The Cities with Jim Mertens
Banned Books Week & Rock Island's Re-birth
Season 15 Episode 45 | 27m 23sVideo has Closed Captions
Banned Books Week & Rock Island's Re-birth
Jim talks with Jack Cullen, Rock Island Downtown Alliance Executive Director, about their Back from the Dead event coming up. In addition to, all of the new and exciting ways that Rock Island is leaning into renovation. Next, Jim speaks with Angela Campbell, Rock Island Public Library Director, and Ryan Collins, Midwest Writers Center Executive Director, about Banned Books Week.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
The Cities with Jim Mertens is a local public television program presented by WQPT PBS
The Cities is proudly funded by Wheelan-Pressly Funeral Home & Crematory.
The Cities with Jim Mertens
Banned Books Week & Rock Island's Re-birth
Season 15 Episode 45 | 27m 23sVideo has Closed Captions
Jim talks with Jack Cullen, Rock Island Downtown Alliance Executive Director, about their Back from the Dead event coming up. In addition to, all of the new and exciting ways that Rock Island is leaning into renovation. Next, Jim speaks with Angela Campbell, Rock Island Public Library Director, and Ryan Collins, Midwest Writers Center Executive Director, about Banned Books Week.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
How to Watch The Cities with Jim Mertens
The Cities with Jim Mertens is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipThe move to restrict what is read in the library, and a rebirth in downtown Rock Island being brought back from the dead in the city's.
We'll.
Rock Island is celebrating a rebirth just in time for it to celebrate being back from the dead.
We'll explain that coming up.
But first, the cities are marking Monday, October 6th as 2025 banned Book Read Day.
It kicks off a week long banned books week organized by the American Library Association.
Last year, more than 2400 different titles were challenged.
The Library Association says that's the third largest number of challenges ever documented by the association.
The average was about a 10th of that each year from 2001 to the year 2020.
So what's behind the challenges and what is done before a book even hits your local library shelves?
I was joined by Rock Island Public Library Director Angela Campbell and the executive director of the Midwest Writers Center, Ryan Collins.
So, ban books out.
Kind of kicks off Banned books Week.
What is the read out all about?
On October 6th, which is drawing attention to, the First Amendment and the right to read.
So we what we do is have people come in and they read selections from their favorite challenged or banned books that have happened across the United States.
And it just shows that, you know, people can have discourse without, you know, and disagree without having any problems is a conversation.
It's just drawing.
You have that right.
The First Amendment is the First Amendment for a reason.
It's the basis of our democracy, and we want to protect that.
Well, and we started off the program by pointing out that the American Library Association says challenges to books are ten times greater now than they were, you know, between the years 2020 20.
What's going on?
I think that, you know, there's definitely some, politics behind it.
There are organizations that have band together to try to get behind banning books.
There are places that, library boards have been appointed with that sole purpose.
So it I don't it's any more.
It feels like if you don't agree with certain folks, then, you're canceled or banned and books are the same.
Videos listening, you know, all of that.
So it's important that we stand up for that First Amendment right to read, listen and view.
Well, you, of course, run a library.
You're in charge of distribution.
Ryan, you're on the other side.
Are you with the writers and the creation.
What kind of a chilling effect is this having right now?
I mean for the writers that I know.
And then I'm privileged to like be in conversation with about this kind of stuff.
I don't I think they're more emboldened than anything else.
I don't think, you know, like dissent and critique and like a lot of those things start in writing, before they maybe make their way to other art forms, you know, like, screenwriting, you know, like, film requires, you know, scripts and things like that.
So, like, writing's pretty foundational to all that.
I think it becomes more of an issue in terms of who's going to put the work out and who's willing to support challenging work, work that maybe is of a dissenting view in whatever kind of way, or maybe deals with topics that people just don't want to deal about because of their own discomfort or, ignorance or unwillingness to engage other people about that which they maybe don't have that much experience about.
So I think writers are going to be just fine being able to find the outlets to get the work to the audience.
I think that might be a struggle.
And, you know, we'll kind of see what publishers are willing to, like, stand by those writers so that they can have their product to sell the public.
A lot of the objections, of course, are towards LGBTQ books, or, you know, real strong sexual content books, and whether or not it should be available to all members of society, the young as well as the old.
