Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
art:21
art in the twenty-first century the series the artists education events discuss

teaching materials:
search the online lesson library:
Home & Displacement

overview

LESSON TITLE:
Migrating Viewpoints

ARTISTS:
Orozco, Osorio, Sikander, Suh, Walker

LEVEL:
Grades 9-12

SUBJECT AREA:
Social Studies

NATIONAL STANDARDS:
#1—Culture & diversity
#2—People over time
#3—People, places & environments
#5—Global connections & interdepence

THEMES:
Identity, Stories

LESSON CONTRIBUTORS:
Thi Bui, Visual Art and Social Studies Teacher, Bayside High School, Brooklyn, NY













































"...At some point in your life you have to leave your home. And whenever you go back it’s just not the same home anymore. I think home is something that you carry along with your life."
— Do-Ho Suh

















"I concentrate on reality in terms of what is happening to me and I try to revolutionize that and try to rethink it and transform it. I try to transform reality with it's own rules, with the things I found there [...] I never carry anything with me."
— Gabriel Orozco




























detail of Osorio's "El Chandelier"
Pepón Osorio:
El Chandelier
detail of Sikander's "Fleshy Weapons"
Shahzia Sikander:
Fleshy Weapons
Lesson 2—Migrating Viewpoints

In an age of global travel and migration, many people identify themselves with multiple cultures or cities – those where they have been born as distinct from those that they travel to later in life or those that represent the cultural identities of their family. This lesson will have students investigate the effects of migration versus voluntary movement and how the process of relocation and dislocation can affect the emotional being of a person.

To initiate research, students will explore how contemporary artists represent their own global experiences in their work. Many artists have talked about shifts in perspective experienced as a result of being born or growing up in one place and moving or traveling to another place later in their lives. How do these artists represent the merging of different cultural influences in their work? How does their artwork reflect new hybrid cultures shaped by migration, transnational identification, and global travel? Do-Ho Suh’s memories of his childhood home and school days in Korea surface in sculptures that address the transnational individual’s dilemma of home and displacement. Gabriel Orozco travels between Paris, Mexico City and New York City, constantly incorporating new techniques, philosophies, and materials into his nomadic practice. Shahzia Sikander explores both Hindu and Muslim imagery in her miniature paintings, viewing the juxtaposition and mixing of their diverse iconography as “parallel to the entanglement of histories of India and Pakistan.” Pepón Osorio’s installations and sculptures often reflect his Latino culture as well as collaborative experiences he creates with specific members of a community as a community activist and former social worker.
objectives

• Students will research and explore the effects and significance of migration, using the viewpoints of a range of contemporary artists.

• Students will create an oral history, collecting stories of immigration or migration to the United States from their own experience or that of family and friends.

materials & resources

Art:21 Web Site
Home Visits – Pepón Osorio interview & clip
El Chandelier - Pepón Osorio art work
Seoul Home/L.A. Home... – Do-Ho Suh interview & clip
Islam and Miniature Painting – Shahzia Sikander interview & clip
Thinking in Clay – Gabriel Orozco interview & clip
The Melodrama of Gone with the Wind – Kara Walker interview & clip

Additional Web Sites
http://bancroft.berkeley.edu/ROHO/1minute.html
  A guide to conducting an oral history and oral history interview
http://www.columbia.edu/cu/lweb/indiv/oral/offsite.html
  Columbia University oral history research office

http://www.loc.gov/exhibits/african/afam008.html
  African-American migration mosaic from the Library of Congress
http://memory.loc.gov/learn/lessons/98/migrate/essay.html
  Immigration/migration essay from the Library of Congress

Classroom Materials
• recording equipment:
• tape or MD recorders
• video camera
• writing notepads

critical questions

• What makes up the culture of the United States today?

• What effects do migration and immigration have on the beliefs, practices, and traditions of individuals and groups?

• How has the cultural make-up of the U.S. changed over time? What factors have contributed to these changes?

• How do large migrations change countries?

• What forces shape how individuals and groups respond to new environments, whether they assimilate, remain separate, prosper, or suffer?

• How do contemporary artists represent the current environment of global exchange, trade, and travel?


activities

Looking at Contemporary Artists
Have students look at the video segments for the artists Gabriel Orozco, Do-Ho Suh, Shahzia Sikander, Pepón Osorio, and Kara Walker. Each of these artists discusses issues of home, dislocation, and travel in their work, either addressing the place they were born or their connections to the crafts or techniques from a particular aspect of their culture.

