New Mexico In Focus
COVID & Masks, Boarding Schools and Soccer Pitch | 7.30.21
Season 15 Episode 5 | 57m 14sVideo has Closed Captions
Masks are Back, Albuquerque’s Soccer Pitch & Native Boarding Schools Probe
Native leaders discuss the need for the painful look back at the history of boarding schools in the U.S., as well as the path forward toward healing. Plus, how the University of New Mexico Medical School is boosting long-slumping numbers of rural primary care doctors. The Line opinion panel talks about the return of masks – even for vaccinated people & a proposed new soccer stadium in Albuquerque.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
New Mexico In Focus is a local public television program presented by NMPBS
New Mexico In Focus
COVID & Masks, Boarding Schools and Soccer Pitch | 7.30.21
Season 15 Episode 5 | 57m 14sVideo has Closed Captions
Native leaders discuss the need for the painful look back at the history of boarding schools in the U.S., as well as the path forward toward healing. Plus, how the University of New Mexico Medical School is boosting long-slumping numbers of rural primary care doctors. The Line opinion panel talks about the return of masks – even for vaccinated people & a proposed new soccer stadium in Albuquerque.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
How to Watch New Mexico In Focus
New Mexico In Focus is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship>> FUNDING FOR NEW MEXICO IN FOCUS PROVIDED BY THE MCCUNE CHARITABLE FOUNDATION AND VIEWERS LIKE YOU.
>> Gene: THIS WEEK ON NEW MEXICO IN FOCUS, THE NATION'S HARD LOOK AT NATIVE BOARDING SCHOOLS.
AND, THE LONG ROAD AHEAD.
>> Charley: THIS WAS A PRACTICE OF GENOCIDE AND IT IS TIME FOR THE COUNTRY TO RECKON WITH THAT.
THERE ARE WAYS IN WHICH NEW MEXICO CAN GRAPPLE THE ISSUE.
>> Gene: AND WHAT IS AHEAD FOR THE STATE IS MASKS MAKE A RETURN IN SCHOOLS AND BEYOND.
NEW MEXICO IN FOCUS STARTS NOW.
THANKS FOR JOINING US THIS WEEK.
I AM YOUR HOST GENE GRANT.
NATIVE COMMUNITIES HAVE WATCHED CLOSELY INTERIOR SECRETARY DEB HAALAND'S ANNOUNCEMENT THAT THE U.S. WILL EXAMINE ITS UGLY PAST WITH THE FORCED EDUCATION OF NATIVE CHILDREN IN BOARDING SCHOOLS.
WE'LL TAKE A DEEP DIVE WITH A LOCAL PANEL AND LOOK AT A RECENT NEWS HOUR INTERVIEW WITH SECRETARY HAALAND.
WE'LL ALSO LOOK AT WHAT IS BEHIND ENCOURAGING NEWS FROM UNM'S MEDICAL SCHOOL WHERE MORE FAMILY PRACTICE RESIDENTS ARE STAYING IN NEW MEXICO.
THE LINE OPINION PANEL TAKES UP THE PROPOSAL FOR A NEW SOCCER STADIUM TOO.
WE BEGIN WITH THE RESURGENCE OF COVID-19 AMONG THE UNVACCINATED AND PROMISE OF MORE MASKS.
HERE IS THE LINE.
FEELINGS OF OPTIMISM WE MIGHT HAVE HAD THIS SUMMER ABOUT A RETURN TO SOMETHING APPROACHING PRE-PANDEMIC NORMALCY HAVE TAKEN A HIT IN RECENT WEEKS.
FIRST, THE NEW SCHOOL YEAR WON'T BE ENTIRELY FREE OF MASKS OR PRECAUTIONS.
SECOND, THE CENTERS FOR DISEASE CONTROL AND PREVENTION HAVE REISSUED RECOMMENDATIONS FOR MASKS EVEN AMONG VACCINATED PEOPLE.
THAT AS THE ULTRA CONTAGIOUS DELTA VARIANT MAKES A RESURGENCE.
TO PARSE OUT WHAT IT MEANS AND WHAT IT MIGHT BE AHEAD IS OUR LINE OPINION PANEL.
FORMER STATE SENATOR DEDE FELDMAN JOINS US THIS WEEK, AS ONE OF OUR LINE REGULARS AS DOES FORMER MINORITY WHIP DANIEL FOLEY.
GLAD TO HAVE HIM BACK.
AND FOUNDER OF SIARZA SOCIAL DIGITAL, KRISTELLE SIARZA.
SHE IS OUR GUEST THIS WEEK.
NOW DEDE, CDC'S RECOMMENDATION WHICH THE STATE OF NEW MEXICO IS FOLLOWING IS FOR PLACES WITH RISING TRANSMISSION AND INFECTIONS.
THAT IS SOME BUT NOT ALL OF NEW MEXICO AS WE KNOW.
AREN'T THESE THE SAME PLACES THAT HAVE BEEN RESISTANT TO MASKS THAT WE ARE SEEING THIS RISE?
>> Dede: YES, THEY ARE.
EDDY COUNTY IN PARTICULAR HAS BEEN RESISTANT TO MASKS.
BUT, I LISTENED TO DR. SCRASE YESTERDAY IN HIS NEWS CONFERENCE AND HE SAID THAT NEW MEXICO WOULD BE FOLLOWING THE CDC GUIDELINES WHICH REQUIRE MASKS OR WHICH SUGGEST MASKS IN AREAS OF HIGH TRANSMISSION ESPECIALLY DUE TO THE DELTA VARIANT AND IN NEW MEXICO HE SAID HE WOULD RECOMMEND THAT ALTHOUGH YOU CAN SEE THOSE CERTAIN COUNTIES, HE RECOMMENDED EVERYONE BE WEARING A MASK VACCINATED OR UNVACCINATED BECAUSE THE TRANSMISSION OF THE DELTA VARIETY IS SO SEVERE AND OUR CASES ARE SPIKING BACK TO EVEN A LEVEL THAT EXISTED BACK IN MARCH.
HE RECOMMENDS THAT EVERYBODY, OF COURSE, GET VACCINATED AND THIS IS AN EPIDEMIC OF THE UNVACCINATED.
THAT IS WHO IS GETTING SICK BUT EVEN RECOMMENDATION FOR THE WHOLE STATE NOT JUST SPECIFIC COUNTIES.
>> Gene: GOOD POINTS THERE.
DANIEL, I HAVE GOT TO ASK YOU.
PLACES LIKE CARLSBAD, HOBBS, ROSWELL, I MEAN, YOU'RE DOWN THERE.
YOU KNOW THESE FOLKS.
IS THIS MASK RECOMMENDATION GOING TO GET ANYWHERE OR WHAT IS THE WAY TO GET IT?
>> Dan: FIRST OF ALL, I AM VACCINATED.
I GOT VACCINATED -- I HAD COVID-19 AND I GOT VACCINATED.
NOT GOT VACCINATED AND HAD COVID.
I THINK THE WHOLE THING FROM THE GET-GO HAS BEEN A PUBLIC RELATIONS DISASTER ACROSS THE COUNTRY FROM THE GET-GO.
WE ARE JUST -- YOU ARE TALKING TO PEOPLE -- YOU HAVE GOT TO LOOK AT PEOPLE -- WHEN YOU TALK ABOUT CHAVES COUNTY, LEA COUNTY, OTERO COUNTY, THEY ALREADY HAVE A SENSE OF DISTRUST OF THE GOVERNMENT IN THE FIRST PLACE.
RIGHT WRONG OR INDIFFERENT THEY HAVE IT.
SO, WHEN YOU START GIVING THEM ANYTHING TO FEED THE SEEDS OF DOUBT, YOU'RE GOING TO GET WHAT YOU'RE GETTING NOW.
WHEN YOU'RE HAVING THE WHOLE, YOU KNOW, LOOK, NOBODY IS GOING TO GET IT IF YOU GET VACCINATED TO NOW YOU'RE GOING TO GET IT TO MAYBE YOU'RE GOING TO GET IT, TO JUST EVEN YESTERDAY YOU HAD CDC DIRECTOR SAYING, THERE IS A ONE IN 10 CHANCE IF YOU HAVE THE VACCINE THAT YOU WILL GET THE DISEASE.
WELL, THAT IS NOT WHAT THE NUMBERS SAY.
THE NUMBERS SAY IT IS ONE OUT OF 1000.
SO, I MEAN, THERE IS JUST ALL THIS STUFF THAT SO MANY PEOPLE -- AGAIN, I AM NOT BLAMING ANY ONE PARTY.
I THINK THERE IS EQUAL BLAME ACROSS THE BOARD.
TO QUOTE RAHM EMANUEL, NEVER LET A CRISIS GO TO WASTE.
I THINK EVERYBODY INVOLVED IN POLITICS SAW THIS CRISIS AND SEIZED AN OPPORTUNITY AND I THINK NOW THE AMERICAN PEOPLE, AN OVERWHELMING NUMBER OF THEM, ARE ABSOLUTELY OVERWHELMED AND NOT SURE WHAT TO DO AND YOU START TALKING ABOUT FOLKS IN SOUTHEASTERN NEW MEXICO THAT ARE ALREADY ABOUT INDEPENDENCE, LEAVE THEM ALONE, THEY ARE NOT GOING TO BUY INTO IT.
>> Gene: GOOD POINTS THERE.
BUT KRISTELLE THIS IS A MATTER OF FAIRNESS ISN'T IT?
WE ALL HAVE THE CHOICE TO DO OR NOT DO ANYTHING WE WANT.
BUT THIS IS AN ISSUE OF FAIRNESS.
YOU'RE IN THE BUSINESS OF PERSUASION.
HOW DO WE PERSUADE PEOPLE THAT MASKING UP IS GOING TO BE GOOD FOR THEM AS WELL AS EVERYBODY ELSE?
>> Kristelle: AND THINK IT IS KIND OF FUNNY AND I SAY THIS VERY SARCASTICALLY AND WITH LOVE TO DAN FOLEY BUT IT IS NICE TO KNOW THAT YOUR PUBLIC RELATIONS PRACTICE (INAUDIBLE) AND SO WHEN WE TALK ABOUT THE SUBJECT OF FAIRNESS, YEAH, I THINK THAT THE BIGGEST LESSON WE HAVE ALL LEARNED FROM THIS IS THAT WE ARE AT THE MERCY OF SCIENCE AT THIS POINT.
NO PUBLIC RELATIONS PRACTITIONER CAN TAKE THIS PLAN WHEN SOMETHING UNEXPECTED LIKE THIS DATA AND RESEARCH IS STILL COMING OUT ABOUT THE SCIENCE OF THE VIRUS.
SO, OF COURSE, IT PUTS US IN A POSITION WHERE, AS OFTEN HAPPENS, THAT ONE PERSON, ONE PERSON THAT MIGHT GET COVID-19 RUINS IT FOR THE REST OF THE HERD, RIGHT?
THAT IS WHAT IS HAPPENING NOW.
EVEN SEEING REPUBLICAN LAWMAKERS GOING BACK ON THEIR THOUGHTS ABOUT THE VACCINE ITSELF SAYING THAT THE VACCINE SHOULD BE INOCULATED IN EVERYBODY'S ARMS AND EVERYBODY SHOULD GET THE VACCINE.
WE ARE AT THE POINT NOW WHERE IF THE CDC PUT IN A RECOMMENDATION A YEAR AGO, WE DIDN'T TRUST IT.
NOW WE ARE AT THE POINT OF THE CDC IS PUTTING THE RECOMMENDATION OUT AND AS MUCH AS WE HATED IT, WE KNOW WE HAVE TO DO WHAT WE HAVE TO DO BECAUSE WE KNOW THAT WE ARE ALL TIRED OF THESE CHANGES, THESE MASK MANDATES, ET CETERA, BUT WE KNOW, I THINK NOW, OUR SOCIETY IS SO USED TO THE UNPREDICTABILITY AT THIS POINT, NOT TO MENTION WE ARE ONE OF THE ONLY COUNTRIES THAT IS ACTUALLY USED TO ACTUALLY LIFE NOW WITHOUT COVID-19 OR WITH LESS OF COVID-19 IN THE GENERAL SPACES.
WATCHING THE OLYMPICS OVER THE LAST WEEK, NOT SEEING CROWDS AND NOT SEEING PEOPLE PARTICIPATE, IT IS SO FOREIGN TO US NOW AFTER BEING OKAY TO START WALKING AROUND WITHOUT A MASK.
>> Gene: THAT IS A FAIR POINT.
>> Dede: IT HAS ONLY BEEN THREE WEEKS.
REMEMBER HOW FAST THESE THINGS ARE CHANGING.
ONLY THREE WEEKS SINCE NEW MEXICO CAME OUT OF A VIRTUAL LOCKDOWN.
>> Gene: DEDE, CAST FORWARD THREE WEEKS.
WE HAVE SCHOOL COMING BACK IN FOR A LOT OF FOLKS.
SANTA FE GOES BACK AUGUST 6, APS RIGHT AROUND THAT TIME AND WE JUST HAD AN ANNOUNCEMENT FROM MY EMPLOYER, UNM HERE, THEIR GUIDANCE IS BACK TO MASKS FOR EVERYONE INDOORS, VACCINATED OR NOT.
LET'S TALK ABOUT BACK TO SCHOOL.
WHAT HAVE YOU SEEN SO FAR THAT GIVES YOU COMFORT WE CAN PULL THIS OFF OR ARE YOU CONCERNED THAT WE CAN GET BACK TO SCHOOL, GIVEN WHAT WE KNOW NOW?
>> Dede: WELL, I THINK THAT IT HAS BEEN A RATHER AWKWARD POSITION FOR THE PED, PUBLIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT, TO HAVE PUT OUT GUIDANCE THAT MIDDLE AND HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS DIDN'T NEED TO WEAR MASKS IF THEY WERE VACCINATED AND THEN THE CDC CAME OUT WITH THIS RECOMMENDATION SO THEY HAVEN'T ACTUALLY BACKTRACKED ON THAT YET BUT THEY WILL.
AND APS IS THE HARBINGER BECAUSE APS JUST INDICATED THAT ALL STUDENTS WILL NEED TO WEAR MASKS INDOORS.
SO, I THINK WHAT HAS HAPPENED HERE IS THAT WE HAVE HAD THE HONOR SYSTEM AND THE HONOR SYSTEM HAS NOT WORKED.
THE PEOPLE WHO HAVE NOT BEEN VACCINATED ARE NOT WEARING MASKS.
SO, IF WE DON'T -- IF OUR RATES DON'T COME DOWN AND SOMETHING DOESN'T HAPPEN, WHAT IS NEXT IS MAYBE SOME SORT OF A MANDATE THAT PEOPLE GET VACCINATED AT UNM WHICH THEY TURNED DOWN OR IF THEY ARE EMPLOYED BY THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT, WHICH, YOU KNOW, EVERYONE HAS BEEN KIND OF EXPECTING THAT BECAUSE VETERANS ADMINISTRATION HAS MANDATED THAT.
NEW YORK, CALIFORNIA, THAT MAY BE NEXT.
>> Gene: LET ME FLESH THAT OUT A LITTLE BIT FOR FOLKS WHO DON'T KNOW WHAT DEDE IS GOING TO HERE.
BASICALLY, THEY ARE REQUIRING IF YOU'RE UNVACCINATED, YOU HAVE TO TEST EVERY WEEK OR EVEN MORE OFTEN TO GET TO WORK IN SOME PLACES.
DAN, DOES THAT FEEL LIKE A LEAP TOO FAR?
LET ME PUT IT IN THIS CONTEXT.
ARE WE MISSING THE FOREST HERE?
THE KIDS ARE GOING BACK TO SCHOOL -- CLASS.
YOU KNOW, IT IS SOMEWHAT NORMAL, IS IT NOT?
CAN WE GET THROUGH THIS?
>> Dan: YEAH, LOOK, THERE IS NO DOUBT THAT I THINK THERE IS A PARALLEL CONVERSATION TO HAVE HERE, RIGHT?
ONE IS WHAT IS COVID DOING AND THE EFFECTS AND HOW WE RESPOND AND REACT TO IT.
HERE WE ARE HAVING THIS CONVERSATION ABOUT MAKING KIDS WEAR MASKS IN SCHOOL AND YET EVEN THE OWN CDC'S INFORMATION SAYS, LOOK, THESE YOUNG PEOPLE ARE NOT A PROBLEM.
IT IS NOT HURTING THESE YOUNG KIDS BUT THE ANSWER IS PUT THEM IN A MASK.
SO, I DON'T KNOW.
I HAVE GOT FOUR KIDS THAT ARE GROWN NOW.
I CAN'T IMAGINE TELLING MY THIRD GRADE KID HE HAS TO WEAR A MASK ALL DAY WHILE HE IS SITTING IN CLASS.
YOU CAN'T GET HIM TO SIT IN A CHAIR FOR 20 MINUTES LET ALONE WEAR A MASK.
>> Gene: THAT IS JUST THE RECOMMENDATION.
THAT IS JUST THE REALITY RIGHT NOW.
>> Dan: I THINK WE HEAR PEOPLE SAY ALL THE TIME WE SHOULD FOLLOW THE SCIENCE THEN YOU LOOK AT SCIENCE AND WE ARE MAKING DECISIONS THAT DON'T FOLLOW THE SCIENCE IN CERTAIN THINGS SO IT MAKES PEOPLE SAY, IF YOU'RE NOT USING THE SCIENCE TO FOLLOW THAT DECISION, WHAT SCIENCE ARE YOU USING TO MAKE THIS DECISION?
WHICH BRINGS ME BACK TO THE WHOLE, IT IS CRAZY.
RIGHT NOW THE WORD IS THERE IS OVER 1/3 OF THE U.S. MILITARY THAT HASN'T GOTTEN VACCINATED.
SO, I MEAN YOU'RE GOING TO START TELLING EVERYBODY IN AMERICA AS A KID THEY HAVE GOT TO GET VACCINATED?
BUT THEY CAN SAY WHAT THEY WANT.
THERE IS A FIGHT RIGHT NOW IN CALIFORNIA FROM BOTH THE PRISON GUARDS UNION AND I THINK THERE IS ANOTHER PUBLIC EMPLOYEES UNION SAYING YOU CAN'T MAKE US GET VACCINATED.
YOU CAN'T MAKE US GET VACCINATED.
THESE EDICTS ARE COMING OUT -- >> Gene: I HAVE A BUT.
HANG ON.
I HAVE A BUT AND I AM GOING TO TOSS IT TO KRISTELLE.
FRANCE, VACCINE PASSPORTS.
GERMANY, VACCINE PASSPORTS.
YOU CAN'T WALK IN THE DOOR.
THEY ARE NOT DOING HONOR SYSTEM.
YOU HAVE TO SHOW SOMETHING OR YOU'RE NOT GETTING IN THE DOOR.
ARE WE HEADED THAT WAY?
IS THERE SOMETHING, A STEP THAT COULD BE TAKEN IN THAT DIRECTION THAT IS PALATABLE TO AMERICANS?
HOW CAN WE POSSIBLY PULL THAT OFF?
>> Kristelle: WE GO BACK TO THE DECISION MAKING BY THE DIFFERENT INSTITUTIONS, BUSINESSES AND BACK TO DAN'S POINT, PEOPLE ARE MAKING CERTAIN DECISIONS BECAUSE OF SCIENCE.
WE ALWAYS GO BACK TO SAFETY AND SECURITY, RIGHT?
SAFETY AND SECURITY OF OUR PEOPLE, SAFETY AND SECURITY OF STAFF, ESPECIALLY HERE AT OUR COMPANY AND THE SAFETY AND SECURITY OF OUR FAMILIES THAT WE GO HOME TO AT THE END OF THE DAY.
SO, SAFETY AND SECURITY FOR PLACES LIKE GERMANY AND FRANCE WHERE THEY ARE PUTTING THESE MANDATES, IT IS THE GOVERNMENTS ONE WAY OF SHOWING SAFETY AND SECURITY FOR ALL THE INDIVIDUALS THAT LIVE WITHIN THAT COUNTRY.
