Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
art:21
art in the twenty-first century the series the artists education events discuss

teaching materials:
search the online lesson library:
Individuals & Collectives

overview

LESSON TITLE:
The Alter-Ego Saves the Day

ARTISTS:
Antin, Barney, Hancock, Pettibon

LEVEL:
Grades 9-10

SUBJECT AREA:
Visual & Performing Arts

NATIONAL STANDARDS:
#1—Media & processes
#2—Structures & functions
#3—Symbols & ideas
#5—Assessing the merits of work

THEMES:
Identity, Stories

LESSON CONTRIBUTOR:
Kristine Bowen, Visual Art Teacher, High School for Legal Studies, Brooklyn, NY











"Gumby is a kind of metaphor for how I work. He actually goes into the book, goes into a biography or historical book and interacts with real figures from the past....Gumby represents an alter-ego for my work as an artist."
— Raymond Pettibon





















"I took on the king who was my male self. As a young feminist I was interested in what would be my male self so I figured, I’ll put hair on my face....I had a marvelous art-making machine, my personas"
— Eleanor Antin

















"Torpedo boy is kind of my alter-ego...He’s super strong except he has an inflated ego. And his pride and all of his other emotions get in the way of him performing his duties. So he’s very limited by his flesh."
— Trenton Doyle Hancock
detail of Antin as Antinova playing Cleopatra
Eleanor Antin: Humor, Personas, & Yiddish Theater interview & clip
Pettibon's "No title (There is a touch of poetry...)"
Raymond Pettibon: Gumby & Vavoom, interview & clip
Lesson 3—The Alter-Ego Saves the Day

Have you ever fantasized that you were psychic, a fictional character, or somebody from the past? Artists often take on different personalities in their work, muddying their own identity with that of someone else or with someone or something they've completely made up. The notion of the alter-ego bears an undeniable appeal: being in two places at once, occupying the body of the opposite sex, transforming into a better or braver self able to perform miraculous feats. From the aging portrait of Oscar Wilde's character Dorian Gray to Clark Kent’s swift phone-booth transformation, the alter-ego has functioned as a literary devise to manifest our deepest desires and compensate for our human limitations.

Several artists in the Art:21 series develop characters or alter-egos in their work. Raymond Pettibon uses the familiar cartoon character Gumby as a personification of his artistic process. Trenton Doyle Hancock invented Torpedo Boy as a flawed super-hero version of himself who attempts to protect an alternate universe populated by ‘Mounds’ and other mythical creatures. Eleanor Antin imagines herself in various guises, acting out idealized personas of both sexes. Matthew Barney also performs multiple roles in his CREMASTER series, including a satyr, Harry Houdini, Gary Gilmore and, in his latest installment, 'The Mason’s Apprentice.'

This lesson examines the function of the alter-ego in contemporary art as well as in other narrative sources. Students will create their own alter-ego and illustrate their adventures in a comic narrative.
objectives

• Students will consider the concept of an alter-ego in visual art and the notion of presenting an alternate, transformed, or idealized self.

• Students will explore the medium of the comic book as a narrative vehicle.

• Students will create their own alter-egos as a tragic, heroic, comedic, or sinister protagonist in a comic book narrative.


materials & resources

Art:21 Web Site
Humor, Personas, & Yiddish Theater – Eleanor Antin interview & clip
Storytelling, Characters & Colors – Trenton Doyle Hancock interview & clip
Gumby, Vavoom, & Baseball Players – Collier Schorr interview & clip
CREMASTER 3: at the Guggenheim Museum – Barney interview & clip

Additional Web Sites
http://www.geosites.com/SoHo/5537/hist.htm
  A history of the comic book
http://www.milieux.com/costume/
  A variety of examples of costumes including ethnic, historical, theatrical, plus costume museums


Classroom Materials
• paper
• pencils
• rulers
• markers or colored pencils
• examples of a variety of comic books

critical questions

• What is an alter-ego?

• What are different examples of alter-ego in literature, film, television, drama, or comic books and how do they function in different ways depending on the medium in which they are conceived and performed?

• What are different roles an alter-ego can assume?

