
Making New York More Accessible for People With Disabilities
Season 2023 Episode 30 | 26m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
NY's accessibility for disabilities, abortion laws demystified & 9/11 Notice Act update.
Join us as we celebrate Disability Pride Month with New York's Chief Disability Officer, Kimberly Hill, discussing accessibility improvements in the state. Get clarity on abortion laws post the Roe v. Wade ruling with NY& Abortion. Stay informed with the latest update on the 9/11 Notice Act in our On The Bill segment.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
New York NOW is a local public television program presented by WMHT
Support for New York NOW is provided by WNET/Thirteen.

Making New York More Accessible for People With Disabilities
Season 2023 Episode 30 | 26m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
Join us as we celebrate Disability Pride Month with New York's Chief Disability Officer, Kimberly Hill, discussing accessibility improvements in the state. Get clarity on abortion laws post the Roe v. Wade ruling with NY& Abortion. Stay informed with the latest update on the 9/11 Notice Act in our On The Bill segment.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
How to Watch New York NOW
New York NOW is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship[ THEME MUSIC ] ON THIS WEEK'S EDITION OF "NEW YORK NOW", JULY IS DISABILITY PRIDE MONTH.
WE SPEAK WITH KIMBERLY HILL, NEW YORK'S FIRST-EVER CHIEF DISABILITY OFFICER, A POSITION THAT ADVOCATES FOR NEW YORKERS WITH DISABILITIES.
AND LATER, EVER SINCE THE SUPREME COURT OVERTURNED ROE V. WADE LAST YEAR, THERE'S BEEN A LOT OF CONFUSION ABOUT ACCESS TO ABORTION ACROSS THE COUNTRY.
WE TELL YOU WHERE THINGS STAND IN NEW YORK AND HOW THAT DECISION AFFECTS THINGS HERE.
I'M DAN CLARK AND THIS IS "NEW YORK NOW."
[ THEME MUSIC ] WELCOME TO THIS WEEK'S EDITION OF "NEW YORK NOW."
I'M DAN CLARK.
MORE EXTREME HEAT OVERWHELMED PARTS OF NEW YORK THIS WEEK AND WHILE NEXT WEEK LOOKS BETTER, IT'S STILL GONNA BE PRETTY HOT.
BUT THIS WEATHER HAS SOME NEW YORKERS ASKING, HAS SUMMER ALWAYS BEEN LIKE THIS, OR IS THIS CLIMATE CHANGE?
AND WHILE SUMMER IS ALWAYS HOT, EXPERTS IN CLIMATE SCIENCE AGREE THAT OUR WEATHER PATTERNS ARE CHANGING, CAUSING MORE EXTREME STORMS AND SOME OF THE HOTTEST DAYS ON RECORD.
SO IN RESPONSE, ADVOCATES MADE A FRESH PUSH THIS WEEK FOR THE NY HEAT ACT.
IT'S A BILL THAT WOULD CAP UTILITY BILLS FOR LOW AND MIDDLE INCOME CONSUMERS AT 6% OF THEIR INCOME.
IT WOULD ALSO END A RULE THAT REQUIRES UTILITY COMPANIES TO BUILD NEW GAS HOOKUPS FOR NEW CUSTOMERS AT NO CHARGE.
THAT COST IS, INSTEAD, SPREAD ACROSS ALL RATE PAYERS DRIVING COSTS UP.
BOTH PARTS OF THE BILL ARE INTENDED TO LOWER ENERGY COSTS FOR CONSUMERS WHO SEE THOSE BILLS SPIKE IN TIMES OF EXTREME WEATHER, LIKE THE HEAT WE'RE SEEING NOW.
STATE SENATOR LIZ KRUEGER SPONSORS THE BILL, WHICH HAS PASSED IN THE SENATE BUT NOT THE ASSEMBLY.
SOME OF THE IMPACTS WE'RE SEEING BECAUSE WE'RE STILL DOMINANTLY DEPENDENT ON OIL AND GAS, AND WE HAVE TO GET OFF IT AS FAST AS POSSIBLE.
SO WHEN PEOPLE SAY THERE'S NOT A RUSH.
LOOK OUT YOUR WINDOW.
READ THE WEATHER REPORTS COMING IN FROM AROUND THE WORLD.
SOME UTILITY COMPANIES ARE AGAINST THE BILL, SAYING IT WOULD DRIVE UP COSTS FOR THEM.
LAWMAKERS SAY THEY'LL CONSIDER THE BILL AGAIN IN NEXT YEAR'S LEGISLATIVE SESSION AND STAYING NOW IN STATE GOVERNMENT, YOU MIGHT NOT KNOW THIS, BUT JULY IS DISABILITY PRIDE MONTH.
THAT'S TO MARK THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, WHICH PASSED IN 1990.
IT'S A LAW THAT MANY AMERICANS AND NEW YORKERS DON'T ALWAYS HAVE AT TOP OF MIND, BUT IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT.
THE ADA BANNED DISCRIMINATION AGAINST PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES, AND THAT MEANS EVERYWHERE FROM HOUSING TO EMPLOYMENT AND A LOT MORE.
AND BECAUSE OF THAT LAW, ACCESSIBILITY FOR PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES HAS IMPROVED, BUT THERE'S STILL A LONG WAY TO GO.
THAT INCLUDES HERE IN NEW YORK, WHERE ABOUT 1 OUT OF EVERY 4 ADULTS HAS A DISABILITY, ACCORDING TO THE CDC, AND UNTIL LAST YEAR, NEW YORK'S WORK ON ACCESSIBILITY WAS SCATTERED ACROSS MULTIPLE AGENCIES AND HAD A COMPLICATED HISTORY.
LAST FEBRUARY, THAT CHANGED WHEN A NEW LAW CREATED THE OFFICE OF THE CHIEF DISABILITY OFFICER, AND TO LEARN ALL ABOUT IT AND HOW THEY'RE WORKING TO MAKE NEW YORK MORE ACCESSIBLE, WE SPOKE WITH KIM HILL, THE FIRST PERSON EVER TO TAKE ON THAT ROLE.
[ THEME MUSIC ] KIM, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR BEING HERE.
I APPRECIATE IT.
THANKS FOR HAVING ME.
OF COURSE, ANYTIME.
SO I WANT TO TALK ABOUT THIS POSITION BECAUSE IT'S A NEW POSITION.
SO YOUR WORK IS RELATIVELY NEW.
YOU WERE CHOSEN FOR IT LAST YEAR.
TELL ME WHAT THE OFFICE OF THE CHIEF DISABILITY OFFICER DOES.
SO THERE'S A COUPLE OF DIFFERENT WAYS I CAN ANSWER THIS QUESTION.
WE ARE REQUIRED, BY LEGISLATION TO DO CERTAIN THINGS, BUT I THINK WHAT IS MOST IMPORTANT FOR ALL NEW YORKERS TO KNOW IS THAT WE ARE THE OPEN DOOR FOR PEOPLE WITH ALL DIFFERENT TYPES OF DISABILITIES.
AND OUR TWO MAIN GOALS ARE TO BE BREAKING DOWN THE SILOS THAT EXIST AMONG ALL OF THE AGENCIES SO THAT ALL THE AGENCIES ARE TALKING AND KNOWING WHAT EACH OTHER IS DOING AND ALSO MAKING SURE THAT NEW YORK IS AS ACCESSIBLE, INCLUSIVE, AND INTEGRATED AS POSSIBLE.
WHAT DO YOU THINK THAT LOOKS LIKE FROM YOUR PERSPECTIVE IN TERMS OF-- IS IT JUST COMPLIANCE WITH THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, OR IS IT SO MUCH MORE THAN THAT?
IT'S SO MUCH MORE.
I MEAN, THE ADA WAS GROUNDBREAKING, RIGHT, IN ITS TIME AND 33 YEARS LATER, THERE'S STILL A LOT OF WORK TO BE DONE AND OUT OF THE ADA HAVE COME OTHER THINGS LIKE THE U.S. SUPREME COURT OLMSTEAD RULING WHICH IS A LARGE COMPONENT OF WHAT OUR OFFICE DOES.
