‘Voter Suppression At Its Finest’: Wisconsin Citizens Say Missing Ballots, Lines and Coronavirus Kept Them from Being Counted in Election

Hali Fisher, 24, waits in line to vote in Milwaukee on Tuesday, April 7, 2020. The Wisconsin primary went forward amid the coronavirus epidemic after Gov. Tony Evers' attempt to shut down the election was rejected by the Wisconsin Supreme Court on Monday.

Hali Fisher, 24, waits in line to vote in Milwaukee on Tuesday, April 7, 2020. The Wisconsin primary went forward amid the coronavirus epidemic after Gov. Tony Evers' attempt to shut down the election was rejected by the Wisconsin Supreme Court on Monday. (Mike De Sisti / Milwaukee Journal Sentinel via USA TODAY NETWORK)

In partnership with:

With just hours before election results are released, many Wisconsin citizens say they never got the chance to cast their votes.

After a chaotic week culminating in a last-minute U.S. Supreme Court order, questions remain about the validity of the process for people who never received their absentee ballots.

Over the past several days, reporters interviewed 32 would-be voters who said they were forced to choose between going to the polls during a pandemic and not having their votes counted.

More than 500 people, responding to the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel in an online form, said they requested their ballots in advance but did not receive them in time.

A picture emerged of voters disappointed, angry and confused about how the election played out in a state that has long prided itself on taking voting seriously.

Roseann Schmidt, an 80-year-old disabled breast cancer survivor who lives in Milwaukee, said she applied twice for an absentee ballot.

After her first attempt was rejected because she did not know how to attach a photo ID, Schmidt applied a second time with the help of a disability rights advocate.

Although Schmidt got confirmation that the ballot was mailed, no envelope had arrived by election day, she said.

“I felt so bad all day,” she said. “All day, off and on, I just burst into crying. I just felt so bad, physically sick and then not being able to go and vote on top of it all. My day just felt so empty. It was nothing. It was just fruitless.”

Several would-be voters in Milwaukee said they were recovering from COVID-19.

Hannah Gleeson, a 34-year-old health care worker, said she knew voting in person was not going to be an option for her after she tested positive for coronavirus in late March.

Gleeson said she and her husband requested absentee ballots ahead of the deadline but never received them. On election day, the couple stayed home as others made their way to the polls.

“I can’t expose hundreds, possibly thousands, of people to something that I’ve been struggling with now for 14 days,” Gleeson said. “I really think it’s voter suppression at its finest. I honestly think that it’s a failing of democracy and everything that America was built on.”

Lee McFadden Jr., 63, a retiree who said he was recently discharged from the hospital after recovering from coronavirus, lugged his oxygen tank to three different poll locations looking for one without a line.

Unable to stand for long, he was confronted with crowds at every location, he said.

“I told my wife, ‘We’re not going to vote this year because my health means more to me than trying to elect some official,’” McFadden said. “So I came home.”

Milwaukee offered only five polling places Tuesday due to lack of poll workers — less than 3% of its normal 180 voting sites.

Unofficial election results are expected after 4 p.m. Monday.

Of the nearly 1.3 million absentee ballots requested for last Tuesday’s election, more than 200,000 had not been returned as of Saturday, according to the Wisconsin Elections Commission.

Over the past week, pockets of evidence surfaced of ballots that never made it to intended recipients. In Milwaukee, election officials called for the U.S. Postal Service to investigate absentee ballots mailed about March 22 and 23 that were never received.

In Fox Point, village officials said hundreds of ballots were returned as undeliverable, without explanation, in the week leading up to the election.

And in Oshkosh and Appleton, officials reported finding three tubs of absentee ballots in a mail processing center.

On top of all that, in a 5-4 vote, the U.S. Supreme Court determined on the eve of the election that ballots postmarked after April 7 should not be counted. But metered mail isn’t postmarked, leaving local election officials wondering what to do with ballots received Wednesday and Thursday that were likely mailed before deadline but weren’t postmarked.

And when the Milwaukee Election Commission met Sunday via Zoom to determine what to do with 354 such ballots, the meeting was “zoombombed” by disruptive hackers and had to be canceled.

Assembly Minority Leader Gordon Hintz of Oshkosh said the online portal where he ordered his ballot confirmed it was sent on March 24, though he never received it.

When speaking with the state elections board, the Democratic lawmaker learned that a “glitch” due to the large number of requests may have resulted in ballots not being sent.

