VIDEO ARCHIVESCHEDULETOPICSABOUT FRONTLINEBUY DVDSTEACHERS

the man who knew


transcript of the 60 minute program
There is also this transcript of the 90 minute version of the program which FRONTLINE broadcast on October 3, 2004.


home
his life and career
what if...
connect the dots
interviews

Program #2103M1
"The Man Who Knew"
Air date: April 15, 2004

 

The Man Who Knew

Produced and Directed by
MICHAEL KIRK

Co-Produced and Reported by
JIM GILMORE

Written by
MICHAEL KIRK

 

9/11 COMMISSION WITNESS: When President Clinton asked me to serve as--

9/11 COMMISSION WITNESS: I've worked for two different administrations--

RICHARD CLARKE, NSC Chief of Counterterrorism '92-'01: I believe the Bush administration was unprepared to act.

DONALD RUMSFELD, SECRETARY OF DEFENSE: I knew of no intelligence--

COLIN POWELL, SECRETARY OF STATE: This administration came in fully recognizing--

ANNOUNCER: In Washington, as the 9/11 commission keeps probing the deadliest intelligence failure in U.S. history, attention has turned from the White House to the FBI.

THOMAS KEAN, 9/11 COMMISSION CHAIRMAN: Now, I read our staff statement as an indictment of the FBI.

LOUIS FREEH, FBI DIRECTOR '93-'01: Well, first of all, I take exception to your comment that your staff report is an indictment of the FBI.

ANNOUNCER: But former White House counterterrorism chief Richard Clarke was blunt.

RICHARD CLARKE: Frankly, the FBI culture, the FBI organization and the FBI personnel are not the best we could do in this country for a domestic intelligence service.

ANNOUNCER: Clarke made those charges two years ago to FRONTLINE in a documentary about the FBI and 9/11. The film is called The Man Who Knew.

 

September 11

3,025 Murdered

One of them knew

it was going to happen

 

JERRY HAUER, Dir. Emergency Mgmt. NYC '96-'00: The night before he died, he had said to me, "We're due, and we're due for something big."

ANNOUNCER: His name was John O'Neill. And long before the world knew about Usama bin Laden, FBI agent O'Neill was obsessed with him.

TEDDY LEB, Friend: He was among the first people to see the bin Laden threat.

ANNOUNCER: He warned of al Qaeda.

TEDDY LEB, Friend: He said that, "We're at war with these people."

ANNOUNCER: He warned of the threat to the United States.

TEDDY LEB, Friend: "And we better not take them for granted because they are here to hurt us."

ANNOUNCER: But people at FBI headquarters thought John O'Neill was too much of a maverick and they stopped listening to him.

JOE CANTAMESSA, FBI Special Agent NYC: You could be flagged as a problem, and your career could pretty much be over.

ANNOUNCER: O'Neill left the FBI and took a new job as head of security at the World Trade Center.

JOE CANTAMESSA: Of all the places to go to work, and of all the ways that you could lose your life.

ANNOUNCER: Tonight FRONTLINE investigates the internal power struggle at the heart of the FBI's failure on September 11th.

NARRATOR: There was after the horror of September 11th the inevitable question: Did anyone in the government know?

The move from Chicago to headquarters in Washington was a big promotion for Special Agent John O'Neill. He drove all night from Chicago and went straight to the office on a Sunday morning.

September 5, 1995

He'd just arrived when the White House called.

RICHARD CLARKE, NSC Chief of Counterterrorism '92-'01: It was a Sunday morning. but I was in my office and I was reading intelligence. And I saw a report that indicated that the man who had plotted the World Trade Center bombing in '93, the ringleader, Ramzi Ahmed Yousef.

Subject: Ramzi Ahmed Yousef

Plots:
WTC bombing
Pope assassination
Pacific airline bombings

Place of Birth:
Kuwait?
Pakistan?
Iraq?
UAE?

RICHARD CLARK: He was about to move within Pakistan. And there was a small window, a closing window, to catch him. And so thinking there might be somebody at the FBI on a Sunday morning, I called.

NARRATOR: O'Neill had made his reputation investigating white-collar crime, drug rings and abortion clinic bombings.

Subject: John P. O'Neill

Age: 43
1976: Baltimore -- White Collar Crime
1991: Chicago -- Drugs and Organized Crime
1994: Task Force Abortion Clinic Violence

RICHARD CLARKE: I said, "Who's this?" And he responded, "Well, who the hell are you? I'm John O'Neill." And I explained, "Well, I'm from the White House and I do terrorism, and I need some help." And I told him my story on the classified phone line. And he went into action.

NARRATOR: In 20 years, he'd chased a lot of bad guys but nobody like Ramzi Yousef.

MARY JO WHITE, U.S. Atty. So. District of NY '93-'02: Yousef is one of the most dangerous people on the planet-- very smart. Getting him and incapacitating him was a significant public safety issue, and John O'Neill recognized that, was not about to take no for an answer anywhere before he was taken into custody.

RICHARD CLARKE: O'Neill put together an arrest team that managed to catch Ramzi Ahmed Yousef in Pakistan just before he moved into Afghanistan, which would have been beyond our reach. It was a pretty intense couple of days, but it worked.

NARRATOR: For the next six years, O'Neill and his agents would follow the bloody and complex trail from Ramzi Yousef to Usama bin Laden.

CHRIS ISHAM: The picture was still fuzzy -- I mean, it was by no means sharp -- that there was an emerging global Islamic fundamentalist terrorist network that was becoming more and more engaged in the objective of attacking American targets.

MARY JO WHITE: When Yousef fled from the Trade Center bombing in 1993, among the places he went, really right before he was apprehended in Pakistan, was to the Philippines, where he was mixing the bombs to blow up, you know, 12 jumbo jets in a 48-hour period, and was not far away from at least attempting to carry out that plot, which would have resulted in thousands of deaths in two days.

