Did Colgan Mislead the NTSB About Flight 3407?

A Bombardier Dash-8 Q400 is shown on it's acceptance flight at Pearson International Airport, Toronto, Ontario on June 10, 2008. A commuter aircraft similar to the one shown crashed into a home and exploded in Clarence Center, N.Y., Thursday night Feb. 12, 2009. Authorites say 49 people are dead after a commuter plane crashed into the home in suburban Buffalo and erupted in flames late Thursday. State police say all 48 people aboard the Continental Connection Flight 3407 are dead. Clarence Center emergency control director Dave Bissonet says the crash also killed one person on the ground

Photo: A Bombardier Dash-8 Q400 is shown on it's acceptance flight in Toronto. A commuter aircraft similar to the one shown -- Continental Connection Flight 3407 -- crashed into a Buffalo-area home in February 2009. (AP/THE CANADIAN PRESS -- Andrew H. Cline)

October 26, 2011

Earlier this week, we brought you the story of internal e-mails from Colgan Air questioning the piloting abilities of Capt. Marvin Renslow. The e-mails revealed that several higher-ups in the company had concerns about Renslow’s competence to fly a Bombardier Dash-8 Q400, the exact type of plane that he later crashed in Buffalo in February 2009, killing all 49 people on board and one on the ground.

Now, the Buffalo News is reporting that at least two of the men exchanging e-mails — former chief pilot Bill Honan and Harry Mitchel, then the vice president of flight operations — may have misled the National Transportation Safety Board [NTSB] when testifying about the crash.

Honan told the NTSB in an interview, in which he was not under oath: “I don’t have anything in [Renslow’s] file that would signify anything significant in his recent history” and that “there weren’t any issues I saw with him transitioning” to the Q400. Yet the emails revealed that in previous August he wrote to colleagues that “Rensloe [sic] had a problem upgrading” and was “off the list” of pilots being promoted. A month later, Renslow was giving the nod to fly the Q400.

In the case of Mitchel, the News says that he “said under oath in 2009 that Renslow ‘had 16 months of a very fine track record’ — even though Mitchel had said in an email only nine months earlier: ‘Anyone that does not meet the mins and had problems in training before is not ready to tackle the Q.'”

Predictably, these revelations have caused outrage among Flight 3407 family members and lawmakers alike, who are pressing to find out why the e-mails weren’t turned over to the NTSB during their investigation of the crash (the NTSB ruled that the cause of the crash was pilot error). A Western New York congressional delegation has written to the NTSB and Colgan Air with their concerns, with Rep. Kathy Hochul [D] in particular asking for a new investigation. And Sen. Charles Schumer [D-N.Y.] is calling for a hearing on the matter by the Senate Commerce Subcommittee on Aviation Operations, Safety and Security.

Colgan admits to not turning over the emails, though the company says it gave investigators the information contained in them. In addition, they say that Renslow “was qualified to begin his transition training into the Q400 aircraft, but the email exchange shows Colgan’s chief pilot required Renslow to pass his next scheduled check flight before being allowed to begin transition training into the Q400.”

Update [Oct. 31, 2011]: Several New York members of Congress sent a letter to U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder on Saturday, urging the Justice Department to consider “an investigation into whether Colgan’s actions constituted the intentional withholding of information sought by a federal agency and whether such actions violated federal law.”

In order to foster a civil and literate discussion that respects all participants, FRONTLINE has the following guidelines for commentary. By submitting comments here, you are consenting to these rules:

Readers' comments that include profanity, obscenity, personal attacks, harassment, or are defamatory, sexist, racist, violate a third party's right to privacy, or are otherwise inappropriate, will be removed. Entries that are unsigned or are "signed" by someone other than the actual author will be removed. We reserve the right to not post comments that are more than 400 words. We will take steps to block users who repeatedly violate our commenting rules, terms of use, or privacy policies. You are fully responsible for your comments.

blog comments powered by Disqus

More Stories

Derek Chauvin, three other ex-Minneapolis officers indicted by Justice Department on civil rights charges in killing of George Floyd
A federal grand jury has indicted four ex-Minneapolis police officers on charges of abusing their positions of authority to detain George Floyd, leading to his death last May.
May 7, 2021
FRONTLINE Earns Five Peabody Awards Nominations
Five FRONTLINE documentaries have been named 2021 George Foster Peabody Award finalists.
May 4, 2021
‘Escaping Eritrea’ Filmmaker Evan Williams Describes ‘Phenomenal Sacrifice’ of Eritreans Sneaking Footage Out of Country
'Escaping Eritrea' producer Evan Williams set out to learn what was driving so many Eritreans from their homeland. He found answers — as well as people trying to smuggle secret footage out of the country.
May 4, 2021
500,000 Refugees, ‘Slavery-like’ Compulsory Service, No National Elections, Border Conflicts & Secret Prisons: 5 Human Rights Crises in Eritrea
From compulsory conscription to the mass exodus of refugees, here is an introduction to five of Eritrea’s biggest human rights crises.
May 4, 2021