The Follow Up
Democratic Socialism Explained | 11/10/26
Season 10 Episode 6 | 27m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
What is democratic socialism and how does it differ from capitalism as we know it?
The midterm Blue Wave also brought a wave of elected democratic socialists. What is democratic socialism and how does it differ from capitalism as we know it? Guests: Michael LaFaive - Mackinac Center for Public Policy; Dr. Zachary Cohle - Saginaw Valley State University.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
The Follow Up is a local public television program presented by Delta Public Media
The Follow Up
Democratic Socialism Explained | 11/10/26
Season 10 Episode 6 | 27m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
The midterm Blue Wave also brought a wave of elected democratic socialists. What is democratic socialism and how does it differ from capitalism as we know it? Guests: Michael LaFaive - Mackinac Center for Public Policy; Dr. Zachary Cohle - Saginaw Valley State University.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch The Follow Up
The Follow Up is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipLocal production scene on Delta College Public Media.
are made possible with support from viewers like you.
Thank you.
I'm Mike Redford, and this is the Follow Up coming up on this edition of the show.
The blue wave of Democratic wins in the midterms has rocked the nation's political landscape, featuring a lot of new faces from the far left who are pushing a democratic socialist agenda.
Is this just a passing fad, or a growing trend where socialism may push capitalism out of the picture in America in time?
What would it look like?
What will it cost you?
Or is this just an overreaction to the midterms?
A robust discussion on socialism versus capitalism is next on the Follow Up.
But first, I don't forget.
You can join the discussion on the Follow Up on our social media platforms, and you can also engage with us through our website at Delta Public media.org.
That's where you can also watch any of our past shows this season.
Guest.
Tonight, both in studio.
As you can see we have Michael LaFaive.
He is senior director with the Morey Fiscal Policy Initiative, with the Mackinac Center for Public Policy, and a familiar face on the program, as well as Zachary Cohle, associate professor of economics with the Scott L. Carmona College of Business at Saginaw Valley State University.
Nice to have you both.
Do frame up the conversation.
I think it's important for us to maybe sort of define social socialism, as you see it, in sort of the current culture coming off the midterms as driven by sort of the DSA, the Democratic Socialists of America, because this isn't one size fits all right, and not sort of the Eastern European model that that many of us may identify as socialists.
And Michael wants to start us off.
Yeah.
There's a wide spectrum of what some people consider socialism.
32% of the voting population has no recollection of the Cold War and socialism in Eastern Europe and in Asia, and it's by definition in a dictionary definition.
Socialism is when the government controls the means of production, distribution and exchange in its most extreme form, say in Cambodia during the Khmer Rouge socialism, their version of it was imposed at the point of a gun, and it led to famine and and deaths from murders.
It's a terrible 20th century, but I don't think the people who went to the polls actually were thinking of that type of socialism when they went to vote for their candidates.
They may have been thinking of the Democratic Socialists of America and their official platform.
Right.
And they may have just been in favor of a more progressive, larger government.
Many progressives are very comfortable with a larger, more robust government at the federal and even state levels without necessarily embracing property confiscation or taking over an entire industry.
There are gradations, right?
Zach...Would you buy into some of that?
What would your take on what we're seeing, particularly with the Democratic Socialists of America and their movement?
What do you think that might look like?
And we'll look at some things later in the show.
But just out of the gate here, you know, I think the term socialism as it's being used by the Democrats, I think that is a passing fad.
I think that's being used as a way to galvanize a lot of the support for particularly health care reform, which has been something that has been tried for decades now in the United States.
And it is something that a lot of us are feeling the hurt from, you know, the money taken out of our paychecks for insurance.
And, you know, if we don't have insurance, paying prices that are extremely inflated for basic medical procedures, I think that is what's kind of underlying the socialism wave that we're seeing.
But as Michael said, I think socialism comes in a lot of different varieties.
And what we're looking at here isn't really a lot of a heavy socialism, at least one that you have to have strictly enforced at the end of a gun.
I think what we're really talking about is a little bit of market reformation.
And in that sense, I actually think that the Democratic Party is pushing a capitalist agenda more so than the Republican Party at this point, which is a fun little reversal of how they're perceived.
Absolutely.
I look at the I look at the statements that have been made and the the goals, and I would I would think that a lot of the problems that they're trying to address with government have actually been caused by the government.
If you look at Mark Perry's chart of the century called that by somebody else, he tracks industry prices over 25 years.