AS CHAIR OF NEW YORK'S MOST INTEGRATING INTEGRATED COUNCIL WHICH IS THE OLMSTEAD ENTITY IN NEW YORK STATE, WE ARE REQUIRED TO MAKE SURE THAT NEW YORKERS LIVE IN THE MOST INTEGRATED SETTING APPROPRIATE TO THEIR NEEDS AND NEW YORK HAS A PLAN TO MAKE SURE THAT THAT HAPPENS.
SO IF YOU THINK ABOUT ALL THE DIFFERENT WAYS THAT SOMEONE LIVES THEIR DAILY LIFE, IT AFFECTS HOUSING.
IT AFFECTS HOME CARE AND HEALTH CARE.
IT AFFECTS TRANSPORTATION, JOBS, EMPLOYMENT, RECREATION.
SO WE CAN KIND OF TOUCH INTO EVERY STATE AGENCY.
WE WORK WITH ALL OF THE PORTFOLIOS THAT EXIST WITHIN THE GOVERNOR'S ADMINISTRATION.
IT'S REALLY PRETTY MUCH EVERYWHERE.
YEAH.
IT'S A REALLY BIG JOB.
YEAH.
YOU COVER A LOT OF GROUND.
WE DO.
YOU'VE GOT A LOT OF PEOPLE.
YOU'VE BEEN DOING THIS FOR ABOUT A YEAR AND A COUPLE OF MONTHS.
HOW HAS IT GONE SO FAR?
IT'S BEEN AMAZING.
HONESTLY, IT'S BEEN A DREAM COME TRUE FOR ME.
I HAVE BEEN DOING DISABILITY POLICY FOR ALMOST 25 YEARS AND TO BE ABLE TO DO IT AT THE STATE LEVEL WITH GOVERNOR HOCHUL, THE FIRST FEMALE GOVERNOR IN NEW YORK STATE, BEING A PART OF HER HISTORICAL ADMINISTRATION, THAT IN AND OF ITSELF HAS BEEN A WHIRLWIND.
IT'S BEEN A DREAM.
BUT TO BE WORKING UNDER A GOVERNOR THAT TRULY CARES ABOUT PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES AND WANTS TO SEE THEM INTEGRATED INTO NORMAL LIFE MAKES MY JOB SO MUCH EASIER TO DO.
BECAUSE SHE'S SO COMMITTED TO IT.
SO IT'S BEEN AMAZING.
THIS OFFICE, I SHOULD MENTION-- I MENTIONED IT WAS NEW, BUT IT KIND OF HAS A HISTORY AND DIFFERENT ITERATIONS.
CAN YOU TALK ABOUT IT, FOR PEOPLE WHO DON'T KNOW WHY IS THIS ROLE SO IMPORTANT?
YEAH.
SO I CAN SPEAK FROM WHERE I CAME FROM.
WHEN I FIRST STARTED IN STATE GOVERNMENT IN 1994, THERE USED TO BE AN OFFICE CALLED THE OFFICE OF THE ADVOCATE FOR PERSONS WITH DISABILITIES, AND THEY WERE KIND OF ABSORBED INTO THE COMMISSION ON QUALITY OF CARE AND ADVOCACY FOR PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES.
AND SLOWLY OVER TIME, AS PEOPLE RETIRED, THAT OFFICE JUST KIND OF DISAPPEARED.
IN THAT TIME, ADVOCATES REALIZED THAT THERE WAS REALLY NO ENTITY OVERSEEING ALL DIFFERENT TYPES OF DISABILITIES.
I MEAN WE HAVE SEVERAL AGENCIES IN NEW YORK STATE AND THE PORTFOLIO THAT I WORK UNDER COVERS ALL OF OUR "O" AGENCIES, LIKE WE CALL THEM THE OFFICE FOR PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES, OFFICE FOR MENTAL HEALTH, OSH, THAT TYPE OF THING, BUT THERE'S NO ONE AND HAS BEEN NO ONE TO TRULY PAY ATTENTION TO THE NEEDS OF PEOPLE WITH JUST PHYSICAL DISABILITIES, PEOPLE WITH HEARING DISABILITIES, PEOPLE WITH VISION DISABILITIES.
SO THAT'S WHAT MAKES OUR OFFICE UNIQUE IS THAT WE ARE REALLY THE ONLY ONES PURELY FOCUSING ON THOSE ISSUES WHILE ALSO WORKING WITH OPWDD AND OMH AND ALL THE OTHER AGENCIES.
YEAH.
I WAS GOING TO ASK YOU ABOUT KIND OF LIKE THE GREATER AREA OUTSIDE OF YOUR OFFICE.
SO YOU HAVE OPWDD, WHICH YOU WORK WITH.
DO YOU ALSO GET INTO PEOPLE MAYBE WITH MENTAL HEALTH CONDITIONS, THINGS LIKE THAT?
SO WITHIN OUR WORK WITH OLMSTEAD, I MEAN, THAT COVERS ALL PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES.
SO SINCE THAT'S SUCH A BIG PART OF OUR JOB, I CONSIDER OUR POPULATION ALL PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES SO WE'RE DEALING WITH MENTAL HEALTH ISSUES.
WE'RE DEALING WITH IDD ISSUES, BUT THAT REALLY FOCUSES MORE-- IT'S MORE FOCUSED ON BY OUR HUMAN SERVICES AND MENTAL HYGIENE PORTFOLIO.
YEAH.
SO WE WORK TOGETHER.
OUR TEAM FALLS WITH IN THEIR TEAM.
WE'RE CONSTANTLY TALKING AND WORKING TOGETHER.
BUT BECAUSE THE PHYSICAL AND SENSORY DISABILITIES AREN'T COVERED BY ANYONE ELSE, WE KIND OF TAKE THE LEAD ON THOSE ISSUES.
YOU KNOW, YOU'RE LOOKING AT THIS TOPIC EVERY DAY.
YOU HAVE SINCE YOU STARTED THIS JOB.
WHAT DO YOU SEE AS THE TOP ISSUES FOR PEOPLE WITH PHYSICAL AND SENSORY DISABILITIES?
THERE'S A LOT AND IT'S A HARD QUESTION TO ANSWER BECAUSE DEPENDING ON YOUR DISABILITY, THE ANSWER MIGHT BE DIFFERENT.
YOUR SHOE.
BUT THE GOVERNOR'S IDENTIFIED EMPLOYMENT AS A MASSIVE GOAL ACROSS ALL DISABILITY TYPES SO THAT IS SOMETHING THAT WE FOCUS ON VERY MUCH.
WE ALSO ARE CONSTANTLY FOCUSING ON HOW TO IMPROVE HOME CARE, THE WORKFORCE CRISIS IN NEW YORK, BECAUSE PEOPLE NEED HOME CARE AND THEN YOU MOVE ON TO HOUSING.
THERE THERE'S NOWHERE NEAR ENOUGH ACCESSIBLE AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
YEAH.
SO ONCE WE COVER THOSE THREE THINGS THAT PEOPLE HAVE THE CARE THEY NEED, THEY HAVE THE HOUSING THAT THEY CAN LIVE IN, AND HOPEFULLY A JOB THAT THEY WANT TO GO TO, THEN DO WE HAVE THE TRANSPORTATION TO GET THEM THERE?
THEN ARE THE RECREATIONAL ACTIVITIES THAT THEY WANT TO PARTICIPATE IN AVAILABLE AND ACCESSIBLE AND INTEGRATED?
SO IT DOESN'T END.
[LAUGHTER] I CAN IMAGINE.
TO BE HONEST WITH YOU, WHEN YOUR POSITION WAS CREATED LAST YEAR AND ANNOUNCED, IT MADE ME THINK ABOUT THIS WHOLE ISSUE VERY DIFFERENTLY IN TERMS OF HIGH EXPERIENCES IN MY OWN LIFE.
I WAS VISITING FRIENDS DOWN IN NEW YORK CITY WHO LIVED IN BROOKLYN, AND WE WERE GETTING ON THE TRAIN TO GO UP TO MANHATTAN, AND IT WASN'T AN ACCESSIBLE STOP.
AND I THOUGHT AT THE TIME THAT WAS KIND OF A RARITY, THAT THERE WOULD BE A STOP THAT'S INACCESSIBLE.
I FOUND OUT THROUGH MY FRIENDS THAT THERE ARE ACTUALLY, MANY, MANY STOPS THAT ARE INACCESSIBLE.
YEAH.
I MEAN, THINKING OF TRANSPORTATION THAT'S A HUGE ISSUE AREA.
THAT IS.
SO WITH ALL THESE THINGS BEING SUCH PARTS OF PEOPLE'S LIVES, HOW DO YOU MOVE FORWARD AND FIND SOLUTIONS?
LIKE, HOW DO YOU STRATEGIZE THAT IN YOUR OFFICE?
WELL, WE TRY TO PRIORITIZE, TRIED TO HAVE LIKE FIVE PRIORITIES AT A TIME.
YEAH.
BECAUSE WE CAN'T DO IT ALL AT ONCE, AND WE ARE A SMALL BUT MIGHTY OFFICE.
SO WE DO TRY TO TAKE A BREATH AND TAKE THINGS ONE AT A TIME.
WE ALSO LISTEN TO THE ADVOCATES THAT WE WORK WITH AND INVITE INTO OUR OFFICE AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE AND BY LISTENING TO THEIR PRIORITIES, THEY GENERALLY ALIGN WITH OURS.
THAT HELPS US FIGURE OUT WHAT WE'RE WORKING ON AND WHAT WE'RE MOVING TO NEXT.
BUT ALSO BECAUSE WE'RE IN CHARGE OF DEVELOPING THIS OLMSTEAD PLAN AND WE'RE HAVING TO PUT IT INTO LIKE A STRUCTURE AND LOOKING AT THINGS FROM HOW, YOU KNOW, WHAT IS THE DEFINED PROBLEM?
WHAT ARE THE PROPOSED SUGGESTIONS?
SURE.
IT KIND OF HELPS US KEEP ORGANIZED WHILE ALSO MAKING SURE IT WE'RE NOT LETTING CERTAIN THINGS FALL OFF THE TABLE.
SURE.
ANOTHER PART OF YOUR JOB OR I GUESS BASICALLY YOUR WHOLE JOB-- [LAUGHTER] IS TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ABILITY.
I WILL SAY I WAS A LITTLE EMBARRASSED NOT TO KNOW THAT IT PASSED IN 1990.
IT FELT MORE RECENT THAN I THOUGHT IT WAS, TO BE HONEST WITH YOU.
YEAH.
WHEN I THINK OF THE ADA IN MY HEAD, THAT WAS SOMETHING WE PASSED IN THE '70S NOT IN 1990.
[LAUGHTER] SO WHEN YOU LOOK AT THAT KNOWING THAT WE HAVE 33 YEARS SINCE THEN, THERE'S BEEN A LOT OF WORK TOWARDS IT, HOW DO YOU APPROACH THAT PART OF THE JOB?
I GUESS, CAN YOU GIVE US A SENSE OF HOW OUT OF COMPLIANCE WE MAY BE?
I THINK THE BIG THINGS, PEOPLE STOPPED, RIGHT?
I MEAN, ANYTHING THAT'S BEEN BUILT SINCE 1990 IS SUPPOSED TO BE ACCESSIBLE, SUPPOSED TO BE.
THEY AREN'T ALWAYS, BUT FOR THE MOST PART IN BUILDINGS FOR PLACES OF PUBLIC ACCOMMODATION, YOU CAN GET IN THE DOOR.
THERE'S ELEVATORS.
THE DEVIL'S IN THE DETAILS WHEN YOU START TO TALK ABOUT MEASUREMENTS AND DOORWAYS, AND IS A BATHROOM ENTIRELY ACCESSIBLE THE WAY THAT IT SHOULD BE?
THERE'S ALWAYS GOING TO BE ROOM FOR GROWTH.
JUST LIKE YOU MENTIONED NEW YORK CITY.
I MEAN, THEY ARE IN THE PROCESS.
A HUGE INVESTMENT HAS BEEN MADE TO MAKE THE SUBWAY STATIONS ACCESSIBLE.
YEAH.
IT'S CLEARLY GOING TO TAKE SOME TIME, AND WHEN YOU LOOK AROUND NEW YORK CITY, THERE'S CONSTANT CONSTRUCTION AND SAME WITH UPSTATE.
EVERY TIME SOMETHING NEW IS BUILT, SOMETHING IS TAKEN DOWN.
WE HAVE TO MAKE SURE THAT THINGS ARE STAYING ACCESSIBLE.
SO I THINK IT'S GONNA BE EVER GROWING AND YOU KNOW, EVERY DAY WE GET MORE AND MORE INTO COMPLIANCE.
BUT THERE'S ALWAYS GONNA BE SMALLER PLACES, PLACES THAT AREN'T FAMILIAR AND HAVE NEVER BEEN EXPOSED TO A DISABILITY POPULATION THAT AREN'T AS FAMILIAR.
SO WE TAKE THEM ONE STEP AT A TIME.
YOU KNOW, IF I'M A NEW YORKER AND I THINK ABOUT THIS ALL THE TIME IN TERMS OF THE SUBWAY STOPS AND I'M THINKING ABOUT THIS AS I'M ENTERING BUSINESSES AND THINGS LIKE THAT.
IF SOMEWHERE IS OUT OF COMPLIANCE OR COULD USE A MORE ACCESSIBLE STRUCTURE OR YOU KNOW, THEY ARE THE DOORWAYS AREN'T WIDE ENOUGH, THING LIKE THAT, IF I'M SOMEBODY WHO WANTS TO MAYBE LET YOU KNOW OR THE STATE KNOW ABOUT THAT, WHAT WOULD I DO?
YOU COULD EMAIL US.
WE HAVE AN EMAIL.
IT'S ACCESSIBILITY@EXEC.NY.GOV.
THAT'S THE BEST WAY TO GET A HOLD OF US.
WE WANT PEOPLE TO REACH OUT TO US.
THROUGH THIS EMAIL, WE'VE HEARD FROM A LOT OF PEOPLE.
SOME ON ACCESS ISSUES.
WE ACTUALLY JUST GOT ONE A COUPLE DAYS AGO AND WE'RE WORKING WITH THE TOWN AND THE INDEPENDENT LIVING CENTER THAT IS IN THAT TOWN TO MAKE THESE CHANGES AND WITH THE STATE AGENCY THAT'S INVOLVED.
SO BECAUSE WE ARE HOUSED IN THE GOVERNOR'S OFFICE, IT GIVES US ACCESS TO ALL OF THE STATE AGENCIES.
YEAH.
WE CAN PRETTY QUICKLY GET TO THE RIGHT PEOPLE THAT NEED TO MAKE THE CHANGES.
SO FAR, PEOPLE HAVE BEEN VERY OPEN, HAPPY, AND ACTUALLY EAGER TO HELP.
I THINK A LOT OF IT IS PEOPLE JUST STILL DON'T KNOW EVEN 33 YEARS LATER.
THAT'S WHAT I THINK, TOO.
THAT'S WHY I BROUGHT UP THE SUBWAY STOPS THING IS I THINK THAT THIS IS AN AREA THAT A LOT OF PEOPLE JUST DON'T THINK ABOUT IN THEIR DAILY LIVES.
YEAH.
BUT IN REALITY, IF I'M GOING TO THE GROCERY STORE AND THAT DOOR IS NOT ACCESSIBLE FOR SOMEBODY WHO NEEDS FOOD, THAT'S A PROBLEM.
RIGHT.
GIVEN THAT, YOU COVER SUCH A WIDE AREA OF ISSUES.
YOU'LL BE GOING INTO YOUR SECOND FULL YEAR SOON.
DO YOU HAVE ENOUGH RESOURCES IN THAT OFFICE TO DO ALL OF THIS?
[LAUGHTER] YEAH.
BECAUSE IT'S A WIDE RESPONSIBILITY.
THAT'S A FUN QUESTION.
MY TEAM, WHO RIGHT NOW IS MADE UP OF A GENTLEMAN NAMED BEN.
HE'S OUR SENIOR POLICY ADVISOR.
MY EA, KYM BUCHAN, KEEPS US ALL TOGETHER, AND WE HAVE TWO INTERNS.
WELL, ONE IS A FELLOW FROM HARVARD, AND WE HAVE AN INTERN FROM THE UNIVERSITY OF DENVER.
SO LIKE I SAID, SMALL BUT MIGHTY.
WE DO HAVE THREE JOBS THAT ARE POSTED RIGHT NOW.
SO WE ARE GROWING.
VERY EXCITED ABOUT THAT.
SO I ENCOURAGE ANYONE WHO'S WATCHING TO LOOK AT LINKEDIN ON THE GOVERNOR'S-- THE EXECUTIVE CHAMBER WEBSITE TO SEEK OUT THOSE JOBS AND WHAT IS REALLY IMPORTANT ABOUT OUR OFFICE IS THAT WE ARE LOOKING FOR PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES TO HIRE.
SO I HOPE THAT WE CAN CONTINUE TO GROW.
I MEAN, I KNOW WE'RE GROWING BY THREE JOBS IN THE NEXT FEW MONTHS, SO THAT'S EXCITING.
I DON'T KNOW THAT ANYONE IN THE EXECUTIVE CHAMBER WOULD EVER SAY WE HAVE ENOUGH PEOPLE TO DO OUR JOB.
YOU KNOW, IT'S A BIG STATE AND THERE'S A LOT OF DIFFERENT PRIORITIES.
SO I'M REALLY PROUD OF WHAT WE'VE BUILT SO FAR AND LOOKING FORWARD TO WHAT'S COMING IN THE FUTURE.
YES.
YOU HAVE QUITE A BIT TO DO.
KIM HILL, NEW YORK'S CHIEF DISABILITY OFFICER, THANK YOU SO MUCH.
THANKS FOR HAVING ME.
[ THEME MUSIC ] AND IF YOU MISSED THAT EMAIL ADDRESS AT THE END THERE, IT WAS ACCESSIBILITY@EXEC.NY.GOV.
BUT TURNING NOW TO A NEW EDITION OF ON THE BILL, WHERE WE TELL YOU ABOUT A BILL OUT OF ALBANY YOU THAT MIGHT NOT HEAR ABOUT OTHERWISE.
THIS WEEK, WE'RE DOING A FOLLOW-UP ON A75B, ALSO CALLED THE 9/11 NOTICE ACT.
IN THE YEARS AFTER 9/11, PEOPLE WHO WERE CLOSE TO THE ATTACK, LIKE FIRST RESPONDERS AND WORKERS WERE GETTING SICK AND DEVELOPING LONG-TERM HEALTH PROBLEMS.
SO CONGRESS APPROVED NEW FUNDING IN 2010 TO HELP PEOPLE PAY FOR TREATMENT.
THAT SET UP THE SEPTEMBER 11TH VICTIM COMPENSATION FUND, BUT TO THIS DAY, A LOT OF PEOPLE WHO WORKED IN THE AREA AND MIGHT HAVE GOTTEN SICK HAVE NOT FILED A CLAIM.
THAT BRINGS TO US THE 9/11 NOTICE ACT.
IT'S A BILL THAT WOULD REQUIRE BUSINESSES WITH 50 OR MORE EMPLOYEES TO TELL PAST AND PRESENT WORKERS THEY COULD QUALIFY FOR THE FUND, AND AFTER WE TOLD YOU ABOUT THE BILL, IT PASSED THE STATE LEGISLATURE UNANIMOUSLY THIS YEAR.
THAT MEANS IT'S NOW UP TO GOVERNOR KATHIE HOCHUL TO EITHER SIGN THE BILL OR VETO IT.
MICHAEL BARASCH IS AN ATTORNEY WHO REPRESENTED 9/11 VICTIMS AND THEIR FAMILIES FOR THE PAST TWO DECADES.
