Our Land: New Mexico’s Environmental Past, Present and Future
Avangrid’s Track Record in Maine
Season 5 Episode 13 | 8m 21sVideo has Closed Captions
Laura Paskus talks with Bangor Reporter Caitlin Andrews to learn more about Avangrid.
New Mexicans are facing some potentially big changes when it comes to the state’s electrical utility, thanks to a proposed merger between PNM Resources and Avangrid. How the merger might play out in New Mexico—and what the consequences might be—remains to be seen. But the company has been operating in Maine for more than a decade, and not without controversy.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Our Land: New Mexico’s Environmental Past, Present and Future is a local public television program presented by NMPBS
Our Land: New Mexico’s Environmental Past, Present and Future
Avangrid’s Track Record in Maine
Season 5 Episode 13 | 8m 21sVideo has Closed Captions
New Mexicans are facing some potentially big changes when it comes to the state’s electrical utility, thanks to a proposed merger between PNM Resources and Avangrid. How the merger might play out in New Mexico—and what the consequences might be—remains to be seen. But the company has been operating in Maine for more than a decade, and not without controversy.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
How to Watch Our Land: New Mexico’s Environmental Past, Present and Future
Our Land: New Mexico’s Environmental Past, Present and Future is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipLaura: I AM LAURA PASKUS.
NEW MEXICANS ARE FACING SOME POTENTIALLY BIG CHANGES WHEN IT COMES TO OUR ELECTRICAL UTILITY.
THAT IS BECAUSE THERE IS A MERGER BEING WORKED OUT BETWEEN PNM RESOURCES AND AVINGRID, THE U.S. SUBSIDIARY OF A SPANISH POWER COMPANY.
HOW THAT WILL PLAY OUT AND WHAT THE CONSEQUENCES MIGHT BE REMAIN TO BE SEEN.
BUT I CHECKED IN RECENTLY WITH CAITLIN ANDREWS A REPORTER FOR THE BANGOR DAILY NEWS.
AVINGRID HAS BEEN IN MAINE FOR MORE THAN A DECADE AND THE COMPANY HAS NOT BEEN WITHOUT CONTROVERSY.
HERE IN NEW MEXICO THERE IS A PLANNED MULTI BILLION DOLLAR MERGER BETWEEN PNM RESOURCES AND AVINGRID.
PNM HAS OPERATED AS A MONOPOLY THE STATE'S ELECTRICAL UTILITIES FOR DECADES AND AVINGRID IS A U.S. BASED SUBSIDIARY OF A SPANISH POWER COMPANY.
THIS IS ALL STILL PLAYING OUT HERE IN NEW MEXICO.
IN MAINE IN 2008 AVINGRID BOUGHT CENTRAL MAINE POWER.
WHEN THE COMPANY WAS COMING TO MAINE WHAT ARE SOME OF THE THINGS THAT THEY PROMISED AND WHAT HAVE PEOPLE SEEN HAPPEN OVER THE PAST 14 YEARS?
Andrews: I SHOULD SAY TO START THE WAY IT ACTUALLY CAME ABOUT, WAS IBERDROLA BOUGHT ENERGY EAST WHICH CENTRAL MAINE POWER WHICH WAS A SUBSIDIARY 2008 AND THEN IN 2015 IBERDROLA BOUGHT THIS OTHER COMPANY CALLED UIL HOLDINGS.
THEY MERGED THEM TOGETHER AND CREATED AVINGRID.
SO, AVINGRID WAS BIRTHED IN 2015 AND CMP ENDED UP BEING SOMETHING UNDERNEATH THAT.
I BELIEVE THE IDEA OF MERGING THEM TOGETHER WOULD CREATE MORE RELIABILITY, CREATE MORE DEPENDABLE CUSTOMER SERVICES AND IT WOULD CREATE A STRONGER UTILITY ALTOGETHER.
SOME OF THE CHALLENGES THAT HAVE COME UP SINCE THEN, YOU KNOW, YOU CAN MAKE THE ARGUMENT, WELL, AT LEAST THE STATE FOUND VERY RECENTLY COULD HAVE STRONG FROM THE AVINGRID MERGER.
THEY RELEASED A AUDIT THAT HAS BEEN THREE YEARS IN THE MAKING WITH LIBERTY CONSULTING GROUP THIS YEAR THAT FOUND AVINGRID ITSELF IS NOT A BAD COMPANY BUT IT HAS STRUGGLED SINCE THE MERGER TO BE ABLE TO PROVIDE CUSTOMER SERVICE, LARGELY BECAUSE IT HAS BEEN CUTTING OR LIMITING SOME OF ITS RESOURCES TO MEETS ITS EARNINGS EXPECTATIONS.
