
NY Lawmakers Clash Over Public Safety Provisions in Budget
Clip: Season 2023 Episode 12 | 13m 12sVideo has Closed Captions
Gov. Hochul's public safety proposals, PACs in the budget process draw criticism & support
As the New York state budget deadline approaches, Governor Hochul pushes for changes to bail reform in her preferred public safety proposals while criminal justice advocates rally for more pretrial services, diversion programs, and jail alternatives. The use of PACs, including one funded by Michael Bloomberg, to support Hochul's agenda raises concerns among progressives.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
New York NOW is a local public television program presented by WMHT
Support for New York NOW is provided by WNET/Thirteen and New York State AFL-CIO.

NY Lawmakers Clash Over Public Safety Provisions in Budget
Clip: Season 2023 Episode 12 | 13m 12sVideo has Closed Captions
As the New York state budget deadline approaches, Governor Hochul pushes for changes to bail reform in her preferred public safety proposals while criminal justice advocates rally for more pretrial services, diversion programs, and jail alternatives. The use of PACs, including one funded by Michael Bloomberg, to support Hochul's agenda raises concerns among progressives.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
How to Watch New York NOW
New York NOW is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipWELCOME TO THIS WEEK'S EDITION OF "NEW YORK NOW."
I'M DAN CLARK.
THERE'S NOW ABOUT A WEEK UNTIL THE NEW YORK STATE BUDGET IS DUE ON MARCH 31ST.
TOP LAWMAKERS AND GOVERNOR HOCHUL STILL SEEMS CONFIDENT THEY'LL STRIKE A DEAL IN THE NEXT SEVEN DAYS.
BUT THEY'RE STILL DIVIDED ON SOME PRETTY BIG ISSUES LIKE PUBLIC SAFETY.
HOCHUL HELD A RARE CAPITAL PRESS CONFERENCE THIS WEEK TO PUSH HER PREFERRED PUBLIC SAFETY PROPOSALS, INCLUDING A CHANGE TO BAIL REFORM.
RIGHT NOW, IF SOMEONE IS CHARGED WITH A BAIL-ELIGIBLE OFFENSE, JUDGES HAVE TO DECIDE IF THEY'LL BE HELD ON BAIL OR RELEASED.
AND THE CURRENT LAW SAYS THAT WHATEVER THE JUDGE DECIDES MUST BE BASED ON THE QUOTE LEAST RESTRICTIVE MEANS.
SO SOME JUDGES, ACCORDING TO HOCHUL HAD TAKEN THAT TO MEAN THAT BAIL SHOULD NOT BE SET AND THAT THE PERSON CHARGED SHOULD BE RELEASED BEFORE THEIR TRIAL AND GOVERNOR HOCHUL SAYS, THAT'S LED TO CONFUSION IN THE COURTS FOR SOME OF THESE BAIL-ELIGIBLE CASES.
SHE WANTS TO DROP THE LEAST RESTRICTIVE MEANS LANGUAGE SO IT'S CLEAR THAT JUDGES CAN SET BAIL IN THOSE CASES.
BUT PROGRESSIVES IN THE LEGISLATURE DISAGREE, SAYING THAT WOULD LEAD TO MORE PEOPLE IN JAIL WHO HAVE NOT BEEN CONVICTED OF A CRIME, AND IT'S A PRETTY BIG DISAGREEMENT TO RESOLVE IN THE NEXT WEEK, BUT GOVERNOR HOCHUL SAID THIS WEEK, SHE'D BE WILLING TO DELAY THE BUDGET TO GET WHAT SHE WANTS.
IF HISTORY IS AN INDICATOR, I THINK PEOPLE KNOW I FEEL STRONGLY ABOUT CERTAIN ISSUES, PARTICULARLY PROTECTING NEW YORKERS.
THAT'S WHAT I'M SUPPOSED TO DO, SO I FEEL CONFIDENT TO BE ABLE TO ACHIEVE AN ON-TIME BUDGET IF&IF WE DON'T, IT'S BECAUSE THERE ARE CONTINUING DISCUSSIONS ABOUT MATTERS THAT I CONSIDER EXTREMELY IMPORTANT.