Where do you draw the line on something like that?
I mean, the right to produce it is is one thing.
The right to distribute it is quite another.
Yeah.
I mean, a good friend of mine, a writer friend of mine, once you know, she's talking about her own children and, she said something that I thought was pretty salient.
She said if they're old enough.
If they're old enough to know, meaning that if they're if her kids have questions, she wants to be open and honest with them and, like, be the source of information and try to help them get good information, as opposed to having things that they just don't talk about, which leads to going to other sources of information that are harder to sort of maybe account for, might have like negative effects, might be bad information.
So, I think there is like a social obligation to, make information, as widely available as possible.
And then it's, you know, it's up to people if they don't want to engage with this or that content, you know, that's there, that's fine.
Nobody's forcing that on them.
But like, there's a market interest in it being out there.
There's an educational interest being out there.
There's a self expression interest in that being out there.
And based on all of these fronts and, you know, given, you know, our foundational document, it's the First Amendment, not the fifth or sixth, so I think there needs to be a space for that.
I think there's always been a space for that.
And I think, that's part of what has made this country great.
Well, Angela, I mean, you don't just get a book in a box and you put it on the shelf.
Oh, no.
Yeah.
So tell me a little bit about the process because, I mean, you review the books before they're distributed.
Yes.
We have a multi-page collection development policy that our librarians follow.
And in fact, when you're in library school, you take a very long class, on how to select items and, you know, delete items from the library.
Weeding is what we call it.
And, there's some guidelines that they follow that it has to be reviewed, mainly because millions of things are published every year, and there's no way a library could own everything.
So we have to look at our community and see, you know, what sorts of things they're most interested in, what sorts of things the public comes in and asks for.
We our collection would be totally different than, Silver's or Coal Valley or something for Rock Island, and that's who we serve.
So we have to be very cognizant of the types of items that we put on the shelf for our citizens.
So and what happens if something is challenged, challenged?
Well, it's changed over the last few years.
We used to have a reconsideration of materials form and policy.
But the secretary of State of Illinois, who is actually the state librarian, and the governor, worked on a bill, to ban book bans.
And so if public libraries, we receive, per capita aid grant our state funding every year, if public libraries don't adopt that, mentality of banning book bans, then we don't get our funding.
And let's be honest, I mean, you're an Illinois library.
You know, it's very different on the other side of river in Iowa, where, as you point out, Illinois actually made a law that you cannot ban books very specific, whereas Iowa seems to be, allowing greater, objections to, materials.
Tell me what you got to be happier to be an Illinois librarian.
I mean, I, I know you probably talk to your brethren on the other side of the river, I guess is what I do.
I feel really bad for our colleagues because when you go to library school, you definitely learn all of this, the First Amendment and giving access to quality information to people and letting people decide what they want to read, view or listen to.
So, I am totally I'm on board.
If a parent doesn't want a child to read something that is there, right?
Absolutely.
Or if somebody checks something out and doesn't like it, I mean, my my joke is if it was all science fiction, I would want to ban it because I don't like to read science fiction.
So, you know, but we have to have everything for everybody.
And, the Iowa folks, I think, I think the public libraries are standing strong.
I haven't heard of a lot of issues except for them, lawsuits against librarians that, they're providing pornography or they're, you know, giving things to children that the parents don't want them to read, ultimately.
But.
I don't I don't know what people's lives are like or what shoes they walk in.
Obviously, some of the books that you had mentioned, LGBTQ, the, incest, rape type stories that are true especially or else fictionalized so people can understand them better.
There's people that go through that and especially young people.
And to have somebody publish a book that speaks to them so they can have help so they know that they're not alone, has saved lives.
And so I look at it that way, that, not not everyone's going to want to read it.
That's fine.
But it's there for those who maybe need some support and aren't getting it elsewhere, and to know that they're not alone.
So hopefully, I can't say what's going to happen in Iowa, but it is, 180 degree difference when Ryan talk about that, because, I mean, you deal with this every single day.
People pouring out their souls, people, people basically therapeutically on paper with pen, telling some of their deepest, darkest concerns and fears.
Yeah.
I mean, it's necessary.
Like, I think writing, among a lot of other things, is a tool for thinking and if you can't write freely, I don't think you can think freely.