“I don’t expect it to ever come,” Hintz said.

Many people of color, sensitive to the hard-fought right to vote, said the experience weighed on them heavily.

“I always tell my family to vote — my aunts and uncles … and my mom,” said Alexandra Salazar, a 26-year-old from Milwaukee who lives with her girlfriend and three family members.

When Salazar’s absentee ballot did not arrive, she said she could not risk bringing COVID-19 back to the household.

As a queer person of color, Salazar said she “felt this sense of weight of having to vote because it is a voice for my community. And the fact that that was taken from me just made it all the more worse.”

Shavonda Sisson, who works for the nonprofit Public Allies Milwaukee, was among several who said they did not receive their ballots but whose spouses, partners or roommates did.

Not receiving her ballot “essentially left me disenfranchised,” she said.

Experiences like this “continue to feed the historical mistrust for systems that we would love to think are there for us,” Sisson said.

Michael DeNomie, a 46-year-old software developer in Milwaukee County, said he and his wife requested ballots around the same time in mid-March. His wife’s ballot arrived promptly; his never did.

DeNomie requested a second ballot, but it arrived two days too late, he said.

“It makes me really angry,” said DeNomie. “And I know that this happened to a lot of people.”

Doug Doeren, 74-year-old from Brown County, said he tried five times to vote: once by absentee ballot, which never came; twice curbside, and twice in person.

Green Bay was among the hardest hit cities in the state, with voters reporting that it took up to four hours to cast their ballots. The third largest city in Wisconsin reduced its normal polling sites from 31 to just two due to a lack of poll workers, according to city officials.

Doeren said he was turned away by the long lines and given incorrect information about voting times. With huge crowds still waiting to vote by 8 p.m., Doeren and his wife gave up and went home.

“I’ve never seen anything like it,” he said. “It was definitely a suppression of the vote, and it upsets me.”

This story is produced in partnership with the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel and Columbia Journalism Investigations, an investigative reporting unit at the Columbia Journalism School.

Reporter Daphne Chen is with the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel; Marcia Robiou, Kacey Cherry and June Cross are from FRONTLINE PBS; and Elizabeth Mulvey is from Columbia Journalism Investigations. Bianca Ladipo of FRONTLINE contributed to this report.

Daphne Chen, Reporter, Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

Marcia Robiou

Marcia Robiou, Associate Producer, FRONTLINE



Elizabeth Mulvey, Reporter, Columbia Journalism Investigations

Kacey Cherry, Reporter, FRONTLINE

In order to foster a civil and literate discussion that respects all participants, FRONTLINE has the following guidelines for commentary. By submitting comments here, you are consenting to these rules:

Readers' comments that include profanity, obscenity, personal attacks, harassment, or are defamatory, sexist, racist, violate a third party's right to privacy, or are otherwise inappropriate, will be removed. Entries that are unsigned or are "signed" by someone other than the actual author will be removed. We reserve the right to not post comments that are more than 400 words. We will take steps to block users who repeatedly violate our commenting rules, terms of use, or privacy policies. You are fully responsible for your comments.

blog comments powered by Disqus

More Stories

In Wake of Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s Death, McConnell Reverses Course on Supreme Court Vacancy; Vows Vote on Nominee
It’s a markedly different approach than he took in the previous presidential election year of 2016, when a different Supreme Court justice died more than eight months before voters went to the polls.
September 19, 2020
Handling of Public Protests a 'Stress Test' for Police Reform
Violent outbursts have marked the period of unrest since George Floyd died May 25, after Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin pinned the 46-year-old Black man to the ground by his neck. In many cases, police have responded with force to disperse protesters, captured on cameras nationwide — including in Cleveland, Chicago, Seattle and Portland, all cities that were already under court-enforced agreements to reform their police departments. Independent monitors overseeing those agreements say it's possible police could find themselves out of compliance for how they've responded to the recent unrest.
September 18, 2020
Amid George Floyd Protests, a Critical Question: Can the Feds Fix American Policing?
As millions of people rallied in the streets this summer demanding an end to police violence, more than a dozen cities were quietly working on their own police reform process — in conference rooms and court hearings.  
September 16, 2020
A Newark Officer Was Filmed Punching Someone. Jelani Cobb Asked a Police Union Head If It Was Justified.
Their resulting conversation in the new FRONTLINE documentary “Policing the Police 2020” illustrates the debate over use of force in policing: what’s legal, what’s justified and whether those definitions should change.
September 15, 2020