And not coincidentally, I think that the prices that have skyrocketed the most are those that where the government interferes the most in the marketplace, whereas products like software, televisions, you know, basically consumer goods that have less government control.
You've seen a decline in prices, including the decline in the hours needed to purchase such goods.
So Zachary, in your talking points that we kind of went over before you had said something, this the effect that you would say that capitalism requires some degree of socialism.
Right.
It does the function.
So it kind of expand on that a little bit.
Right?
Yeah, yeah.
So capitalism very different than socialism in the sense that we like to own or the fruits of our labor.
So capitalism is all about going in, and competing in the marketplace.
And through that competition we get innovation, we get lower prices, we get better quality goods.
The problem with a lot of markets, though, if you just let them go in this laissez faire way, then they start spinning out and destabilizing and they become anti-competitive.
So you get these clumping effects going on.
We have an you have a single firm ruling an entire market.
Look at, say, the merger that happened recently between, Warner Brothers and Paramount.
That was a huge effect that's going to have anti-competitive forces on the entire market within that industry.
But that's the role of the government, really, is to prevent anti-competitive behavior and to keep that competitive market so that the forces can interact and do what they do best, right, as well as to protect against force and fraud.
So we have a mixed capitalist economy right now.
I don't think we've had a pure laissez faire economy since the 1880s.
Thomas Cooley was a was a Supreme Court justice.
But what we have right now is already mixed, and we still suffer from distortions in the marketplace not only caused by government, but caused by the cozy relationships between business and government.
All too often, regulators who are meant to do some good with, you know, preventing force and fraud and this clumping and the monopolies often get captured by the very people that the regulation is meant for.
So we do have a mixed capitalist economy.
I think there are areas where we could have more market, but we still need an adjudicator of contracts, protector of property rights to facilitate more market capitalism.
Absolutely.
Yeah.
I couldn't agree more.
And in fact, that's an area where capitalism kind of fails, is you can go through systems around capitalism to enforce a, a less capitalistic environment.
So capturing regulators, for example, right.
And facilitating crony capitalism.
Absolutely.
So you have, you know, just in Michigan.
Michigan Economic Development Corporation spent billions of dollars trying to subsidize our way to prosperity.
And yet, Michigan's, you know, GDP growth is fairly anemic, right?
I like where you're going because at the beginning of the show, we talked about how do we sort of define this democratic socialist agenda?
Not one size fits all.
I guess it's the same with capitalism, right?
It's not just one form of capitalism.
There are different models.
Sometimes it's a bit mixed as well.
Right.
Right.
Absolutely.
And at different levels of government, federal, the federal government.
And then states have their own, you know, their laboratories of democracy.
They experiment with their own policies, some more interventionist than others.
And even at the metropolitan statistical level with local governments.
So there is a wide variety, and scholars have tried to measure the impact of these wide variety of policies on various outcomes I think we would all care about.
Yeah.
So what is history telling us as socialism, whatever form it's in.
Has it stood the test of time elsewhere?
A little bit in Europe?
I mean, there are different models.
We talked about this before hand.
The Nordic countries, for instance, Norway, Finland, Denmark, Sweden, another one that's doing something in the form of socialism.
And then you're looking at France with all the things that are happening there with the protests and the demonstrations.
They have what's called, I guess, a mixed market capitalism.
So they do have a welfare state a little bit, and they have every government intervention and they all have universal health care.
So love to have your thinking caps on as you see what's happening elsewhere.
And is it working for them in the forms that they are, whether it's the Nordic countries, whether it's France, you mentioned China, which some see as communist, but it's really more socialistic now.
So are we going to see, models like that in America morph over time?
Oh, do you want the first to be happy to take the the opening salvo here?
You know, I looked at statistics that recently came out of Europe itself, and they argued, they showed data that said America's poorest state, Mississippi, is wealthier than almost every European country.
Luxembourg does better.
Ireland does better.
Germany is currently doing better, but Mississippi is expecting to pass them.
So if that's the model we're looking to, I think we can look toward slower rates of real economic growth, which matter to positive outcomes.
As far as some of the Nordic countries, they're only slightly less capitalist than America.
There's a data set that I love to look at from Canada's, from the Fraser Institute, and it's been used to measure as a proxy economic freedom for 165 nations around the world.
And the Netherlands and Denmark are in the top ten freest economies in the in the world, according to the Fraser Institute.
That is pretty fascinating.
So again, I think it's good to look at that.