THE CHALLENGES IT CREATED THAT HAPPENED FROM THAT WAS THAT IT CREATED STAFFING FLUCTUATIONS, WITH STAFF SOMETIMES BEING CUT AND SOMETIMES RESTORED, WHICH CREATED AN UNEVEN EXPECTATION OF CUSTOMER SERVICE RELIABILITY.
THAT INVESTIGATION REALLY SPRANG OUT OF A SCANDAL THAT CAME OUT IN OCTOBER OF 2017 WHEN THERE WAS A LOCAL STORM WHERE SOME PEOPLE LOST POWER FOR AT LEAST A WEEK AND RECEIVED HIGH BILLS AFTERWARDS.
WHICH, LATER LED TO THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION IN MAINE FINDING THAT CMP NEEDED TO ACCOMMODATE ITS CUSTOMERS FOR BILLING THEM WHEN THEY EXPERIENCE HIGH OUTAGES.
Laura: RECENTLY REPRESENTATIVE SETH BERRY, A MAINE LAWMAKER, HE WROTE AN OP ED THAT WAS CIRCULATED PRETTY WIDELY HERE IN NEW MEXICO WARNING THE STATE AGAINST THE MERGER.
IS THE COMPANY THIS UNPOPULAR IN MAINE?
Andrews: CERTAINLY, I THINK ANY CONVERSATION ABOUT AVINGRID IS REALLY A REFLECTION OF CMP.
THAT IS A LOCAL UTILITY, ONE MORE PEOPLE ARE FAMILIAR WITH.
YOU SEE AVINGRID COMING UP IN THE CONVERSATION AROUND THE NEW ENGLAND CLEAN ENERGY CONNECT WHICH IS A HYDROPOWER CORRIDOR THAT IS GOING TO BRING HYDROPOWER ELECTRICITY DOWN THROUGH MAINE INTO MASSACHUSETTS AND ALSO INTO THE REGIONAL GRID BUT IT IS HAPPENING TO FULFILL A BIG MASSACHUSETTS ATTEMPT TO FILL ITS RENEWABLE ENERGY GOALS.
SO, WHEN PEOPLE ARE TALKING ABOUT AVINGRID, THEY ARE USUALLY TALKING ABOUT IT THROUGH THE PERSPECTIVE OF THE CORRIDOR ABOUT HOW THIS COMPANY DOESN'T CARE ABOUT THE MAINE CUSTOMERS BECAUSE THEY ARE SUCH A SMALL PERCENTAGE OF EARNINGS OVERALL.
THERE IS NO GUARANTEE THEY ARE GOING TO HAVE YOUR BEST INTERESTS IN MIND WHEN IT COMES TO THIS.
Laura: SO, ONE OF THE THINGS THAT REPRESENTATIVE BERRY WROTE ABOUT IN HIS SORT OF WARNING TO NEW MEXICANS, HE MENTIONED THAT THERE IS A BILL THAT THE MAINE LEGISLATURE PASSED TO REVOKE AVINGRID'S MONOPOLY AND REPLACE CENTRAL MAINE CENTRAL POWER WITH A NONPROFIT CONSUMER-OWNED UTILITY.
HE ALSO WROTE THAT THE BILL IS SUPPORTED BY 75% OF MAINERS AND THAT IF IT BECAME LAW, IT WOULD SAVE RATE PAYORS NINE BILLION DOLLARS IN THE FIRST 30 YEARS AND ACCELERATE THIS STATE'S TRANSITION TO RENEWABLE ENERGY.
BASED ON YOUR REPORTING, IS THIS ACCURATE INFORMATION?
IS THIS AN ACCURATE ASSESSMENT?
Andrews: WELL, I CAN'T QUITE SPEAK TO HOW, I GUESS, WIDESPREAD FAVORABILITY IS FOR THE CONCEPT OF CONSUMER-OWNED UTILITIES.
I ACTUALLY WOULD SAY THAT I DON'T KNOW THAT A LOT OF PEOPLE WOULD KNOW WHAT IT WOULD DO BUT I DO KNOW THAT THERE WAS A STUDY THAT CAME OUT THAT IF A CONSUMER-OWNED UTILITY HAPPENED WHICH IN MAINE THE CONCEPT HERE IS THAT IT WOULD CREATE A NONPROFIT THAT WOULD THEN GO TO BOND IN ORDER TO BUY OUT CMP AND VERSANT POWER WHICH ARE THE TWO BIGGEST UTILITY COMPANIES IN THE STATE.