NARRATOR: From the beginning, O'Neill obsessed about the details of the Ramzi Yousef case. He dug into that plan to blow up the planes, known as the Bojinka plot. Investigators had found a connection with the World Trade Center bombing that led to Yousef's co-conspirator, Ahmad Ajaj, and a terrorist training manual with a title that would translate into "Al Qaeda" -- "the base."

They uncovered a list of phone numbers called by Yousef and other World Trade Center conspirators from their safe houses. One of those numbers belonged to Usama bin Laden, identified by an early CIA report as an "Islamic extremist financier."

RICHARD CLARKE: I think if you ask most terrorism experts in the mid-1990s, "Well, what about this man, bin Laden?" most people in the mid-1990s would have said, "Ah, yes, the financier, the terrorist financier." And what O'Neill said was, "No, this man is not a financier. The money is money for a purpose. The purpose is building a worldwide terrorist network based out of Afghanistan, the point of which is going after the United States and after governments friendly to the United States, particularly in the Arab world."

NARRATOR: Once convinced bin Laden was a threat to America, O'Neill began a campaign within the FBI to sound the alarm.

ROBERT "BEAR" BRYANT, Deputy Director FBI '97-'99: The first time I ever heard the name Usama bin Laden was from John O'Neill. And John O'Neill was very much aware of who he was, who his group was, al Qaeda.

NARRATOR: Over time, Robert "Bear" Bryant would become second in command at the FBI.

ROBERT "BEAR" BRYANT: He was a person that I had immense personal regard for, and I-- we could argue like a couple of thieves in the night.

NARRATOR: O'Neill argued for a plan that would represent a seismic shift in the way the FBI had always operated. He would give authority to a new, more analytic agent who would have enhanced technology to fight the new terrorism. That directly threatened the dominance of the group who held sway over the culture, the criminal division.

ROBERT "BEAR" BRYANT: From his point of view, it was very clear what had to be done. You would basically have a whole branch of the FBI that would be-- not be touched by the criminal side.

NARRATOR: The criminal side-- the J. Edgar Hoover G-men who carried the guns and made cases and arrests. The man who would eventually lead the criminal division, Tom Pickard, aggressively competed with O'Neill for the attention of the director, Louis Freeh.

Subject: Louis J. Freeh

1974: J.D. Rutgers Law
1975: Agent FBI
1981: Federal Prosecutor
1991: Federal Judge
1993: Director FBI

NARRATOR: As a former street agent himself, Freeh identified with the criminal division, and Tom Pickard was a long-time friend. To reinvigorate the counterterrorism effort, O'Neill would try to muscle his way through the bureaucracy that surrounded Louis Freeh. But in that struggle, O'Neill's personal style got in the way. They said he was too intense, pushed too hard, had what they called "sharp elbows."

JOE CANTAMESSA, FBI Special Agent NYC: We often talked and joked about the fact that we weren't really in the club, and we really didn't care. And that was something that John and I had shared on occasion. And there is a difference between those people who spend time in an organization and are happy to make it to the top and have never rolled over a stone or created a problem or solved a problem, you know, just to carefully run through, and be there and be promoted. John was not like that.

NARRATOR: O'Neill just didn't do anything the FBI way. Where at the end of a long shift, they went home to their families--

MICHAEL SHEEHAN, Chief Counterterrorism, State Dept. '98-'01: He was the type guy who'd put his arm around you and take you out to dinner, and smoke cigars and drink whiskey with at the end of the day, and really-- and talk about all the issues in great depth. And he-- that's-- he took his-- the business-- his business beyond the work hours and well into the evenings, or he'd like to do that.

NARRATOR: And in the buttoned-down FBI, O'Neill was considered too flashy.

FRAN TOWNSEND, Deputy U.S. Attorney general '95-'01: It was the presentation. It was the-- as he would call it, it was the "package." They resented sort of the Burberry suit and the white pocket square and the expensive tie and the Bruno Magli shoes. You know, this wasn't the bureau.

CLINT GUENTHER, FBI Agent NYC - Counterterrorism: I kind of thought he was kind of a dandy. You know, he was impeccably dressed and looked like his fingernails were polished and his hair swooped back. And a bunch of us kind of, you know, started to call him the "Prince of Darkness."

ROBERT "BEAR" BRYANT: He worked both ends of the candle pretty hard. We had a morning briefing every morning at 7:30, and sometimes he would come in late. And I told him I wanted him there. I don't care if he came in his slippers and pajamas, be there. And he was.

[www.pbs.org: Read the complete interview]

NARRATOR: O'Neill's days were spent analyzing fragments of information. There was the story about two of Ramzi Yousef's Bojinka co-conspirators, Wali Kahn Amin Shah and Abdul Hakim Murad. In 1995, Murad told a story of Middle Eastern pilots training at U.S. flight schools and of a proposal to divebomb a jetliner into a federal building. It was a tantalizing bit of information. Agents were dispatched but then withdrawn. The investigation languished.

JAMES KALLSTROM, Director FBI NYC '95-'97: I had a fairly low opinion of headquarters throughout my whole career. It seemed like, you know, the headquarters was a very negative place, where they would find a million reasons why you couldn't do something, as opposed to why you could do something.

NARRATOR: James Kallstrom was the powerful boss of the FBI's New York office. Watching from a distance, he saw O'Neill's attitude and expertise make enemies among the group that surrounded Louis Freeh.

JAMES KALLSTROM: Yeah, I'm sure there was some jealousy in the bureaucracy. There always is. You can get by with some sharper elbows for a while, but you need to be right a lot. You know the old saying, "When you run with the wolves, don't trip," you know?

NARRATOR: At headquarters, a whispering campaign began about O'Neill's personal life. There was one version: married his high school sweetheart and had a couple of kids. Then there was the truth.