Which means you can't ask questions that you might need to ask about your life and living in the world, which is a hard thing to do.
And yet historically, like all throughout history, not just our culture, all cultures.
Storytelling is one way that we do that.
Whether it be highly fictionalized or whether it be something that's very close to the bone, very real.
And I think what people forget is, these people who want to ban books, be they, elected officials or you know, private individuals and organizations or whatever, I think they forget sometimes that what they're talking about is what they want, and they think what they want should stand in for everybody else.
And that's the exact opposite of being free and having choice, which seems to be things that they also say that they want.
So it's confusing, but it's also like missing the point.
We're not having a conversation about these texts.
A lot of times, people who want to ban books haven't actually read the books.
And in fact, I know there were districts in the state of Iowa that were using I just to sort of scan for content and sort of, you know, keywords.
Right.
So we're not really having a conversation about what these books are or what they do or what they say.
They just are seen to be in have, you know, in the eyes of some people, objectionable material.
And that makes it objectionable for everybody.
And the I think they need to check themselves and realize, like, what they're doing is actually very selfish.
In terms of thinking about what I want as what everybody wants, I don't think that's true for anybody.
And probably much of anything bad week has been going on.
I mean, you've done it for a number of years.
Yeah.
Are you preaching to the choir or what do you really hope is accomplished?
I mean, we hope we can get a mix of people librarians, teachers, artists, you know, community members, activists together to, you know, celebrate these books that we love that have been important to us, but also, to, yeah, to draw some attention to the fact that, you know, this has been quietly going on for a while.
I think, like a lot of things, people have been taken aback by the number of book bans like that.
You mentioned earlier, that they've shot up in recent years.
But this is, you know, like anything else that sort of builds slowly.
And so I think the more events there are like this, you know, not just during Banned Books week, but all the time, that we're, you know, putting the focus on, writers and self-expression and people who, you know, have something to say that maybe not everybody agrees with, but maybe it's worth everybody engaging with a little bit.
And like, we can't engage with that which is not available to us or which is being concealed or hidden.
And so, if we want to be a free and open society.
Yeah, yeah, this is important.
Absolutely.
And I think what's really unnerving right now is the the content is to be, like I say, specific things were red flags.
Now they're just stopping actual history being published.
I mean, things that really happened.
And you know, if you ban one thing, it's a snowball effect.
Everything starts to be questioned, exactly the way Ryan said.
And it doesn't fit in with their values or this and that.
And the other, but it is happening.
So, I mean, we want to have books on the shelf that are historically accurate that come from all sides.
Not.
And, and that's one of the things the librarians always look for to.
Well, as part of the read out, there's going to be books that will be or sections of books that will be read out loud.
I mean, tell me a little bit about those books.
I mean, some of the titles may surprise people because they're they're relatively mainstream.
I mean, you have things as, all all of the classics that you would consider classics.
So kill a mockingbird, Fahrenheit 451.
All of those have been challenged in some way, shape or form, but even things like the Bible have been because, you know, there are sections of that that people don't agree with.
So it really the children's books are kind of shocking sometimes.
I know I read The Lorax once, and because that had, been challenged in California, the forestry industry didn't like how they were presented in the book.
So I mean, the reasons really vary, which, yeah, I mean, like, that's the thing that strikes me more than any one particular title because I think, you know, people return to books that are familiar, like Toni Morrison's Beloved in 1984.
These are the books that are commonly read at these kind of events.
But like the children's books and like recent children's books, I think that's the really striking thing when you look at these, these list of books that are being banned, so many of them are like books that are written for children that are maybe about, you know, kind of like difficult or touchy subjects, you know, like death, you know, like Bridge to Terabithia is one book.
And like, I was kind of shocked when I first found out that that was banned.
And then I found out it was banned because it talked about death.
And it was like, well, children don't have to experience that.
Like, we don't want to make a space where we can have a healthy conversation about that, like, and utilize a creative text to maybe help us do that, that as a parent and an educator and a writer seems, misguided to me.
So, yeah, the children's books always kind of jump out.
Yeah.
For sure.
Our thanks to Rock Island Public Library Director Angela Campbell and the executive director of the Midwest Writers Center, Ryan Collins.