ON THE SAME DAY CRIMINAL JUSTICE ADVOCATES RALLIED AT THE CAPITOL AGAINST HOCHUL'S PLAN.
THEY WANT THE BAIL LAW LEFT ALONE AND SAY THAT INSTEAD THE STATE SHOULD PUT MORE FUNDING INTO PRE-TRIAL SERVICES, DIVERSION PROGRAMS AND OTHER JAIL ALTERNATIVES AND THEY ALSO WANT NEW TENANT PROTECTIONS AND HEALTH CARE FUNDING IN THE BUDGET.
STATE SENATOR JESSICA RAMOS.
WHY DO WE WANT ALL THOSE THINGS?
BECAUSE THAT IS PUBLIC SAFETY!
BECAUSE IF YOU LIKE PUBLIC SAFETY, IF YOU'RE HONEST ABOUT WANTING PUBLIC SAFETY, THEN YOU'LL DECLARE WAR ON POVERTY!
BUT GOVERNOR HOCHUL IS GETTING SOME EXTRA SUPPORT THIS YEAR.
"THE TIMES UNION" AND THE "NEW YORK TIMES" REPORTED THIS WEEK THAT FORMER NEW YORK CITY MAYOR MIKE BLOOMBERG HAS QUIETLY FUNNELED $5 MILLION INTO A MEDIA CAMPAIGN SUPPORTING HOCHUL'S AGENDA, AND IT'S NOT SITTING WELL WITH PROGRESSIVES WHO WANT HIGH INCOME EARNERS IN NEW YORK, LIKE BLOOMBERG, TO PAY MORE IN TAXES TO THE STATE, AND THE IDEA WOULD BE TO USE THAT MONEY TO PROVIDE MORE SERVICES AND RELIEF TO LOW AND MIDDLE INCOME NEW YORKERS.
STATE SENATOR JABARI BRISPORT.
IT IS SO DISGUSTING, SO DISGUSTING TO SAY I DON'T WANT TO PAY MY TAXES.
I'D RATHER THROW AWAY MILLIONS OF DOLLARS TO TRY AND FORCE A BUDGET THAT HIKES FARES ON WORKING CLASS NEW YORKERS, THAT RAISES TUITION ON SUNY AND CUNY, THAT ALLOWS RENTS TO KEEP SPIRALING UP, THAT DOESN'T ADDRESS SPIRALING HEALTH CARE COSTS.
IT IS DISGUSTING.
IT IS DECEITFUL AND IT IS SELFISH AND GREEDY.
LET'S GET INTO IT WITH THIS WEEK'S PANEL.
ANNA GRONEWALD IS FROM POLITICO AND JOSH SOLOMON IS FROM THE TIMES UNION.
THANK YOU BOTH FOR BEING HERE.
I WANT TO START WITH THIS BLOOMBERG NEWS, JOSH.
YOU HAD A STORY THIS WEEK KIND OF REVEALING THIS AMERICAN OPPORTUNITY THING.
IT'S A PAC, WHAT IS IT?
BLOOMBERG IS SPENDING $5 MILLION TO FUND THIS DIRECT MAIL CAMPAIGN THAT'S INFLUENCED THE BUDGET.
DO WE KNOW WHY?
BEFORE I SAY I REVEALED IT, ANNA HAD IT IN THE PLAYBOOK FIRST.
THAT IS TRUE.
THAT IS TRUE.
[LAUGHTER] I REVEALED A LITTLE MORE DETAIL.
YES.
NICK VAN DOSE REVEALED THE BLOOMBERG BIT.
YES.
IT'S REPORTED THAT BLOOMBERG'S GIVING $5 MILLION TO SOMEONE TO HAVE THE TV CAMPAIGN, MAILERS, THE WHOLE DEAL TO SUPPORT HOCHUL'S BUDGET.
IT'S LIKE TOP LINE ITEMS FROM IT WITHOUT GETTING INTO ANY OF WHAT THE OPPOSITION IS.
WHAT YOU SEE ON THE MAILER IS A D.C.
ADDRESS AND IT SAYS PAID FOR BY AMERICAN OPPORTUNITY.
