Amid U.N. Climate Talks, Trump Officials Attend Event Hosted By Skeptics

The flag of the United Nations is presented during the opening of the World Climate Conference in Bonn, Germany on Nov. 6, 2017.

The flag of the United Nations is presented during the opening of the World Climate Conference in Bonn, Germany on Nov. 6, 2017. (Oliver Berg/picture-alliance/dpa/AP Images)

In partnership with:
November 10, 2017

BONN, Germany — As global leaders gathered here at the annual United Nations climate talks Thursday, several senior Trump administration energy and environment officials were thousands of miles away participating in a much different kind of conference: One hosted by climate change skeptics. 

While the focus in Bonn is on combating climate change, at the America First Energy Conference in Houston, hosted by the libertarian Heartland Institute, the talk was about fossil fuels and how – as one of the event’s panels asserted – “human activity … is not causing a climate crisis.”

Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Scott Pruitt, who is not expected to go to Bonn, appeared at the conference with a welcome video to the attendees and speakers – many of whom were from groups like Heartland that reject the scientific consensus on climate change.

“There’s great optimism across the country, and I hope you’re feeling that in Houston, Texas,” Pruitt said in the video. “God speed in what you’re doing.”

Under Pruitt, the EPA has moved to roll back regulations related to climate change, notably the Obama administration’s signature domestic effort to limit carbon emissions, the Clean Power Plan.

The Heartland event included discussions on energy and national security; the future of coal; the costs of excessive regulations; and the benefits to health, agriculture and the environment of ending the “war on fossil fuels.”

Heartland spokesman Jim Lakely called the timing of the two conferences “a happy coincidence.” He said Heartland has been impressed with President Donald Trump’s energy policy and conceived of the conference as a forum to discuss its progress. Heartland has sought to promote a more skeptical view on climate change, arguing that the near-unanimous consensus among scientists that humans are changing the climate is incorrect. Earlier this year, it mailed climate change skeptical materials to hundreds of thousands of science teachers across the country.

At the Houston conference, the keynote speaker was Vincent DeVito, a senior official at the Department of Interior involved in shaping policy around energy development on public lands. Richard Westerdale, a senior energy adviser for the State Department who worked at ExxonMobil for two decades, spoke on a panel on energy and national security. Also at the conference was Myron Ebell, who led Trump’s transition team for the EPA and has frequently rejected the threat of climate change.

In his keynote, DeVito said the Trump administration is moving as quickly as possible to open up the Interior Department’s lands to fossil fuel extraction, which he said would generate billions of dollars a year for the government.

“The war on American energy is completely over,” said DeVito of the Trump era in his keynote address. “We are becoming the strongest energy superpower that the world has ever known.”

Meanwhile, at the U.N.’s COP23 conference in Bonn, the United States has taken a backseat to ongoing international negotiations that address global warming. Notably, it became the sole U.N. party to reject the Paris Agreement, the historic 2015 climate accord, after both Nicaragua and Syria signed onto the agreement in recent weeks. In June, Trump vowed to withdraw from the Paris Agreement, calling it “draconian” and arguing it was not made on good terms for American taxpayers. A full U.S. withdrawal from the Paris Agreement would take a few years.

As in years past, the U.S. is being represented here by a State Department-led delegation, including some members that were involved in creating the Paris Agreement. This year’s negotiations are focused on teasing out the rules that will govern the climate accord.

In previous years the U.S. has hosted a large pavilion and dozens of events showing off U.S. efforts to curb carbon emissions. This year, the U.S. declined to host a pavilion and has organized just one event: A panel on how to make fossil fuels and nuclear power cleaner and more efficient.

This has inspired sneers from participants in the Bonn talks, many of whom believe keeping fossil fuels in the ground is the best way to stave off global warming’s most catastrophic consequences. Just last week, 13 federal agencies released a report saying that evidence of the human role in global warming is stronger than ever. The Trump administration did not stand in the way of the report’s release, as critics had feared, but downplayed its findings.

Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.), who is in Bonn, said the timing of the Heartland conference was meant to confuse the public on the issue of climate change during the U.N. conference.

“Trump is a dream come true for the climate denial operation, which has always craved legitimacy,” Whitehouse said. “Trump being willing to send government officials to one of these phony-baloney things is really regrettable because there’s no science behind it.”

This story was produced as part of a collaboration between FRONTLINE and The GroundTruth Project.

Katie Worth

Katie Worth, Reporter, FRONTLINE



In order to foster a civil and literate discussion that respects all participants, FRONTLINE has the following guidelines for commentary. By submitting comments here, you are consenting to these rules:

Readers' comments that include profanity, obscenity, personal attacks, harassment, or are defamatory, sexist, racist, violate a third party's right to privacy, or are otherwise inappropriate, will be removed. Entries that are unsigned or are "signed" by someone other than the actual author will be removed. We reserve the right to not post comments that are more than 400 words. We will take steps to block users who repeatedly violate our commenting rules, terms of use, or privacy policies. You are fully responsible for your comments.

blog comments powered by Disqus

More Stories

Of the 5 States with the Most Farmworkers, Only 3 Are Prioritizing Vaccines — and Not All Means of Prioritizing Are Equal, per the CDC
Months after the July 2020 film "COVID's Hidden Toll," FRONTLINE checked in with farmworkers in California and four other big agricultural states and found vaccine rollouts have been uneven.
April 16, 2021
The War in Afghanistan: As Biden Sets U.S. Withdrawal Date, 13 Documentaries Explore the Conflict and Its Impact
Explore nearly two decades of reporting from FRONTLINE on America’s longest war.
April 15, 2021
After Jan. 6, Investigating the Contours of a “Broad Fascist Movement” in the U.S.
In a scene from the new documentary “American Insurrection,” correspondent A.C. Thompson talks with sociologist Pete Simi about the state of domestic extremism in the U.S.
April 14, 2021
“I Felt Hate More Than Anything”: How an Active Duty Airman Tried to Start a Civil War
Steven Carrillo’s path to the Boogaloo Bois shows the hate group is far more organized and dangerous than previously known.
April 13, 2021