Flashback: Inside Facebook’s First Tangle with the FTC

Facebook co-founder, Chairman and CEO Mark Zuckerberg testifies before the House Energy and Commerce Committee in the Rayburn House Office Building on Capitol Hill.

Facebook co-founder, Chairman and CEO Mark Zuckerberg testifies before the House Energy and Commerce Committee in the Rayburn House Office Building on Capitol Hill. (Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)

July 26, 2019

The Federal Trade Commission announced this week that it will fine Facebook $5 billion and institute new oversight programs and business restrictions on the company for privacy violations.

It’s the highest fine a company has ever paid for consumer privacy violations, according to an announcement from the FTC — but it represents only about one percent of Facebook’s current $500 billion-plus market cap.

In order to “prevent Facebook from deceiving its users about privacy in the future,” the settlement also dictates a restructuring of how the company handles and reports on privacy, and boosts government oversight — which includes holding Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg civilly and criminally liable if the company submits false quarterly or annual privacy compliance certifications to the FTC.

In a post on the platform he founded, Zuckerberg discussed the settlement and outlined the “major structural changes” he says Facebook will make. “We’re going to set a completely new standard for our industry,” he wrote.

The FTC announcement also noted that the Department of Justice is filing a civil complaint on behalf of users.

This isn’t the first time Facebook has settled with the FTC over privacy violations. In the below excerpt from 2018’s The Facebook Dilemma, former director of the FTC Bureau of Consumer Protection David Vladeck discusses the agency’s earlier investigation — which began in 2010 — into whether Facebook had been deceiving its users about how their data was being shared.

“The heart of our cases against companies like Facebook was deceptive conduct,” Vladeck told FRONTLINE. “That is, they did not make it clear to consumers the extent to which their personal data would be shared with third parties.”

Vladeck found that Facebook had been sharing users’ personal data with third-party developers. And because Facebook wasn’t keeping track of what those developers were doing with it, Vladeck and his FTC colleagues saw the potential for data to be misused.

As the documentary recounts, Facebook settled with the FTC without admitting guilt but agreed to fix the problems. Part of the expectation, Vladeck told FRONTLINE, was that the company would boost staffing dedicated to privacy issues.

But in the above excerpt, a former Facebook platform operations manager named Sandy Parakilas told FRONTLINE he was put in charge of working on Facebook’s privacy problems just nine months into his very first job in the tech sector.

“I was horrified. I didn’t think I was qualified,” he told FRONTLINE.

Parakilas said that when he brought his findings on how the data Facebook was sharing with third-party developers could be misused to senior executives, their focus was instead on growth.

Facebook said that despite Parakilas’ account, it had large teams of people working to improve users’ privacy.

The company has also said it took the 2012 FTC order seriously. This week’s agreement, however, indicates that the company continued to mislead users.

For more on Facebook’s pursuit of growth and its consequences for privacy and democracy, stream The Facebook Dilemma in full on pbs.org/frontline, on-demand, or on the PBS Video App. As part of the FRONTLINE Transparency Project, you can also explore an interactive version of the film and 29 extended interviews from the making of the documentary.

Patrice Taddonio

Patrice Taddonio, Digital Writer & Audience Development Strategist, FRONTLINE



More Stories

Kherson After Liberation: Co-producer of ‘Putin’s Attack on Ukraine’ Documentary Describes Visit
A Ukrainian filmmaker and journalist who was on one of the first trains traveling to the newly liberated city talks to FRONTLINE about the damage he saw in Kherson after eight months of Russian occupation.
November 29, 2022
As Donald Trump Announces His 2024 Run, a Look Back at His Presidency and Impact
FRONTLINE has built a unique public record, in documentary format, of the former president’s impact on American life, politics and democracy — and his previous battles with a special counsel and the Department of Justice.
November 16, 2022
How American Politics Reached This Fraught Moment: 12 Documentaries to Watch Ahead of the Midterms
As a divided America prepares to vote and fears of political violence continue, these FRONTLINE documentaries show how U.S. politics reached this moment.
November 4, 2022
How Russian Soldiers Ran a "Cleansing" Operation in Bucha
"I’ve already killed so many civilians,” a Russian soldier told his wife from Bucha, Ukraine. The Associated Press and FRONTLINE obtained hundreds of hours of CCTV footage and intercepts of audio calls by Russian soldiers that show for the first time what a Russian "cleansing" operation looked like.
November 3, 2022