The yield curve, a key economic indicator that has been used to predict recessions, is renewing fears in the U.S. bond markets.
This week, the difference between the yield on the 10-year and three-month Treasury notes grew significantly larger than it was in March, when the yield curve inverted for the first time since 2007 and sent stocks plummeting.
At the time, investors were, in part, reacting to a move by the Federal Reserve that signaled it was more pessimistic about the future economy. The investors’ response led to this crucial economic indicator becoming inverted from its “normal” state.
The further inversion this week again put stocks on a downward trajectory. The Dow Jones Industrial Average dropped more than 200 points Wednesday.
What is an inverted yield curve?
Here’s how the yield curve works: When investors buy bonds, they are lending the government money. The Treasury then pays back interest on that money each year and returns the full amount to investors whenever the bond reaches the end of its set term — or, as it’s called, its maturity date.
The yield on a Treasury bond is the interest rate the U.S. Treasury is offering investors to get them to lend it money.
In “normal” circumstances, this is what a yield curve looks like.
See how the curve tilts upward? On Oct. 22, 2018, the yield — or interest rate — on the 10-year Treasury bond was 3.22 percent. The yield on the three-month bond was lower — 2.34 percent.
But something changed in March. The yield curve was “inverted” and looked like this.
See how the curve dips and the 10-year interest rate is slightly below the three-month rate? What investors are always watching is the yield on the 10-year Treasury. On March 22, that yield dropped to about 2.44 percent, but the yield on the three-month Treasury bond was slightly higher, at around 2.46 percent.
As of Wednesday, that gap had widened to 0.12 percent, or 12 basis points, as it’s called in the financial world. The three-month note was yielding 2.37 percent compared to the 10-year note’s 2.25 percent.
Why is that? Basically, investors are buying more of the 10-year bond. And based on the rules of supply and demand, that pushes the interest rate down.
So why are they buying more? It’s a signal they may be betting the economy is going to slow down.
What is making investors pessimistic?
The Federal Reserve announced in March it was not planning any more interest rate hikes. That could be taken as a sign it, too, is pessimistic about the economy — even that a recession might be down the road.
The news was just “the straw that broke the camel’s back,” said Diane Swonk, chief economist at Grant Thornton.
A slowdown in European and the Chinese economies, growing corporate debt and concerns over Brexit have all caused investors to become gloomier in recent months.
But as the U.S.-China trade war has intensified, fears that the countries might not made a trade deal and instead enter a long-term economic “cold war” have rattled the financial markets even more.
Even before the yield curve became “inverted,” it had remained relatively “flat,” meaning the difference in the short and long-term bond yields had been fairly small. A flat yield curve is often seen as a sign of slower economic growth.
But earlier this year Former Fed Chair Janet Yellen downplayed the idea a recession was a foregone conclusion at a Credit Suisse investors conference in Hong Kong.
The inverted yield curve “might signal that the Fed would at some point need to cut rates, but it certainly doesn’t signal that this is a set of developments that would necessarily cause a recession,” Yellen said.
So are investors’ fears justified?
David Wessel, a fellow at the Brookings Institution, a Washington, D.C.-based think tank, said the recent moves in the bond market are more worrisome than they were a couple of months ago.
“The bond markets around the world seem to be suggesting they see some pretty gloomy times ahead. It doesn’t mean they’re right, but it’s a signal worth contemplating,” he said.
Wessel reminds us, however, that markets run on psychology, not just the fundamentals, and if investors react too strongly to any or all of these factors, their fear could become a self-fulfilling prophecy. And if businesses and consumers become overly cautious — i.e., stop investing and spending — that could cause the U.S. economy to contract and fall into a recession sooner than it might have otherwise.
“People get uneasy, people pull back and then it doesn’t take much to push it over the edge,” he said.