The banned books read Out featuring Stephen Pico is Monday, October 6th, from six until eight at the Rock Island Library's What's Midtown Branch?
That's on 30th Street.
A social time and networking starts at 530.
Still to come.
Bringing downtown Rock Island back from the dead.
But first, the events that are kicking off October in the cities.
Thanks to visit Quad Cities.
Check out the things to do this week in the Quad Cities.
Start your week off by attending the QC Flavor Office.
Sample food and drinks made here in the Quad Cities.
Also on October 2nd, check out Taste of East Moline.
Try food from 27 local restaurants, then major league fishing's Phoenix Bass Fishing League regional tournament is returning to the QC.
Then enjoy the free fall festival at Nahant Marsh.
There will be games, music and a petting zoo.
Finally, enjoy the line dance party at the Landing Ice Rink on October 4th.
For more events like these, check out our events calendar at visit Quad cities.com.
And almost $9 million downtown infrastructure renovation is now finished in downtown Rock Island, just in time to celebrate the Halloween season.
So it's time to bring back the dead, a party whose name is not lost on the downtown merchants who are sponsoring it.
It's coming up next weekend, October 11th and 12th.
Rock Island Downtown Alliance executive director Jack Cullen joined us to talk about the big downtown changes.
So back from the dead is coming up.
It's October 11th through the 12th.
And I was looking I mean, everybody, it seems, is involved in downtown Rock Island.
We're excited about this.
It, I think it shows how our businesses are embracing some of the authentic, amenities and assets in downtown Rock Island.
And, you know, it started with two major haunted attractions here at Skellington Manor, closer to the west end of downtown and then on the east end, shark House at the Expo Center and figuring out how do we fill in the gaps there.
And businesses are embracing the spooky season in downtown Rock Island and here we are with back from the dead second year.
It is coming at a time that the, renovation of downtown Rock Island is complete.
You know what?
I talk about this because it's just infrastructure.
It's just roads and improving lighting.
But it is so much more for a downtown like Rock Island.
Yes.
And to make the connection back from the dead, I have to give credit to downtown business owner Brandy Vandewalle, owner of Skeleton Key Art and antiques.
And, she had the idea for this name of back from the dead again, embracing the spooky season in downtown.
But to show that our businesses are showing up for progress and to show those around us that downtown Rock Island is back and we are celebrating that.
And yes, we are on the heels of the largest, single largest investment in downtown's public infrastructure in a generation.
There were roads that were reconstructed, but we have a lot of amenities that were built as part of that project.
It's not your typical infrastructure improvement, meaning that, we have beautiful new signage, large scale murals that went up in Arts Alley.
A lot of pieces of that project that were designed to enhance public spaces, improve quality of life, and to, really get people excited and proud about the heart of Rock Island, because it's more than just street work and sidewalks, because it's creating basically a festival area when it's not a major street.
Yes.
Enhancing that sense of place for the community, is a big goal of this project.
Right in the center of downtown.
Center of the rebuild downtown project area is the 1800 block of Second Avenue.
Businesses on that block include El patron Mexican restaurant bar.
Sorry to, the former Rib Co and you know, the idea there is that it was formerly a pedestrian mall, and we wanted to balance the pedestrian friendly, aspects of of that, while enhancing access to that street.
So what we have now is a shared street or festival street concept, 25ft wide sidewalks on both sides.
No curb and bollards on each end of the block that make it easy to shut down for regular events such as the QC Farmers Market.
That started there, this season, which has been great.
This is really unique to the Quad City area.
I mean, it was it's a concept that because you had the district and you said it was a pedestrian mall.
And this almost brings it an updated version of that.
Yes.
It is really that balance of, you know, increasing access, for maintenance, emergency vehicles, you know, regular vehicle access, again, while maintaining the pedestrian friendly traits there.
There's no curb and no trip hazards.
Easy to shut down for events.
The the vendors at the farmers market pull right up onto the sidewalk, and patrons are welcome to walk through the middle of the street.
There's an adjacent green lawn, which makes it extra inviting.
So it's not just a concrete jungle.
We have the brand new Rock Island letters that become a great photo op.
And then on the green lawn, we we put additional seating and outdoor games and other activities adjacent to the farmers market.
So it's become a nice gathering spot.