What's working, what's not working, what we can learn from that.
Right.
Yeah.
I think there's other statistics though to take a look at.
I think growth is an amazing thing.
As an economist I am pro growth.
I think we should be expanding our economic abilities than contracting them.
But I do think there is a case of happiness and there is the case of well.
Am I able to do the things I want to do?
I think if you pulled a lot of Americans today, you would say that the American dream is dead.
It's just too hard to move upwards in our system.
And because of that, the system doesn't seem to be serving a lot of Americans, at least as what we would want as a society for the system to have.
There have been 1400 academic studies published in peer reviewed journals from academics with no dog.
In our fight tonight, about a thousand of them using international data from the Fraser Institute, about 400 based on the provinces of Canada and the states.
And they've used this empirical data to look for associations between economic freedom and positive outcomes, including happiness and other quality of life issues that matter to people.
So the gradations, actually, you can measure differences between them and the resulting outcomes happiness, lower poverty rates among children, better environmental outcomes, at least internationally.
And and that list goes on.
It's a long one, right.
You know, the distribution of wealth gap has really been a talking point when you talk about affordability.
And I think American voters spoke loudly in the midterms that the gap and the question would become, if we move toward whether it's a mixed market of socialism and capitalism.
Could we move that the dial on the wealth gap?
Not overnight, but would that be a move in the better direction?
Because right now it's not going well?
Yeah, yeah, I think there is a lot of room for us to close that wealth gap.
I think that is possible.
It's going to take a lot of work.
It's going to take a lot of inspection of markets and markets that aren't working, because at the end of the day, people don't want handouts.
They want to be able to work, and they should be working and being paid what they're due.
So that's not happening in some industries.
We need to figure out why that's not happening and that's going to take some time.
But definitely with this, the sentiment that people are unhappy.
I think that that is going to carry politics for the next few years, to close that wealth gap and to make people happier at large.
Right.
That's a very good point.
I agree completely, I think closing the wealth gap, there's a number of things that need to change, whether that's at the federal government of the state level.
Greater economic opportunity that I've been talking about is one of those issues.
You look at state to state migration data, and people are immigrating to where there's more economic opportunity within the United States, Florida, Texas, the Carolinas, Tennessee.
It's not just the sunshine variable, it is the opportunity variable.
And that's important.
Another thing is, I think you recognize from the data that returns to education are still very positive.
And so, improving education, especially for the folks with the lowest in the lowest income quartiles, is absolutely vital to helping them earn their way up the dynamic income ladder.
You know, along that same vein, the underemployment for college graduates, very, very high right now, about 50% under employment.
Underemployment okay.
Different than unemployment.
And sense of you have a job.
You don't necessarily want that job.
You're working fast food when you have a bachelor's degree.
I think that's a real problem right now.
So yeah, returns to education are great.
I hope that they keep expanding personally because that is the industry that I found myself in.
But right now, I think there's a lot of people who are getting jobs and not seeing those returns.
And that's a huge problem.
It's either we are over expanding in terms of education, which I don't necessarily think is the case, or we are stagnant in a lot of the areas that we should be growing in that would normally absorb these college graduates.
I agree, economist Richard Vedder of Ohio University, now retired, once said, and this is probably 15, 20 years ago.
We have in America more college educated baristas than we do members of the U.S.
Army.
Yeah, and it's part of the reason it's because we've tried to subsidize it a number of ways, and it's led people to go to college and choose majors that they may not have otherwise chosen, had their price mechanism not been distorted.
So it's interesting you mentioned the migration specifically.
More and more people are moving, maybe because of economic opportunity, whether it's the southeast, southwest, but aren't people also moving because of more, I guess, liberal social issues?
A lot more people from California going to Texas.
You saw what happened in Texas with Talarico winning North Carolina, South Carolina.
They had some surprises down there.
And those folks are coming down from New York, New England.
So would you buy into that?
It's not just for economic benefits.
They're moving to places that are more, you know, responsive to their social views.
Well, I think social views are variables in the overall equation.
But I think that the measure of last week's election is not a vote in favor of a radical pendulum swing and economic policies necessarily.
That's one reason why I like to see this, you know, annual data of people voting with their feet instead of going to the polls because there's a revealed preference for a particular set of policies that are adopted in these variety of states.
And they keep moving.
And, you know, Michigan, only in the last year enjoyed a net positive increase in migration, 1800 people.
That's nothing.
We've been stuck at 10 million for a long time.