FRAN TOWNSEND: John had been separated from his family for some time. And I think John would have said to you his family suffered as a result of that, as a result of his devotion to his job.

VALERIE JAMES: I think the FBI was his mistress. He loved it. He loved it more than he loved any woman in his life. He loved it.

NARRATOR: And he loved Valerie James.

VALERIE JAMES: Very first time I saw John, I did something I had never done before and will never do again. I sent him a drink. He just had the most-- he was standing at the bar, and he had the most compelling eyes I had ever seen.

NARRATOR: She had her own children, and after a while, they started calling him "Dad." He hinted he might marry their mom. The trouble was, he hadn't told her he was already married.

VALERIE JAMES: I didn't know for two or three years. And someone that John worked with in the FBI's wife told me, and it was bad. I was shocked. You know, my family was shocked. I loved him. It had been two or three years, by that point. What are you going to do, you know?

NARRATOR: There weren't exactly FBI regulations against O'Neill's behavior, but there were unwritten rules of the road, and the whisperers said O'Neill's lifestyle made him unfit for his sensitive job. But for every enemy O'Neill made at headquarters, it seems he'd made an ally elsewhere. One of them, in the midst of her own struggle with Louis Freeh and the headquarters bureaucracy, he kept secret.

FRAN TOWNSEND, Deputy U.S. Attorney general '95-'01: The attorney general had seen John at meetings, knew he was an expert from his position at the FBI. And she would frequently say, "Well, what does John think?" There were times I was sitting in her office, and she'd ask that, and I'd say I didn't know. And she said, "Well, call him."

And literally, I would be dialing John's cell phone from the attorney general of the United States' office. And you know, he'd get on the phone, "Hi. How are you?" And I'd-- "Look, I'm in Ms. Reno's office." And so if she wanted to know, she knew she had the ability to reach out to him. This made him, in fairness, a little bit uncomfortable. He knew that this would not have been looked upon kindly by other people in the bureau.

[www.pbs.org: Read the complete interview]

NARRATOR: Around Washington, O'Neill's allies and drinking buddies began to warn him that he should take his al Qaeda crusade to a field office. He should leave headquarters.

JERRY HAUER, Dir. Emergency Mgmt. NYC '96-'00: You got to be careful whose toes you step on, particularly in Washington, because there are some pretty big shoes. And he created some headaches for himself at headquarters because he did manage to step on some toes.

NARRATOR: There was an opening in the New York City division. The boss up there, Jimmy Kallstrom, was also a tough guy, a thorn in Washington's side. He grabbed O'Neill-- saved him, really. At headquarters, they were happy to see him go, and on January 1st, 1997, John O'Neill moved to New York.

It was a promotion, assistant special agent in charge of counterterrorism and national security. He'd be in charge of a team of about 350 agents. And best of all, it was in New York.

JAMES KALLSTROM: New York was the flagship office of the FBI. It's where it happens, in New York. I mean, that's where you wanted to be if you were an FBI agent. So it's only natural that John O'Neill, who was-- you know, his whole life was the FBI, from what I could see-- would want to be in New York.

NARRATOR: In the New York office, they were still piecing together the evidence in the 1993 World Trade Center bombing. They also had new information that bin Laden had been involved in the shooting down of two American Black Hawk helicopters in Somalia. The confession of captured al Qaeda member Jamal Ahmed al Fadl told of Usama bin Laden's efforts to develop chemical weapons, buy weapons-grade uranium and to spread the al Qaeda network into Europe.

O'Neill was becoming obsessed, haunted by the specter of bin Laden.

JOHN P. O'NEILL, Jr.: My dad had a lot of video of Usama bin Laden. Whatever was out there was actually in his apartment. He studied him several times, watched the videos, I know, several times.

VALERIE JAMES: He would watch videotapes. He would read whatever material he could get his hands on. We had a fax in the house. People would fax him information all the time. John would sit in bed or sit on the couch or wherever and constantly underline everything.

CHRIS ISHAM, ABC News: He was obsessed by him. I think there's no question about it. He always knew that there was so much more that he didn't know, and that's what spooked him. What spooked him and what really used to drive him crazy was what he didn't know and how much was out there that he didn't know.

NEWSCASTER: [August 7, 1998] Two bombs, minutes apart, exploded without warning Friday outside the U.S. embassies in Nairobi, Kenya, and Dar es Salaam, Tanzania.

LEWIS SCHILIRO, Director of FBI NYC '98-'00: We had turned on the TV, watching CNN. And John O'Neill put it together in relatively short order and was convinced, in his own mind, that Al Qaeda was behind that.

MICHAEL SHEEHAN, Chief Counterterrorism, State Dept. '98-'01: That clearly was the event that changed bin Laden's profile dramatically because it was such a major event. Two embassies done simultaneously showed a great deal of sophistication in the organization. So this was a major event.

NARRATOR: But at headquarters, the brass were engaged in a procedural dispute.

FRAN TOWNSEND, Deputy U.S. Attorney general '95-'01: We're in the command center, and people are being pulled in. I'm over there. There's all sorts of senior bureau people there. Everybody's coming together. And the reason this becomes a significant question almost immediately is because the FBI's got to deploy people overseas. They're going to deploy people initially to Kenya and Tanzania. And who's going to be the on-scene commander?

NARRATOR: O'Neill believed his experience and expertise made him the obvious choice to lead the investigation as the on-scene commander. But down in the SIOC, there were those who wanted to cut New York and O'Neill out. On the QT, Townsend called O'Neill.

FRAN TOWNSEND: And he was-- to say angry, disappointed, hurt-- there becomes this bureaucratic arm-wrestle over who's going to be the office of origin.

NARRATOR: O'Neill desperately needed the help of U.S. attorney Mary Jo White.