LIKE WE STILL HAVE -- >> Gene: THEY ARE GETTING PROTESTS.
IN PARIS.
>> Kristelle: OF COURSE THERE IS ALWAYS GOING TO BE PEOPLE THAT DON'T WANT TO DO THINGS LIKE THAT BUT IF YOU THINK ABOUT IT, RIGHT, IF THERE ARE MANDATES LIKE CURFEWS IN OUR NATIVE RESERVATIONS, IT IS BECAUSE OF THE SAFETY AND SECURITY, RIGHT, OF A NATION NOT BEING WIPED OUT BECAUSE OF A PANDEMIC.
SO, OF COURSE, THERE IS GOING TO BE COMPLAINING AND MOANING ABOUT MANDATES OF THIS SORT BUT, YOU KNOW, BACK TO DEDE'S POINT, IF PEOPLE ARE WORKING ON THE HONOR SYSTEM OR NOT COMPLYING WITH THE HONOR SYSTEM, THEN, YOU KNOW, WE HAVE TO TAKE MATTERS INTO THE HANDS OF THE INDIVIDUALS AND ONE OF THE THINGS WE ALSO SEE TOO, ESPECIALLY IN OUR NATION, I'LL MAKE IT QUICK, WE SEE HOW THINGS GO ON A MICRO LEVEL.
WE SEE EMPLOYERS ARE TRYING TO MANDATE VACCINES WITHIN THEIR WORKFORCES AMONG EMPLOYEES AND THEN WE STARTED TO SEE IT GO ON A CITY-WIDE LEVEL, ON A COUNTY LEVEL AND THEN EVENTUALLY TO GO NATIONWIDE.
THAT IS THE NATURE OF THE COURSE OF AMERICA.
WE START SMALL THEN THE MANDATES GO BIG SO I WOULD ANTICIPATE SOMETHING LIKE THIS FOR VACCINE OF SOME SORT.
>> Gene: GOOD POINTS THERE.
WE ARE OUT OF TIME.
THIS GROUPS KICKS AROUND ANOTHER TOPIC, PUBLIC FINANCING FOR NEW MEXICO UNITED SOCCER STADIUM IN JUST A FEW MINUTES.
>> McCLAIN: HOW DO YOU MATCH PEOPLES' INTERESTS WHO ARE COMING WITH A MISSION OF OUR HOSPITALS AND OF OUR PROGRAMS?
I THINK HE SAW A LOT ABOUT THAT AND DID AN EXCELLENT JOB FIGURING OUT KIND OF THE CRITERIA TO LOOK AT TO MAKE SURE FOLKS ARE INTERESTED IN UNDERSERVED COMMUNITIES STAYING IN NEW MEXICO AND GOING TO A RURAL LOCATION.
>> Gene: THE TROUBLED LEGACY OF INDIAN BOARDING SCHOOLS IN THE UNITED STATES IS FINALLY BEING ACKNOWLEDGED BY THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT.
THE SCHOOLS CREATED BY FEDERAL POLICY AND OFTEN RUN BY CHURCHES WERE INTENDED TO ASSIMILATE NATIVE AMERICAN CHILDREN AND STRIP THEM OF THEIR TRIBAL CULTURE.
TRADITIONS, DRESS, LANGUAGE, ALL OF IT.
SECRETARY OF INTERIOR DEB HAALAND RECENTLY LAUNCHED A FEDERAL INVESTIGATION TO LOCATE SCHOOL FACILITIES, BURIAL GROUNDS AND TO IDENTIFY THE TRIBAL AFFILIATIONS OF CHILDREN WHO DIED AT THESE SCHOOLS.
THAT FOLLOWS THE GRIM DISCOVERY OF HUNDREDS OF REMAINS IN CANADA AT SITES OF FORMER INDIAN RESIDENTIAL SCHOOLS THERE.
THOSE DISCOVERIES ARE PAINFUL REMINDERS FOR NATIVE AMERICANS WHO HAVE BEEN IMPACTED BY INTERGENERATIONAL TRAUMA OF THE SCHOOLS.
THIS WEEK, CORRESPONDENT ANTONIO GONZALES SPEAKS WITH SOME MEMBERS OF THE NATIVE COMMUNITY ABOUT THAT TRAUMATIC HISTORY.
>> Antonia: I WANT TO THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE TODAY AND JUST ACKNOWLEDGING THAT THIS IS A DIFFICULT SUBJECT FOR MANY PEOPLE TO TALK ABOUT AND MAYBE EVEN OUR VIEWERS TO WATCH.
WE ARE TALKING ABOUT BOARDING SCHOOLS IN THE UNITED STATES AND IMPACTS ON NATIVE AMERICAN PEOPLE HERE.
ACROSS THE COUNTRY AND IN NEW MEXICO.
COUNCILMAN GARCIA, YOU WERE THERE AT THE NATIONAL CONGRESS OF AMERICAN INDIANS, MIDYEAR CONVENTION, WHEN SECRETARY OF THE INTERIOR DEB HAALAND MADE HER ANNOUNCEMENT ON HER BOARDING SCHOOL INITIATIVE.
WHAT WAS YOUR REACTION HEARING THAT?
>> Garcia: THE INITIAL REACTION IS THAT IT IS -- IT DID HAPPEN.
BECAUSE IT STARTED -- AFTER IT STARTED WHILE SHE WAS STILL CONGRESSWOMAN AND SHE WAS CONSIDERING SETTING UP AN INVESTIGATION OR SOMETHING TO THAT EFFECT OF WHAT FINALLY TRANSPIRED.
AND THE FACT THAT SHE MOVED OVER TO SECRETARY OF INTERIOR, WHICH WAS ONE OF THE BEST MOVES IN THE COUNTRY FOR INDIAN COUNTRY, SHE WAS ABLE TO MOVE THIS EFFORT A LITTLE FASTER THAN NORMAL.
SO, I THINK THE EFFORT HAS BEEN LONG OVERDUE BUT THERE IS A WHOLE LOT OF HISTORY THAT MOST PEOPLE IN THIS COUNTRY JUST DON'T KNOW ABOUT AND THAT IS INDIAN HISTORY.
ALL OF THE THINGS THAT WE HAVE GONE THROUGH, THE SUFFERING AND ALL OF THAT -- >> Antonia: AND ANGEL, WHAT WAS YOUR RESPONSE WHEN YOU HEARD THE NEWS OF THIS INVESTIGATION, NOT ONLY JUST AN INVESTIGATION BUT THE U.S. GOVERNMENT ACKNOWLEDGING ITS PART IN FEDERAL INDIAN BOARDING SCHOOLS?
>> Charley: IT COULDN'T HAVE COME AT A BETTER TIME.
IF WE ARE PAYING ATTENTION TO WHAT IS HAPPENING IN CANADA RIGHT NOW, IT IS DISCOVERY AFTER DISCOVERY AFTER DISCOVERY OF BURIAL SITES, HUNDREDS OF INDIGENOUS CHILDREN BURIED AT RESIDENTIAL SCHOOLS AND SO WE ARE BOTH GRATEFUL AND HOPEFUL WITH SECRETARY HAALAND BEING AT THE HELM OF THE DEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR TO PUSH FURTHER THESE EFFORTS.
>> Antonia: CAN YOU TALK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THE IMPACT ON PUEBLO PEOPLE HERE IN NEW MEXICO WITH BOARDING SCHOOLS.
THERE IS A HISTORY THAT TRIBAL COMMUNITIES ARE WELL AWARE OF, EVEN THOUGH IT IS JUST NOW BEING BROUGHT TO LIGHT IN THE PUBLIC AND U.S. WE HEAR STORIES FROM OUR PARENTS AND GRANDPARENTS.
IT IS A LIVING HISTORY AND IMPACTS, INCLUDING TRAUMA AND ABUSE, HAVE BEEN INTERGENERATIONAL.
>> Garcia: THERE IS NO UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT THE INTENT WAS OTHER THAN TRYING TO PROMOTE EDUCATION BUT THAT IS NOT EVEN A VENUE THAT THE UNITED STATES HAD ITS MIND ON.
IT WAS SOMETHING DIFFERENT.
AND I THINK THE UNITED STATES HAS NOT TALKED ABOUT THAT.
AND THE WORD IS CALLED GENOCIDE AND GENOCIDE IS WHAT IT IS ABOUT.
WHAT HAS HAPPENED IS THAT RELIGION AND WAY OF LIFE ARE MISUNDERSTOOD BY THE DOMINANT SOCIETY.
SO, THE FACT THAT WE HAVE CULTURE AND TRADITION, THAT IS NOT RELIGION.
THAT IS WAY OF LIFE.
THAT IS OR WAY OF LIFE AND TO JUST CATEGORIZE IT INTO RELIGIOUS THINGS, WHICH IS THE CONVERSION THING THAT YOU WANT TO DO, AND FOR PUEBLO COUNTRY BECAUSE OF WHAT WE STILL GO THROUGH IN OUR TRADITIONAL WAYS FOR TAKING CARE OF OUR LOST ONES, IT IS VERY, VERY HURTFUL IF SOMEONE IS BURIED ELSEWHERE THAT THEY ARE NOT PART OF THAT LAND BASE, IF YOU WILL, NOT PART OF MOTHER EARTH AT THAT POINT.
SO, TRYING TO UNDERSTAND THAT IS A BIG, BIG ISSUE BUT THE FACT THAT IT IS KIND OF COMING OUT NOW, BEING EXPOSED, I THINK, IT IS NOT GOING TO HAPPEN IN A YEAR'S TIME.
IT IS NOT GOING TO HAPPEN IN FIVE YEARS TIME.
IT IS GOING TO TAKE A LONG, LONG TIME.
THE HEALING PART HASN'T EVEN BEEN MEASURED AT THIS POINT.
BECAUSE, IT IS SO SMALL.
>> Antonia: AND ANGEL, COUNCILMAN GARCIA MENTIONED HEALING.
AND WORKING WITH A LOT OF PEOPLE THROUGH YOUR COALITION, DEALING WITH TRAUMA AND IMPACTS OF INTERGENERATIONAL TRAUMA IS WHAT THE COALITION YOU WORK WITH DOES.
HOW IS USING CULTURE PART OF HEALING AND CAN HELP WITH HEALING OF IMPACTS FROM BOARDING SCHOOLS?
>> Charley: WHAT COUNCILMAN GARCIA MENTIONED, THE CEREMONIES THAT WE HAVE, THE PROCESS OF RETURNING OUR PEOPLE INTO THE EARTH IS SO IMPORTANT.
WHEN WE BEGAN HAVING THESE CONVERSATIONS JUST AS A STAFF ORGANIZATION, SO MANY FEELINGS OF ANGER AND GRIEF AND HURT AROSE JUST WITHIN THE 12 OF US AT THE COALITION.
AS WE BEGAN TO HAVE THESE CONVERSATIONS WITH OUR MEMBERS AND COMMUNITY MEMBERS, IT CONTINUED TO RISE AND SO WHEN WE PULLED, ALONG WITH ALBUQUERQUE MUTUAL AID AND FIGHT FOR OUR LIVES, THESE COMMUNITY BASED ORGANIZATIONS PUT TOGETHER A COUPLE OF EFFORTS.
IT BEGAN AS A CONVERSATION, WHAT DO WE DO NEXT AND WHEN WE REALLY GOT DEEP INTO THE FEELINGS THAT WE WERE EXPERIENCING, IT WAS VERY IMPORTANT THAT WE HAD A SPACE AND A TIME FOR FOLKS TO COME TOGETHER TO HEAL AND WHAT THAT MEANT WAS TO GRIEVE COLLECTIVELY.
WE DID A LOT OF FOCUS AROUND THE CHILDREN WE DO HAVE AND A LOT OF EVENTS TO SUPPORT THEIR WELLBEING.
BUT THAT HEALING PROCESS IS VERY IMPORTANT AND ALSO NOT ONE YEAR.
IT IS GOING TO TAKE A LOT OF TIME AND A LOT OF TURNS.
THE MORE INFORMATION THAT COMES OUT FROM INVESTIGATION THROUGH THE DEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR WILL CONTINUE TO SURFACE THESE FEELINGS FOR FOLKS.
AND IT IS IMPORTANT THAT WE CONTINUE TO HOLD SPACE AND COME TOGETHER IN NEW WAYS ESPECIALLY GIVEN COVID-19 AND THE REMOTENESS OF WHAT INTERACTION LOOKS LIKE NOW, TO HEAL.
AND TO CONNECT.
>> Antonia: COUNCILMAN GARCIA JUST TO FOLLOW UP WITH THAT, WHAT DO YOU HOPE COMES OUT OF THIS FIRST YEAR OF THE INVESTIGATION?
>> Garcia: WELL, I HOPE THAT IT DOESN'T COME INTO A POLITICAL BATTLE AND FROM MY EXPERIENCE IN BEING INVOLVED IN TRIBAL GOVERNMENT AND INDIAN GOVERNMENT, PER SE ACROSS THE COUNTRY AND COLLABORATIONS AND WORKING WITH THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT, SOMETIMES EFFORTS LIKE THIS TEND TO STALL OUT AND IT BECOMES A POLITICAL GAME RATHER THAN THE REAL TRUE SPIRIT OF WHAT IT IS WE ARE TRYING TO ACCOMPLISH.
THE ACCOMPLISHMENTS, I THINK, HAVE TO DO WITH HEALING AND UNLESS YOU UNDERSTAND THE PARTS OF HEALING AND HOW LONG IT TAKES AND WHAT IS NEEDED BY THE PEOPLE THAT NEED THAT HEALING, NO.
1, IT HAS GOT TO BE ACCEPTED THAT THESE THINGS HAPPENED.
BUT, THE GUILTY PARTY ALSO HAS TO ACCEPT THAT THESE THINGS HAPPENED AND THE HISTORY OF IT IS THAT IT WASN'T WRITTEN IN EVERYDAY BOOK LITERATURE THAT I HAVE GOT HERE.
SO, HOW MANY TIMES HAVE INDIAN PEOPLE, IN THEIR HISTORY, COURSES THEY HAVE TAKEN BECAUSE IT IS A REQUIREMENT IN THE EDUCATION PROCESS, HOW MANY TIMES HAVE THEY READ ANYTHING LIKE THIS IN THE HISTORY BOOKS AND I THINK NIL BECAUSE IT IS NOT IN THE HISTORY BOOKS.
SO, WHEN YOU'RE AT THAT LEVEL OF DENIAL BY THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT THAT THESE THINGS HAPPENED, THEN IT BECOMES A HARDER EFFORT TO BRING IT TO THE SURFACE AND THEN MOVE IT ALONG.
>> Antonia: ANGEL, ANY FINAL THOUGHTS?
>> Charley: HEALING REQUIRES CONNECTION.
THAT WE CANNOT HAVE RECONCILIATION WITHOUT TRUTH, THAT THIS WAS A PRACTICE OF GENOCIDE AND THAT IT IS TIME FOR THE COUNTRY TO RECKON WITH THAT.
THERE ARE WAYS IN WHICH NEW MEXICO CAN GRAPPLE THIS ISSUE, THROUGH THE PROVISIONS OF YAZI VERSUS MARTINEZ TO GET THAT CURRICULUM INTO THE TEXTBOOKS OF CHILDREN.
NOW, IT IS ENSURING THAT EVERYONE IS ABLE TO HAVE A FIRM UNDERSTANDING OF, THIS IS THE HISTORY OF THIS COUNTRY.
>> Antonia: THANK YOU FOR JOINING US TODAY ON NEW MEXICO IN FOCUS AND THERE IS DEFINITELY A LOT OF WORK AHEAD ON BOARDING SCHOOL, LOOKING AT BOARDING SCHOOL HISTORY HERE IN THE UNITED STATES AND DEFINITELY FOR THE HEALING PROCESS.
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
SECRETARY OF THE INTERIOR DEB HAALAND RECENTLY ANNOUNCED HER U.S. BOARDING SCHOOL INITIATIVE TO INVESTIGATE BOARDING SCHOOL HISTORY HERE IN THE UNITED STATES.
SHE RECENTLY SAT DOWN WITH PBS NEWS HOUR TO SHARE SOME THOUGHTS.
>> Host: SECRETARY HAALAND THANK YOU SO MUCH JOINING US.
I HAVE TO SAY AT THE OUTSET THAT THIS IS ONE OF THE SADDEST MOST DISTURBING STORIES I HAVE EVER SEEN, TO THINK OF THESE THOUSANDS AND THOUSANDS OF CHILDREN TAKEN FROM THEIR FAMILIES SO MANY OF WHOM NEVER CAME BACK.
THE FAMILIES NEVER KNEW WHAT HAPPENED TO THEM.
IT IS UNSPEAKABLE.
YOUR OWN FAMILY WAS TOUCHED BY THIS.
>> Haaland: YES, IT IS A TRAGIC ERA IN OUR HISTORY, IN AMERICAN HISTORY.
THE BOARDING SCHOOL ERA -- THINK ABOUT AS SORT OF ONE LAST DITCH EFFORT TO GET NATIVE AMERICANS OUT OF THEIR COMMUNITIES AND PUT THEM INTO MAINSTREAM SOCIETY AFTER GENOCIDE, AFTER THE KILLING OFF OF VAST NUMBERS OF NATIVE FOLKS SO THAT FOLKS COULD TAKE THEIR LAND.
IT WAS TRAGIC AFTER EVERYTHING ELSE THAT HAD HAPPENED AS WELL AND THEY TOOK INDIANS FROM THEIR COMMUNITIES AND THEIR FAMILIES SO THEY COULD INDOCTRINATE THEM, RIGHT?
TO TAKE AWAY THEIR CLOTHING, TO BRUTALLY TAKE AWAY THEIR LANGUAGES AND THEIR CULTURES AND MANY CHILDREN, YES, THEY NEVER MADE IT BACK HOME.
I AM GRATEFUL THAT MY GRANDPARENTS MADE IT BACK HOME.
I WOULDN'T BE HERE TODAY IF THEY HADN'T, OF COURSE.
SO, THIS IS A HISTORY THAT ALL OF US NEED TO KNOW ABOUT SO THAT WE CAN BEGIN A HEALING PROCESS FOR THE FAMILIES WHO ARE STILL LIVING WITH THE GENERATIONAL TRAUMA OF THE BOARDING SCHOOL ERA, OF THE ASSIMILATION ERA, OF ALL OF THE TERRIBLE ERAS OF FEDERAL INDIAN POLICY THAT TRIBES HAVE HAD TO LIVE WITH.
>> Host: DO YOU HAVE A GOOD UNDERSTANDING DO YOU THINK OF WHAT HAPPENED TO THE CHILDREN WHO DIED?
>> Haaland: WE DON'T KNOW, RIGHT?
AND THAT IS ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WE HOPE TO FIND OUT WITH OUR FEDERAL BOARDING SCHOOL INITIATIVE.
IT WAS WIDELY KNOWN THAT IN INDIAN BOARDING SCHOOLS THAT MALNUTRITION WAS AN ISSUE.
IF YOU TALK TO FOLKS WHOSE GRANDPARENTS WENT TO BOARDING SCHOOL AND THEY HAVE HEARD STORIES, THE STORIES ABOUT KIDS JUMPING OFF OF TRAINS BECAUSE THEY DIDN'T WANT TO GO TO THE BOARDING SCHOOL.
RUNNING AWAY AND NEVER BEING SEEN AGAIN.
THIS WAS, YOU KNOW, THERE WERE MANY WAYS, YES, THAT CHILDREN DIED IN THOSE SETTINGS AND THAT IS ONE OF THE THINGS WE ARE HOPING WE CAN FIND OUT.
>> Host: IT WAS, AS YOU SAID, A WIDELY ACCEPTED POLICY IN THIS COUNTRY, U.S., AND IN CANADA.