And I think it surprises people who haven't been downtown for some time when they visit for the farmers market or second Saturdays on second Ave, which has become a monthly event adjacent to the farmers market this season.
Also kind of an extension for Schriever Park as well.
That just kind of all ties in that way.
Yes.
Are you expecting?
And of course you are.
More festivals, more type of events, more family friendly, activities that that are planned for like the summer.
Definitely.
I think back from the dead is an example of that.
We've also seen an uptick in interest from the community of using these spaces.
You know, we have the green lawn, this new Festival Street, as well as Arts Alley, which has been renovated, where we hosted, our, our holiday market.
And we posted some different pop up events in that space.
And we'll continue to do so.
But we're seeing, community, organizations such as the Rock Island Public Library Foundation during back from the dead will be hosting, a party in that space, in addition to partnering with, the next door neighboring business, the iconic.
So, I think we're excited about seeing more programs happening in these renovated spaces again, as an extension, from so we were park in the key also, of course, is to spark business activity, and economic growth, in the downtown area.
Are you starting to see because the merchants went through a lot to get to this point, an almost $8 million, no more than $1 million, renovation.
And they had to deal with the construction and all that.
Now the construction is done.
Are you seeing more interest in businesses and others looking to come downtown?
Yeah.
Number one, we're trying to ensure that our existing businesses have the support and resources that they need to thrive.
That's vital, especially coming off a large construction project.
That did make it challenging at times for operations.
And so, that's number one priority.
In addition, one of the major goals of this large infrastructure improvement project was to encourage private investment.
And so we are seeing that private investment from existing building owners and business owners, which is fantastic.
In addition to seeing some new faces come downtown and purchase real estate, looking to open new businesses, in the central business district.
So, that's obviously exciting.
It comes at a good time.
The city's downtown tiff has been reestablished.
So there are additional, financial assistance and incentives available.
And Rock Island is taking advantage of a of a new statewide legislation.
The city, the River's Edge redevelopment zone as well, which is a boost in historic tax credit.
So it's a great time, to look to invest in downtown Rock Island with those incentives.
And I think just the momentum that is starting to build again on the heels of this, of this major project.
But once again, the key is back from the dead, October 11th through the 12th, second year.
So it's growing.
But what a nice way to really kick off, the end of the construction.
It is where, you know, everything is open.
And, a cool part of that, event are these walking tours that really highlight some of the notorious history of downtown.
Right?
Yeah.
We got to talk about the gangsters.
Yes.
And the Looney era.
It's because Rock island's got a phenomenal history.
It really does.
That's one of, I think, a unique part of our brand.
And something that we're trying to lean into, not to glorify some of that.
You know, I hope the the violent past, however, it is part of our authentic history.
Yeah.
And so how do we tell that story?
In an appropriate way?
I think one way is through these, gangsters and ghost tours led by Minda Powers Douglas.
Yeah.
And we're excited about that being part of back from the dead, learning about, again, some of those landmarks downtown and the connections to to that notorious past.
Our thanks to Rock Island Downtown Alliance executive director Jack Cullen.
America is getting ready for its 250th birthday next year, but we're already celebrating throughout the year leading up to the 4th of July.
We're asking local community leaders about their civic spark, why they've chosen their careers, and how their work is improving our lives.
We posed that question to State Representative Greg Johnson, Democrat from East Moline.
What is your civic spark?
My spark for me.
It took me 38 years to really find purpose in my life.
I had always helped a lot of people.
I had always been very active politically with my union and other social groups.
But my father dying gave me just, just even more purpose, and I realized I had to double down on that in order to help people.
I had to get very engaged.
I continued to ascend through my local, ended up becoming a political chair for me and realized that if you if you want to get things done and you want to build a better world, you have to advocate.
You have to do work.
Our thanks to State Representative Greg Johnson on the air, on the radio, on the web, on your mobile device and streaming on your computer.
Thanks for taking some time to join us as we talk about the issues on the cities.
- News and Public Affairs
Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.
- News and Public Affairs
FRONTLINE is investigative journalism that questions, explains and changes our world.
Support for PBS provided by:
The Cities with Jim Mertens is a local public television program presented by WQPT PBS
The Cities is proudly funded by Wheelan-Pressly Funeral Home & Crematory.