Our Land: New Mexico’s Environmental Past, Present and Future
Balancing Renewable Energy with Local Impacts
Season 5 Episode 6 | 10m 42sVideo has Closed Captions
Examining the long term impacts of a proposed renewable energy transmission project
Plans for the SunZia Transmission Project have been in the works since 2006, with $150 million already spent. That $4 billion project is supposed to someday bring wind-generated power from New Mexico to markets in Arizona and California. This week, correspondent Laura Paskus talks to a SunZia official as well as a Socorro County resident who worries how the project will affect migrating birds.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Our Land: New Mexico’s Environmental Past, Present and Future is a local public television program presented by NMPBS
Our Land: New Mexico’s Environmental Past, Present and Future
Balancing Renewable Energy with Local Impacts
Season 5 Episode 6 | 10m 42sVideo has Closed Captions
Plans for the SunZia Transmission Project have been in the works since 2006, with $150 million already spent. That $4 billion project is supposed to someday bring wind-generated power from New Mexico to markets in Arizona and California. This week, correspondent Laura Paskus talks to a SunZia official as well as a Socorro County resident who worries how the project will affect migrating birds.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
How to Watch Our Land: New Mexico’s Environmental Past, Present and Future
Our Land: New Mexico’s Environmental Past, Present and Future is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipLaura: JOHN RYAN, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING ME TODAY TO TALK ABOUT ENERGY TRANSITION AND THE SUNZIA LINE.
ELECTRICAL TRANSMISSION IS SOMETHING THAT AFFECTS ALL US AND YET I FEEL LIKE WE DON'T TALK ABOUT IT VERY MUCH.
AND A LOT OF US DON'T REALLY UNDERSTAND IT.
SO, CAN WE START OFF, CAN YOU KIND OF LAY OUT THE PURPOSE AND THE NEED FOR THIS PROPOSED TRANSMISSION LINE?
Ryan: I WOULD BE HAPPY TO, LAURA.
THANKS FOR HAVING ME.
THE SUNZIA PROJECT, WE HAVE BEEN WORKING ON FOR A LONG TIME.
TRANSMISSION LINES TAKE A LONG TIME.
SUNZIA IS ONE OF THOSE LINES THAT IS A RENEWABLE TRANSMISSION LINE.
SO WE ARE BUILDING TO GET TO THE WIND ENERGY IN CENTRAL NEW MEXICO.
GETTING TO THAT POINT TO WHERE THAT WIND ENERGY CAN GET ON THE TRANSMISSION LINE AND WE WOULD TRANSFER IT INTO ARIZONA AND ONCE WE GET INTO ARIZONA, THE POWER COULD BE SOLD TO THE ARIZONA UTILITIES OR CALIFORNIA UTILITIES, WHATEVER THE CASE MAY BE.
IT IS REALLY EXCITING.
IT HAS BEEN A LONG HAUL.
WE HAVE A NEW IDEA ABOUT ALTERNATIVE ROUTES AND I WOULD LOVE TO GET INTO SOME OF THAT DETAIL BUT, REALLY, IT IS A TRANSFORMATIONAL PROJECT FOR NEW MEXICO.
IT WILL BRING A GREAT DEAL OF ECONOMIC BENEFIT TO THE STATE, TO A LOT OF THE RURAL COMMUNITIES THAT WE DEAL WITH, TO A LOT OF THE LANDOWNERS AND WE ARE TRYING TO DO IT IN ENVIRONMENTALLY SENSITIVE WAY.
Laura: IN TERMS OF THE ELECTRICITY THAT NEW MEXICANS WILL USE, DOES THIS MEAN THERE WILL BE MORE RENEWABLE ENERGY IN THE MIX FOR NEW MEXICANS OR DOES IT GO TO OTHER MARKETS?
Ryan: IT COULD BE BOTH.
WE ARE DOING TWO LINES, LIKE I SAID.
ONE OF THE FIRST LINES WILL BE A DC LINE WHEREBY WE ARE TRANSPORTING A LOT OF WIND ENERGY INTO ARIZONA AND THEREFORE INTO THE WESTERN MARKETS.
THE SECOND LINE WILL BE AN AC LINE THAT WILL INCLUDE SUBSTATIONS IN LUNA COUNTY, ONE IN TORRANCE COUNTY AND THAT ALLOWS FOR INTERCONNECTIONS INTO THE NEW MEXICO GRID.
ALL IN ALL, THE EXPANSION OF TRANSMISSION IS REALLY VALUABLE, NOT ONLY WHETHER WE ARE TRANSPORTING OUT OF STATE OR WITHIN STATE, ELECTRICITY IS BECOMING MORE OF AN AREA WHERE WE NEED TO GET PATHED INTO COMMUNITIES, SO A DIFFERENT PATH WOULD ALLOW FOR IMPROVED RELIABILITY FOR THE REGION AS A WHOLE AND SO A LOT OF THAT IS WHAT WE ARE AFTER, WHAT WE ARE TRYING TO DO, WHAT WE THINK IS VALUABLE ABOUT SUNZIA.