I READ IN YOUR QUOTE FROM THE CIVIL WAR VETERAN WHO FOUNDED THE SCHOOL FOR CHILDREN IN PENNSYLVANIA, CARLISLE, PENNSYLVANIA, WHO SAID, I AM QUOTING, KILL THE INDIAN IN HIM AND SAVE THE MAN.
IT IS ASTONISHING TO THINK THAT WAS THE MINDSET BEHIND THIS.
>> Haaland: INDEED.
NATIVE AMERICANS WERE NOT THOUGHT OF AS HUMANS IN THIS COUNTRY.
WE WEREN'T CITIZENS IN THIS COUNTRY UNTIL 1924.
WE DIDN'T HAVE THE RIGHT TO VOTE IN MANY, MANY COMMUNITIES, SOME AS LATE AS 1960 OR '62.
WE WEREN'T THOUGHT AS VALUABLE CONTRIBUTORS TO THIS COUNTRY AND YET TODAY, WE SEE THAT NATIVE AMERICANS HAVE THE HIGHEST RATE OF MILITARY SERVICE.
THE RATIO IS HIGHER THAN ANY OTHER GROUPS OF PEOPLE.
WE STEP UP TO DEFEND OUR COUNTRY AND, OF COURSE, TODAY, WE DEFIED ALL THE ODDS.
MANY OF OUR FAMILIES, ANCESTORS, PERSEVERED.
MY GRANDPARENTS WERE ACTUALLY PART OF THE ASSIMILATION ERA.
AFTER BOARDING SCHOOL, THEY WENT AND WORKED ON THE RAILROAD IN WINSLOW, ARIZONA.
>> Host: HOW CAN WE BE CONFIDENT WE ARE GOING TO GET TO THE BOTTOM OF IT WHEN IT IS THE GOVERNMENT, IN EFFECT, INVESTIGATING ITSELF?
>> Haaland: I FEEL THAT WITH OUR INITIATIVE THAT WE CAN WORK ON HEALING.
I REALLY FEEL CONFIDENT THAT, I MEAN, THAT IS A GOAL FOR US AND WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT THE FAMILIES GET THE ANSWERS THEY NEED AND THEY WANT.
THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT HAS A TRUST OBLIGATION TO INDIAN TRIBES.
THAT IS IN EXCHANGE FOR ALL THE LAND THAT ESSENTIALLY BECAME THE UNITED STATES.
THIS WAS ALL INDIAN LAND AT ONE TIME.
SO, I FEEL CONFIDENT THAT THIS IS PART OF OUR TRUST OBLIGATION TO INDIAN TRIBES, AN INITIATIVE WE ARE MOVING FORWARD WITH.
I FEEL CONFIDENT THIS IS A NEW ERA AND WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT TRIBES HAVE A SEAT AT THE TABLE.
>> Host: ULTIMATELY, HOW DO YOU SEE HOLDING THE INSTITUTIONS ACCOUNTABLE THAT WERE RESPONSIBLE FOR THIS?
>> Haaland: THAT REMAINS TO BE SEEN OF COURSE.
THERE IS A LOT -- RECENTLY I WAS ABLE TO PARTICIPATE IN A CEREMONY AT CARLISLE, NOW AN ARMY WAR COLLEGE.
IT WAS A CARLISLE INDUSTRIAL SCHOOL FOR NATIVE AMERICANS.
MY GREAT GRANDFATHER ATTENDED THAT SCHOOL AND I WAS INVITED BY THE ROSEBUDS SIOUX TRIBE AS THEY WORK TO REMOVE CHILDREN FROM THEIR TRIBE WHO WERE BURIED IN THE CEMETERY THERE, TO TAKE THEM HOME TO THEIR HOMELAND IN SOUTH DAKOTA.
I THINK THAT IT IS UP TO EVERY TRIBE, RIGHT, HOW DO THEY WANT TO MOVE FORWARD?
WHAT IS THEIR IDEA OF HEALING AND WHAT WOULD MAKE THEM FEEL LIKE THEY HAVE GOTTEN THE ANSWERS THEY WANT.
WE ARE GOING TO DO OUR BEST TO MAKE SURE WE ARE ATTENTIVE TO THOSE NEEDS.
>> Host: YOU ALSO WROTE RECENTLY ABOUT THE CHALLENGE OF LOVING YOUR OWN COUNTRY, A COUNTRY THAT WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR COMMITTING THESE ACTS.
HOW DO YOU EXPLAIN THAT TO OTHERS, TO OTHER NATIVE AMERICANS WHO LOOK AT THIS AND QUESTION HOW CAN YOU LOVE A COUNTRY THAT HAS DONE THIS?
>> Haaland: FIRST OF ALL, MY ANCESTRAL HOME LANDS ARE HERE AND I CAN'T GO ANYWHERE ELSE.
THIS IS MY HOME AND THIS IS WHERE MY FAMILY IS.
THIS IS WHERE MY HISTORY IS.
WE HAVE BEEN HERE FOR 10'S OF THOUSANDS OF YEARS AND WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE ARE DEFENDING THIS LAND FOR FUTURE GENERATIONS.
>> Host: SECRETARY OF INTERIOR, DEB HAALAND THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
>> Gene: WE ARE ALL UNITED.
IN ALBUQUERQUE THAT MIGHT BE ESPECIALLY TRUE IF VOTERS IN NOVEMBER APPROVE A PROPOSED BOND FOR A SOCCER STADIUM.
THAT WHILE IT WILL BE BUILT AS A MULTI-USE STADIUM, WILL MOST NOTABLY BE USED AS A HOME FOR THE CITY'S SUCCESSFUL PROFESSIONAL SOCCER TEAM, NEW MEXICO UNITED.
MAYOR TIM KELLER AND TEAM OWNER PETER TREVISANI MADE THE ANNOUNCEMENT AT LAST WEEKEND'S GAME AGAINST EL PASO.
KRISTELLE, I THINK YOU WERE THERE AND YOU'RE A HUGE SUPPORTER OF THE TEAM.
I HAVE GOT TO ASK YOU THIS RIGHT OFF THE TOP.
WE HAVE TO HAVE A CONVERSATION ABOUT THIS.
>> Dan: ASK HER IF SHE REMEMBERS EVEN BEING AT THE GAME.
>> Kristelle: I WAS NOT AT GAME, NO, NOT THAT TIME.
>> Gene: OKAY.
LET ME ASK YOU THIS KRISTELLE.
PUBLIC FINANCING.
IS THIS THE APPROPRIATE WAY TO GO ABOUT IT?
>> Kristelle: YES, I DO THINK PUBLIC FINANCING IS THE APPROPRIATE WAY TO DO THIS.
PEOPLE FORGET THAT SOME OF THE MAJOR EVENT CENTERS LIKE TINGLEY COLISEUM IS OWNED BY THE STATE OF NEW MEXICO AND RIO RANCHO, THAT ON A GOOD YEAR, ACCORDING TO THE MAYOR GOES NEGATIVE A MILLION DOLLARS IN TERMS OF LOSS.
MOST OF THE MAJOR EVENT CENTERS HERE IN TOWN IT IS A KEY PHRASE THAT YOU KNOW, YES, LEGISLATIVE USE AND POLITICIANS USE BUT REALLY IT IS BEST DEFINITION.
IT IS A PUBLIC AND PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP.
THAT IS THE CRITICAL PIECE THAT PEOPLE FORGET.
IS ALBUQUERQUE READY FOR ANOTHER MULTI-USE STADIUM?
ABSOLUTELY.
OUR ORGANIZATION AT SIARZA ALWAYS CONSTANTLY DOES EVENTS BEFORE THE PANDEMIC, OF COURSE, AND I CAN'T TELL YOU HOW MANY TIMES THERE IS AN EVENT GOING ON ALMOST EVERY DAMN WEEKEND HERE IN NEW MEXICO THAT IT CAN BE STATE-WIDE.
IT CAN BE LOCAL AND NEW MEXICO UNITED, NOT ALBUQUERQUE, NEW MEXICO UNITED, PURPOSEFULLY BRINGS THE ENTIRE STATE TOGETHER TO HELP BUILD AROUND THE COMMUNITY OF SOCCER.
IT WAS RON PATELL AND LAWRENCE ESPINOSA -- >> Gene: I DON'T WANT TO BE RUDE.
I HAVE GOT TO BUZZ TO FOLKS ON THE IDEA OF PUBLIC FINANCING.
I HEAR YOUR PR POINTS.
PUBLIC FINANCING, IS IT APPROPRIATE?
LET'S PUT IT THIS WAY, WE HAVE AN OWNERSHIP GROUP NOT WILLING TO RISK ANY OF THEIR OWN CAPITAL ON A STADIUM BUT YET AGAIN THEY ARE GOING TO CLEAN-UP ON SOME OF THE LARGESS OF THAT PARTNERSHIP.
IS THIS THE APPROPRIATE WAY TO GO?
>> Dede: I THINK IN THIS CASE IT IS.
I WOULD HAVE A DIFFERENT ANSWER IF WE ARE TALKING ABOUT THE DENVER BRONCOS AND SUBSIDIZING THE DENVER BRONCOS WITH A HUGE STADIUM AND THE BRONCOS THREATENING TO LEAVE THE CITY IF THEY DIDN'T GET THIS KIND OF PUBLIC FINANCING.
BUT, HAVING SAID THAT, YOU KNOW, THE CITY HAS TO BE CAUTIOUS.
THERE HAVE BEEN MANY PROPOSALS FOR DOWNTOWN STADIUMS, DATING BACK TO THE FESTIVAL MARKETPLACE AND MANY OTHERS AND, YOU KNOW, PUBLIC MONIES -- WE ARE TALKING HERE ABOUT 75 MILLION-DOLLARS TO CONSTRUCT THE STADIUM AND THEN THE TEAM WOULD RENT THE STADIUM FROM THE CITY WHICH WOULD FLOAT BONDS IN ORDER TO FINANCE IT.
THERE ARE A LOT OF IF'S AND'S OR BUT'S ABOUT THAT.
WHAT IF THE TEAM DOESN'T DO SO WELL ONE YEAR?
WILL THEY BE PAYING THEIR RENT?
WHERE DOES TICKET SALES PLAY IN THAT?
ARE THERE A CERTAIN AMOUNT OF THOSE THAT ARE GUARANTEED?
IN THIS CASE, I THINK THAT IT IS A GOOD BET AND WE NEED IT AT THIS TIME IN OUR CITY AND STATE'S HISTORY.
>> Gene: WHY?
>> Dede: THERE ARE VERY FEW THINGS THAT BRING US TOGETHER IN THE WAY THIS YOUNG, NEW TEAM AND SPORT HAS DONE.
>> Dan: DEDE IS A HOOLIGAN.
>> Gene: HOW BIG IS THE US?
THIS IS WHAT I WANT TO KNOW.
I HEAR THE WHOLE THING ABOUT STATE-WIDE AND WE AND US.
IS IT REALLY THAT BIG?
DAN, LET ME ASK YOU THIS OR IS THIS MORE ILLUSION BECAUSE THE TEAM IS NEW, IT IS EXCITING?
HOW BIG HONESTLY IS THIS FOR A 70 MILLION-DOLLAR STADIUM WHICH I MIGHT REMIND YOU, I'LL REMIND EVERYBODY, WE ARE TALKING ABOUT LESS THAN 20 HOME GAMES A YEAR.
LESS THAN 20.
OKAY?
SO, 70 MILLION-DOLLARS, LET'S THINK ABOUT THIS.
BACK TO MY QUESTION.
>> Dan: SO THE FIRST THING, LET ME SAY THIS.
I'LL APPLAUD WHAT THEY ARE DOING FROM THE STANDPOINT OF PUTTING IT TO THE VOTERS.
THIS IS NOT BEING DONE IN A BACK-ROOM DEAL AND WE ARE FINDING OUT.
VOTERS ARE GOING TO DECIDE.
THAT IS THE GREATEST FORM OF DEMOCRACY WE HAVE.
IF VOTERS OF THIS CITY THINK IT IS SO, HOW DO I THINK IT AFFECTS NEW MEXICO?
I THINK YOU'RE LOOKING AT IT FROM ONE LENS WHICH IS NOT WRONG, EVEN THOUGH YOU'RE WRONG MOST OF THE TIME, THIS ONE YOU'RE NOT.
IT IS FROM THE STANDPOINT OF THAT PEOPLE TRAVELING FROM OUT OF THE CITY, RIGHT, COMING TO BUY TICKETS, SUPPORTING NEW MEXICO UNITED, BUT I THINK THAT IT IS A STATE TEAM BECAUSE THEY ARE ON A STAGE.
THEY ARE WALKING AROUND WITH THE NAME NEW MEXICO UNITED, NOT ALBUQUERQUE UNITED.
SO IT GIVES THE OPPORTUNITY FOR THERE TO BE A STATE BUY-IN.
I THINK THAT THE OTHER THING THAT I DO THINK IS GOOD ABOUT SOCCER IS, LOOK, THESE GUYS CAN START WINNING AND GO ON A STREAK AND KEEP MOVING UP IN CLASSES AND YOU COULD WIND UP WITH AN MSL SOCCER TEAM FOR NOT A LOT OF MONEY.
>> Gene: THAT IS PART OF THE PLAY TO BUILD A STADIUM.
FIRST, LET ME ASK KRISTELLE.
>> Dan: THE STADIUM CAN BE USED BY MORE AND DON'T FORGET OUR DISCOUNT THAT I AM A FOOTBALL FAN.
DON'T DISCOUNT THE FACT WE HAVE HAD A PRETTY GOOD SOCCER PROGRAM IN THE PAST AT UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO THAT PLAYED ON THE BACK OF A TRACK DEAL.
SO IF WE BRING BACK SOCCER AT UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO WHO WAS NATIONALLY RANKED AND GIVE THEM A FACILITY LIKE THIS, NOW YOU'RE HOSTING NCAA TOURNAMENTS.
SO, I SEE AN OPPORTUNITY FOR IT BUT I JUST WANTED TO POINT THAT OUT.
>> Gene: LET ME ASK YOU THIS.
TWO LOCATIONS, YOU HAVE THE PLAN THERE, I SAW IT ON YOUR LAP THERE A SECOND AGO.
YOU HAVE SECOND AND IRON, COAL AND BROADWAY.
IT HAS EVERYONE LIT UP WHEN YOU PICTURE IN YOUR MIND COAL AND BROADWAY.
THIS HAS TO GO BEFORE COUNCIL AND WHAT HAPPENS IF COUNCIL DECIDES TO TAKE A FREE MARKET APPROACH TO THIS AND SAY, OKAY, GUYS, UNITED HERE IS WHAT WE ARE GOING TO DO.
YOU DON'T WANT TO ASSUME ANY RISK.
YOU DON'T GET TO PICK WHERE IT IS GOING TO BE BUT YOU ALSO DON'T GET TO OPEN WHAT WE KNOW YOU'RE GOING TO DO IS A SNAZZY GIANT NEW UNITED BAR LIKE THIS GIANT THING THAT IS ON THE SITE, GUARANTEED TO HAPPEN, BECAUSE MR. TREVISANI SAYS HE WANTS TO BE IN THE DEVELOPMENT SIDE OF THIS THING AS WELL.
WHAT HAPPENS IF COUNCIL SAYS, YOU KNOW WHAT GUYS, IF YOU SAY THIS IS GOING TO REVITALIZE DOWNTOWN, WHY DON'T YOU PUT YOUR BIG NEW BAR DOWNTOWN AND WE WILL LET -- WE'LL LET THAT BE THE END OF THE RAINBOW DOWN THERE?
YOU'RE NOT PUTTING ANY MONEY INTO THIS THING.
>> Kristelle: YEAH.
I WOULD IMAGINE IF CITY COUNCIL SAID NO OR HAD ANY TYPE OF HESITATION, YOU BET THAT THE SUPPORTERS OUT THERE, THAT HAVE NO OUNCE OF EXPERIENCE WHATSOEVER IN POLITICS, ARE GOING TO BE SHOWING UP IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS WITHOUT A DEBT.
REMEMBER THAT WHAT MAKES A TEAM A TEAM, WHAT MAKES A FRANCHISE A FRANCHISE, IS THE FANS.
THE FACT THAT IT WAS A GREAT IDEA FOR THEM TO PUT MAYOR KELLER AND PETER ON THE BACK OF A TRUCK, NOT IN A PRESS CONFERENCE, THEY PUT THEM IN THE HEART OF THE FANS TO CHEER ON FOR THIS PROJECT.
>> Gene: WHY IS THAT A GREAT IDEA?
>> Kristelle: BECAUSE OF THE PR OPPORTUNITIES, OBVIOUSLY.
BECAUSE ESPECIALLY WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT WHENEVER CAMPAIGN MANAGERS, WHATEVER IT IS, THEY NEED TO SHOW THERE IS A SUPPORTER BASE AND NEED TO SHOW THERE IS A GROUP OF STAKEHOLDERS IN FAVOR OF A CERTAIN PROJECT.
BASIC TO POLITICS.
THEY ALREADY HAVE ONE BUILT IN AND THERE IS A LOT OF THEM IN THAT SUPPORTER SECTION THAT SITS IN SECTION 201 AND 202 EVERY SINGLE GAME APRIL.
AT LEAST 500 PEOPLE EASILY AND THAT IS WHY THE STADIUM IS SO UNIQUE BECAUSE IT ACTUALLY DOES A BIGGER CAPACITY FOR STADIUMS BECAUSE -- FOR THE SUPPORTER SECTION IN THE STADIUM AND THE SUPPORTER SECTION -- I KNOW I AM SOUNDING LIKE SUCH A FAN GIRL RIGHT NOW -- BUT SUPPORTER SECTIONS ARE GOING TO BE THE PEOPLE THAT DRIVE THE REVENUE.
>> Gene: I HEAR NOTHING IN YOUR RAP THAT SUPPORTS THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND THEIR NEEDS.
IT IS ALL ABOUT THE FANS.
ALL RIGHT.
ADMINISTRATION SAYS AUGUST 2 MEETING WILL HAVE A COMPREHENSIVE LOOK AT THE CITY'S PROPOSAL FOR TAXPAYER FUNDING.
WE ARE GOING TO CHECK IT OUT WHEN THAT HAPPENS.
THANKS TO ALL THE PANELISTS FOR THEIR WORK THIS WEEK.
BE SURE TO HEAD TO OUR FACEBOOK PAGE FOR MORE DISCUSSION FROM THE GROUP INCLUDING INITIAL REACTIONS TO SURPRISE NEWS THIS WEEK THAT INVESTIGATORS FROM THE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S OFFICE RAIDED THE HOME OF LONG TIME MAJORITY FLOOR LEADER SHERYL WILLIAMS STAPLETON.
>> Matt: I AM MATT GRUBS.
FOR YEARS, NEW MEXICO HAS HAD THE NATION'S HIGHEST PROPORTION OF PHYSICIANS AGED 60 OR OLDER.
THE STATE'S RURAL NATURE AND WIDE OPEN SPACES, SOMETHING WE HAVE ALL GROWN TO LOVE AND APPRECIATE, HAS BEEN A TOUGH SELL FOR NEW DOCTORS AND WHEN RESIDENCIES ENDED THIS SPRING FOR UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO, 15 FAMILY MEDICINE PHYSICIANS WERE RESIDENTS AND 13 OF THEM CHOSE TO STAY.
THAT DOESN'T MEAN THE GAP IS CLOSED.
THAT DOESN'T MEAN THE PROBLEM IS SOLVED BUT THIS IS A BIG STEP.
DR. MOLLY MCCLAIN AND ARTHUR KAUFMAN ARE WITH THE HEALTH SCIENCES CENTER AND MEDICAL SCHOOL AND JOINING US BY ZOOM IS DR. DARSHAN PATEL, WHO WILL BE PRACTICING AT THE END OF AUGUST IN LOVINGTON.
THANK YOU ALL FOR BEING HERE.
WHY DON'T WE JUST START WITH A VERY GENERAL QUESTION.
IS THERE SORT OF A SECRET SAUCE TO GET A RESULT LIKE THIS WITH A CLASS OF PHYSICIANS TO GET SO MANY PEOPLE -- WE SHOULD POINT OUT NOT ALL OF THEM ARE FROM NEW MEXICO -- TO STAY IN STATE, SOMETHING WE REALLY NEED?
>> McCLAIN: I THINK THERE IS A SECRET SAUCE AND I THINK MANY PEOPLE HAVE BEEN WORKING ON THIS FOR MANY YEARS.
HISTORICALLY LOOKING BACK TO 2011 ABOUT 65 TO 70% OF GRADUATES DO TEND TO STAY AND 25% HISTORICALLY HAVE GONE RURAL.
WHAT MAKES THIS YEAR SO SPECIAL IS 87% STAYED AND ABOUT 62% ENDED UP GOING RURAL.
I THINK OVER THE PAST SEVEN YEARS OUR PREVIOUS PROGRAM DIRECTOR DAN WALDMAN DID A LOT OF WORK THINKING ABOUT HOW DO YOU MATCH PEOPLES' INTERESTS WHO ARE COMING WITH A MISSION OF OUR HOSPITAL AND OUR PROGRAM.
AND I THINK HE SAW A LOT ABOUT THAT AND DID AN EXCELLENT JOB FIGURING OUT WHAT KIND OF CRITERIA TO LOOK FOR TO MAKE SURE FOLKS ARE INTERESTED IN UNDERSERVED COMMUNITIES, STAYING IN NEW MEXICO AND GOING TO A RURAL LOCATION.
I THINK THE RURAL PIECE THIS YEAR WAS PARTICULARLY POWERFUL AND HAS BEEN VARIABLE OVER THE PAST YEARS AND SO DR. WALDMAN, DR. KAUFMAN WAS INVOLVED, TOO, REALLY INSTEAD OF FOCUSING ON AN URBAN RESIDENCY, CREATING A RURAL RESIDENCY SO THEY HAVE CREATED A RURAL RESIDENCY AT IHS AT SHIPROCK.
FIRST IHS RESIDENCY EVER.
THEY ARE RECRUITING FIRST CLASS THIS YEAR AND SO THERE IS A LOT MORE GOING ON THAT JUST AT UNMH IN TERMS OF MAKING SURE PEOPLE STAY IN NEW MEXICO AND GO TO RURAL NEW MEXICO AS WELL.
>> Matt: IHS BEING INDIAN HEALTH SERVICE.
THAT IS PRETTY REMARKABLE.
DR. PATEL, WHEN YOU WERE LOOKING AT PLACES WHERE YOU WOULD LIKE TO BE A RESIDENT, WHAT DREW YOU TO THIS PROGRAM?
DID SOME OF THAT STUFF DR. MCCLAIN WAS TALKING ABOUT PLAY INTO YOUR CHOICE?
>> Patel: CERTAINLY.
I GREW UP HERE IN ALBUQUERQUE AND IT WAS REALLY IMPORTANT TO ME TO TRAIN WHERE I CALL HOME AND START WITH A COMMUNITY THAT HELPED ME WHEN I WAS BEING RAISED.
SO, YOU KNOW, IT WAS A PRIVILEGE TO BE ABLE TO BE PART OF THE UNM FAMILY MEDICINE RESIDENCY PROGRAM.
AND I THINK THE COLLEAGUES AND MENTORS THAT I WAS ABLE TO WORK WITH REALLY HELPED SHAPE MY DECISION TO SERVE THE RURAL COMMUNITIES IN NEW MEXICO.
>> Matt: THAT IS SOMETHING THAT STRIKES ME AS POTENTIALLY BEING A CHANGE IN THE WAY RESIDENTS ARE THINKING ABOUT HOW THEY WANT TO SERVE.
I KNOW THAT WORKING IN A BIG HOSPITAL, IN A BIG CITY WITH LOTS OF AMENITIES MIGHT BE ATTRACTIVE BUT IT SOUNDS LIKE RESIDENTS ARE THINKING A LITTLE BIT DIFFERENTLY HOW THEY WANT TO START THEIR MEDICAL CAREERS.
>> Patel: RIGHT, IN FAMILY MEDICINE WE ARE TRAINED TO BE GENERALISTS AND WE RECOGNIZE THAT OUR SKILLS ARE NEEDED AND ALSO SOMETIMES BEST SERVED IN RURAL AREAS WHERE ACCESS TO RESOURCES MIGHT BE LIMITED.
EVEN MORE LIMITED THAN IN ALBUQUERQUE.
SO, THROUGH THE ROBUST TRAINING PROCESS PROVIDED BY OUR RESIDENCY PROGRAM, I THINK MY COLLEAGUES AND I REALIZE WE WOULD BE ABLE TO KIND OF STEP INTO FILLING NEEDS OUTSIDE OF ALBUQUERQUE.
>> Matt: DR. ARTHUR KAUFMAN, YOU HAVE HAD A LONG HISTORY WITH THIS PROGRAM.
DOCTORS AND THEIR PARTNERS AS THEY LOOK AT PLACES THEY WANT TO LIVE AND BEGIN THEIR CAREER, I KNOW THEY CAN FEEL ISOLATED, NOT JUST GEOGRAPHICALLY BUT SOCIALLY.
HOW DO YOU ADDRESS SOME OF THOSE NEEDS THAT EVERYONE HAS BUT THAT MIGHT BE PARTICULARLY DIFFICULT FOR DOCTORS?
>> Kaufman: I THINK YOU HAVE TO CREATE AN ENVIRONMENT IN SMALLER COMMUNITIES WHICH NOT JUST REPLICATE WHAT WE HAVE IN URBAN AREAS BUT GOES BEYOND IT IN MANY WAYS.
SMALLER COMMUNITIES ARE VERY SUPPORTIVE OF EACH OTHER AND SOMETIMES IN LARGE COMMUNITIES PEOPLE FEEL ANONYMOUS AND LONELY.
BUT THE SMALLER COMMUNITIES EVERYONE KNOWS EACH OTHER AND IT IS VERY ATTRACTIVE ESPECIALLY TO PEOPLE WHO HAVE NEVER SEEN THAT BEFORE SO THAT WE CREATED, FOR EXAMPLE, WHERE DR. PATEL IS GOING, CREATED A LOVINGTON AND HOBBS ALMOST AS A LEARNING DESTINATION.
STUDENTS, RESIDENTS, OTHERS ARE ALL GOING THERE SO THEY ARE NOT ISOLATED, THEY ARE PART OF A LARGER COMMUNITY AND THE UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO IS INVESTING IN DECENTRALIZING OUR RESOURCES NOT JUST IN FAMILY MEDICINE BUT IN NURSING, PHARMACY, PHYSICAL THERAPY SO THERE IS A WHOLE COMMUNITY THAT SUPPORTS EACH ONE OF THOSE PRACTITIONERS.
>> Matt: IN THE PAST WOULD A RESIDENCY WITH FAMILY AND COMMUNITY MEDICINE, WOULD THAT HAVE TAKEN PLACE PRIMARILY AT UNMH AT THE HOSPITAL HERE IN ALBUQUERQUE?
>> Kaufman: ALMOST ALL TRAINING TRADITIONALLY IS IN LARGE ACADEMIC HEALTH CENTERS AND LARGE CITIES.
BECAUSE THE INCENTIVES WERE THERE BUT NOW ESPECIALLY WITH THE LEADERSHIP IN OUR STATE, WE ARE DEVELOPING MODELS WITH PARTNER COMMUNITY HOSPITALS, PARTNER COMMUNITY HEALTH CENTERS AND STATE GOVERNMENT TO SHIFT THAT WHERE RESOURCES ARE GOING TO COMMUNITIES TO HIRE AND TRAIN RESIDENTS.
THAT MAKES ALL THE DIFFERENCE IN THE WORLD.
I USED TO WORK AT THE INDIAN HEALTH SERVICE.
IT CHANGED MY LIFE.
I SAW THE WORLD IN A DIFFERENT WAY.
WE HAVE TO GIVE OUR RESIDENTS COMMUNITY EXPERIENCES WHICH CHANGE ATTITUDES AND WHERE THOSE COMMUNITIES BECOME FAR MORE ATTRACTIVE THAN WHAT THEY CAN DO IN A LARGE URBAN CENTER.
>> Matt: DR. MCCLAIN, ARE RESIDENTS OR PERSPECTIVE RESIDENTS ARE THEY RESPONDING TO THIS TYPE OF A PROGRAM?
>> McClain: IT IS AMAZING.
I THINK UNM HAS BEEN A LEADER IN CREATING FAMILY MEDICINE DOCTORS FOR QUITE SOME TIME.
WE HAVE A VERY STRONG PROGRAM AND BECAUSE WE HAVE SUCH EXCELLENT RESIDENTS THAT COME THEY ARE ALSO GOOD AT HELPING MEDICAL STUDENTS SEEING HOW POWERFUL FAMILY MEDICINE IS AND IT IS AMAZING TO WORK WITH BUT YOU DON'T HAVE TO DO A LOT OF WORK.
WE ATTRACT THESE RESIDENTS AND THEN THE RESIDENTS KIND OF DO THAT WONDERFUL WORK FOR THEMSELVES AND I THINK THEY HAVE JUST DONE AN AMAZING JOB.
THEY COME IN PASSIONATE TO WORK FOR UNDERSERVED COMMUNITIES AND THEY DEDICATE THEIR ENERGY AND TIME AND THEIR FUTURES TO DOING THAT AND I THAT WE JUST DID -- WE DON'T CREATE THAT IN THE RESIDENCY PROGRAM.
WE JUST FACILITATE THE EDUCATION THEY KIND OF WANT.
AND SO I THINK IT SEEMS LIKE THE MEDICAL -- FUTURE OF MEDICINE REALLY IS, I THINK, MIRRORED IN OUR RESIDENTS AND I THINK THE MEDICAL STUDENTS WE WORK WITH, THEIR DRIVE IS TO SERVE UNDERSERVED, GO RURAL, DO ALL THE THINGS THAT FAMILY MEDICINE DOCTORS CAN DO THAT OTHER SPECIALTIES CAN'T DO.
