NCAA Approves New Rules — But Do They Matter?

A detail view of an Wilson NCAA basketball is seen on a court at Bracket Town on Sunday April 3, 2011 in Houston, Texas.

Photo: A Wilson NCAA basketball on a court at Bracket Town on April 3, 2011 in Houston, Texas. (AP/Aaron M. Sprecher)

October 28, 2011

As expected, the NCAA yesterday approved a new set of regulations for Division I sports:

+ Conferences will have the option of increasing scholarship funds by $2,000 (on average, scholarship money falls about $3,000 short of covering a college student’s essential expenses).

+ Starting in 2012, teams competing in postseason play, including the March Madness basketball tournament and the Bowl Championship Series in football, will have tougher academic requirements that will increase in strictness over time. According to the NCAA, the new rules would have kept 30 teams out of last year’s men’s March Madness, including national champion Connecticut.

+ Conferences will have the option of giving one-year or multi-year scholarships to student-athletes. Since 1973, schools have only been allowed to guarantee aid for a year at a time.

The Washington Post is reporting that there are also new changes coming to the way coaches recruit, including an extended recruitment period.

Former Nike executive and NCAA critic Sonny Vaccaro, who appeared in our film Money and March Madness, told us by phone today that the rule changes won’t change the underlying realities.  “It’s all cosmetic.  It means nothing.  The NCAA has done nothing more than throw a bone to the people who have been crying about this for years,” he said.

Vaccaro’s concern is that the NCAA is merely making a “request” of the conferences to carry out the scholarship reforms, leaving it to them to provide up to $2,000 in additional aid — at some schools, scholarships fall well below the cost of attendance — or to allow for multi-year scholarships.  “The NCAA took away the four-year scholarship in 1973.  They took it away.  Why are they leaving it up to others to undo this ungodly rule?”

The NCAA has been under fire over the past year, with critics like Vaccaro and historian Taylor Branch accusing the organization of operating like a cartel and taking advantage of students financially. The March Madness basketball tournament alone rakes in $700 million per year in a TV deal with CBS and Turner Broadcasting, and some student-athletes say they deserve a cut.

Vaccaro points out that the new academic benchmarks to participate in the postseason don’t begin to phase-in until the 2012-13 academic year.  “Isn’t it ironic that the one rule that affects the financial situation of the NCAA tournament and the bowl games is delayed?” Vaccaro asks. “This is for the benefit of the NCAA… Nothing’s changed really. Nothing.”

While NCAA president Mark Emmert, as evidenced by the new rules, has said he’s open to scholarship reform, he emphasized to us this spring that amateurism is the name of the game.

“What would be utterly unacceptable,” Emmert said, “is to convert students into employees. The point of March Madness, of the Men’s Basketball Tournament, is the fact that it’s being played by students. We don’t pay our student-athletes.”

Zachary Stauffer produced FRONTLINE’s Money and March Madness.

In order to foster a civil and literate discussion that respects all participants, FRONTLINE has the following guidelines for commentary. By submitting comments here, you are consenting to these rules:

Readers' comments that include profanity, obscenity, personal attacks, harassment, or are defamatory, sexist, racist, violate a third party's right to privacy, or are otherwise inappropriate, will be removed. Entries that are unsigned or are "signed" by someone other than the actual author will be removed. We reserve the right to not post comments that are more than 400 words. We will take steps to block users who repeatedly violate our commenting rules, terms of use, or privacy policies. You are fully responsible for your comments.

blog comments powered by Disqus

More Stories

Ex-MPD Officer Thomas Lane Pleads Guilty to Manslaughter Charge for Role in George Floyd’s Murder
He was one of three officers convicted in federal court and expected to face trial next month on state charges.
May 18, 2022
9 Documentaries That Provide Context on the Buffalo Shooting
As America grapples with the deadly massacre, FRONTLINE's past reporting sheds light on the current moment and the circumstances that led to it, from guns to America's history of racist killings.
May 17, 2022
War Crimes Watch: Targeting Ukraine Schools, Russia Bombs the Future
The destruction of schools is about more than toppling buildings and maiming bodies, experts told our reporting partner The Associated Press. It hinders a nation’s ability to rebound after the fighting stops, injuring entire generations.
May 17, 2022
Minneapolis Agrees to Pay $200,000 to Settle Discrimination Complaints by Two Former Police Officers
Colleen Ryan alleged she was denied promotion because she's an openly gay woman, while former Deputy Chief Art Knight alleged his demotion was retaliatory.
May 12, 2022