If we dive headlong into a more status and interventionist system, I think here in the Michigan level, our state model might need to change from if you seek a pleasant peninsula, look about you to if you seek a pleasant peninsula, move to Florida.
Yeah.
Wow, that's a lot.
So let's take a look at the DSA platform.
As we see at the Democratic Socialist America platform, we're going to show it to you guys and show it to the viewers on the screen.
So this is kind of what it looks like.
There it is.
A public ownership at least more of it.
Institute a 32 hour workweek, expand labor unions, provide universal health care, housing, education and childcare, canceling student debt, and implement a Green New Deal.
Which any of these items would you say will ever get passed in the next couple of years, or should pass, for that matter?
As you take a look at that list, what sticks out, what we'd what would we like to see?
You can't do all of it or any of it.
What do you make of that?
Well, I'll tell you right now, health care is a broken system.
Well, I'll tell you right now, health care is a broken system.
That's a market that is very much not participating within the market, the characteristics that we normally see.
So I think that needs to be addressed.
I think there's a ample amount of momentum to address it.
Everything else.
Very skeptical on maybe expanding labor unions 32 hour work week sounds great.
I think there's a lot of pushback against it, even though there's a lot of research saying that you can be overstressed at work and that messes up the productivity.
So 32 hours isn't just based on nothing.
There is actually a good amount of of literature out there that says 32 hours is the optimum productivity level that says 32 hours is the optimum productivity level for a worker.
We certainly need a lot more in terms of affordable housing, and we also need a little help in the childcare, the cost of daycare.
Zachary, you've got a little baby.
You know what that's about.
Yeah, I have grandkids and the cost of daycare is ridiculou So I think we definitely need some help there.
Go ahead.
I was just going to say childcare is one of the areas I was just going to say childcare is one of the areas of the areas of spending where the government plays a heavy role.
And you can see on Mark Perry's chart of the century that childcare escalates very dramatically and probably as a result of lots of government mandates.
What the things I like about this are more general.
I am sympathetic to wanting to lower the price of housing so more people can have housing.
You do that.
There's even it even cascades down, so there's less homelessness.
it even cascades down, so there's less homelessness.
It's a great thing.
I think I would disagree on the path to get us to more affordable housing, more affordable child care than a member of the DSA would.
But at least we have the same positive outcomes that we want to see facilitated, right?
I like Zachary's thought on the universal health care.
You know, some of my inside circles say, how dare you talk about that?
But I think we've got to do something.
There are a form of it I think makes sense.
Yeah, I think that deregulating health care so that we allow for more price competition and put the patient back in charge as a consumer is what we need to do for health care.
That's interesting because I do think the insurance companies are making things a lot worse as playing a double sided market.
They're trying to increase prices on consumers and at the same time decrease the prices that are being paid for physicians.
But there'd be fewer third party payers and mandates within the law for those third party payers, the insurance companies, if government deregulated.
It's fascinating its definitely something to exp I mean, this was a topic explored by the Obama administration for years and years.
And even so, the largest health care reform in the United States history post New Deal, still very minor in terms of what it accomplished, a very minor, but it also escalated the costs of the health care and limited supply to a very big degree.
If you're talking about escalated cost.
Wait until the new year hits.
Oh, yeah.
Absolutely.
These go away, you know, the old saw.
If you think it's expensive now, wait til it's free.
Yeah, well it's interesting the Republicans for how many years they controlled both houses of Congress and had the, the white House and they talked about repairing and replacing the ACA, the Affordable Care Act.
And that hasn't been that hasn't happened.
So a lot of work to be done there.
The other thing about that list is going back to the Green New Deal.
Which the Biden administration had pushed and the automakers were retooling, and we were pushing toward EVs.
Donald Trump comes in in his second term and wipes it all away.
Automakers had to retool again.
Now we want to go back to that again.
It's just two steps forward and three steps back when it comes to the Green New Deal, I think we have to get there and sell them elements.
I think for the environment, for the country and the world in general.
I think we need to go there a little bit.
But, that one we just can't figure out.
It seems like with every administration, we just we just change it up.
Our priorities change.
And I think that's a problem, you know?
So yeah, well, energy policy is another big nut to crack.
But from my position in all of the above strategy, because you need affordability, but you also need reliability.
And currently batteries.
And you know, electric vehicles aren't as dependable as gas power when you need them, especially up here in the northern climes when batteries will degrade faster in the cold weather.
