen carefully to the qualifiers, phrases
like"at auction, I'd expect this to bring..." and "If I had this in my
shop I'd price it at..." and "I'd suggest you insure this for..."they can
make a big difference.
You could consider an auction sale price to be roughly the same thing as
a wholesale price. An auction house typically takes a 10 to 15 percent
commissiona "buyer's premium," added to the price the high bidder pays.
There may be a similar commission charged to the seller. An auction
estimate is likely to be conservative, at the lower end of the expected
price range, perhaps to encourage bidding and keep sellers' expectations
realistic. Of course, when highly motivated people bid against each
other for an itemor "lot," as it is known in the tradethe final price
may have nothing to do with anyone's expectations. On the other hand, if
there's little interest, the lot may sell for less than the estimate, or
even "pass"not be sold.
Conversely, you might think of a dealer's price as retail value. Unlike
auction houses, a dealer keeps an inventory, perhaps for long periods;
when you want to buy a piece at a specific time, he's had it there for
you. Depending on market conditions, a dealer may routinely mark things
up from 30 to 100 percent ... something to keep in mind if you want to
sell an item to a dealer.
Another type of value viewers will often hear on ANTIQUES ROADSHOW UK is
an estimate for insurance purposesa valuation concerned with an
object's replacement value. In other words, how much a particular object
should be insured for in order to be able to replace it if it should be
lost. Typically this is based on retail value (except, of course, for an
item that is unique or otherwise irreplaceable). However, to carry
through with insuring an object, the owner will probably need to obtain
a written appraisal.
Which brings us to the last point about the values ascribed to objects
on ANTIQUES ROASHOW UK. Though we commonly refer to "appraisals" taking
place on the show, that is not, strictly speaking, what they are. A
formal appraisal is a legal document, a written opinion, generally paid
for by the recipient. The appraisal is made for a specific purposefor
insurance, for the IRS, for settling estates. Lastly, a written
appraisal assigns a fixed amount, rather than the range of values you'll
usually hear on show.
What the appraisers actually deliver on ANTIQUES ROADSHOW UK is what
appraisers call "verbal approximations of value." Most people who come
to the US ROADSHOW events are interested in whatever information an
expert can add to their own recollections and speculations about their
object. Usually they find that informationincluding the approximation
of valueto be a useful and entertaining part of everything they have
learned about it.
We hope as a viewer you receive the same pleasure and satisfaction from
watching, even amid the sometimes dizzying flurry of numbers.
|