MARY JO WHITE, U.S. Atty. So. District of NY '93-'02: He and I were both very adamant that the New York field agents who were most knowledgeable about bin Laden and the al Qaeda organization get over to Africa as quickly as possible as the investigation was unfolding because those first few days are often the most critical to whether you capture somebody or not, or figure out who's involved.

NARRATOR: And as it happened, Deputy Director Bear Bryant was out of cell phone range, on vacation. So the head of the criminal division, one of those men in Louis Freeh's inner circle, Tom Pickard, was temporarily in charge. He decided the New York team would not take the lead in the investigation, Washington would. And John O'Neill would not get command.

FRAN TOWNSEND: This is the World Series, and he's gotten benched. And that's exactly how he feels about it. And he is very hurt, very upset about it. And bitter.

NARRATOR: O'Neill hit the phones. He ended up venting to Bear Bryant.

ROBERT "BEAR" BRYANT, Deputy Director FBI '97-'99: I said, "You're going to have a stroke." He was so intense.

INTERVIEWER: This is the first guy you heard the word al Qaeda and bin Laden from. Shouldn't he be there?

ROBERT "BEAR" BRYANT: Well, he wasn't.

INTERVIEWER: But that wasn't your decision. I got a feeling that wasn't your decision.

ROBERT "BEAR" BRYANT: Well, he wasn't there.

INTERVIEWER: It wasn't your decision, was it.

ROBERT "BEAR" BRYANT: He wasn't there.

NARRATOR: Stuck in New York, O'Neill had to be content to learn as much as possible long-distance. Agents in East Africa had found another training manual nearly identical to the one found in the World Trade Center bombing. One cooperating witness revealed that bin Laden was planning to send operatives to the U.S. for pilot training. A computer found in a raid showed hundreds of targets around the world already surveilled and approved.

O'Neill's agents identified a man named Muhammed Rasheed Daoud al Owahali. He led them to a safe house in Yemen that acted as a kind of terrorist telephone exchange, relaying messages to and from bin Laden in Afghanistan.

[www.pbs.org: Explore the full map of connections]

RICHARD CLARKE, NSC Chief of Counterterrorism '92-'01: Certainly, after the embassy bombing in Africa in '98, it was very obvious that what John was saying was right, that this was more than a nuisance, that this was a real threat.

But I don't think everyone came to the understanding that it was an existential threat. Question was, "You know, this group is more than a nuisance, but are they worth going to war with? After all, they've only attacked two embassies, and maybe that's a cost of doing business. This kind of thing happens. Yes, we should spend some time and some energy trying to get them, but it's not the number-one priority we have."

NARRATOR: At just this time in New York, a new crisis was emerging that would eventually get the entire bureau's attention. O'Neill's international contacts were on full alert about the upcoming millennium celebrations, and O'Neill was lobbying for a full-blown FBI response in the United States.

MARY JO WHITE, U.S. Atty. So. District of NY '93-'02: The millennium, not only because of what that represented symbolically -- which, again, raises its danger value tremendously, but also because of intelligence we were getting throughout our government -- had us all extremely concerned.

NARRATOR: From the New York SIOC, O'Neill and his team began to track a case that proved his theory that al Qaeda had infiltrated the United States. An Algerian national, Ahmed Ressam, had been arrested on the border between Canada and the state of Washington. Among his possessions, they found bomb-making material and maps. He had circled the Los Angeles airport on this one.

RICHARD CLARKE: We had always talked about the possibility that there were al Qaeda cells in the United States, and we had looked for evidence. And we had encouraged FBI offices other than John O'Neill's office in New York to start looking for evidence.

NARRATOR: The agents dug into the details of the plot. From the plan to blow up the Los Angeles airport, another trail led from Boston to a planned attack in Jordan. There were other conspirators in Seattle, Brooklyn, and Manhattan, where O'Neill was worried about the massive New Year's Eve celebration in Times Square.

LEWIS SCHILIRO, Director of FBI NYC '98-'00: Certain documents were found on Ressam's possession, documents that indicated a New York connection-- in fact, a pretty strong connection to New York.

NARRATOR: One of Ressam's co-conspirators lived in New York. Abdel Meskini was supposed to deliver money and a cell phone to Ressam. O'Neill's agents arrested him.

MARY JO WHITE: Arrests were made that, had they not been uncovered, the plot had not been uncovered and those arrests made, we could have had horrific tragedies around the millennium.

NEWSCASTER: We have two million people -- two million people -- compressed in this small area here in mid-town Manhattan. No incidents in--

NARRATOR: O'Neill was one of those two million people. If al Qaeda struck here, this was where he wanted to be.

LEWIS SCHILIRO: And I remember talking to John shortly after midnight. There was a sense of accomplishment. We had just made the arrests in the Ressam spin-off. And you know, certainly, we believed that we got everybody that we needed to find, but you know, you're never really 100 percent sure of that.

RICHARD CLARKE: And so I think a lot of the FBI leadership for the first time realized that O'Neill was right, that there probably were al Qaeda people in the United States. They realized that only after they looked at the results of the investigation of the millennium bombing plot. So by February of 2000, I think senior people in the FBI were saying, "There probably is a network here in the United States, and we have to change the way the FBI goes about finding that network."

[www.pbs.org: Read Clarke's extended interview]

NARRATOR: If the bureau was finally going to reorganize itself to take on terror, O'Neill wanted significant influence in that process. He needed a highly visible, powerful platform. As it happened, Jimmy Kallstrom's old job, head of the New York office, was open. O'Neill pulled out all the stops and made a play for it.

But there were some administrative problems on his record. He'd lost a bureau cell phone and a Palm Pilot. Then there was the time his old Buick broke down. Val was with him. He figured he'd just pop into an FBI safe house to pick up a bureau car. He'd take her home, and that would be that. But headquarters called taking the car "unauthorized use of government property."