• Why might a visual artist create an alter-ego in a work of art?


activities

The Fictionalized Self
Discuss the concept of the alter-ego. Identify alter-egos in literature and other media such as film, television, and comic books. What are the different functions an alter-ego might perform in a narrative (tragic, heroic, comedic, sinister)?

View Art:21 segments on artists Raymond Pettibon, Trenton Doyle Hancock, Eleanor Antin, and Matthew Barney and read portions of their interviews that describe their relationships to the alter-egos they have created in their work. Identify the various alter-egos created by each artist. How are they similar to and/or different from each other? How are they similar to and/or different from the artist themselves? What purpose does each alter-ego serve for its creator? What can the alter-ego do that the artist cannot?
(Time: One 45 minute session)

Altering the Ego
Look at examples of protagonists in comic books (The Hulk, Spiderman, Wonder Woman). Have students choose a persona that they would like to become. This person can be a compilation of the real (Michael Jordan), impossible (someone without a memory or a head), fictional (Tom Sawyer), historical (Cleopatra), or non-human (animal, plant or alien). Ask students to consider how this personae will stand-in for them in given situations and whether they will be heroic, tragic, comedic, or sinister. How will the character differ from them and how will they be similar? What special powers, characteristics, strengths or weaknesses will they have? How might they have acquired these qualities? What would they look like? What kind of costume would they wear? Would they have an archenemy or a sidekick? A love interest?
(Time: Half a 45 minute session)

Making the Costume
Have students create a sketch of their alter-ego and ask them to design a costume or outfit that this figure will wear in a separate drawing. Ask students to consider whether their identity or costume will change (like Bruce Banner to the Incredible Hulk or Clark Kent to Superman) or whether they will always look the same (like Professor Xavier of the X-Men or the Joker). How will their costume reflect their role, powers, and identity? Have students make a full-scale version of their costume or create a multi-media drawing or collage of the costume that incorporates the materials, colors, and accessories that would be used.
(Time: Two to four 45 minute sessions)

Constructing the Narrative
Have students create a narrative in which their alter-ego goes through a single day. What will the day include – a rescue, an argument, a sneak attack? Ask students to write out a beginning, a middle, and an end to the day as well as the issue, or the event that they will then interpret visually. Ask students to draw one issue of a comic book illustrating their alter-ego in this narrative. Consider conventions of comic book art such as incorporating dialogue, thought and sound bubbles, or altering long shot, close-ups and extreme close-ups for visual interest. Make a cover for your comic featuring your alter-ego. Photocopy each comic book for distribution and compilation classroom volume.
(Time: Four 45 minute sessions to long term project)

reflection & evaluation

• Have students examined the use of the alter-ego in art and other media such as comic books and cartoons?

• Have students explored the function of the alter-ego as a fictionalized, transformed, or idealized self?

• Have students devised their own alter-egos, created a related costume or outfit, and designed a comic book narrative illustrating the adventures of their alternate self?

Find out if this lesson plan correlates to your state's education standards! On PBS TeacherSource do a search for "Art in the 21st Century" and click on the Standards Match icon.

going further

Other lessons that could be combined with this lesson to form a longer unit or an extended course of study include:

Characters & Caricatures
Cartoon Commentary
Re-Made Myths: Remaking Myths


Did you use this lesson or generate your own activities based on ideas inspired by the lesson? Submit student art work, new lesson plans, and your comments to Art:21 and have them posted on the site. Help the Online Lesson Library grow!

additional lesson plans on featured artists

Eleanor Antin
Characters & Caricatures
Dictators, Collaborators, Managers & Soloists
Describing the Real
Looking at Likeness
The Alter-Ego Saves the Day
Wartime Voices

Matthew Barney
Converging Media
Dictators, Collaborators, Managers, & Soloists
The Alter-Ego Saves the Day
New Tools, New Materials

Trenton Doyle Hancock
Characters & Caricatures
Remaking Myths
Looking at Likeness
The Alter-Ego Saves the Day

Raymond Pettibon
Cartoon Commentary
Dictators, Collaborators, Managers & Soloists
Describing the Real
The Alter-Ego Saves the Day
Copyright Art21, Inc. 2001-2006. All Right Rreserved. terms of use site map help credits go to top