justice for sale


To see these clips you'll need RealPlayer G2 or later.
Interview with U.S. Supreme Court Justices Stephen Breyer and Anthony Kennedy.

on the threat to judicial integrity and independence from campaign money in judicial races (or read the transcript of this interview). (5 minutes)
Excerpt on the elections of judges at the Supreme Court level in the state of Texas

from FRONTLINE's program "Justice For Sale."(3 minutes)
In 1998, Pascal Calogero, Chief Justice of the Louisiana Supreme Court, faced re-election. A business lobby group--the Louisiana Association of Business and Industry (LABI) --targeted Calogero for replacement following a review of the judge's record which they felt to be unfriendly to business interests. To run against Calogero, LABI put forward its own handpicked candidate, Chuck Cusimano, a former politician.
 Cusimano's attack on Judge Calogero

In the heat of the campaign, Cusimano ran this ad suggesting that Calogero was a friend of sexual predators who didn't deserve re-election. Though television ads have become common in judicial elections--even negative ads--this ad alarmed many court-watchers as unusually vicious and threatening to the integrity of the judiciary.
Calogero's response to Cusimano

Judge Calogero responded to Cusimano's "molester" ad with a presentation of his "tough on crime" bona fides and endorsements. Calogero ultimately prevailed at the polls.

home how bad is it? my state history selecting judges video discussion

home · how bad is it? · what's happening in my state? · how did we come to elect judges?
how should judges be selected? · video · quiz
discussion · links · synopsis · press · tapes · funding · teachers' guide
frontline · pbs online · wgbh

some images copyright © 1999 photodisc all rights reserved
web site copyright 1995-2014 WGBH educational foundation