Blocked nominees reignite filibuster fight

“Something has to change,” Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev., said Thursday after Senate Republicans derailed two federal nominations. File photo of Reid by Getty Images

Senate Republicans have mounted a fight with the White House over President Barack Obama’s nominees to lead key agencies and serve on the courts, reigniting a battle over power and Senate rules.

The GOP on Thursday blocked two of Mr. Obama’s nominees — Rep. Mel Watt of North Carolina to lead the Federal Housing Finance Agency and Patricia Ann Millett to fill one of three vacant seats on the Circuit Court of Appeals in Washington D.C.

The Morning Line
After the Senate failed to muster the 60 votes needed to break the filibuster, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid hinted he would revisit rule changes and the so-called “nuclear option” giving the majority more power to approve nominees. That basically means using a parliamentary move to adjust the rules governing the chamber with a simple majority vote instead of a two-thirds vote. Democrats control 55 seats.

“Something has to change,” Reid said.

“I think it’s worth considering it,” Vice President Joe Biden told reporters when leaving the Capitol Thursday night. “I think it’s time for some common sense on confirmation. Mel Watt is absolutely, totally thoroughly qualified. It’s a gigantic disappointment.”

Republicans contend Watt, nominated in May, does not have enough experience to lead the agency, which oversees Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. He is the first sitting member of the House to be denied confirmation in 170 years, the Los Angeles Times’ Michael Memoli reports. “Members of the Congressional Black Caucus stood silently on the floor during his vote to protest Republicans’ blocking of an African American to a senior post,” he writes.

Democrats complained change is necessary, and called for action.

The votes put a screeching halt on what looked like progress when it came to Mr. Obama’s selections for major posts. Earlier this week, the Senate approved the president’s choices to lead the Office of Personnel Management and the Federal Communications Commission.

But still pending are the other vacant slots on the D.C. court and two big nominations: Jeh Johnson to be Homeland Security Director and Janet Yellen to lead the Federal Reserve Bank. And Sen. Rand Paul, R-Ky. indicated he will block the president’s Yellen nomination, even though he predicts she ultimately will be confirmed.

White House Press Secretary Jay Carney scoffed at Thursday’s action, calling it nothing more than “politics.” Carney told reporters the White House hopes there is “an opportunity for these nominees to move forward.”

Sen. John McCain on Thursday called for a “fix” to constant confrontations on the floor.

Earlier this summer, McCain was among a group working to negotiate a smooth process for some of the president’s nominees, with leaders agreeing not to change the chamber’s rules so the majority can muscle nominees through. It’s a process described by Politico’s Burgess Everett as a “relative peace” over the last few months.

Roll Call’s Niels Lesniewski has a tidy explainer about what happened Thursday:

The outcome was foretold when Sen. John McCain appeared on the floor shortly before noon to announce that he thought the Watt and Millett nominations were extraordinary circumstances under the terms of the 2005 “gang of 14? agreement that avoided a similar standoff.

“As to both the nominees we are considering today, I find and it is my judgment as a United States senator that extraordinary conditions exist,” the Arizona Republican said.
McCain was acutely aware what his declaration might mean, immediately suggesting further discussions with Reid.

“If we go to the nuclear option, which I understand some of my colleagues are now frustrated to the point where they’d like to, meaning that 51 votes will now determine either nominees or other rules of the Senate, we will destroy the very fabric of the United States Senate,” McCain said.

And the New York Times’ Jeremy Peters explains the court fight:

Another confrontation — on these nominations or others — seems inevitable. Even as Republicans pledged to stop Ms. Millett, two more nominees to the appeals court were working their way through the Senate confirmation pipeline.

Robert L. Wilkins, a Federal District Court judge, cleared the Senate Judiciary Committee on Thursday by a 10-8 party-line vote. Cornelia T. L. Pillard, a Georgetown law professor, was already approved by the committee and is awaiting a vote on the Senate floor.

The court is split evenly with four Republican and four Democratic appointees among the judges who regularly hear cases. Among the judges who are semiretired, five are seen as conservative, one as liberal.

There are still three vacancies that Mr. Obama is trying to fill. Republicans are pushing a bill that would eliminate those seats permanently because they argue the court has a light caseload. That has prompted Democrats to accuse Republicans of trying to change the rules simply because they do not like the president who is picking judges.

The Senate is not expected to vote again until Monday evening. With control of the upper chamber on the line next fall, the issue isn’t likely to go away any time soon.


On the NewsHour Thursday, Judy Woodruff spoke with Maine Republican Sen. Susan Collins about the GOP’s future amid autumn turmoil.

She said recent poll numbers showing the GOP at its lowest levels in history are a “clarion call” for her party. While Collins said she strongly disagreed with the “tactics” that led to the partial government shutdown, she applauded the tea party’s ability to shine new light on spending and the national debt.

“I believe in a big-tent Republican Party where there’s room for a variety of views,” Collins said. Though she lamented the “shrinking middle.”

She also briefly discussed new reports about government surveillance programs.

Watch here or below:

And you can see the other interviews in the series here.


  • Dramatic cuts to the nation’s food stamp program kick in Friday. Lawmakers are still attempting to negotiate a compromise on Capitol Hill.
  • New York’s controversial “stop and frisk” policy will continue, after a court blocked an earlier ruling that found it unconstitutional. The effort can continue during the appeals process, the court found.
  • The next “Game Change” book from Mark Halperin and John Heilemann includes juicy details on Mr. Obama considering replacing Biden on the ticket in 2012.
  • Biden told HLN in an interview that the president tried to log on to and experienced its problems firsthand.
  • The chairman of the Virginia Republican Party wrote an open letter to newspapers asking them to rescind their endorsements of Democratic gubernatorial candidate Terry McAuliffe. He wrote: “Given your previous partisan histories, I have no illusions that any of you would switch your support to Ken Cuccinelli. But after all the information that has become public about Terry McAuliffe, I simply must ask: How can you continue to endorse Terry McAuliffe in good conscience?”
  • Don’t miss our piece — produced by Morning Line co-author Deputy Political Editor Terence Burlij — about the Virginia contest Friday on the NewsHour.
  • The president can sometimes gab with columnists — off the record — for hours, Politico’s Dylan Byers reports.
  • The New York Times previews the runoff election for a House seat in Alabama as a test of the tea party.
  • Meet Sen. Cory Booker, D-N.J., sworn in Thursday after winning a special election to replace the late Democratic Sen. Frank Lautenberg. Booker cast his first vote as Oprah Winfrey looked on.
  • Liberal billionaires are influencing Tuesday’s off-year election contests.
  • Is Hillary Clinton offering an implicit rebuke of the Obama years? Phil Rucker explores the question in the Washington Post.
  • Here’s the latest on the Canadian drug bust implicating the mayor of Toronto.
  • 2012 GOP presidential nominee Mitt Romney will appear on NBC’s “Meet the Press” Sunday.
  • The House of Representatives calendar for 2014 is up.
  • It was Halloween on Capitol Hill, too. So no shock that a pirate crashed a press conference.
  • Huffington Post finds there are several kinds of a**holes in Washington.

NEWSHOUR: #notjustaTVshow













For more political coverage, visit our politics page.

Sign up here to receive the Morning Line in your inbox every morning.

Questions or comments? Email Christina Bellantoni at cbellantoni-at-newshour-dot-org.

Follow the politics team on Twitter: