State of Affairs with Steve Adubato
Exploring an AI tool for journalists & NJ local media
Clip: Season 10 Episode 20 | 14m 7sVideo has Closed Captions
Exploring an AI tool for journalists & NJ local media
Steve Adubato sits down with Stefanie Murray, Director of the Center for Cooperative Media at Montclair State University’s College of Communication and Media, to explore the current state of New Jersey’s media ecosystem and how a new AI tool can help journalists cover local government more efficiently.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
State of Affairs with Steve Adubato is a local public television program presented by NJ PBS
State of Affairs with Steve Adubato
Exploring an AI tool for journalists & NJ local media
Clip: Season 10 Episode 20 | 14m 7sVideo has Closed Captions
Steve Adubato sits down with Stefanie Murray, Director of the Center for Cooperative Media at Montclair State University’s College of Communication and Media, to explore the current state of New Jersey’s media ecosystem and how a new AI tool can help journalists cover local government more efficiently.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch State of Affairs with Steve Adubato
State of Affairs with Steve Adubato is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship[INSPRATIONAL MUSIC STING] - We're honored once again to be joined by Stefanie Murray, director of the Center for Cooperative Media at Montclair State University's College of Communication and Media.
Stefanie, good to see you again.
- It's good to see you too, Steve.
Thanks for having me.
- You got it, this is part of our ongoing series, "Media Matters."
You'll see the information come up, also produced in cooperation with our newly established foundation, the Adubato Center for Media Leadership.
But what is way more important is that Montclair State University, if you haven't heard, is the new operator of public broadcasting in the great state of New Jersey, NJPBS.
First of all, congratulations, Stefanie, to you and the team at the university.
- Thank you.
It's been a wild ride the last several months, but we're really excited to steward this incredibly important public treasure in our state.
- Yeah, and actually, we're taping literally a couple weeks before October 1st when that happens officially, around the 15th of September.
Talk to folks before we talk about Civilio, which is an important initiative and you'll explain why it matters.
Why is public broadcasting and operating public broadcasting for the university, for you as a media professional, as an academic who also has been hands-on in media, why is it so important to you professionally and personally?
- This whole adventure has been a highlight of my career, to be honest with you.
We really believe strongly at the center that I work with and here at the College of Communication and Media in a robust civic infrastructure for information in our state and across the country too.
Having access to nonpartisan factual information is critical for democracy.
And it's really, really important that we not only preserve public media in New Jersey, but grow it and innovate so that it can continue to evolve with the needs of residents of the state of New Jersey.
And to be able to have a hand in that is really exciting.
- Stefanie, for those who don't know, and put up the website for the Center for Cooperative Media, what is that at Montclair?
What is it and why does it matter so much?
- Yep, so the Center for Cooperative Media is a journalism support organization that's based at Montclair State.
We were started in 2012 to help support the New Jersey news ecosystem after the Great Recession that started in 2008 when there was a huge wave of layoffs and downsizing in the state.
And that was about the same time that there were a lot of hyperlocals started in New Jersey.
And that was also right after the transfer of NJTV, yeah, which is now NJPBS at that time.
- Well, it was WNET.
- That's right.
- For a lot of years, for 15 years.
- A long time, yeah.
And so we have been around since that to support the news ecosystem.
We really focused on hyper-local news organizations at the very beginning of our center, but today, we work with news organizations big and small across New Jersey and around the country.
In New Jersey, we provide professional development, communications, all sorts of training support, some direct support.
We are kind of a one-stop shop for organizations that need support, individual journalists that need support in helping to better serve their communities.
And then we do research here.
We research the state of the local news ecosystem.
Last week, we released a paper examining news influencers on social media.
Two weeks prior to that, we released a report that just looked at the overall ecosystem of news in the state.
So we also analyze and keep track of what's happening in New Jersey.
And then nationally, we're known for collaboration in journalism.
We run a collaborative journalism program where we coach people how to work with each other across organizational lines.
- You know, I've had several conversations, several interviews with you.
Stefanie, I've never asked you this.
- Yeah.
- I know it sounds like a cliche sometimes, but it's still important.
What's your "why" as to why media matters so much for you professionally and personally?
- That's a great question.
I have always been a storyteller.
Ever since I was little, I was one of those people as a child that was always taking notes and making up stories.
And I believe really deeply in people's access to news and information that they can use to live their daily lives with dignity.
Information is a commodity.
Information, and also in many cases, is a public good and a human right.
And I just believe strongly that open and free access to information is something that every person who, I mean, every person in the world, but especially every person who lives in our country should have access to.
And I think a lot of people, I think more people know today, but still a lot of people don't quite understand how much narrative drives decisions in this country and around the world.
The story that we tell each other and how we're interpreting the world around us and how we're explaining that to others drives so many decisions.
And I think a lot of people see that more today because of social media.
- And PS, "Media Matters," which is a new podcast that we've created, also the name of a course I'm teaching at Montclair, a one-credit course, which I'm excited about with our colleague, Chloe Swift, will be working with me on that, who's our senior producer of "One-on-One" and also an alum of Montclair State University.
Why am I saying all that?
Because media does matter more than ever, and media's changing dramatically and I'm not gonna get on my soapbox, but I do know this: media professionals need more help than ever before, which is what leads me to this, Civilio.
What the heck is it?
- What the heck is this?
So one of the things that our center also does is try to provide tools and other kinds of infrastructure that help local journalism survive.
So right now, for example, we have the New Jersey Newswire, which is a new wire service for small news organizations.
We're starting an advertising network, helping news organizations access advertising that they might not otherwise be able to land.
And we've also started with Civilio.
So Civilio is a tool that was built for journalists that helps to scrape, tag, categorize, summarize public meetings.
- Hold on, what do you mean scrape?
What's that mean?
- Yeah, so scrape means go to the website of the public organization, whatever it may be, whether it's your town council or your school board, and take the information from public meetings, so publicly available information, and put it into our database.
That's what it means.
- Is it AI?
- So I wouldn't call it AI because it's a tool, but they have some AI elements to the tool.
Yeah, there's some automation and there's some AI used in it.
It was built for journalists, and it basically helps journalists track what's happening in public meetings because we have lost 80% of local journalists in the United States over the last, what, 20-some years?
Huge decline.
And we see that in New Jersey especially because we have so many municipalities that don't have anyone covering them.
No one's at the school board meetings.
No one's going to these town council meetings.
And this is happening all over the country.
- Stefanie, tell folks, sorry for interrupting, tell folks outside of our world of journalism and media why that matters so much to them.
- So that matters to you because when there is no one to watch what's happening or to take any sort of notes or report back what's happening in your town government, that means that oftentimes, if you don't go searching that information out yourself, you're not gonna know what's happening.
Research shows that a lack of accountability, also lack of journalists watching, leads down the road to higher rates of corruption, misspending of money, people lose trust in government, and also voting goes down.
And so this is a civic health issue as much as anything else.
- Everything you just described, at least as I interpret it, talks about those of us in media as stewards, not only of what we do professionally, but also as we are there to be helpful to the general public.
We're there 'cause the general public doesn't have the time.
The average person should not be expected to do that.
I don't know why I have a bug somewhere about this.
"Enemy of the people."
I couldn't care less about anyone's politics.
And if you've watched us long enough to know, you can't guess my politics because it's irrelevant to what I do here.
And here's why I'm saying it.
"Enemy of the people."
That phrase is used a lot about the media.
That's a dangerous phrase.
That's a dangerous mentality, not just for those of us in the media, but way more importantly, for you watching right now.
I'm off my soapbox, Stefanie.
- Yeah, so Civilio was built to help journalists be able to track public meetings, because so many journalists today have to cover multiple municipalities.
And so there's been a lot of efforts across the United States and a bunch of different vendors to do this.
There's the Documenters program that City Bureau out of Chicago runs, which has been tested in New Jersey, that sends people to a public meeting to take notes.
But when you have always trying to send people to public meetings, you have to have enough people, you have to have them trained, they have to be willing and able to go.
It just introduces a lot of potential for error.
But if we are putting into a database and scraping things that are already publicly available and making it easier for journalists to track what was said at the meeting, what was voted on, who said what, find a quick video clip, find a quick quote, it just makes their job a lot easier to be able then to relay that information to the public.
And we liked Civilio because it was built for journalists and it's continuing to be tested to make sure that it's summarizing correctly because there's some AI usage in summarizing and looking for correct clips, but it's been pretty good.
And it will look at the agenda, it will look at what the meeting minutes are, and it can match things up.
And it really paves the way for journalists then to call up those officials and say, "Hey, you voted on this, you said this, you did this, why?"
So it enables that human reporting afterward, kind of clears the way for that.
- Got a minute left.
By the way, it doesn't sound like enemy of the people to me, it sounds like being helpful to people.
- That's right.
- Final question on this.
- Yeah.
- I spend too much, no, not too much.
I'm not gonna complain.
I spend a lot of my time raising money, why?
'Cause public, not-for-profit media is expensive and media is expensive.
Everything is expensive.
How concerned are you about the economics of media, which Montclair is gonna have to deal with operating NJPBS?
Why is that a relevant issue to independent journalism, media that helps people make sense of their lives?
Loaded question I know, a minute left.
- Yeah, so I spend most of my day actually thinking about that question, about how we can build revenue for news organizations around the state of New Jersey and now for PBS because it's right here down the stairs from me.
The answer right now is diversification, is that most media organizations have to make sure that they are bringing in multiple streams of revenue.
We still have a lot of news organizations in New Jersey that bring in a very strong advertising revenue stream, so that's not dead.
But to be successful today, you just have to look at multiple streams.
I have to say that I am a little concerned looking ahead about news organizations that rely on philanthropic donations because the philanthropic scene is really starting to change quite a bit.
There has been a push for more philanthropy to go into news, and we have a lot of news nonprofits in the state.
They're popping up all the time and people are converting.
But I am a little worried as I look toward 2028 is what's gonna happen with the philanthropic scene because folks are starting to pull back.
So that's my caution.
- Stefanie, let's continue the conversation.
We'll be talking to you in the future and many of your colleagues at Montclair as part of our "Media Matters" series.
And once again, congratulations for being the operator of the network, but also an incredible challenge and it matters to all of us.
Stefanie Murray from Montclair State University, thanks so much, Stefanie.
- Thank you, Steve.
- I'm Steve Adubato and I will not get on my soapbox, but media matters a lot, see you next time.
- [Narrator] State of Affairs with Steve Adubato is a production of the Caucus Educational Corporation.
Funding has been provided by The New Jersey Economic Development Authority.
New Brunswick Development Corporation.
The Adubato Center for Media Leadership.
PSE&G.
Valley Bank.
EJI, Excellence in Medicine Awards.
A New Jersey health foundation program.
Delta Dental of New Jersey.
New Jersey Public Charter Schools Association And by The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey.
Promotional support provided by BestofNJ.com.
And by CIANJ, and Commerce Magazine.
- The EJI Excellence in Medicine Awards was established in 1939, shining a light on New Jersey's health care leaders.
Current awards include the Excellence in Medicine, Research, Medical, Education and Community Service.
EJI also funds annual scholarships to medical, dental, pharmaceutical and physician assistant students throughout the state.
Learn more at EJIAwards.org.
George Helmy discusses the future of healthcare in NJ
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: S10 Ep20 | 12m 12s | George Helmy discusses the future of healthcare in NJ (12m 12s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.

- News and Public Affairs

Today's top journalists discuss Washington's current political events and public affairs.




New Episode


New Episode


Support for PBS provided by:
State of Affairs with Steve Adubato is a local public television program presented by NJ PBS