Laura: WE KNOW THE CLIMATE IS CHANGING.
WE KNOW THAT IS BECAUSE OF OUR EXPENDITURES OF FOSSIL FUELS AND RENEWABLE ENERGY IS A REALLY IMPORTANT PART OF THE CONVERSATION LOCALLY AND GLOBALLY.
HOW DO YOU BALANCE, THOUGH, THAT THESE SORTS OF INDUSTRIAL PROJECTS DO HAVE ALL SORTS OF LOCAL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS?
LIKE HOW DO WE BALANCE THOSE TWO THINGS THAT WE NEED TO BE THINKING ABOUT?
Ryan: WE HAVE TO DO IT.
WE HAVE TO BALANCE THOSE.
WE WORK REALLY HARD AT DOING THAT.
WE KNOW THAT THERE IS A LOT OF FOCUS ON LOW CARBON GENERATION AND SO WE ARE TRYING TO FACILITATE THAT.
WE ARE TRYING TO ADDRESS THE CLIMATE CRISIS.
WE UNDERSTAND IT.
WE RECOGNIZE THE IMPORTANCE OF RENEWABLE ENERGY AND CLEAN ENERGY.
BUT, YOU'RE RIGHT, WE HAVE GOT TO CONVINCE LOCAL COMMUNITIES, LOCAL ELECTED OFFICIALS, STAKEHOLDERS, ENVIRONMENTAL GROUPS THAT NOT ONLY ARE THESE PROJECTS IMPORTANT, BUT WE HAVE TO DO THEM IN AN ENVIRONMENTALLY SENSITIVE WAY.
AND THERE IS LOTS OF THINGS THAT WE ARE DOING THAT I HOPE TURNS INTO A MODEL FOR HOW OTHER PROJECTS SHOULD PROCEED.
REACHING OUT TO STAKEHOLDERS, LIKE I MENTIONED, IS REALLY IMPORTANT.
WE FOR THE LAST COUPLE OF YEARS HAVE VISITED WITH NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL GROUPS, LOCAL ENVIRONMENTAL GROUPS, SOME OF THE LANDOWNERS DON'T LIKE TRANSMISSION LINES IN THEIR AREA.
AND WE HAVE TO FIGURE OUT WAYS TO IMPROVE THE ENVIRONMENT WHEN WE ARE DONE.
THERE IS THINGS THAT WE CAN DO TO PRESERVE THE TOURISM, THE BEAUTY OF NEW MEXICO, THE BOSQUE WHERE WE CROSS THE RIVER, THOSE ARE ALL REALLY SENSITIVE AREAS THAT WE ARE FOCUSED ON AND ARE DOING A LOT OF THINGS TO MAKE IT A MUCH MORE ENVIRONMENTALLY SENSITIVE PROJECT THAT CARES ABOUT HOW WE CROSS THE RIVER, WHERE WE CROSS THE RIVER.
CAN WE PUT IN TECHNOLOGY ON THE TRANSMISSION LINES THAT WILL HELP THE SAND HILL CRANES OR OTHER MIGRATORY BIRDS AVOID THE LINE.
CAN WE CORRIDIZE OUR TRANSMISSION LINES?
CAN WE FOLLOW OTHER TRANSMISSION LINES SO THAT WE ARE NOT GOING IN PRISTINE AREAS THAT ARE UNTOUCHED.
CAN WE CO-LOCATE LINES ON OTHER PEOPLES' LINES.
ALL THOSE THINGS ARE WHAT WE TRY TO DO.
WE ALSO ARE TALKING TO LOCAL GROUPS ABOUT IMPORTANT THINGS RELATIVE TO THE BOSQUE.
YES, WE ARE GOING TO IMPACT THE BOSQUE.
WE ARE GOING TO BE CROSSING THE MIDDLE RIO GRANDE VALLEY.
IT IS INEVITABLE THAT WE DO THAT.
THAT IS THE ONLY WAY TO GET TO THE WIND BUT WE CAN LOOK AT PURCHASING CONSERVATION PROPERTY, WATER RIGHTS.
WE CAN LOOK AT DEVELOPING THE BOSQUE AND CREATING OPPORTUNITIES FOR SOME OF THE LOCAL ENVIRONMENTAL GROUPS, NONPROFIT GROUPS TO IMPROVE THE BOSQUE.
Laura: JOHN RYAN, THANK YOU FOR JOINING ME.
I APPRECIATE IT.
Ryan: THANK YOU SO MUCH.
Laura: SANDRA NOLL, THANK YOU FOR JOINING ME TODAY.
WELCOME TO NEW MEXICO IN FOCUS.
Noll: THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THE OPPORTUNITY.
Laura: YOU LIVE IN SOCORRO COUNTY AND YOU HAVE SOME CONCERNS ABOUT THAT.
WHAT ARE YOU WORRIED ABOUT?
Noll: THIS HAS BEEN IN PROCESS FOR QUITE SOME TIME AND IT IS NOT JUST TWO LINES.
THESE ARE TWO PARALLEL HIGH VOLTAGE LINE SETS AND SO WE ARE CONCERNED ABOUT A NUMBER OF THINGS.
THIS IS THE SECOND TIME IT IS BEING CONSIDERED AS AN ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT BY THE BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT AND SO THERE IS SOME CROSSINGS THAT ARE BEING CONSIDERED.
ONE OF THEM WILL IMPACT SEVILLA NATIONAL WILDLIFE REFUGE.
THAT IS A GREAT CONCERN.
THE SECOND CONCERN IS THAT THE MIDDLE RIO GRANDE VALLEY IS PART OF THE CENTRAL FLYWAY FROM ALASKA AND CANADA DOWN TO SOUTH AMERICA AND WE HAVE MORE THAN 400 BIRD SPECIES THAT USE THAT FLYWAY.
SO, TWO SETS OF HIGH VOLTAGE MULTIPLE LINE CROSSINGS OF THAT RIVER, OF OUR RIO GRANDE, WILL BE OF GREAT IMPACT.
THE THIRD MAJOR THING THAT WE ARE CONCERNED ABOUT IS REALLY THE IMPACT ECONOMICALLY ON ECOTOURISM PARTICULARLY ON COUNTIES LIKE SOCORRO THAT COUNT A LOT ON THAT.
Laura: YOU MENTIONED MIGRATORY BIRDS.
WHAT KIND OF SPECIES ARE WE TALKING ABOUT AND WHY IS THE RIO GRANDE IMPORTANT TO THESE PARTICULAR SPECIES?
Noll: THERE IS MORE THAN 400 SPECIES THAT MIGRATE ALONG OR UTILIZE THIS RIVER CORRIDOR FOR HABITAT.
AND JUST HISTORICALLY IT HAS BEEN A PART OF THE EAST/WEST, MID CONTINENT FLYWAY FOR THOUSANDS OF YEARS.
THE BIRD PEOPLE OFTEN THINK ABOUT IN THIS AREA IS THE SAND HILL CRANE.
IT WINTERS AT BOSQUE DEL APACHE AND IT IS ICONIC TO THIS PART OF NEW MEXICO.
WE ALL TELL OUR SEASONS BY WHEN THIS BIRD COMES AND GOES BUT THE LARGE BIRDS LIKE THE SAND HILL CRANE AND WATERFOWL ARE NOT SO MANEUVERABLE.
A LOT OF THEM ROOST ON THE RIVER.
THESE BIRDS DON'T ROOST IN TREES.
AND SO WE ARE CONCERNED ABOUT THEIR COMING AND GOING TO ROOST IN THE RIVER.
THE SONG BIRDS MOSTLY MIGRATE AT NIGHT.
SO, AGAIN, WIRES THAT HAVEN'T BEEN THERE AND THEY HAVE BEEN DOING THIS FOR GENERATIONS AND GENERATIONS OF BIRDS, THEY WILL BE IMPACTED AS WELL.
Laura: CAN YOU TALK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THE CHALLENGE THAT RURAL NEW MEXICANS FACE WHEN THERE ARE PROJECTS LIKE THIS IN TERMS OF HAVING YOUR VOICE HEARD, BEING A PART OF THE PROCESS, MAKING IT THROUGH THE PROCESS?
Noll: WE OFTEN TALK ABOUT IT AS A MATTER OF SOCIAL OR ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE.
A LOT OF TIMES, BIG PROJECTS LIKE THIS ACTUALLY SAY THEY ARE LOOKING FOR THE PATH OF LEAST RESISTANCE AND THAT HAPPENS TO BE OFTEN RURAL AREAS AND INDIVIDUAL FARMERS AND RANCHERS THAT DON'T HAVE THE BIG VOICE OR CLOUT OF OTHER AREAS.
SO, THAT IS SOMETHING THAT PEOPLE ARE REALLY CONCERNED ABOUT.
I THINK STUDIES HAVE SHOWN THAT PROPERTY VALUES DROP ABOUT 15 TO 20% WHEN THEY ARE IMPACTED BY THIS KIND OF CONSTRUCTION.
SOME PEOPLE HAVE HEALTH CONCERNS.
THAT IS STILL AN ISSUE WITH SOME OF THESE HIGH VOLTAGE LINES.
AND THEN THE POTENTIAL TO DECREASE TOURISM IS A BIG PART OF THAT AND THE BURGEONING FILM INDUSTRY IS JUST BEGINNING TO USE AREAS LIKE OURS MORE AND MORE.
SO, I THINK THOSE ARE SOME OF THE THINGS.
WE ARE NOT SAYING DON'T GENERATE.
WE ARE NOT SAYING DON'T TRANSMIT.
JUST DO IT AS SMART AS POSSIBLE.
CONSIDERING PEOPLE AND WILDLIFE.
Laura: SANDRA NOLL, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING ME.
Noll: APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY TO BRING THIS TO YOUR VIEWERS.

- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.

- News and Public Affairs

FRONTLINE is investigative journalism that questions, explains and changes our world.












Support for PBS provided by:
Our Land: New Mexico’s Environmental Past, Present and Future is a local public television program presented by NMPBS