ROBERT "BEAR" BRYANT, Deputy Director FBI '97-'99: I think what happens in the FBI-- it's a very militaristic society, and you have to-- if you're being investigated by OPR, Office of Professional Responsibility, there's a question, they don't want to promote somebody that's got a cloud over them, even a minor thing like a vehicle.

NARRATOR: Bear Bryant had retired. Louis Freeh promoted his long-time friend, Tom Pickard, to deputy director. It was not good news for Agent O'Neill. It was Pickard who decided O'Neill would not lead the investigation in East Africa, and now Pickard and Freeh decided John O'Neill would not get the big job in New York.

ROBERT "BEAR" BRYANT: My daddy always said don't kill your mavericks. They might save your life some day, and they're the ones that will always have the great ideas. So try to take care of them. And John was a maverick. A brilliant maverick.

NARRATOR: The buzz around the New York office was that the new boss, Barry Mawn, wasn't keen on keeping O'Neill around.

FRAN TOWNSEND, Deputy U.S. Attorney general '95-'01: Barry was a skeptic. He had heard sort of the headquarters gossip about John O'Neill's style. But it was funny. I can remember saying to John, "Barry doesn't stand a chance. If you decide to win him over, you'll win him over."

BARRY MAWN, Director FBI NYC '00-'02: There was a knock on the door, and John was holding two beers. And he said, "Well I understand you're an Irishman and you like to drink beer. These are for you." So I laughed. He wanted to stay in New York. He said, "I will be your most loyal supporter, and all I ask in return is that you be supportive of me in my efforts." And so I said, "Well, we got a deal. And we'll go forward."

NARRATOR: As the weeks wore on, and just as that investigation about the car incident seemed a thing of the past, O'Neill attended a conference of other agents in Florida.

VALERIE JAMES: We were meeting in Bal Harbor at the Marriott. John came in. He is just-- I don't remember seeing John as distraught as he was this night. What has happened? He told me he left his briefcase in this room of 150 FBI agents and got a phone call, couldn't hear on his cell phone, so he just walked outside to take his call. Walked back in, his briefcase was gone. He was completely freaked.

NARRATOR: O'Neill's bag contained classified documents. Taking them out of his FBI office was against the rules.

FRAN TOWNSEND: And he knew-- even if there had been nothing in it, his sense was, because the bureau had come down hard on him the time before for something stupid, that even if it was nothing more than he lost bureau equipment, he was going to get-- this was going to become a federal case. This was going to be a big deal in terms of the bureau, and it was going to be used to hurt him.

NARRATOR: Hours later, the bag was retrieved. Fingerprint analysis showed the documents hadn't been tampered with. But the damage was done.

RICHARD CLARKE: John always wanted to be thought of as being close to perfect. And for him to be criticized for something like the suitcase -- the briefcase incident -- whatever the truth value of that incident was, it hurt him a lot because he always wanted to be thought of as close to perfect -- perfectly dressed, perfectly briefed -- and didn't want anybody to think that he was in any way not the number-one guy in terms of performance.

NARRATOR: At headquarters, they pounced. The FBI's Office of Professional Responsibility began a criminal investigation. O'Neill was in real trouble. He hired a lawyer and hunkered down to save his job.

FRAN TOWNSEND: He was consumed by this job, and the job turned on him. When he would make some foolish mistake, they came down awfully hard on him. Given what his contribution was, given what he had sacrificed, there was a sense of entitlement. And it's a terrible sense of unfairness. His view was people above him felt threatened by him, by his expertise, and so didn't really want him around.

NARRATOR: As the criminal investigation against O'Neill dragged on inside the FBI, O'Neill had his agents paying attention to American embassies, especially in Jordan and Saudi Arabia, and U.S. military targets, because an Egyptian informant had told them an American warship would be hit by al Qaeda.

Then, on October 12th, 2000, al Qaeda struck. The guided missile destroyer USS Cole was the target of a suicide mission. Seventeen sailors died.

BARRY MAWN, Director FBI NYC '00-'02: John came to me and said, "It's al Qaeda," and I totally agreed with him. And he said, "You got to get to the director, and we got to get this so the New York office responds initially."

NARRATOR: It took hours for Barry Mawn to convince Director Freeh to let New York take the lead and to authorize O'Neill as the on-scene commander.

INTERVIEWER: Washington Headquarters of the FBI happy that O'Neill was going?

BARRY MAWN: My recollection is that I got questioned on it. "Is John the best guy to send?" And I had no hesitancy and said, "Absolutely, he's the best guy to send."

INTERVIEWER: Why would they have said that?

BARRY MAWN: Well, again, I think it kind of goes back to a little bit of the history John had with some of the folks back there, that there was probably some questioning as, "Well, do we want to send O'Neill?" And "He does have sharp elbows" or "His style may be--" they were concerned that he wasn't the best guy to go, and that you needed someone more of a diplomat to-- my view, to a certain extent, is when you have a major incident like that, you really don't need a diplomat at that particular point in time. You need somebody that knows what to do and is going to do it and get it done.

NARRATOR: O'Neill and the members of his rapid deployment team immediately headed for Yemen.

CHRIS ISHAM, ABC News: This was a case that he was really pushing hard on, that he understood that this wasn't just a venue where they set off a bomb, that there were connections between Yemen and East Africa, and Yemen and Afghanistan, and Yemen and Europe, and that there were-- this was very much of an important operational base for these guys, and that if he could illuminate that base, that he could begin to really put a dent in this network.

NARRATOR: But when he got to Yemen, O'Neill discovered how hard his task was going to be.

FRAN TOWNSEND: They're in impossible conditions, the agents. They don't have anyplace to sleep. He's got agents sleeping on the floor. They're working ridiculous hours. It's hot as all get-out. And you're in an impossible-- and it's in a hostile environment.

