Education Department Finds No Evidence Of Widespread Cheating On D.C. Exams


January 8, 2013

An investigation by the U.S. Department of Education Inspector General has found no evidence of widespread cheating in the Washington, D.C. school system in response to a whistleblower lawsuit filed by a former principal featured in tonight’s FRONTLINE film, The Education of Michelle Rhee.

The department’s findings, released Monday, were hailed by Rhee, the former D.C. chancellor. In interviews for the film, Rhee denied that she had been aware of allegations of pervasive cheating on standardized tests and that subsequent investigation of the charges had exonerated school officials.

The confidential lawsuit was brought in 2011 by Adell Cothorne, a former principal of the Noyes Education Campus. In her complaint, which was recently unsealed, Cothorne alleges that the district provided results from tampered student exams to the Department of Education while applying for federal grants, including $75 million in Race to the Top funding ultimately rewarded to D.C. in 2010.

The department said its investigation — which according to a spokesman looked at multiple schools — identified one instance of cheating on the D.C. Public Schools’ standardized examinations that may have had an impact on federal funding.

“Our investigation was unable to substantiate the allegations that false claims were made to [the U.S. Department of Education] for payment of funds, and the U.S. Department of Justice declined to intervene,” the department said in a statement.

As chancellor from 2007 to 2010, Rhee placed an emphasis on student test scores, tying exam results to the pay and employment status of teachers and principals. The approach produced higher scores, but also became the focus of public controversy in 2011 after a USA Today investigation documented an unusually high number of wrong-to-right pencil erasures on standardized test papers going back to 2008. The testing company, CTB-McGraw/Hill, however, pointed out the erasures to then state superintendent Deborah Gist in 2008.

While erasures on their own are not proof of cheating, experts say they can suggest some sort of tampering. The D.C. Inspector General launched an investigation in 2011, and though it uncovered a number of concerns about test security, it found no evidence of test altering. The Education Department said its investigation was “conducted in tandem” with the D.C. inspector general.

The D.C. inspector general’s report (pdf) did not investigate erasures during Rhee’s first year as chancellor, 2007-2008, the year with the highest number of suspicious erasures. Rather, it looked at only one school, even though approximately half of district schools had been flagged for a high rate of erasures.

After stepping down as chancellor, Rhee launched a national education advocacy group, StudentsFirst. In a statement released Tuesday, she said the results of the investigation “confirm what we’ve long believed, that the vast majority of educators would never compromise their personal or professional integrity to cheat on a test, thereby cheating children. With six separate, consecutive tests … showing significant improvements in academic achievement, we congratulate the children and educators in D.C. for their hard work and accomplishments.”

Cothorne was principal of Noyes during the 2010-2011 school year. She told FRONTLINE that she alerted district officials about possible cheating after discovering three school employees in an office with completed student practice test sheets and erasers.

“One staff member said to me, in a lighthearted sort of way, ‘Oh, principal, I can’t believe this kid drew a spider on the test and I have to erase it,'” Cothorne told FRONTLINE. She added that to her knowledge, there was no follow-up by officials.

In her lawsuit, Cothorne outlines several other incidents of alleged cheating she said she observed while principal at Noyes. Each involved the DC BAS test, a practice test leading up to the year-end DC CAS test.

In one instance, Cothorne reported walking in on a teacher teaching materials that were going to be on the DC BAS exam while test booklets were in front of the students. In a separate incident, a Noyes teacher allegedly told her, “You know they cheat on their tests,” according to the complaint. When test security was later tightened at Noyes, according to Cothorne, scores fell by 25 percent.

Rhee’s successor, Kaya Henderson, said in a statement Tuesday that DCPS has no record showing that Cothorne reported any alleged tampering. Henderson also said that Cothorne never revealed the alleged incidents when questioned by independent investigators.

Attorneys for Cothorne said their client has documentation supporting her claim that she alerted DCPS officials of the incidents. Her attorneys also said their client was unable to tell independent investigators about what she witnessed, because she was questioned by them before the alleged incidents occurred.

Henderson also expressed disappointment with FRONTLINE’s investigation into the scandal.

“PBS did not give DCPS the opportunity to respond to these specific allegations,” said Henderson, adding, “I am disappointed that PBS elected to produce a poorly researched piece rather than offering a meaningful contribution to improving education.”

Correspondent John Merrow said that Henderson denied multiple requests to be interviewed for the film. Merrow said he learned of the Cothorne lawsuit when it was first reported on Monday.

Jason M. Breslow

Jason M. Breslow, Former Digital Editor



In order to foster a civil and literate discussion that respects all participants, FRONTLINE has the following guidelines for commentary. By submitting comments here, you are consenting to these rules:

Readers' comments that include profanity, obscenity, personal attacks, harassment, or are defamatory, sexist, racist, violate a third party's right to privacy, or are otherwise inappropriate, will be removed. Entries that are unsigned or are "signed" by someone other than the actual author will be removed. We reserve the right to not post comments that are more than 400 words. We will take steps to block users who repeatedly violate our commenting rules, terms of use, or privacy policies. You are fully responsible for your comments.

blog comments powered by Disqus

More Stories

A Look at Colin Powell’s Legacy, Following His Death at 84
Colin Powell, who was America’s first Black secretary of state, died Oct. 18 at age 84. FRONTLINE traced his roles in shaping the Gulf War and then the Iraq War.
October 18, 2021
Shooting Not to Kill. This Utah Case Fuels a Debate That Frustrates Police.
If there’s nothing barring officers from shooting someone in the leg or arm, it raises a question many civilians wonder about: Why don’t officers, if possible, shoot a suspect there, instead of in the chest or head? It’s a question that frustrates and annoys many in law enforcement.
October 18, 2021
PANDORA PAPERS: Video & Major Stories From Our Partners
Watch the trailer for an upcoming FRONTLINE investigation into the Pandora Papers, exposing how U.S. trusts are sheltering millions in controversial assets, and read major stories from our ICIJ partners.
October 17, 2021
Former Boeing 737 Max Pilot Pleads Not Guilty to Federal Grand Jury Indictment
Mark Forkner’s role at Boeing leading up to the crashes that killed 346 people was detailed by The New York Times and FRONTLINE in ‘Boeing’s Fatal Flaw.’
October 15, 2021