THERE IS A LOT OF QUESTIONS ABOUT WHETHER THEY WOULD BE ABLE TO SELL.
THERE IS ACTUALLY A COMPETING REFERENDUM TRYING TO STOP THAT, BUT THERE WAS A STUDY THAT CAME OUT THAT INITIALLY RATES WOULD INCREASE FOR THE FIRST FEW YEARS BUT THEN EVENTUALLY THE CUSTOMERS WOULD SEE POSSIBLE RATE DECREASES OVER TIME.
Laura: HERE IN NEW MEXICO, PNM RESOURCES IS LIKE A POLITICAL POWERHOUSE.
YOU KNOW, THEY HAVE A GREAT DEAL OF INFLUENCE IN THE LEGISLATURE AND OVER STATE GOVERNMENT.
I AM CURIOUS IN TERMS OF POLITICAL INFLUENCE KIND OF WHAT THE SITUATION IS WITH CMP AND AVINGRID IN MAINE?
Andrews: WELL, CERTAINLY, CMP AND AVINGRID HAVE NOT BEEN SHY ABOUT FLEXING SOME POLITICAL MONEY AROUND THIS REFERENDUM.
THE REFERENDUM SPENDING ALTOGETHER IS BETWEEN THIS ONE AND FIRST ONE THAT WAS STRUCK DOWN FOR CONSTITUTIONAL PURPOSES IS OVER 62 MILLION AND WITHIN THIS QUARTER ALONE, AVINGRID SPENT 8.7 MILLION TO CLEAN ENERGY MATTERS.
THERE HAS BEEN A LOT OF SPENDING ON LIKE ADS AND MAILERS AND YOU CAN MAKE ARGUMENT ABOUT HOW USEFUL THOSE CAN BE IN A POLITICAL SEASON BUT IT IS CERTAINLY WAYS THAT PEOPLE LIKE TO FLEX THEIR POLITICAL FORCES.
THEY HAVE VERY POWERFUL INFLUENCE IN AUGUSTA.
THEY HAVE SOME OF THE MOST HIGH PAID LOBBYING FIRMS THAT WORK TO DEFEAT THE CONSUMER-OWNED UTILITY BILL.
I CANNOT SPEAK SPECIFICALLY TO SOME OF THE OTHER BILLS BUT THAT ONE THEY WERE DEFINITELY HAVING SOME PRESENCE ON.
Laura: I AM CURIOUS, WHAT QUESTIONS DO YOU THINK THAT PEOPLE SHOULD BE ASKING AVINGRID RIGHT NOW TO HOLD THE COMPANY ACCOUNTABLE IF THE MERGER GOES THROUGH AND INTO THE FUTURE?
Andrews: ONE OF THE THINGS THAT REALLY STOOD OUT TO ME IS THAT AUDIT LIBERTY CONSULTING GROUP WHEN THEY REALLY EXPLAINED HOW BIG AVINGRID IS, YOU KNOW.
IT SAID THAT ITS FORCE, WHICH MEANS WORKFORCE, HAS RECEIVED 35,000 COMPARED TO CMT WHICH HAS JUST OVER 900 PEOPLE.
MADE A NOTE THAT SAYING THAT MAINE COMPRISES ABOUT 20% OF U.S. UTILITIES OPERATIONS BUT JUST 2% OF OVERALL UTILITY CUSTOMERS.
IF I AM IN NEW MEXICO, I WOULD ASK AVINGRID, HOW ARE YOU GOING TO GUARANTEE THAT YOU UNDERSTAND OUR SPECIFIC ENERGY NEEDS, YOU KNOW, WHAT OUR UTILITY NEEDS ARE.
WHO ARE YOU GOING TO WORK WITH, YOU KNOW, IF THERE IS AN UNSATISFACTORY CUSTOMER SERVICE, WHAT ARE YOU GOING TO TRY TO DO TO MAKE THAT BETTER, HOW WELL IS YOUR UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT NEW MEXICO CUSTOMERS NEED?
Laura: WELL, CAITLIN ANDERSON, I REALLY APPRECIATED READING YOUR COVERAGE OF UTILITY IN MAINE AND I REALLY APPRECIATE YOU COMING ON NEW MEXICO FOCUS TODAY.
THANKS.
Andrews: THANK YOU SO MUCH.
- News and Public Affairs
Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.
- News and Public Affairs
FRONTLINE is investigative journalism that questions, explains and changes our world.
Support for PBS provided by:
Our Land: New Mexico’s Environmental Past, Present and Future is a local public television program presented by NMPBS