MICHAEL DORSEY, Naval Criminal Investigative Service: We had to move in caravans from the hotel out to the Cole, or from the hotel to some of the sites where we believed the terrorists and their support network had been. And those were in caravans of NCIS-FBI personnel, all armed, surrounded by Yemeni security force personnel. So these caravans would be 8, 10, 12 cars long. It was certainly announcing our presence. Any time we went somewhere, everybody in that city knew who we were and where we were going. And it gave us an uneasy feeling.

NARRATOR: To protect the hundreds of investigators on the ground, O'Neill and American military commanders wanted to show the Yemenis a forceful presence -- guns ready, perimeters established. But much to O'Neill's surprise, that approach quickly angered the American ambassador, Barbara Bodine, who felt his actions were harming U.S.-Yemeni government relations.

Subject: Amb. Barbara K. Bodine

Age: 53
Career Diplomat
Postings: Hong Kong
Thailand
Iraq
Kuwait
Yemen

RICHARD CLARKE, NSC Chief of Counterterrorism '92-'01: You had an ambassador who wanted to be fully in control of everything that every American official did in the country and resented the fact that suddenly there were hundreds of FBI personnel in the country and only a handful of State Department personnel. She wanted good relations with Yemen as the number-one priority. John O'Neill wanted to stop terrorism as the number-one priority. And the two conflicted.

FRAN TOWNSEND, Deputy U.S. Attorney general '95-'01: This results in meetings between the attorney general and State, FBI, CIA and Justice. But Ambassador Pickering is at it, the undersecretary, and the attorney general. I mean, things are getting raised to that kind of a level, this has become such a bone of contention between them.

NARRATOR: But on the ground in Yemen, law enforcement agents saw a very different John O'Neill.

MICHAEL DORSEY: I think he developed a real sense of closeness with the senior Yemeni officials. They referred to him in Arabic as "al Ach [sp?]," which is "the brother," and oftentimes referred to him as "the commander" or "your commander." They had a real sense of appreciation for his seniority in the U.S. government and for what he represented. And I knew that they came to trust John.

NARRATOR: For six years at the center of the FBI's counterrorism effort, O'Neill and his team had built the evidence on the mounting bin Laden threat: failed plots to kill hundreds of Americans in Jordan, Ressam's explosives headed to LAX, an aborted al Qaeda plot to blow up another American warship, the USS The Sullivans, and now the Cole. The Yemenis finally agreed to let the FBI join in the interrogation of one of their most prominent suspects, Fahad al Quso.

O'Neill and his agents believed al Quso knew about bin Laden's desire to videotape the destruction of the Cole, and possibly a whole lot more. O'Neill worked his newly developed Yemeni police officials and old allies in the CIA.

But the weeks were taking their toll. O'Neill needed a break. He'd get back to al Quso after he returned from New York at the first of the year.

VALERIE JAMES: I have to tell you, when John came home-- he got home, I think it was two days before Thanksgiving because he kept telling me he was going to try to be home for Thanksgiving. He-- John had dropped 20, 25 pounds.

NARRATOR: In New York, he plotted his return to Yemen. He had taken a Yemeni police delegation on a tour of Elaine's and other hotspots. He was working them, trying to get unfettered access to al Quso and what he knew. But then he was told he wouldn't be allowed to return to Yemen. Ambassador Bodine denied his visa.

CHRIS ISHAM, ABC News: I mean, John was not rational on the topic of Ambassador Barbara Bodine. He was-- I mean, "livid" would be putting it mildly. I mean, one can't forget that John was-- he very American, but he was also very Irish.

INTERVIEWER: And that means?

CHRIS ISHAM: That means when he got hot, he got hot. And he was hot. There's no question about it. I think he felt that she was on the wrong side.

NARRATOR: Ambassador Bodine would not grant FRONTLINE's request for an interview. She was quoted in The New Yorker magazine. "The idea that John or his people or the FBI were somehow barred from doing their job is insulting to the U.S. government, which was working on al Qaeda before John ever showed up. This is all my embassy did for 10 months."

For weeks, the ambassador had been making the case against O'Neill, even lobbying Louis Freeh. Finally, her accusations had their intended effect. Headquarters supported her decision not to let O'Neill back into Yemen.

BARRY MAWN, Director FBI NYC '00-'02: John was upset. She was bad-mouthing him. She had caused a stir at headquarters. I actually think John was more disappointed that our headquarters didn't back us, as far as sending him back and taking a stronger stand with the State Department. Eventually, our headquarters said, "Well, let's try and work around not having John go back." And so that's what I had to do.

NARRATOR: So O'Neill would not be in Yemen. The investigation slowed to a crawl.

MICHAEL SHEEHAN, Chief Counterterrorism, State Dept. '98-'01: I watched with dismay as the issue of the USS Cole completely disappeared from the U.S. scene, completely-- again, in a new administration. It was just not on their agenda. Clearly, it was not on the agenda of the Congress, the media or anyone else. Again, it went into oblivion.

NARRATOR: By spring, intelligence about al Qaeda forces in Yemen convinced O'Neill they were about to target his agents. O'Neill pleaded with Barry Mawn to pull them out, and Mawn agreed. O'Neill's investigation in Yemen was effectively over.

[www.pbs.org: More on the CIA, FBI and Yemen]

CHRIS ISHAM: We don't know what would have happened if John could have done his job in Yemen and had really had the full back-up to go and to really push in Yemen and what kind of networks he could have exposed. But you know, we do know that there were Yemenis involved in the attacks of September 11th. So is it possible that if he had been able to really open up that network and really expose that network, that he could have in some way deterred the tragedy of September 11th? I don't think we know, but it's sad because we won't know the answer to that. But I think there is at least a fighting-- he would have had had a fighting chance if he'd been able to do his job.

NARRATOR: By early summer of 2001, other intelligence services were putting the Bush White House on full alert. Every single indication was that al Qaeda was planning a major attack on the United States.

RICHARD CLARKE: In June of 2001, the intelligence community issued a warning that a major al Qaeda terrorist attack would take place in the next many weeks. And so in my office in the White House complex, the CIA sat, briefed the domestic U.S. federal law enforcement agencies -- Immigration, Federal Aviation, Coast Guard, Customs -- and the FBI was there, as well, agreeing with CIA -- told them that we were entering a period where there was a very high probability of a major terrorist attack.

NARRATOR: In New York, O'Neill was also convinced al Qaeda had picked a target. But he was by now more marginalized than ever at the FBI. And so in July of 2001, when that memo from the Phoenix office pleading for investigations of flight schools made its way to headquarters, it was not passed on to O'Neill or Mawn in New York, nor was the struggle that August of the Minnesota office to investigate the alleged 20th hijacker, Zacarias Moussaoui.

The leaders of the most sophisticated office in the FBI, the office that, under O'Neill, had been dealing with these matters for six years, apparently were out of the loop.

CHRIS ISHAM: John had heard the alarm bells, too, yet he felt that he was frozen out, that he was not in a capacity to really do anything about it anymore because of his relationship with the FBI. So it was a source of real anguish for him.

NARRATOR: Thirteen months after that briefcase incident, with the investigation still open, a well-placed leak to a newspaper made sure his government career was over.

FRAN TOWNSEND: The New York Times is now starting to ask questions about that incident both at the headquarters level and at the New York field office.   In spite of sort of Jimmy Kallstrom and others trying to persuade The New York Times that somebody had an agenda here, this was really sort of ill-motivated, it was clear that they were going to run with it.

VALERIE JAMES: And that was the final nail in John O'Neill's coffin that they were going to use to have him retire.

INTERVIEWER: Did he know who did it?

VALERIE JAMES: He suspected.

INTERVIEWER: Did he confront them?

VALERIE JAMES: Yes.

INTERVIEWER: And what happened?

VALERIE JAMES: It was completely denied. The person that he felt did it said, "Absolutely not. Wouldn't want to hurt you in any way, shape or form."

INTERVIEWER: It's been reported that was Tom Pickard.

VALERIE JAMES: That's who John felt it was, Tom Pickard. And John really never knew. He was out to get John for a long time, and John never really knew why.

NARRATOR: At the time, Tom Pickard was interim director of the FBI. Now retired, Pickard would not agree to an interview, but in a letter to FRONTLINE, he wrote, "I did not leak it, and there are no facts that even remotely suggest that I did."

Earlier, in Esquire magazine, Pickard was further quoted on the matter. "The briefcase was a big deal. It was not so much that he lost it, he shouldn't have had those materials with him in the first place. Losing the briefcase just added to it. Let's just say it was not John O'Neill's finest hour."

At the end of August, 2001, Agent O'Neill ended his 25-year career with the FBI. He was 49 years old.

O'Neill needed to make some money. Just being John O'Neill had gotten very expensive. Jimmy Kallstrom and others made some calls. There was one job, in particular, he was really interested in. It paid $350,000 a year, but it also had a special kind of significance for O'Neill. It was chief of security at those buildings Ramzi Yousef had tried to destroy, the World Trade Center.

CHRIS ISHAM: And I joked with him. I said, "Well, that'll be an easy job. They're not going to bomb that place again." And he said-- he says, "Well, actually" -- he immediately came back and he said, "No, actually, they've always wanted to finish that job. I think they're going to try again." And of course, that's something I'll just never forget.

NARRATOR: On the night of September 10th, John O'Neill did what he loved doing, and he did it from his favorite table at Elaine's.

JERRY HAUER, Dir. Emergency Mgmt. NYC '96-'00: It was classic John. To this day, I can remember John sitting in a chair, looking up at me with that classic John O'Neill smile, saying, "It doesn't get better than this."

NARRATOR: The talk, of course, turned to bin Laden.

JERRY HAUER: He had said to me, "We're due. And we're due for something big." That was just-- he said that, "Some things have happened in Afghanistan. I don't like," you know, "the way things are lining up in Afghanistan." And he said, "I just-- I sense a shift, and I think things are going to happen." And I said, "When?" He said, "I don't know, but soon." And that was just his sense of things.

We left about 2:30. John gave me a big bear hug and said, "I'll see you tomorrow." And John went home, and that was the last I saw of him.

September 11, 2001

NEWSCASTER: It appears that there is more and more fire and smoke enveloping the very top of the building.

WITNESS: Oh, my God!

NEWSCASTER: That looks like a second plane has just hit.

FRAN TOWNSEND: I saw the second plane hit. And of course, by then, there's no doubt of what the issue is. And I call again, and I don't get through, and I leave a message.   I knew he should have been there by then. And frankly, I'm just concerned, as a friend, that he's OK.

VALERIE JAMES: We got on the phone and he says, "Hey babe, it's me." I said, "Are you OK?" He says, "Yeah, I'm fine." He said, "Val, it's horrible. There's body parts everywhere." We said a few other things to one another, and he said, "OK, I'll call you in a little bit." I said "OK."

JOHN P. O'NEILL, Jr.: He said, "Look, I'm on my way out now. Have you talked to your mother today?" And I said, "No." He said to me, "Well, give her a call. She's worried about you." And I said, "OK."

FRAN TOWNSEND: He paged me to let me know he was OK. And that was the last contact I had.

JOHN P. O'NEILL, Jr.: I was running down the street. Right after I got around St. Vincent's Hospital, on the "Y", and I started to run a little bit, I saw the south tower collapse.

VALERIE JAMES: I knew immediately John was dead. I don't know why I knew, I just knew. And I just-- I slumped down into a chair, and I said, "Oh, my God. John's dead." And everybody said, "Don't say that. Don't say that. Don't talk like that." About 2:00 o'clock in the afternoon, I said to my assistant-- we were just sitting there, waiting for him to call. Everyone went back to my office. And he never called.

