What do you think? Leave a respectful comment.

The video for this story is not available, but you can still read the transcript below.
No image

Senate Vote Against F-22 Funds a Win for Obama

In a key political victory for President Obama and Defense Secretary Robert Gates, the Senate on Tuesday voted 58-40 to block $1.75 billion in financing for new F-22 fighter jets. Kwame Holman reports.

Read the Full Transcript


    And next tonight, a Senate showdown on defense spending. NewsHour congressional correspondent Kwame Holman reports.


    The F-22 Raptor fighter is a stealth aircraft built to ensure American air dominance over the battlefield. But on a vote of 58-40 today, the U.S. Senate called a halt to further production of the planes that cost more than $350 million each.

    The vote to keep the F-22 fleet at 187 aircraft was a significant victory for President Obama and Defense Secretary Gates, who have labeled the F-22 program an outmoded, expensive luxury.


    Every dollar of waste in our defense budget is a dollar we can't spend to support our troops or prepare for future threats or protect the American people. Our budget is a zero-sum game. And if more money goes to F-22s, it is our troops and our citizens who lose.


    The F-22 originally was planned and designed to take on the Soviet air force. None has flown in combat over Iraq or Afghanistan. That's why Secretary Gates decided earlier this year no more F-22s were needed.

    ROBERT GATES, Secretary of Defense: The military advice that I got was that there is no military requirement for numbers of F-22s beyond 187.


    But that led to a confrontation with Congress, one of the biggest on defense spending in decades. Mark Thompson covers the Pentagon for Time magazine.

  • MARK THOMPSON, Time Magazine:

    The F-22 was a very symbolic issue for Secretary Gates based on the people I'm speaking to, simply because it's emblematic of an old-fashioned kind of war that most military experts don't see looming on the horizon. In fact, they don't see it for the next 20 to 30 years at the earliest.


    Members from both parties, along with contractors, counterattacked and the climax today came on the Senate floor. The fight was over an amendment to the defense authorization bill offered by the top senators on the Armed Services Committee, Carl Levin and John McCain, to cut funding for the plane, which is manufactured or subcontracted in 44 states.

    The stakes were raised by the president's promise to veto any bill with extra F-22 money, a message reinforced in strong terms by Secretary Gates in a speech last week in Chicago.


    Where do we draw the line? And if not now, when? If we can't get this right, what on Earth can we get right? It is time to draw the line on doing defense business as usual.


    Gates' vehemence was echoed today by Senator Levin.

  • SEN. CARL LEVIN, D-Mich.:

    If not now, when? If not now, when? When will we end production of a weapons system if not now, when you have both President Obama and President Bush trying to end it, secretaries of defense trying to end it, chairmen of the Joint Chiefs trying to end the production of the F-22. We must now do the sensible thing.