Daily News Lesson

SHOW ALL

Aug. 4, 2020, 3 p.m.

How the Electoral College and claims of voter fraud may complicate election 2020

DOWNLOAD VIDEO Directions: Read the summary, listen to the excerpt of the podcast (9m:30s) and answer the discussion questions. Summary: In the first episode of a brand new podcast, Office Hours, produced by Classroom interns Ramses Rubio and Carolyn McCusker, Rubio interviews Professor Lawrence Douglas who teaches Law, Jurisprudence and Social Thought at Amherst College. The interview covers teaching during the pandemic and Douglas's new book, "Will He Go? Trump and the Looming Election Meltdown in 2020."
  • Though he won the 2016 election, President Donald Trump questioned the legitimacy of the popular vote, which his opponent, won by about 3 million votes. Trump claimed at the time — without supporting evidence — that many of those votes for former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton were fraudulent.
  • Douglas began writing his book after asking himself what powers and political leverage a president might have in seeking to delegitimize an election result.
  • Douglas believes that Trump may already be setting out a strategy to question the legitimacy of any loss in closely contested states. Because of the Electoral College system in the Unites States, a large popular vote loss may be offset by close swing state results.
Discussion questions:
  1. Essential question: Why might the Electoral College system help create uncertainty about results on election night?
  2. According to this interview, why was the Electoral College established as part of the democratic process? What might have changed in the United States since the Electoral College was first established?
  3. Should states each have their own rules for national elections, or should there be a single electoral system? What are the advantages and disadvantages of each system?
  4. Do you think presidents should be elected through the Electoral College system? Why or why not? What are the possible advantages or disadvantages of a direct popular vote?
  5. Media literacy: This podcast is an interview between a student and his teacher. Were there details from the questions and answers that you think might be different if the interviewer had been a journalist instead of a student?
    • What are the advantages and disadvantages of interviewing someone you know?
Extension activity: 1. Listen to the full Office Hours podcast episode here . If you would like to pitch an interview with your professor on Office Hours, email pbsofficehours@gmail.com . 2. Donald Trump has claimed that mail-in voting will lead to fraud, as explained in this NewsHour story . Have students watch this video and then research your own state's vote by mail rules. Answer the following questions:
  • Who is permitted to vote by mail in your state? What restrictions exist?
  • What is the process for obtaining, filling out and returning ballots?
  • What procedures does your state follow to make voting by mail more safe and secure?
  • Do you think voting by mail should be more accessible in your state or less accessible? Why? Should your state adopt new vote by mail rules? What new rules would make voting safe, secure and accessible?
[embed]
[/embed]

Recent Daily News Lessons

springsteeen-1024x576

Daily News Lesson

Bruce Springsteen on 'critical patriotism' and the power of protest music

Learn more about "the Boss's" efforts to simultaneously express his devotion to the United States and hold its leaders accountable

Illustration shows Claude app icon

Daily News Lesson

Anthropic disables new AI model after White House security directive

Learn about the current challenges facing the U.S. government’s broad use of powerful yet largely unregulated AI models

Image 6-23-26 at 2.42 PM

Daily News Lesson

Plagued by algae and peeling paint, reflecting pool set to undergo more repairs

Learn about the controversy surrounding repairs to the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool ahead of America's 250th anniversary

Dedication ceremony for the opening of the Obama Presidential Center in Chicago

Daily News Lesson

How the Obama Presidential Center offers a new vision for presidential legacies

With his new Presidential Center in Chicago, Barack Obama is hoping to display a "vibrant, living celebration of community."

SUPPORTED BY VIEWERS LIKE YOU. ADDITIONAL SUPPORT PROVIDED BY:

PBS News Hour Classroom

Copyright © 2025 News Hour Production LLC. All Rights Reserved

Illustrations by Annamaria Ward