
How Lead (Maybe?) Caused the Downfall of the Roman Empire
Season 7 Episode 12 | 5m 55sVideo has Closed Captions
We unwrap the possibility that lead caused the Roman Empire’s collapse.
Ancient Rome’s emperors did some pretty bizarre stuff—bursting into uncontrollable fits of laughter, appointing a horse as a priest, dressing in animal skins and attacking people… the list goes on. Why did they act this way? Possibly… lead poisoning. In this week’s episode, we unwrap the possibility that lead caused the Roman Empire’s collapse.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback

How Lead (Maybe?) Caused the Downfall of the Roman Empire
Season 7 Episode 12 | 5m 55sVideo has Closed Captions
Ancient Rome’s emperors did some pretty bizarre stuff—bursting into uncontrollable fits of laughter, appointing a horse as a priest, dressing in animal skins and attacking people… the list goes on. Why did they act this way? Possibly… lead poisoning. In this week’s episode, we unwrap the possibility that lead caused the Roman Empire’s collapse.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
How to Watch Reactions
Reactions is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipAncient Roman emperors were known for some bizarre behaviors.
Caligula apparently appointed his horse as a priest and Nero would cover himself in wild animal skins, run into an arena and brutally mutilate people.
Claudius was known for his clumsy walk, sudden fits of rage and bursting into uncontrollable laughter.
Most historians think these stories are exaggerated gossip spread by political rivals, but even if they're just 10% true, something was going on.
Could have been a bunch of things, stroke, tumor, maybe a traumatic brain injury, but it also could have been caused by eating a lot of lead.
So did lead lead to the fall of the Roman empire?
Ancient Rome was really into lead.
Lead is super malleable and corrosion resistant so it was used in tons of stuff.
Dishes and utensils contained lead.
Pipe, transporting water were made of lead.
Even coffins had lead in them.
Because it was in so much stuff, lead also made its way into food and drink.
And Roman rulers and aristocrats were notorious gluttons.
A cookbook from back then called The Roman Apicius Cookbook, has about 450 recipes and lead is in almost a hundred of them in the form of lead acetate, often called sugar of lead.
When I read that, my first question was “You guys ever heard a sugarcane?” Turns out sugar cane wasn't big back then.
So the options to sweeten something were honey, which there also wasn't a lot of or grapes, which they had plenty of.
They boiled down grape juice to concentrate the sugars, but then they found that if they boiled it in lead pots, the syrup would become even sweeter.
What was happening was that the acetate from the grapes was combining with lead ions that were leaching out of the pot to form lead acetate and lead acetate is sweet.
So it was used in a bunch of different foods and wine.
And apparently Roman aristocrats were drinking somewhere between one and five liters of wine per day.
That's a lot of inadvertent lead consumption.
One story goes that the politician Lucullus served around 4 million liters of wine for just one of his banquets.
I apologize for nothing.
Why were they so okay with drinking and eating that much lead?
Well, they had no idea it was toxic.
Lead serves zero purpose in our bodies.
Lead's bad for all of our organs, but what we often hear about is how much it damages our brains.
Lead is able to substitute for calcium.
And that's usually why it's so toxic.
Your brain needs calcium to send messages between neurons and lead competing with calcium can cause two major things.
One-- the calcium that should be getting into your neurons and triggering that message isn't or two--neurons that aren't supposed to active start randomly sending messages.
Too much or too little signaling in your brain can cause a bunch of behavioral changes.
Think Claudia’s erratic mood swings, or it can cause issues processing information, which might make you think appointing a horse to be a priest is a good idea.
Today we still use lead in some stuff like car batteries.
But compared to the amount of lead that the Roman empire used 2000 years ago, or even the amount of lead that we used a hundred years ago, we're using very little.
But it is still in our environment and the stuff that was made before people realized how toxic it was, like water pipes in Flint, Michigan.
Corroded pipes leached lead into the water, making a lot of people very sick.
Okay.
Back to ancient Rome.
Was all the led that they were eating and drinking enough to take down an empire?
People have been trying to figure that out for a while.
Throughout the 1900s, researchers recreated some of those syrups that were commonly used in foods and wine, and they found lead concentrations of 240 milligrams to one gram per liter.
That's around 60 times more than what the EPA allows in public drinking water.
And that was enough to convince a lot of people that lead played a big role in ancient Rome's downfall.
But the research didn't stop there.
In 2014, a team dredged for sediment in the waters around Rome and compared the amount of lead in that sediment to the amount preserved in ancient Rome's pipes.
They figured out that the water in ancient Rome probably had way more lead in it than today's tap water, but not enough to be that harmful or be a major culprit in Rome's demise.
So we know there was at least a good amount of lead in ancient Rome's water and the syrup they use to sweeten stuff.
But how much of that lead was getting into people?
You need to study skeletons to answer that.
Most Roman empire rulers like Claudius were cremated so their skeletons aren't around anymore.
But since the 1970s archeologists have been studying the skeletons of Roman commoners to find some answers.
In 2019, a team compared skeletons from the Roman empire to skeletons from the Iron Age, before lead was popular.
Skeletons from the iron age contained 0.3 to 2.9 micrograms of lead per gram.
Whereas the ones from the Roman empire had from 8 to 123 micrograms per gram.
That's up to 400 times more lead, absolutely enough to be messing with brain chemistry.
But does it mean that it caused the Roman empire to implode?
Can't say for sure.
What we do know is that human created lead pollution was a serious problem 2000 years ago.
And unfortunately it's still causing problems today.
- Science and Nature
A series about fails in history that have resulted in major discoveries and inventions.
Support for PBS provided by: