Trump Inherits Guantanamo’s Remaining Detainees

A guard tower stands at a closed section of the U.S. prison at Guantanamo Bay on Oct. 22, 2016.

A guard tower stands at a closed section of the U.S. prison at Guantanamo Bay on Oct. 22, 2016. (John Moore/Getty Images)

In partnership with:
January 19, 2017

Earlier this week, the U.S. Department of Defense announced they had transferred 10 more Guantanamo detainees, this time to Oman. Now, 45 remain at the facility, leaving challenges on what to do with the prisoners for President-elect Donald Trump.

Back in 2009, on his third day in office, President Barack Obama ordered the detention facilities at Guantanamo to be closed “as soon as practicable, and no later than one year from the date of this order.”

The executive order also called for a review of the 240 detainees then held in Guantanamo.

“We concluded that 126 detainees would be approved for transfer. And that means transfer to another country, with security measures,” says Matt Olsen, the former head of Obama’s Guantanamo Review Task Force, which compiled and evaluated all the available information on the detainees. The files had never been brought together in one place.

But the year-long review also revealed how complicated the job of closing Guantanamo would be. It still wasn’t clear where to put those who could not be released: those who would be tried as war criminals, those considered too dangerous to release but too difficult to prosecute, as well as individuals in more ambiguous categories.

In 2011, Congress began placing restrictions on Guantanamo transfers in their yearly defense authorization bill — effectively stopping the president from transferring the detainees to a U.S. facility.

Even the detainees cleared for release were stuck in Guantanamo if they couldn’t return home. For example, there were dozens of Yemenis who had been cleared but couldn’t return to a country descending into a civil war.

It was up to the U.S. State Department to find a country willing to take the men the U.S. would not.

“Rather than being the worst of the worst, there are some who have the worst luck because they were from Yemen — because they were from a country that they cannot go back to,” says Cliff Sloan, who served as special envoy for Guantanamo closure in 2013 and 2014. He was responsible for convincing other countries to accept the detainees.

“It’s a very interesting process talking to foreign governments about their willingness to accept detainees for resettlement … the conversations are difficult. There are many things to work out,” he says.

The State Department won’t discuss details of the deals between the U.S. and foreign governments to take detainees, but they’ve ended up all over the world, from Kazakhstan to Uruguay.

Ambassador Lee Wolosky, the current special envoy for Guantanamo closure, says one of the things that makes it difficult to convince foreign governments to accept detainees is that old but sticky label, “worst of the worst.”

“The fact that they have been labeled in a political discourse as the worst of the worst, which some of them are, but some of them aren’t. And the ones we’re moving out are not, but they’re lumped in there,” says Wolosky. “That certainly makes the task of doing what we do, which is looking at each case and convincing our foreign partners to look at the facts of each case, more difficult, because of the labeling.”

The dozens of detainees left in Guantanamo after Monday’s transfer include seven men being tried in military commissions, like Sept. 11 mastermind Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, as well as others whose actual value and danger are contested.

Even if Obama had been able to serve a third term, it’s unlikely they’d be anywhere else.

“Until we are able to get a policy, a plan agreed to by a president — and by a Congress — to deal with the reality of, ‘What are you going to do to … address that last group of really hardcore people who are down there?’ then this will stay open indefinitely,” says Chuck Hagel, who served as U.S. secretary of defense from 2013 to 2015.

Trump has said he intends to start loading up Guantanamo with new war detainees — “bad dudes,” in his words.

Hagel says Trump will have plenty of opportunities to do just that.

“The reality is that we are at war. I mean, America is still at war after 15 years. So, as long as that’s the reality, we’re going to be dealing with Guantanamo. And what you do with those that you capture and you pick up, and … you have responsibility for.”

There are still a handful of detainees who have been cleared for release in Guantanamo, and it’s possible the transfers could continue up until the moment Trump takes office. The new commander in chief has called for the transfers to stop, so any prisoners cleared for release when Trump takes office may end up stuck in Guantanamo indefinitely.

This story was produced in partnership with NPR as part of a collaboration about Guantanamo Bay, Out of Gitmo, which will air on NPR and FRONTLINE on Feb. 21.

More Stories

Ukrainian Teen Describes Being Taken From School by Armed Men & Held in Russian-Controlled Territory
Artem Hutorov is among the Ukrainian teens who share their experiences of being taken to Russian-held territory in the new FRONTLINE documentary ‘Children of Ukraine.’
April 16, 2024
'Children of Ukraine' Filmmaker Describes How 'Wars Take Place on Many Different Levels'
"Children of Ukraine" director and producer Paul Kenyon spoke about the challenges of filming during a war, interviewing children who’ve lived through traumatic situations and what may happen to the thousands of children still held by Russia.
April 16, 2024
For Years She Thought Her Son Had Died of an Overdose. The Police Video Changed All That.
For six years, Karen Goodwin believed her son died of an overdose. But after she finally saw the police body-camera footage, her memories now conflict with stark images of restraint and force.
March 29, 2024
He Didn’t Trust Police but Sought Their Help Anyway. Two Days Later, He Was Dead.
Jameek Lowery, a 27-year-old Black man, was among more than 330 Black people who died after police stopped them with tactics that aren’t supposed to be deadly, like physical restraint and use of stun guns, The Associated Press found.
March 29, 2024