NARRATOR: In the aftermath, what John O'Neill had come so tantalizingly close to discovering became clear. Some of it came from Yemen, from that suspect, al Quso. He told about a secret meeting in Malaysia attended by two Cole bombing conspirators, Nawaf Alhazmi and Khalid Almidhar. They had been coming in and out of the U.S. on legal visas. They'd trained in American flight schools. They, too, had died on September 11th, piloting flight 77 as it crashed into the Pentagon.

Among the 2,749 people murdered on September 11th, in the debris of a fallen stairwell, under what was once the south tower of the World Trade Center, they found John O'Neill's body.

 

THE MAN WHO KNEW

WRITTEN, PRODUCED AND DIRECTED BY
Michael Kirk

CO-PRODUCED AND REPORTED BY
Jim Gilmore

EDITOR
Steve Audette

ASSOCIATE PRODUCER
Corey Ford

DIRECTOR OF PHOTOGRAPHY
Ben McCoy

SOUND
Steve Lederer

PRODUCTION ASSISTANT
RESEARCHER
Mike Wiser

NARRATOR
Will Lyman

ONLINE EDITOR
Michael H. Amundson

SOUND MIX
Jim Sullivan

MUSIC
Associated Production Music

ADDITIONAL CAMERA
Mark Molesworth
Greg Larsen
Jan Maliszewski

ADDITIONAL SOUND
Donna Bertaccini
Craig Gibson
Aaron Frutman
Jack McPhee

ARCHIVAL MATERIALS
ABCNEWS VideoSource
America by Air
AP/Wide World
CBS News Archive supplied by
BBC Worldwide
CNN ImageSource
Corbis Images
Evan Fairbanks/Magnum Photos
ITN Archive/Reuters
Jessica Burstein
Images courtesy of
"WTC: The First 24 Hours"
directed by Etienne Sauret
and David Carrera,
camera and direction by
Etienne Sauret.

FOR FRONTLINE

PRODUCTION MANAGER
Tim Mangini

ON-AIR PROMOTION
PRODUCER
Missy Frederick

SENIOR EDITOR
Steve Audette

AVID EDITORS
Michael H. Amundson
John MacGibbon
Michael Simollari

POST PRODUCTION
SUPERVISOR
Chris Fournelle

POST PRODUCTION
ASSISTANT
Chetin Chabuk

SERIES MUSIC
Mason Daring
Martin Brody

COMMUNICATIONS
MANAGER
Erin Martin Kane

SENIOR PUBLICIST
Christopher Kelly

PUBLICIST
Jessica Smith

PROMOTION WRITER
Jennifer McCauley

PROMOTION DESIGNER
Dennis O'Reilly

ASSOCIATE PUBLICIST
Jenna Lowe

FOUNDATION GRANT MANAGER
Jessica Cashdan

SECRETARY
Robert Chung

ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT
Danielle Gillis

COMPLIANCE MANAGER
Lisa Palone-Clarke

LEGAL
Eric Brass
Jay Fialkov

CONTRACTS MANAGER
Adrienne Armor

UNIT MANAGER
Mary Sullivan

BUSINESS MANAGER
Tobee Phipps

WEBSITE EDITORIAL
ASSISTANTS
Kate Cohen
Justin Grotelueschen

WEBSITE COORDINATING
PRODUCER
Sarah Moughty

WEBSITE PRODUCER/
DESIGNER
Sam Bailey

EDITORIAL RESEARCHER
Catherine Wright

COORDINATING PRODUCER
Robin Parmelee

SERIES EDITOR
Ken Dornstein

SENIOR PRODUCER
SPECIAL PROJECTS
Sharon Tiller

EXECUTIVE PRODUCER
SPECIAL PROJECTS
Michael Sullivan

EDITORIAL DIRECTOR
Marrie Campbell

SERIES MANAGER
Jim Bracciale

EXECUTIVE EDITOR
Louis Wiley Jr.

EXECUTIVE PRODUCER
David Fanning

A FRONTLINE Co-Production with Kirk Documentary Group, Ltd.

(c) 2004
WGBH EDUCATIONAL FOUNDATION
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

FRONTLINE is a production of WGBH Boston, which is solely responsible for its content.

 

ANNOUNCER: Explore more about John O'Neill and the FBI at our Web site, including a rare video interview with O'Neill, a look at how the 9/11 commission is examining issues that were raised by John O'Neill, also a chart of how al Qaeda came into focus for O'Neill and U.S. intelligence in the '90s and a chance to watch the longer 90-minute version of this report on line. Then join the discussion at pbs.org.

 

Next time on FRONTLINE: He grew up with bin Laden's children.

ABDURAHMAN KHADR: Three times, my father himself tried to get me to become a suicide bomber.

ANNOUNCER: But Khadr was different.

ABDURAHMAN KHADR: I don't believe in blowing myself up, killing innocent people.

ANNOUNCER: FRONTLINE tells the inside story of a young man who was groomed to be a terrorist but became instead a CIA informant.

ABDURAHMAN KHADR: My dad told me, "If you ever sell out on us, I will be the one to kill you."

ANNOUNCER: Son of Al Qaeda. Watch FRONTLINE.

 

To order FRONTLINE's The Man Who Knew on videocassette or DVD, call PBS Home Video at 1-800-PLAY-PBS. [$29.98 plus s&h]

 

Support for FRONTLINE is provided by U.S. News & World Report.

Trust. For over 70 years, a commitment to playing it straight, getting it right. U.S. News & World Report. Trust matters.

With additional funding from the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation.

FRONTLINE is made possible by contributions to your PBS station from viewers like you. Thank you.

home + his life and career + what if... + "connect the dots" + interviews
timeline: al qaeda's global context + introduction + video: 1997 interview + discussion + readings & links
producer's chat + tapes & transcripts + press reaction + credits + privacy policy
FRONTLINE + wgbh + pbsi

web site copyright 1995-2014 WGBH educational foundation