IT IS EXCITING TO BE A PART OF IT AND BE ABLE TO FACILITATE THAT.
>> Matt: DR. PATEL, YOU ARE ONE OF THE FEW PEOPLE IN THE PROGRAM WHO ACTUALLY IS FROM NEW MEXICO AND CHOSE TO STAY HERE.
SOUNDS LIKE MOST OF THE FOLKS, AT LEAST IN THIS CLASS, WHO CHOSE TO STAY HERE WEREN'T FROM HERE.
HAVE YOU DISCUSSED THOSE CHOICES TO STAY IN NEW MEXICO AND WORK IN RURAL HOSPITALS WITH ANY OF YOUR CLASSMATES OR FOLKS IN THAT RESIDENCY CLASS?
>> Patel: YES.
I MEAN, I THINK WE HAVE ROBUST OPPORTUNITIES TO TRAIN IN RURAL SITES THROUGHOUT OUR RESIDENCY PROGRAM AND THAT ALLOWS PEOPLE WHO AREN'T FAMILIAR WITH THE RURAL COMMUNITIES OF NEW MEXICO TO ACTUALLY HAVE STRONG TRAINING OPPORTUNITIES WHILE THEY ARE COMPLETING A RESIDENCY PROGRAM.
AND SO, YOU KNOW, I THINK THAT WAS A REALLY IMPORTANT PART OF HAVING PEOPLE DECIDE TO GO RURAL BUT IT IS TRUE, WE ARE COMPETING NATIONALLY FOR RESIDENTS TO COME TO NEW MEXICO.
WE KNOW THAT PEOPLE WHO TRAIN IN NEW MEXICO WILL STAY, STATISTICALLY HAVE A HIGHER LIKELIHOOD OF STAYING.
SO, I THINK, WE NEED TO RECOGNIZE AS A STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO NEEDS TO ATTRACT RESIDENTS SO THAT WE CAN CONVINCE THEM TO STAY AFTER THEY ARE DONE WITH THEIR TRAINING.
>> Matt: HAVING A CHANCE TO WORK IN A RURAL HOSPITAL OR RURAL MEDICAL SETTING PRIOR TO ACTUALLY TAKING A JOB IN A PLACE LIKE LOVINGTON, HOW DID THAT PLAY INTO YOUR EDUCATION AND EXCITEMENT FOR HEADING OUT INTO SORT OF THE WILDS OF NEW MEXICO, AT LEAST AS FOLKS FROM MAYBE ALBUQUERQUE, SANTA FE AND LAS CRUCES SEE IT?
>> Patel: WELL, YOU KNOW, I THINK EVEN THOUGH WE ARE PRIMARILY SERVING PATIENTS IN ALBUQUERQUE MANY PATIENTS HAVE FOOTPRINTS IN RURAL AREAS.
YOU KNOW, YOU CAN BE RURAL VERY QUICKLY EVEN IF YOU LIVE IN ALBUQUERQUE, SANTA FE AREA.
SO, MY CONTINUITY CLINIC SITE, FOR EXAMPLE, WAS IN ALBUQUERQUE INDIAN HEALTH CENTER WHICH IS AN IHS FACILITY AND MANY MOVE PATIENTS WERE TRAVELING MANY, MANY MILES, HOURS TO COME TO SEE THEIR PROVIDER HERE IN ALBUQUERQUE.
SO, I THINK EVEN IF YOU ARE PRACTICING IN ALBUQUERQUE, YOU RECOGNIZE THAT OUR STATE IS VERY RURAL AND I THINK BEING A FAMILY MEDICINE PHYSICIAN WE RECOGNIZE THAT EVEN THOUGH WE SERVE PATIENTS IN ALBUQUERQUE, NEEDS ARE EVEN GREATER OUTSIDE OF THE CITY.
>> Matt: SURE.
AS YOU LOOK AT THE FUTURE OF THIS PROGRAM, DO YOU FEEL LIKE THE FUTURE IS OF A MORE DECENTRALIZED MODEL?
>> Kaufman: YES, I THINK THE MODEL THAT DR. PATEL AND DR. MCCLAIN ARE DEVELOPING REALLY DEMONSTRATES A HUGE CHANGE IN OUR THINKING ABOUT TRAINING.
BECAUSE, IT HAS TO BE DRIVEN BY COMMUNITY NEED NOT NECESSARILY BIG CITY HOSPITAL NEED.
AND ONE OF THE DATA FRAGMENTS THAT IS IMPORTANT IS THAT IF YOU CAN LOCATE A GRADUATE PHYSICIAN IN A RURAL COMMUNITY, THAT PHYSICIAN GENERATES ABOUT A MILLION DOLLARS IN BUSINESS FOR THAT COMMUNITY.
IT SUSTAINS RURAL HOSPITALS, IT BRINGS JOBS TO THAT COMMUNITY, RAISES THE TAX BASE.
THERE IS A HUGE ECONOMIC IMPACT AND THAT IS WHY THERE IS SO MUCH INTEREST IN THIS KIND OF PROGRAM.
GRADUATE EDUCATION IS NOT JUST FOR A FEW DOCTORS.
IT IS THE IMPACT ON COMMUNITY HEALTH THAT IS SO IMPORTANT.
>> Matt: DO YOU GET THAT WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE PLACES TO PUT YOUR RESIDENTS, YOU KNOW, IN RURAL COMMUNITIES?
DO YOU HEAR FROM NOT JUST THE HOSPITALS AND CLINICS BUT, YOU KNOW, FROM THE MAYORS, COUNCIL AND THINGS LIKE THAT?
>> McCLAIN: THAT IS ONE OF THE BIGGEST DRAWS.
WE HAVE A REQUIRED RURAL ROTATION FOR ALL OF OUR RESIDENTS AND WE HAVE RELATIONSHIPS REALLY STRONG AND IMPORTANT RELATIONSHIPS WITH THE INDIAN HEALTH SERVICE AT ZUNI, SHIPROCK.
WE HAVE SITES AT GALLUP AND THERE ARE A NUMBER OF RESIDENCY PROGRAMS AT RURAL SITES, SILVER CITY.
SANTA FE IS STILL CONSIDERED RURAL ALTHOUGH I THINK THAT IS KIND OF FUNNY AND WE WORK CLOSELY WITH THEM AS WELL.
WHAT HAPPENS IS RESIDENTS GO TO THE SITES AND SEE WHAT IT FEELS LIKE TO BE A RURAL PHYSICIAN AND SEE HOW -- WHAT AN IMPORTANT BUT ALSO PARTNER ROLE THEY PLAY WITH THE COMMUNITY, THAT IT IS NOT JUST A DOCTOR BEING IN CLINIC, SEEING PATIENTS AND HAVING KIND OF ISOLATED FROM THAT RELATIONAL PIECE.
THEY GO INTO THE COMMUNITY AND I HAD THAT SAME EXPERIENCE AT SHIPROCK, YOU GO INTO A COMMUNITY, AND JUST LIKE WHAT DR. KAUFMAN WAS SAYING, IT FEELS COMPLETELY DIFFERENT AND FEELS MORE POWERFUL IN TERMS OF THE RELATIONAL PIECE WHICH IS SO IMPORTANT FOR FAMILY MEDICINE.
PRIMARY CARE IS ABOUT RELATIONSHIPS AND ABOUT BUILDING CONNECTION WITH PEOPLE.
AND I THINK IF YOU HAVE CAPACITY TO DO THAT IN A COMMUNITY SETTING IT FEELS LIKE SO MANY OF US FEEL THAT IS WHAT FAMILY MEDICINE IS ALL ABOUT AND THOSE RURAL ROTATIONS ARE JUST SO IMPORTANT FOR THAT EXPERIENCE THAT WE MAY NEVER HAVE HAD BEFORE AND I THINK THAT MAY HAVE A LARGE PART IN WHY WE HAD RESIDENTS LIKE CLAMORING TO GET TO ZUNI WHEN THEY GRADUATED, CLAMORING TO GET TO SHIPROCK.
WE HAVE TWO FOLKS GOING TO GALLUP.
WE HAVE TWO FOLKS GOING TO SANTA ROSA.
THEY HAD THAT EXPERIENCE IN THE RURAL SETTING THAT THEY DON'T GET IN A MORE URBAN SETTING AND I THINK THAT HAD A LOT TO DO WITH WHY THEY STAYED.
>> Matt: IT'S AN ENCOURAGING RESULT AND THANK YOU ALL FOR THE TIME YOU SPENT THINKING ABOUT IT AND THE TIME YOU SPENT TALKING WITH US ABOUT IT.
THANKS FOR YOUR WORK, WE APPRECIATE IT.
>> Gene: I HAVE A QUESTION, ARE YOU HONESTLY ALL THAT SHOCKED WE ARE BACK WHERE WE ARE ON MASK USAGE?
NOT IN THAT, I TOLD YOU SO, KIND OF WAY BUT MORE OF A CONFIRMATION, NO, WE ARE PAST NOTHING AND NEVER WERE.
I AM INTERESTED ALSO IN WATCHING THE POLITICAL CALCULUS AT THIS POINT.
WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT IT, NO GOVERNOR HAS TRULY WON OR LOST THE COVID FIGHT.
IT IS JUST A NEW PHASE.
WHICH MEANS EACH GOVERNOR IS GOING TO BE MANAGING THIS COVID FIGHT AND CORRESPONDING CRITICISM FOR THOSE DECISION THEY HAVE TO MAKE RIGHT UP TO ELECTION SEASON AND POSSIBLY RIGHT UP TO ELECTION DAY.
FOR NOW IT IS BACK TO THE FIGHT.
YOU DIDN'T THINK THIS WAS GOING TO BE A ONE-ROUND KNOCKDOWN, DID YOU?
NO WAY.
THANKS FOR JOINING US AND STAYING INFORMED AND ENGAGED.
SEE YOU AGAIN NEXT WEEK, IN FOCUS.

- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.

- News and Public Affairs

FRONTLINE is investigative journalism that questions, explains and changes our world.












Support for PBS provided by:
New Mexico In Focus is a local public television program presented by NMPBS