Sure, absolutely.
So looking at the platform as we looked at it, economists, forecasters, analysts, whatever you might call them have said the price tag is going to be upwards 50 million, 50 trillion.
Excuse me.
Trillion with a T. And so which would drive up the debt.
So much for affordability.
That that's that it's that number that.
Okay.
It sounds good.
It sounds great on paper.
But is the price thing just too much?
Can we really afford it's going to drive the national debt up.
And so much for affordability, right.
Yeah.
You know it doesn't get talked about enough is if you put a lot of those policies in place that is massive government spending going on 50 trillion.
That's going to cause inflation to go up.
So when affordability is an issue, you're you don't want to spend to get out of it.
You want to have a very strategic movements to try and bring costs down while also keeping supply high and quality high as well.
So a lot of these, items that they have on their list are just untenable.
Right.
Margaret Thatcher once said, the problem with socialism is that sooner or later, you run out of other people's money.
Right.
And so the taxes that would be necessary to pay for all of these ideas, however well intentioned, might do more economic harm and cause via inflation.
Than might be worth it.
So it's interesting.
And a couple of minutes we have here, we should kind of look at what the American public and Michiganders in general sort of think about socialism.
So we have a have a little graphic here that shows that, have a little graphic here that shows that, show us your screen.
So a Gallup poll, 43% of Americans view democratic socialism positively.
And you see that number, which is interesting, up 7% in 2026 from 36% in 2010.
That's a short amount of time.
And they are at least looking at it more positively.
And just just a few years.
And then as far as I think we've got the Michiganders, how do we feel about it?
There we go.
52% of Michigan voters support capitalism.
You can see 86% by and large Republicans support it.
And then of course, 20%, 26% support the democratic socialism.
No surprise there.
So when you look at those numbers, does that say that we're at least in the country, we're moving there were more inclined we're moving there were more inclined to support it, depending on what it looks like.
I mean, if you look at the results of the midterms, they spoke a lot in clear.
I don't necessarily think that maybe they wanted democratic socialism, but they were certainly looking for change.
And that was certainly a big issue.
Right.
So is it a trend?
Is it a overreaction of the midterms?
What do you guys see?
You can definitely make the case that it's an overreaction.
It may be a fad.
I can tell you that people are unhappy with the way in which the economy is serving them.
And that is a very relatable feeling to have.
Whether or not that's going to translate into democratic socialism.
I think a lot of people who say they are for democratic socialism don't quite understand what it is exactly, because there are a lot of flaws to it.
And there are a lot of things we don't discuss about democratic socialism.
Same thing with capitalism.
Capitalism means something different to everyone else, right?
So whether or not we're going to move in socialist trends, I don't think that's very likely in America.
I think we are very centrist.
We are very capitalist by nature.
However, I do think that a lot of things need to change, and a lot of markets are currently in market failure and that needs to be fixed by our politicians.
Right.
I've been in the policy business for 35 years, and I've seen this pendulum swing back and forth.
It seems to have swung harder in the last couple of elections.
So there's a sort of a bias in favor of a different action.
And the action that's been discussed most recently is democratic socialism, in part because people don't have a real association with old school dictionary definition of socialism.
But to me, the data tells me it's a revealed preference that people are more comfortable with market capitalism.
Beyond the polls, it shows up in how they move, where they how they vote for their feet with their feet.
So it's going to be interesting, as you said, the next couple of years.
I mean, here in Michigan, there's a clean sweep in the Democrats, the House, the Senate, the governor in Washington, they've got the Congress and the Senate.
They still got to deal with Donald Trump.
So as much as the Democrats may want to set some of this agenda through the DSA or otherwise, they're going to hit a big veto pen.
But it's interesting discussion.
Love having you both in Michael LaFaive, the Mackinac Center Love having you both in Michael LaFaive, the Mackinac Center Public Policy, and Zachary Cohle, economist with the Saginaw Valley State University.
Thank you for having a great discussion.
Thank you guys.
Thank you.
And that's the Follow Up for this week.
But be sure to join us again next week.
What does the term affordability mean to local rescue missions serving the most vulnerable people in our communities?
In advance of the upcoming holiday season.
That's next Tuesday night right here in the Follow Up.
Thanks for tuning in this week.
We'll see you next time.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Today's top journalists discuss Washington's current political events and public affairs.

New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode

New Episode


Support for PBS provided by:
The Follow Up is a local public television program presented by Delta Public Media