Support Intelligent, In-Depth, Trustworthy Journalism.
Steve Karnowski, Associated Press
Steve Karnowski, Associated Press
ST. PAUL, Minn. — President Donald Trump says he’s celebrating Tax Day.
Trump flew to Minnesota on Monday to highlight the $1.5 trillion package of corporate and individual tax cuts he signed into law in 2017. U.S. taxpayers across the country are rushing to meet a midnight Monday deadline for filing their income tax returns with the IRS.
A smattering of boos rose from the audience at a trucking company in the Minneapolis suburb of Burnsville after Trump said “today is Tax Day that we’re celebrating.”
Trump says incorrectly that he enacted the largest package of tax cuts in history. But the facts don’t bear that out.
Trump’s package considerably trails Ronald Reagan’s 1981 tax cuts, Barack Obama’s 2013 extension of George W. Bush’s tax cuts, and others.
Minnesota is an erstwhile Democratic stronghold Trump hopes to flip in 2020 after nearly winning it in 2016. Questions remain, however, about just how much he’s politically benefiting from his signature legislative accomplishment.
Minnesota, which gave the country Democratic Vice Presidents Hubert Humphrey and Walter Mondale, hasn’t given its 10 electoral votes to a Republican since Richard Nixon in 1972. Trump came within 1.5 percentage points of carrying the state in 2016 thanks to his strength among rural voters.
The state’s Democrats saw a huge overall resurgence during the anti-Trump backlash of 2018, notably in traditionally Republican suburbs of Minneapolis and St. Paul. Giving the president hope is the memory that his popularity outside the Twin Cities area helped the GOP flip two Democratic U.S. House seats last year.
“I’m glad he’s coming to Minnesota,” said state Senate Majority Leader Paul Gazelka, the top Republican in state government. “I think he realizes Minnesota’s in play.”
READ MORE: Unhappy with your refund under the new tax law? Here’s what to do
Ahead of Trump’s visit, Kevin Hassett, chairman of the White House Council of Economic Advisers, talked up the 2017 tax law during a teleconference with reporters Friday. He said it’s working exactly as its proponents predicted and that it quickly made the U.S. an attractive place to do business again, leading to increased hiring and higher wage growth. He also said the tax cuts continue to provide “sustained, long-term nourishment for our economy.”
Trump planned to visit a truck and equipment company in the suburb of Burnsville on Monday for a roundtable discussion on the tax cuts and the economy.
Minnesota Sen. Amy Klobuchar, a Democratic presidential candidate, on Sunday criticized Trump’s tax cuts, saying they added trillions of dollars to the nation’s debt and disproportionately helped the wealthy.
“That tax bill was a major missed opportunity,” she said. “That tax bill should have been a bill that would have not only brought some taxes down for working people but also could have funded a major infrastructure investment.”
So far Trump doesn’t appear to be getting a lot of credit for the tax changes. An NBC/Wall Street Journal poll last week showed that the vast majority of Americans don’t think they even got a tax cut. Just 17% of those polled believed their taxes went down.
More evidence came from a report by tax preparer H&R Block on Thursday that said Americans are undergoing a “confusing tax experience” this season. While its customers’ overall tax liability fell 24.9% in the first year under the new tax law, refunds were roughly flat at just 1.4%. While the average filer is better off, it said, they’re not seeing it in their refunds, “which many people think of as their ‘bottom line.'”
Federal data also shows a negligible increase in refunds. According to the IRS, as of March 29 the average refund nationally was $2,893, which is just $20 more than at the same point last tax season.
Further muddling the picture is that the federal deduction for state and local taxes was capped at $10,000, which matters in high-tax states such as Minnesota, California and New York, among others. Minnesota Senate Minority Leader Tom Bakk said that might be why Trump is visiting.
“It was a pretty bad bill for Minnesota,” said Bakk, a Democrat who is considered one of the Legislature’s leading tax experts. “He’s coming on the last day you can file — he’s coming here to try and put a smiley face on a real pig that Minnesota got handed.”
This has been a frustrating filing season for many Minnesota taxpayers and preparers. The GOP-controlled 2018 Legislature and Democratic former Gov. Mark Dayton were unable to agree on how to sync the state’s code with the federal changes. That wasn’t Trump’s fault, but the extra paperwork and hassles in understanding the diverging rules are likely further obscuring the benefits of the federal changes for Minnesota taxpayers.
Trump plans to talk trade during his visit, but that’s another tricky issue for him in Minnesota. His tariffs on imported steel are popular among blue-collar workers in the state’s north, where the iron mining industry has seen a resurgence thanks to increased demand from domestic steelmakers. His mentions of steel tariffs drew loud cheers at a raucous campaign rally last year in Duluth, which is in northern Minnesota.
But Trump’s trade war with China has depressed already low prices for some of southern Minnesota’s most important farm exports — soybeans and pork. Trump has had strong support in Minnesota’s farm country, but continued low prices amid uncertainty about whether farmers can plant in time due to the wet spring will put that to the test.
READ MORE: How U.S. tax laws discriminate against women, gays and people of color
Support Provided By:
Support PBS NewsHour:
Subscribe to Here’s the Deal, our politics newsletter for analysis you won’t find anywhere else.
Thank you. Please check your inbox to confirm.
Additional Support Provided By: