Homegoings
Cailin Marcel Manson Ain’t Your Average Maestro
Season 4 Episode 14 | 42m 8sVideo has Closed Captions
What it means to command a space long dominated by white men.
Cailin Marcel Manson is a conductor, baritone opera singer, and longtime vocal studies teacher who’s performed on some of the world’s biggest stages — from the Conservatoire de Luxembourg to Carnegie Hall. In this episode, we talk with Cailin about what it means to command a space long dominated by white men — armed with Black skin, a bit of Philly swagger, and a corset.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Homegoings is a local public television program presented by Vermont Public
Sponsored in part by the Rutland Regional Medical Center and the Vermont Arts Council
Homegoings
Cailin Marcel Manson Ain’t Your Average Maestro
Season 4 Episode 14 | 42m 8sVideo has Closed Captions
Cailin Marcel Manson is a conductor, baritone opera singer, and longtime vocal studies teacher who’s performed on some of the world’s biggest stages — from the Conservatoire de Luxembourg to Carnegie Hall. In this episode, we talk with Cailin about what it means to command a space long dominated by white men — armed with Black skin, a bit of Philly swagger, and a corset.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
How to Watch Homegoings
Homegoings is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship-This is -Cailin Marcel Manson.
-As you can see, -he's a hell of a conductor.
-And that's just one thing -he does.
-He's a baritone opera -singer, a long time -vocal studies -teacher, and has performed -at major concert venues -all over the globe.
-From the Conservatoire de -Luxembourg to Carnegie Hall.
-And while this tapestry -of talent is who Cailin is, -let's take a moment and talk -about who Cailin isn't.
-He's not this guy.
-Or this guy.
-He's definitely not -this guy.
-You know these guys, -the Mozarts, the Bachs, -the guys who maybe -come to your mind -when you think of big names -in the classical music -canon.
-But as history tends -to reveal in time, -these long dead white dudes -were, of course, -not the only guys or gals -in town -contributing to that canon.
-There was also this guy, -Chevalier, otherwise known -as the Black Mozart, -a nickname given to him -after his death.
-And there was this guy, -Julius Eastman.
-He was an openly gay black -composer in the 70s and 80s -in New York City, -whose avant garde -contributions -to the late 20th century -challenged classical norms.
-That is, until he died -penniless, homeless -and almost completely -forgotten in 1990.
And there was even this lady, Florence Price, who made history as the first African-American woman to have a symphony performed by a major -American orchestra.
-But she struggled -to get her flowers for it -all due to her sex -and her race.
Many of her compositions were considered -lost for years -until after her death, -only to be found -in some dilapidated -summer home in 2009.
-You get the picture.
-These are the lesser name- -dropped -powerhouse black folks -who paved the way for people -like Cailin to exist -and do his thing today.
-So today we're going to -talk with this guy because -you won't be forgetting the -name Cailin Marcel Manson.
-He ain't your average -maestro -I will sit in that room -with all those people -and I will -look at the altos.
-I'm like, -can you like y'all?
-I need some more Sarah -Vaughan in that sound.
-Can you stand up and show us -what is going on -over there?
And also, -are we matching?
-We're sort of matching.
-We got the beige memo.
-Certainly.
-I decided that -I wanted to do something -a little more blue.
-So I have these like cobalt -blue ankle boots -and this embroidered pants.
-And have this hashtag -corsets are daily -wear thing.
-Oh my God.
About like 5 -or 6 different corsets.
-I don't wear them every day -but frequently.
-So we wear that.
-That's so good.
-It's so good.
-When it comes to this world -world of classical music, -which you'll learn later -I too know a thing -or 20 years about -when it comes to -who's allowed -in, who's actively -welcomed in, -and who is genuinely -accepted, -Cailin has gone -beyond the basics of -being allowed, well -anywhere, -he is running this world -while shaping -this music his way.
-What is the liberation -we're looking for?
-We are looking -that we are looking for -black artists, okay.
-We're black -people as black artists.
-Is it -that we want to be able to -just tell our own stories, -or is it that we want to -tell whatever story we want?
-and Cailin is remaining -fully himself, -unapologetically and -unbothered through it all.
-I'm going to -try not to sip and do too -many Asmr moments.
-(laughing) -I'm sipping my coffee -right now.
-Listen, that's a whole -corner of the internet.
-We can go there -if you want to.
-From Vermont public, -this is Homegoings, -a show that invites you -to eavesdrop -on candid conversations -with people -who will challenge -what you think you know.
-I'm Myra Flynn, -today on the show, -A conversation -with Cailin Marcel Manson -about what it means -to command a space long -dominated by white men -armed with black skin, -a bit of Philly swagger, -and a corset.
-This is homegoings.
-We're a proud member -of the NPR network.
-Welcome home.
-Not to put you on the spot, -but I do have to mention -we did teach together -at Governor's Institute -for the Arts, -and I think at one point -we were sharing a wall, -and if we weren't, it -definitely sounded like -we were sharing a wall.
-Okay.
-And I just remember -waking up -to the craziest sounds -coming from your room, -and I think I learned later -they were vocal warmups, -but I might have -thought you were dying.
-I'm just saying - -You know what's really funny -is, remember -when we were at lunch, like, -what was it?
-Was Hazel -and all those, like, -they were like -two floors down -and they're like, -yeah, we heard Cailin -warming up too, because, -like, -oh, I hear you will be cut.
-Because I think it's also -because the vent -from the shower.
-I think -it's because of the you.
-Im here trying to -explain the physics.
-No.
I'm going to go ahead -and say it's the you.
-But yeah.
So so so -there are a couple things.
-I mean, I do this thing -now where I just kind of -check in with my, -with my voice.
-And I say, my friends -laugh at me.
-I say, Is Mariah in there?
-So what I do is, -so what I do is I, -I suck air in while -I close the vocal folds -because I want to, -I want to feel how easily -I can get the finer -edges of the folds -to approximate.
-And that tells me, -like I would -so I could do something -like this.
-And if I can do that easily, -I can always make it happen.
-But if I can do that easily -and I'm like, -like I just did right there, -I'm like, oh, -it's like I'm Mariah's here.
-Mariah's in there.
-That's good.
-But so there are some things -that I do, -which are like -they call the false -vocal folds, things -which are -like some overtone stuff.
-So I do a hum -and I move the, -I move my tongue -up and down in the back -and back -and forward in the middle.
-Something like this.
-unnie, something like that.
-Just so I can feel the -resonance happen already.
-That is.
-Are you a didgeridoo?
-You sound like -a whole instrument.
-Like a drone instrument?
-That's so cool.
-So I do stuff like that -just to feel where -the resonance is.
Okay.
-what is it you do?
-Because I don't think -it squares -with how you're dressed -historically, right?
-Well, so okay, I have -I do multiple things.
-So I'll just say like singer -you can pretty much do -whatever, right?
-I mean so like I cannot sing -like you saying -I call myself a singer.
-But anyway, we'll get -we'll get there.
-Still, this thing is -the singer I conduct.
-But I also feel like -being an academic -and, and an educator, -and then the other thing is -just, -you know, arts management, -I wouldn't call -it being an impresario, -because that seems like -a little too, -Snidely Whiplash for me.
-Okay.
-Like, -I don't do it -then all the things, -but but, you know, -I think someone, -someone -actually used this term -in reference to what I did, -which I thought -was interesting.
-They called me -a cultural architect.
-Wow.
And, like, it's stuck.
-That's beautiful.
-So sort of building -all of these bridges between -different institutions -and communities -and stakeholders to -either get them to dream -a little bigger -and see what was possible.
-And I think you're -still leaving something out, -though.
-Classical music is again, -this is couched in -classical music, right?
-Yes, in the world -of classical music.
-But, I mean, yeah, -there's -just so much about you -that stands out -in this world -that has always kind of -notoriously -not even just looked -the same -or sounded the same, -but really made an effort -to create like, a right -and a wrongness -absolutely around -going outside of that box.
-So please tell us all -how did you arrive here?
-this started -very early.
Okay.
-So there -there was an interesting -moment where the, former -highs of, like, -this person who taught -at the high school -that I went to, -but I never had her for a -class.
She wrote my mother, -this had to -be maybe 6 or 7 years ago -on Facebook -because I just posted -something I was doing, -and she wrote to her saying, -like, I just I never -you don't remember -me, whatever.
-But I just wanted -to tell you -about -how much of an amazing -mother -you must have been -for your son to show up -in three piece -suits every day, -because we were not rich, -but I decided I wanted to -dress up for school.
-The school's my job.
-I shit you not.
-I would wear a big cloak -and a cape -or whatever to school.
-And I was like -throw it off and toss it.
-And she was like that.
-That was it.
-So it started there.
-Okay.
It's just -it was always in you.
-So it's it's always in me -to dress that way.
-And I was always.
-And I was going to say -something -about like, in my 40s, -I'm in my 40s.
-I think I've -turned more into this.
Like, -cause I -like quasi contemporary, -but also like fantasy thing.
-So which is why I always -I love brooches and -and buckles and corsets -and things like that.
-But but I like long lines -in the way flow.
-But when you go into -classical music, -you first you do feel like -you have to prove something.
-You have to imagine, -you know, you do have to -you go through -all these steps, -you train, -you learn all the languages.
-Went to study -over in Austria.
Right.
-So for classical musicians -particularly -and particularly, -you know, black -classical musician, -classical musicians -of color.
-There's this thing that -you feel you have to do.
-To prove that you belong.
-And some of that has to do -with, -you know, -do you put your blackness, -you put your other -ness on the shelf -while you learn the style, -the expectations, -the etiquette.
-Right.
But I found myself -sort of it.
-This happened in the early -the early aughts.
-I'm dating myself, -by the way.
-You're you're in your 40s.
-It was like.
-But, but, -but but I still feel the -I do what 20 year -olds or or late -teens are almost like, -where I noticed -I just noticed something -like, -okay, I am, -you know, cis male whatever.
-And I have to wear -a penguin suit -while the ladies over there -get to have these poofy -things or whatever, they get -to do whatever they want.
-And I'm sitting here -like dirt, dirt.
-And I was like, -no, not for you canned that.
-So I just started -I had some friends -that I had made through -productions at first, -and they were costumers -and they loved to dress me.
-And so I was like, hey, -do you have anything -you've like been dying -to make?
-Like a garment -you've been dying to make?
-for years, -they created things -for me to wear, and, -and I just started wearing.
-And the things that I would -wear almost, like, dared -people like, I -I look better than -the penguin suit.
-Matter of fact, -I look better than, like, -what I'm wearing -is more striking than what -the ladies are wearing.
-So I dare you to say -something to me right?
-And say you're -not supposed to wear that.
-But did they?
-No!
-Nobody said anything -that they wouldn't dare.
-And this is in Austria.
-But everywhere it's just.
-And I started doing that -when I was in Europe, -when I was, -when I was singing -and in Bremen and, and, -and then just -when I came back -to the States, -I just like people say -I'm like, -I have not I have not worn -the penguin suit -for the better part of 20 -years, at least 18 years.
-And I'm not going back.
-Oh my goodness.
-So you've -clearly tackled that -and how you show up -and your presence -and what you wear.
-How are you tackling -that same outside of the box -thinking and mentality -and that right, -and wrongness -we were talking about -in what you do -in your conducting -and in your art?
-there -is this thing about the arts -where, we're expected by -to like, innovate -and do all this other stuff.
-But in classical music -especially, -there is this thing -where it's like, you're -definitely commodified, -like you're -you're a singer, -you're a conductor.
-And once you like, once -you conduct you, -it's very rare -that you keep singing if -or if you I say, -and if you are a conductor -that sings, you're probably -They assume -you're a choral conductor.
-Like you -must just work with singers.
-But I'm -an orchestral conductor, -and that's my training.
-My training is as an -orchestral conductor.
-I've worked with choirs -like I was -with the Bennington -County Choral Society -and NGIA.
-And because I'm like, I'm -an orchestral conductor, -that is a singer, -and I know how to teach -people how to sing.
Right.
-So it works that way.
-But I take -it can take companies -and boards of directors -and agents, -agents in particular, -especially in the aughts -when I was really starting -my career internationally.
-Like, it's -they find that really -difficult -to wrap their head around.
-Like how do you do -all these things?
-How can we market you?
-Is it like like, -oh girl, why you so fly?
-Or is it like, -we don't know?
-We don't know what to do?
-Or is it even worse?
-Is it like -we can't take one seriously -if you're doing so many?
-I mean, for me, -I would say -from an agent standpoint, -that's not the issue, -but from companies, -Absolutely.
Yeah.
You know, -they need you to fit.
-They need you to fit -in a particular way.
-even now.
-I think -what's really jarring -is that the higher -the tier, let's say, -what you tier really just -means budget level.
-Interestingly, -the less provincial -I've been treated.
-You know, -I find that -like mid tier and low tier -They've bought -the conventions -a little more whole hog.
-I think it's -because they're trying -to prove themselves.
Right.
-Because they're not -on the top tier.
Right.
-And so there's a lot -more of like, -I don't know, what's the -word like self-censoring.
-Yeah.
Maybe.
-Right.
Censoring yourself.
-Yeah.
Yeah.
-And so I, I can't tell you -many conversations -I've had when I'm talking -to like, a medium tier -or a low tier orchestra.
-And they refer to me -as a choral conductor -and I'm like, -you completely skipped over -the fact that that was -not what I did in my resume.
-Interesting.
Like -they just assume, -you just assume.
-So we're going to put you on -for the Google concert.
-I'm like, no, no, you do, -you do sing.
I do sing.
-But that's not why I came to -y'all for.
-Yeah.
You know, got it.
-so there is some of that.
-Yeah.
-I kind of push it.
-Yeah, yeah.
-You know, -you have to remind people -of who they're dealing with.
-And who they're talking to -and what your expectations -are about how you should be -treated.
Right.
-And that you do belong -here.
I belong here right.
-(hip hop piano music) -I have a -classical piano background -and then switched over -to being a singer songwriter -myself.
-And the fear of just, -you know, -I get this jazz chord -I'm going to play.
-It was like, -is anybody watching?
-Is anybody looking?
-And we can get more -into that later.
-But yeah, -but you know, I'd really I, -I'm having like a homie -question for you -just like black person -to black person honestly -previous to you -being -in this classical world -tell me about -Cailin and music -previous -to the classical world.
-I mean, are we all listening -to usher?
-So this is so this is -interesting that classical -the classical music -piece was always present -interesting, -which is different.
-So, so amongst many of our, -you know, you know, black, -you know, -brethren and sisters.
Yes.
-You know, -if they started singing, -they started -singing in the church, -particularly -the black church, -some of them, -for my mother, -who I feel like -I'm still trying to keep up -with, you know, -was in her third career -as a Lutheran clergy person.
-Hi, mom.
-Because I'm -sure you got to watch this.
-She left the black church -before I was born.
-Actually, because she felt -like the person, the -the god she encountered -when she read and study -the Bible was not -what she was hearing.
-And so she went in, -so she became Lutheran, -and I was raised in -what was then arguably, like -one of the oldest -German founded -Lutheran congregations -in the country.
-Like were soldiers -from the Revolutionary War -buried in the cemetery -outside -the church.
Real old.
-it was an ethnically mixed -congregation.
-It was also a reconciling -in Christ congregation.
-So it was a -it was a congregation -that actively supported -LGBTQ families.
-Okay.
-So I - and it had two -female pastors.
-So this is what -I was raised in.
-pretty revolutionary, right?
-So in one minute -we would be doing -we've come this far by faith -and you know that.
-And then the next one -would be like, -(singing in German) -In the same church -service.
Yeah.
-So I've always had both.
-And for that -to be my experience -and to be in a place -like Philadelphia -where there was always, -I mean, WEBE Da Boys -wrote about the Philadelphia -Negro.
-Like, there was always -this very strong -culture of only African -American classical music -going on, like Mother Bethel -Congregation Zion Baptist.
-the Clayton White Singers, -I mean, like, -there were at least 2 -or 3 choirs -that were all black -and all classical, -when I was growing up -in Philadelphia.
-So I didn't have such -a switch, such a switch, -and I didn't have to feel -that I needed to belong -in that sphere because I -had examples in front of me.
-Right, right.
-But but when I was like, oh, -I think I actually like -when I do this for a job, -it was like, yeah, I just -wait a minute, -you want what?
-Oh yeah.
-So we would not be -catching you at the club -then in Philly during -any of these times?
-So you just -that you gravitated -towards this world -and stayed in it?
-Well, I gravitated -toward the world -in my high school years, -but I was, you know, -I was a nerd.
I nerd it out.
-I was really into foreign -languages and mythology -and so I see this for you.
-I was I was that child.
-I was that child -that literally, like, -my dad was an environmental -chemist, like I would -we would stay with him for -parts of the summer.
-And I was that child -that literally, like, -took his old Encyclopedia -Britannica -and read the whole thing.
-Like, -this is my summer reading.
-That was that was me.
-So, you know, -and my friends, -when I was in college, -they wanted to hit up like -clubs in the gayborhood -in Philly or whatever.
-And I was like dragged -kicking and screaming.
-And I was younger -than everybody.
-I was 3 or 4 years.
I'm -going to everybody.
-I was not legal.
-They were.
-But I presented as older, -so they never carded me, -but they carded them.
-OK, we are getting -all of the T now.
-We're getting all of this -T okay.
-So so yeah it was so -but interestingly enough -because I was at the club -and I knew how to dance.
-You know me, -my brother two step well -and I grew up around the hip -hop culture too.
Okay.
-That's the other thing.
-So my brothers -were very much into it.
-My brother Lamar is, -extremely well known spoken -word artists, -one of the original Russell -Simmons Def Poets, -Black Ice, so like -that was a world that was a -part of what I was doing.
-Amazing.
And you will -be connecting me -with Lamar.
Yes.
-After this.
-Okay.
Yes.
Wonderful.
-Austria.
So, so -I feel like -I know I have like a good -I have, like a good picture -of a young Cailin and -you know, the, -the surroundings, like, -which sounds so magical.
-Like to have that many black -classical choirs -in one area.
-But what took you -to Austria?
-How did you get there?
-Oh, Lord.
-So, you know, -I could get, like, -the vainglorious -one is like, well, you know, -I applied for this, -apply for a fellowship, -and I got a scholarship that -supported me to get there, -and all that.
-But really, what what -what drove me to Austria -And studying -at the Mozarteum, -which is the school -that was founded -by a foundation -founded by Mozart's wife.
-Wow.
to preserve his music.
-And then it became -this school.
-I ended up there really -Because, I mean, -I was exceedingly young, -so, you know, -I started college, by my -I started college at 15.
-Wow.
I finished early.
-I, I graduated -from grad school -a few months after I was 20.
-Brag about it and but I was -when I was young.
-Yeah.
-And I didn't really know -what I, I didn't know -what my next steps were that -talking about challenges.
-So I had a voice that was -a little more mature -for my age, -that belied my age.
-I could learn music -really, really fast.
-because of that, -the things that I felt good -for me to sing -were not necessarily things -that the establishment would -hire me for at that point.
-So I needed to figure out -what to do.
-You had a gap.
-You had some time.
Yeah.
-I had to figure out -what to do.
-And I was singing recitals -and doing concert stuff -and blah, blah, blah, -but just local stuff, -at Philly and I, -and there were things -there was some, -you know, trouble -in, you know, my, -in my household life.
-And so I just needed I, -I went to the minute -that I had an opportunity -to get off of the soil -and go to an environment -where I didn't know anyone, -I took -it, I took it, and I ran.
-And while I was -there, like right away, -I had like -immediate imposter syndrome.
-Yeah, immediate -imposter syndrome.
-And and not because -and that was -it was such -a learning experience for me -because I left -I left my undergraduate -really, -really despising education.
-Like, I felt like -I was jumping through hoops -that the school, -while I appreciated, -I appreciated -what I was learning -and I had great mentors -and great teachers there, -I felt like I was -always just trying to be -who I was, do what I felt -I was compelled to do, -but not quite fitting into -the box of what they felt -I should be doing.
-But then over there, -I just felt like, -wow, I'm surrounded by all -this music -all the time -and performing all the time.
-I've got these -great teachers.
-I'm literally like, -I look out -of my practice room -and there's freakin -this floral garden -and The Sound of Music -in the background.
-Yeah, you know, -and it was just, -I felt myself kind of doing -this, like, just kind of -walling myself -in, closing myself in, -about 3 or 4 months -in when they decided, -they decided, I did not.
-They decided that I was -going to include a major -in orchestral -conducting in my studies.
-I was there for - -as an opera major, opera -and musical theater major.
-I was like, wow, -this is actually the -ethos is actually completely -different here.
-When I was in the States, -when I was in my undergrad -and even doing competitions -and stuff like that, -you know, I felt like -I needed to prove myself.
-I felt like I needed to show -that this young black boy -from Northwest Philadelphia, -had it going on -or at least knew -what he was doing enough -to be trusted -with opportunities.
-Right?
-And over there, -the ethos was -you wouldn't freakin be here -if we didn't think -you belong, right?
-You already made it.
-You're here.
Yeah, like.
-And so now, -now that you're here, -learn -what you need to learn.
-And also, once you learn -what you need to learn, -get the fuck out and do it.
-I mean, which was, -which was like, oh, wow.
-And it, it gave me and -and they were training -everyone that way.
-And, and I was going to say -it sounds like true -equal treatment, -which is like as a -black person you're like, -what do I do?
-What do I do with my hands?
-Like, this is -and that's the thing, -I think there's a great -there's a great book -by Juwita Garai -called like post-traumatic -slave syndrome.
-And, and I was feeling -a lot of those things.
-Right.
-Like some, -some of the things -she talks about, -just like you're, you're -I was constantly on this -and I was young, so honest.
-Right.
But I was constantly -on this alert.
-Like, I'm like, who?
-When is the other shoe -going to drop, right?
-When are they going -to be like, -wait a minute, -you snuck in or someone -you only got here because -someone in power -liked you or -You know what I mean, right?
-Of course, -people, someone's -going to come with that -question about like, -why are you truly here?
-And when that didn't happen, -And not only that -didn't happen -but they were like, -youre so - -you've got so many skills -that we want -to help you grow.
-Because -I have been conducting -since I was in high school, -but I kind of -put that on the shelf -while I was studying -to be a singer.
Okay.
-But they saw that -and they're like, no, -bring it back off the shelf.
-Come on, come on.
-And we were going to -give you this world class, -you know, education to help -you do it.
-That must have felt amazing.
-Yeah, yeah, -yeah, it was, it was -I felt incredibly -seen there.
-Arguably for the first time -while I -was running -away, by the way.
-(lofi music) -while I was, like, trying to -get away from my whole, -problems with the family -and finances -and all the other stuff.
-I was trying to -just get away from America.
-Yeah.
-While I was, -I was at a place that I felt -completely saw me, -at least creatively, -and I was inventing myself -there, like I was claiming -who Cailin was as a young -adult in this place -that had nothing to do -entirely with -really what I came from.
-So that was -kind of an empowering thing -and also a little weird.
-Yeah, I had to go -so far away from home to -get back to self, in a way.
-So, your identity -in all of this, it -Gosh, -it sounds like it's been -squeezed and stretched -and also, like, completely -justified -and and had a lot of beauty -and beautiful experiences.
-Was your queer -identity -feeling as confident -as your identity as -a musician during this time?
-I feel like I really dug -into my queerness once -I, I feel like I entered -the profession full time.
-Because I felt like it's -not - and -Trust me, it's not this, -It's not that I didn't, -you know, -do what I needed to do -and scratch -An itch -that needed to be scratched.
-And I had relationships -and stuff like that.
-I mean, -but I, I found that I, I, -I was focused and I, -I mean it like I, -while I was exploring -queerness and how I wore it -and I think -that's but let's just -talk about that.
Sure.
-there are two things -that happen, -I think, with queerness, -especially in queerness -in America.
Right.
-Like there's this idea -that, you know, -we are the rainbow and it's, -you know, and everyone, -but there's not -I mean, there's a lot of -friction within that.
-And I found myself -in the late 90s, -struggling to see -how I, being a young queer -person, -fit into the prevailing -queer culture.
-That's one of the reasons -why I didn't like -I was dragged -kicking and screaming -to the clubs.
Right?
-Because, -you know, my friends - -I would see my friends -who would be, you know, -with a Rice Krispie -treat in hand, -wearing their, -you know, fleece -pajamas to class.
-I was never going to -show up to class like that.
-Literally -almost changed themselves -into anime characters -with hair -that look like soft -serve to go to the club, -because that's what was, -I guess, attractive -or what was expected.
-And you could see it.
-Or freeing maybe?
-Although I did find that -there was visual - -There's a lot of visual -similarity, amongst -people of a certain age -that I saw -in these environments.
-Whereas I with my -I had locs at the time.
-You did not.
Yes, -I did, I had locs never.
-Yes, yes I did.
-My pictures weren't -getting the pictures.
-You have to dig.
-Show this picture!
-Yeah.
You have to dig.
-There's always this -one moment every semester -where students -must Google me or something, -and they're like, -oh my God, you had hair.
-And I'm like, okay, -you know, but also locs -like I had locs.
-Yeah, But I was there -and they were long -too, like, wow, I'm here.
-So I had them -up, you know, Big Ponytail -and I -just couldn't remake myself.
-But they wanted me to go.
-So I was like, -okay, I'm going to go.
-And they would be out on -the dance floor and I would -And there was something -about -being on the dance floor -or whatever, like, -I love to dance.
-I would bop with my mom -and family reunions like, -cut it up.
-There's a great -there's a great video, -this great -Instagram of me teaching -the entire Putney School -the Electric Slide, -by the way.
-Okay, -we're going to find it.
-(bass driven music) -But being crowded like that -constantly, -like with people kind of -in your personal space, -the way I presented, like, -I dressed -more formally and I ended up -actually sitting.
-I enjoyed it, but I didn't -get on the dance floor.
-I was sitting at the bar -talking to some of the older -queer men -that were just at the bar.
-Yeah.
Just chillin.
-Just chillin.
-I got to know -the bartenders.
-They came to know that one -because my mom -bartended her way through -University of Pennsylvania -like that - -I knew what liquor I wanted.
-I was like, can you?
-They're like, oh, okay.
-Okay young man.
-What do you want?
-I was like, -it's been a hard day.
-I need a kettle -One dirty martini.
-Yeah.
They're like, -I'm like, yes.
-And dirty, dirtier -the better.
Okay.
-Noted that, you know, like, -it's been a hard day, -So I had that experience -as a young queer man -that just felt like I was -I was struggling -to figure out where I fit -into the sort of the queer -landscape of things.
-And and I felt that.
-And because I felt that so -strongly, I kind of didn't -focus on it very much.
-And I focused on achievement -and not because not -because I felt -anyone required me.
-That's the thing -I didn't feel like -anyone required me -to achieve.
-But achievement was -achievement -was my safe place.
-Achievement was like, -I can do this, -I can learn this music, -I can write these papers.
-I can memorize these roles.
-I can sing -these recitals off book.
-Let me, let me, -let me hit that.
-And it wasn't really until -like I said, I was done -with my schooling and -entered into the profession -and then realized oh crap, -Like what -am I singing about?
-What am I, what am I making -music about?
-What am I trying to express?
-I think about -when we talk as black people -And its like, oh gosh, -theres -so many conversations -out there of like, oh, -how is it working -in a sea of whiteness?
-And it's like we learned -how to navigate that -forever ago because -you figured out some hack -to not have to code switch -very, very early on.
-Like, -even though you didn't know -everything -you were ready to learn.
-But you didn't -stop being yourself -and you allowed yourself -some slow self-discovery -which, like, -please write that book -because so many can use -that.
-All of this to say, -I think what I struggled -with in the classical world -is just like playing -all the music -of some of these old, dead -white people that not only -are they old and white, -but also problematic.
-And also - Wagner - -there you go, Wagner.
-Wagner, anyone?
-Oh my goodness.
-and on top of that, unmoved, -unchanged, really kept -in a sacred way of playing -and performing these pieces.
-And, as a black man, -my question for you -is definitely like, -how are you -waking up every day -and dealing with that inner -struggle -of playing these old, -dead, problematic -white men's music?
-So I can say -one of the issues that I've, -I felt like I've combated -and and and still fight -is particularly -classical music is this idea -and this is where I think -DEI went a little awry in -the classical music world.
-Only went to half -measures.
-Our most recent movement.
-Yeah, yeah, yeah, it's the -most recent developments.
-Is that and rightly so.
-There are a number of, -you know, -African-American composers.
-Think about Florence Price, -William Grant still.
-Leslie Adams, Ulysses Kay, -Julia Perry, like the, -you know, Margaret Bonds.
-That should have always -been played -as part of the -American music lexicon.
-Right, right.
-But what ends up -happening is you -you specialize them, -so they become special.
-We're going to do an all -black composers -concert, right?
-We're going to do an all -female composers concert.
-We're going to it's -I don't want to - -tokenizing them -box checking all of that.
-Right.
-And the real transformation, -you know, I talk about -like what is the liberation -we're looking for?
-The real -transformation is like -you don't normalize -when you specialize.
-Can you say that?
-But slower.
-What is the liberation?
-What is the liberation -we're looking for?
-We are looking -that we are looking for -black artists, okay.
-We're black -people as black artists.
-Is it -that we want to be able to -just tell our own stories?
-or is it that we want to -tell whatever story we want?
-Because to me, that's true -Liberation, is not saying, -oh, you're black, -so you can only tell stories -that look like you -or that you can only tell -stories that we understand -you to be the experts of.
-Because that's not really -liberating to me, -is that, yes, -I want to be able -to tell my story, -but actually -I can use your music -and tell my story too, I can -literally be on a stage -and be the supreme -Norse god as a black man -and have all of -that dimension and all that -psychological development -and all of that symbolism -rest in my very brown, -very black body.
-And in order to do that, -I don't have to leave.
-What comes with that.
-I think it was -really telling -when we were going -through the pandemic.
-And so many of, -our fellow artists -of course, were struggling -because there were -no performances going on.
-I was still the music -director of the Bennington -County Core Society, -and I was the music director -of the Keene -Chorale in New Hampshire.
-You know, -pretty white spaces and, -and, and these -that even pretty, like, all -white really they might have -a couple, a couple here -and there.
Yeah, yeah.
-But had been basically going -to the marching orders of -this black man.
-How's that feel?
-Right.
Yeah.
-Well and it -but it was telling -because it was -a very different story -than other like like -I go to these board meetings, -theyre all white people -but I say -this is what this is, -this is how -we need to meet this moment.
-You know, -this is what we need to do.
-I'm not going -to do a virtual choir, -but I am going to share, -you know, I'm going -to we're going to connect.
-We're going to remember -why this is important to us.
-We don't need to show -anything.
-We don't need -to do anything.
-But we're going to connect.
-We're going to come back out -of this -and we're going to do, -you know, -the ordering of Moses, -you know, -which is by Robert Nathaniel -Dett, Black -Canadian composer.
-We're going to do -all of these things.
-I'm going to bring these, -black classical artists -to this area, -not because or whatever, -but because, you know what?
-At the end of the day, -they are and they have been -actually being black.
-They probably have exceeded -the level -of some of the many artists -that you've been exposed to.
-But I'm not going to -bring them up -Just do the little black -piece.
-They're going to do Bach -and they're going to do -Handel -because what you need to see -is that these are people -that carry -that tradition -And in classical music, -it's not just about -doing black music or music -by black people, -but the way forward, if -we're really going to do it, -is you have to hand over -power of curation -to black people.
-Right?
-And that means, yeah, -we haven't heard enough -black, -we have not heard enough -black people conduct -Beethoven five.
-I know white people think -that they've heard it enough -because it's been there.
-But you haven't -heard the way I do it.
-You haven't heard the way -Anthony Parnther does it.
-We bring something of -ourselves to that music -and how we do it, -especially when you're like -a mature black artist -and you don't give a crap.
-like you're like, what?
-Like, the we -do not care club?
-And I and I literally, -I mean, I literally sit -there, I will sit in Keene -Chorale - -We talk about how I bring my -blackness to this like, I, -I will sit in that room -with all those people -and I will -look at the altos, -I'm like, -can you like y'all?
-I need some more Sarah -Vaughan in that sound.
Wow.
-And they're like, -oh yeah, we -because they listen to her -you know, -we're singing Mendelssohn -and I'm talking about Sarah -Vaughan.
-You know, -I'm telling the Sopranos -they need to bring more -Ethel -Merman -into their sound.
-when I -was, I had great teachers.
-I didn't hear -any of my teachers -using those type of similes, -but they come from -my experience, -my multifaceted -musical theater, -man of the theater, black -raised in hip hop, -listening to mom's jazz -and soul experience.
-And I bring that -into the classical space.
-And they, as white -people from New England, -are still receptive to it -because -in some ways, me -being my whole complete self -invites them -to be themselves, too.
-Could you sing us something -that you find profound -and or means -something to you, -or maybe even speaks to -some of what we've been -talking about here today?
-Oh, so I was thinking -about this, -I would just love -to hear you sing.
-So.
So there's something -it's interesting -because it's kind of it -kind of fits.
-So what was it yesterday?
-Was yesterday, Yom Kippur.
-And there's this piece.
-It's borrowed by Maurice -Ravel called Kaddash.
-and I, it's I'm going to -what can be accompanied -by piano, -but I'll sing just -a little bit of it.
Sure.
-Yithbara'kh Weyischtaba'h -weyithpaêr weyithroman, -weyithnassé weyithhaddar, -weyith'allé weyithhallal -!scheméh dequoudschâ beri'kh hou, -!l'êla ule'êla mikkol bir'khatha -weschi'ratha touschbehata -wene'hamathâ -daamirân ah!
Be' olma ah!
-Ah!
-Ah!
-We imrou.
-Amen -Wow, wow.
-Thanks so much -for joining us.
-If you want to continue -to be a part -!of the homegoings family, stay -in touch at homegoings.co -and subscribe -to the homegoings podcast -wherever -you listen.
Take good care.
Support for PBS provided by:
Homegoings is a local public television program presented by Vermont Public
Sponsored in part by the Rutland Regional Medical Center and the Vermont Arts Council