WHAT'S AMERICAN OPPORTUNITY?
THEY ARE SOMEWHAT ASSOCIATED WITH THE DEMOCRATIC GOVERNOR'S ASSOCIATION OUT OF D.C IT APPEARS THAT THEY ARE RUNNING THE CAMPAIGN.
THEY WILL NOT TELL YOU THAT.
THEY SHARE A LOT OF THE SAME STAFF.
THEY HAVE THE STAFF, THE ADDRESSES, THE PHONE NUMBER, THE BANK.
SOME OF THEIR-- THERE'S AT LEAST ONE TV AD THAT THE FCC INFORMATION SAYS, DEMOCRATIC GOVERNOR'S ASSOCIATION.
SO THEY'RE GASLIGHTING EVERYBODY.
YOU CAN SAY THAT.
I WILL SAY THAT.
[LAUGHTER] THEY'RE ALL CONNECTED AND IT APPEARS THAT THEY'RE RUNNING THE CAMPAIGN.
IT'S THE SAME AD BUYS.
THEY'RE USING THE SAME AD COMPANY THAT THEY DID FOR HOCHUL DURING THE CAMPAIGN SEASON.
INTERESTING.
ANNA, YOU HAVE COVERED MULTIPLE BUDGETS.
WHAT KIND OF IMPACT CAN SOMETHING LIKE THIS HAVE ON THIS KIND OF PROCESS?
IF AT ALL.
I THINK IT'S UNCLEAR.
I DON'T KNOW THAT THIS HAS BEEN DONE VERY REGULARLY TO TRY TO GET VOTERS TO INFLUENCE THEIR LAWMAKERS TO INFLUENCE THE BUDGET NEGOTIATIONS, WHICH ARE STILL KIND OF I WOULDN'T SAY EARLY BECAUSE THE BUDGET'S BEEN OUT ABOUT A WEEK, BUT THERE'S A LOT OF FLUX THERE.
[LAUGHTER] I THINK MAYBE THIS SOUNDS A LITTLE BIT TOO CYNICAL BUT IT'S HARD TO GET PEOPLE TO EVEN COME OUT TO VOTE.
YES.
I CAN'T IMAGINE EXPLAINING TO THEM THAT THERE'S SOME IDEAS BEING THROWN AROUND IN ALBANY, YOU NEED TO CALL YOUR LAWMAKERS ABOUT THESE SPECIFIC PROPOSALS THAT EVEN US IN THE PRESS HAVE DIFFICULTY DECIPHERING SOMETIMES.
RIGHT.
WE WERE JUST TALKING ABOUT BEFORE THIS, THE LEAST RESTRICTIVE MEANS THING WITH BAIL, IT'S JUST SO DIFFICULT FOR ME TO EVEN EXPLAIN IT TO OUR AUDIENCE FOR TELEVISION BECAUSE IT'S SUCH A COMPLICATED TOPIC.
IT'S SUCH AN INTERESTING PERCEPTION.
WHY DOES KATHIE HOCHUL NEED THIS RIGHT NOW?
RIGHT.
I THINK THERE ARE-- THERE ARE YOU A LOT OF HYPOTHESES BUT IT SEEMS LIKE SHE COULD BE LOOKING INTO KIND OF A TOUGH BATTLE AND I DON'T KNOW IF THIS IS THE PERCEPTION SHE WANTS TO PUT OUT THERE THAT I NEED MIKE BLOOMBERG'S MONEY TO HELP ME WITH MY BUDGET NEGOTIATIONS.
WHAT DO YOU THINK THAT SAYS BETWEEN THE DYNAMIC BETWEEN THE LEGISLATURE AND THE GOVERNOR IN IS THIS KIND OF A DIVIDE?
ARE WE JUST TALKING ABOUT MORE OF THE-- NOT FAR LEFT BUT PROGRESSIVE MEMBERS VERSUS HOCHUL?
ARE THE MODERATES ON HER SIDE A LITTLE BIT?
I THINK WE SOMETIMES LIKE TO BLOW UP THE IDEA THAT NO ONE IS GETTING ALONG AND EVERYONE IS REALLY MAD AT EACH OTHER ALL THE TIME.
RIGHT.
I THINK THAT THERE ARE A LOT OF THINGS THAT EVERYONE CAN AND WILL SIT DOWN AND AGREE ON, BUT THERE IS AN IDEA THAT THERE'S A LITTLE BIT OF TENSION AMONG THE LEGISLATURE NOT ONLY FROM KATHIE HOCHUL'S PROPOSALS, NOT QUITE AS FAR LEFT AS SOME GROUPS WOULD WANT BUT AFTER THIS WHOLE DEBACLE EARLIER THIS YEAR WITH HER CHIEF JUDGE PICK.
RIGHT, RIGHT, THAT HAS BEEN QUITE THE NEWS STORY FOR THE PAST COUPLE OF MONTHS.
I'M INTERESTING TO SEE IF THAT DIVIDE BECOMES MORE OF A PUBLIC REAL THING.
YOU HAD, WITH ANDREW CUOMO, WHEN WHENEVER ANYBODY WENT UP AGAINST ANDREW CUOMO, HE HIT RIGHT BACK REGARDLESS OF REGARDLESS OF HOW LIGHT THE BLOW WAS, ANYTHING LIKE THAT, THEY COULD NEVER TAKE A PUNCH.
WITH HER OFFICE I DON'T SEE THEM THAT WAY.
SHE HAS SAID THAT SHE WANTS TO BE A MORE COLLABORATIVE GOVERNOR.
I DON'T KNOW IF THAT MEANS SHE WANTS TO COLLABORATE WITH PROGRESSIVES.
I DON'T KNOW IF SHE'S GOING TO GO ON THE ATTACK AGAINST THEM NECESSARILY.
ONE ISSUE THAT IS KIND OF DEFINING THIS WHOLE CONVERSATION IS THIS BAIL REFORM DEBATE THAT WE WERE TALKING ABOUT.
JOSH, YOU'VE COVERED THIS A LOT.
THE GOVERNOR'S SEEKING THIS CHANGE THAT SHE KIND OF THINKS AS A BIG CHANGE, THE PROGRESSIVES THINK OF IT AS A BIG CHANGE OF REMOVING LEAST RESTRICTIVE MEANS.
DO YOU SEE THAT AS A BIG DIVISION IN THESE FINAL DAYS OF THE STATE BUDGET?
WE SAW THAT LAST YEAR WITH BAIL REFORM.
IS IT THE SAME THIS YEAR?
I THINK I SAID ON THE SHOW RECENTLY THAT I WASN'T SURE HOW BIG OF A DEAL IT WOULD BE.
YEAH.
OBVIOUSLY, I WAS WRONG.
[LAUGHTER] IT'S-- IT'S EMERGING TO BE A BIG DEAL.
SHE HELD THE RED ROOM THIS WEEK.
SHE BROUGHT OUT FOUR MODERATE STATE SENATORS EARLIER IN THE DAY FOR PROGRESSIVE STATE SENATORS, INCLUDING BRAD HOYLMAN-SIGAL WAS A FLOOR ABOVE RAILING AGAINST HER.
YOU COULD SEE THAT THE NUMBERS GAMES, HOW MANY SENATORS DOES SHE HAVE IN HER SUPPORT, IT'S CURIOUS.
THE ISSUE ON BAIL SHE SAYS SHE'S CONCERNED ABOUT JUDGES' DISCRETION AND WANTING TO KIND OF MAKE SURE THAT WHATEVER WE SAID THE LAW IS, THAT'S GOING TO BE WHAT IT'S GOING TO BE AND YOU CAN'T NECESSARILY, EVERY TIME THERE'S A NEWS STORY FOR THE NEXT, YOU KNOW, 12 MONTHS AND YOU'RE SAYING, WELL, THAT PERSON COULD HAVE BEEN HELD BUT THEY WEREN'T HELD PRE-TRIAL.
IT'S NOT GOING TO BE THE STATE'S FAULT, AND THAT'S KIND OF WHERE IT IS.
IT'S NOT SHIFTING THE BLAME BUT IT'S SAYING THIS IS COMPLETELY ON YOU, JUDGES.
IT'S THIS-- THIS ISSUE IS REALLY ENGRAINED IN POLITICS, I THINK, AT THIS POINT ESPECIALLY BECAUSE REPUBLICANS HAVE DONE A VERY, VERY EFFECTIVE JOB OF TRYING TO CONNECT THE RISE IN CRIME TO BAIL REFORM.
THERE'S NO EVIDENCE THAT SAYS THOSE TWO THINGS ARE CONNECTED.
ON THE FLIP SIDE, I THINK DEMOCRATS HAVE HAD A LOT OF TROUBLE TRYING TO SHINE A POSITIVE LIGHT ON BAIL REFORM.
YOU SEE CRIMINAL JUSTICE GROUPS TALKING ABOUT HOW IT'S BENEFITED PEOPLE WHO DON'T LOSE THEIR JOBS BECAUSE THEY DON'T GET INCARCERATED BEFORE THEIR TRIAL.
THEY GET TO STAY WITH THEIR FAMILIES BEFORE TRIAL.
AND OF COURSE, THEY HAVEN'T BEEN CONVICTED YET.
IT'S JUST ONE OF THOSE ISSUES THAT I DON'T KNOW IS EVER GOING TO GO AWAY.
SO I'M INTERESTED TO SEE, THIS CHANGE WOULD CHANGE ONE LINE OF THE LAW.
I WONDER IF WE HAVE A BIGGER CHANGE NEXT YEAR OR IF IT KIND OF FIZZLES OUT AFTER THIS?
WE ONLY HAVE A FEW MINUTES LEFT.
I DON'T WANT TO SPEND IT JUST TALKING ABOUT BAIL.
I WANT TO GO TO BOTH OF YOU.
OVER THE NEXT WEEK, WHAT ARE YOU WATCHING?
WHAT ARE THESE ISSUES THAT THE LEGISLATURE AND THE GOVERNOR SEEM TO NEED TO COME TOGETHER THAT WE HAVE TO KEEP TRACK OF THE NEXT YOU CAN COUPLE OF DAYS?
THE BIG ONE, ESPECIALLY ACCORDING TO THE GOVERNOR, IS THE HOUSING PLAN THAT SHE PUT OUT.
YEAH.
I THINK SHE DOES WANT IT TO BE A KIND OF LEGACY ISSUE OVER THE NEXT DECADE.
SHE SAYS SHE WANTS TO BUILD 800,000 NEW UNITS.
THOSE NUMBERS ARE FLEXIBLE ACCORDING TO WHO YOU SPEAK WITH.
THE LEGISLATURE SAYS YOU CAN'T REALLY FORCE THESE MUNICIPALITIES TO BUILD IN A SPECIFIC WAY.
HOW ABOUT WE JUST INCENTIVIZE THEM TO AND WE GIVE THEM REASONS TO DO IT OUR WAY AND HOCHUL, I THINK, WANTS TO GO A LITTLE BIT STRONGER.
IT'S BECOME A BIG FIGHT.
THERE'S SO MANY DIFFERENT OPINIONS ON THE BEST WAY TO GET THIS HOUSING BUILT.
I THINK EVERYONE AGREES ON THE OVERLYING PREMISE, BUT IT'S VERY, VERY COMPLICATED AND IT COULD TAKE A LOT LONGER THAN A WEEK TO FIGURE OUT A GOOD HOUSING PLAN FOR THE STATE FOR THE NEXT DECADE.
I WONDER IF-- BECAUSE THE HOUSING THING WITH ALLOWING LOCAL ZONING TO BE OVERRIDED, I THINK THAT'S THE BIG STICKING POINT.
I'M WONDERING IF THAT DOES GO THROUGH FOR WHATEVER REASON IF HOCHUL IS ABLE TO CONVINCE THE LEGISLATURE, IF THERE'S JUST A LAWSUIT AND IT GETS STRUCK DOWN.
I FEEL LIKE WE TALK ABOUT THESE ISSUES SOMETIMES AND SIX MONTHS LATER THAT ALL WAS FOR NOTHING.
JOSH, WHAT ARE YOU WATCHING OVER THE NEXT COUPLE DAYS?
I DO THINK THAT THE SUBURBS HOUSING PART OF IT MAY JUST BE A BARGAINING CHIP OF SENATE DEMOCRATS OR THE LEGISLATURE SAYING, WELL, YOU'RE GOING TO HAVE TO EARN THAT BACK.
YEAH.
WE GENERALLY AGREE WITH YOU BUT WE'RE GOING TO WORK OUT THE DETAILS AND YOU'RE GOING TO HAVE TO EARN THAT BACK.
I THINK THAT'S WHAT'S INTERESTING ON THE HOUSING FRONT IS WHAT THE ASSEMBLY AND SENATE CHAIRS ARE IN FAVOR OF GOOD CAUSE EVICTION.
THE TOP PROGRESSIVE PRIORITY, THE MENTAL HEALTH CHAIRS ARE IN FAVOR OF AN 8.5% COLA, COST OF LIVING ADJUSTMENT, FOR WORKERS.
THOSE ARE SOME OF THE MORE EXPENSIVE PIECES OR BIGGER IDEAS IN THE BUDGET THAT THE LEGISLATURE WANTS AND HOCHUL HAS IT PUT INTO YOUR BUDGET.
THAT COULD BE AN INTERESTING PIECE.
IT'S NOT JUST FRINGE MEMBERS OF THE PARTY THAT WANT IT.
IT'S THE CHAIRS OF THESE COMMITTEES.
RIGHT, EXACTLY.
YOU KNOW, THE BUDGET IS SUCH A COMPLICATED, WONKY THING I WISH WE COULD TALK ABOUT EVERY ISSUE THAT'S INVOLVED IN IT.
I WANT TO OPEN UP AN OPEN-ENDED QUESTION TO ANNA ON THE WAY OUT OR JOSH, YOU CAN ANSWER TO.
[LAUGHTER] THIS IS GOVERNOR'S HOCHUL SECOND BUDGET.
LAST YEAR, WE SAW A LOT OF THINGS BLOW UP IN THE LAST TWO WEEKS.
DOES IT LOOK LIKE IT'S A SMOOTHER RIDE THIS YEAR MAYBE?
YOU KNOW, I'M NOT SURE.
I THINK LAST YEAR NOT ONLY WAS IT KIND OF A SHORTER TIME LINE AFTER SHE CAME INTO OFFICE AND SHE HAD TO GET HER BUDGET THROUGH, BUT EVERYONE IS STILL TRYING TO FIGURE OUT EACH OTHER'S OPERATING STYLES.
I THINK THIS YEAR THEY'RE UNDERSTANDING A LITTLE BIT MORE AND PEOPLE DO SEEM TO BE TALKING MORE.
LIKE WE'VE ALREADY DISCUSSED THE DYNAMICS ARE PRETTY FROT AND EVERYONE IS STILL TRYING TO DECIDE HOW MUCH THEY CAN NEEDLE EACH OTHER AND WHETHER OR NOT THAT WILL BE EFFECTIVE.
SO I DON'T HAVE A CLEAR IDEA YET WHETHER THIS SEEMS BETTER.
WE DIDN'T KNOW UNTIL NINE DAYS LATER LAST YEAR, BUT I DO THINK THAT PEOPLE PROBABLY UNDERSTAND AT A BASE LEVEL HOW TO TALK TO EACH A LITTLE BIT MORE.
WE'LL SEE IF THAT HELPS.
I HOPE SO.
JOSH, WE'RE OUT OF TIME.
I'M SORRY.
[LAUGHTER] THANK YOU BOTH FOR BEING HERE.
ANNA GRONEWALD FROM POLITICO, JOSH SOLOMON FROM THE TU, THANK YOU BOTH.
Assm. Ed Ra Discusses State Budget, Housing & Infrastructure
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: S2023 Ep12 | 9m 31s | Assm. Ed Ra gives his perspective on the state budget, housing, infrastructure, and more. (9m 31s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship- News and Public Affairs
Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.
- News and Public Affairs
FRONTLINE is investigative journalism that questions, explains and changes our world.
Support for PBS provided by:
New York NOW is a local public television program presented by WMHT
Support for New York NOW is provided by WNET/Thirteen and New York State AFL-CIO.