Walker moved from California to Georgia as a child while Do-Ho Suh came from Korea to the United States as an adult to pursue his education. Have students compare and contrast the effects of dislocation in Kara Walker’s work with Do-Ho Suh’s. Have students compare Do-Ho Suh’s relationship to travel with Gabriel Orozco’s. How are Suh’s and Orozco’s travels reflected in their work? How do these artists merge different cultural and geographic influences in their work?
(Time: One to two 45 minute sessions)


Leaving Home – An Oral History Project
Have students collect responses from friends and family who have relocated from a home in another area of the U.S. or from another country. Use the one-minute guide provided at U.C. Berkeley to teach students how to conduct an oral history interview.

Brainstorm interview questions. For example, why did you leave your home? How did you feel about leaving? Did you take anything with you? What did you take? What do you remember about your hometown or home country? What do you miss about your hometown or home country?

Decide how much time will be spent on the project and assign a feasible number of persons for each student to interview (perhaps each student only does one in-depth interview). Explain the role of primary documents in the writing of history, and discuss the value of interviewing people whose experiences would not be written down otherwise. Provide time for students to do background research on their persons’ place of origin before conducting the interview. Plot places of origin on a map of the world before interviews are done; have students share the stories they learned after talking with interviewees about their experiences of leaving home. The same can be done before and after watching video clips on the artists featured in this lesson.

Practical things to consider:
• Do students have access to recording equipment? If not, consider having them do informal interviews and take notes by hand.
• Transcribing a recorded interview is a tedious task. Make sure students have enough time to do this essential part of the project.
• Bringing a photograph to an interview often helps trigger memories and sensory responses.

Ethical considerations:
• How much background research should be done about someone’s country of origin ahead of time?
• How much of a transcribed interview should be edited?
• What is the power relationship between the researcher and the subject?

Presentation:
Consider the different forms that oral histories can take. What form would best serve the stories that students have collected? How will they represent both their voice and the voice of their subject in their presentation?
Will the presentation take a written form, a visual form, or a combination of both?

Have students consider different forms of presentation such as a screenplay, a video, a comic book, a short story, an oral reading, a newspaper article, etc.
(Time: Five 45 minute sessions to long-term project)

reflection & evaluation

• Have students articulated an understanding of how different artists have represented the current environment of global exchange, trade, and travel?

• Have students generated thought-provoking interview questions?

• Have students conducted an oral history interview on the assigned topic?

• Have students made a written record of the interview?

• Have students articulated a range of responses to the question of what makes a home?

• Have students related the experiences of individuals to the larger phenomena of migration and immigration?


Find out how this lesson plan correlates to your state's education standards! On PBS TeacherSource do a search for "Art in the 21st Century" and click on the Standards Match icon.

going further

Create an oral history archive for the school that future students can use for research. Index entries according to research topics and have each successive class add to the archive through their own oral history projects.

Other lessons that could extend this lesson into a longer course of study include:

Understanding Home
Model Homes
Personal Stories in the Public
Honoring Heroes and History
Wartime Voices


Did you use this lesson or generate your own activities based on ideas inspired by the lesson? Submit student art work, new lesson plans, and your comments to Art:21 and have them posted on the site. Help the Online Lesson Library grow!

additional lesson plans on featured artists

Gabriel Orozco
In the Landscape
New Rituals
Migrating Viewpoints
Ode to a View

Pepón Osorio
Migrating Viewpoints
Model Homes
Understanding Home
Personal Stories in the Public
Describing the Real

Shahzia Sikander
Confronting Conflict
Migrating Viewpoints
Remaking Myths
Traditional Crafts, Contemporary Ideas

Do-Ho Suh
Honoring Heroes & History
Migrating Viewpoints
Model Homes
Understanding Home
Traditional Crafts, Contemporary Ideas
Wartime Voices
Yearbook Tribes & Nomads

Kara Walker
Cartoon Commentary
Characters & Caricatures
Confronting Conflict
Describing the Real
Looking at Likeness
Migrating Viewpoints
Copyright Art21, Inc. 2001-2006. All Right Rreserved. terms of use site map help credits go to top