WHILE OVER 85% OF THE FIRST RESPONDERS HAVE BEEN ENROLLED IN THE WORLD TRADE CENTER HEALTH PROGRAM, LESS THAN 10% OF THE DOWNTOWN OFFICE WORKERS, STUDENTS, TEACHERS AND RESIDENTS ARE ENROLLED.
THEY SIMPLY DON'T KNOW THAT THEY ARE ENTITLED TO THE BENEFITS, AND THIS BILL GOES A LONG WAY TO EDUCATING PEOPLE.
THAT'S ALL WE'RE ASKING.
WE'LL LET YOU KNOW WHEN THE GOVERNOR MAKES A DECISION, BUT MOVING ON NOW TO THE ISSUE OF ABORTION IN NEW YORK.
WHEN THE U.S. SUPREME COURT OVERTURNED ROE V. WADE LAST YEAR, IT CAUSED A LOT OF CONFUSION ABOUT ACCESS TO ABORTION.
A LOT OF PEOPLE DIDN'T KNOW IF ABORTION WAS STILL LEGAL IN THEIR STATE AND IN THE PAST YEAR, SOME STATES HAVE PASSED SOME REALLY STRICT LIMITS ON ABORTION.
AND THAT'S BECAUSE IT'S BEEN THE FIRST TIME IN FIVE DECADES THAT WAS EVEN AN OPTION FOR THOSE STATES.
BUT IN NEW YORK THAT HASN'T HAPPENED AND IT'S NOT EXPECTED TO, AT LEAST ANYTIME SOON.
AND THAT GOT US THINKING ABOUT HOW CONFUSING ALL OF THIS IS FOR EVERYONE.
SO IN THIS NEW INSTALLMENT OF OUR CIVIC SERIES, NEW YORK AND, WE EXPLORE THE TOPIC OF ABORTION AND HOW DIFFERENT LEVELS OF GOVERNMENT PLAY A ROLE.
[ THEME MUSIC ] WELCOME TO NEW YORK AND ABORTION LAW.
I'M ALEXIS YOUNG.
FOR DECADES, REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH CARE HAS BEEN A CONTENTIOUS POLITICAL ISSUE IN THE U.S., PARTICULARLY WHEN IT COMES TO ABORTION, AND WHEN THE SUPREME COURT OVERTURNED ROE V. WADE IN 2022, THE ISSUE GAINED NATIONAL ATTENTION.
BUT WHAT DOES THE OVERTURNING OF ROE V. WADE MEAN AND WHAT DO ABORTION LAWS LOOK LIKE AT THE STATE LEVEL IN NEW YORK?
LET'S TAKE A LOOK.
ROE V. WADE WAS A 197 FEDERAL SUPREME COURT DECISION, WHICH GUARANTEED THE RIGHT TO AN ABORTION WITH CERTAIN STIPULATIONS.
STATES WERE LIMITED IN THE RESTRICTIONS THEY COULD PUT ON ABORTION BECAUSE THE PROCEDURES WERE CONSTITUTIONALLY PROTECTED AT THE FEDERAL LEVEL.
IN THE DECADES AFTER ROE WAS ENSHRINED, THERE WAS A CONSTANT STRUGGLE BETWEEN SETTLED FEDERAL LAW AND STATES WHO WANTED THE ABILITY TO SELF-REGULATE.
IN 1992, THE SUPREME COURT HEARD PLANNED PARENTHOOD VERSUS KACIE IN WHICH THEY, AGAIN, YOUNG HELD THE RIGHT TO AN ABORTION BUT ALSO GAVE STATES MORE ROOM TO REGULATE IT.
IN 2022, THE SUPREME COURT HEARD DOBBS VERSUS JACKSON WOMEN'S HEALTH ORGANIZATION, IN WHICH THEY EXAMINED A MISSISSIPPI LAW THAT PLACED CERTAIN TIME RESTRICTIONS ON ABORTION PROCEDURES.
THE COURT DECIDED THE MISSISSIPPI LAW IS LEGAL WHILE ALSO OVERTURNING ROE V. WADE.
THE RESULT OF THIS IS NOT A FEDERAL ABORTION BAN BUT RATHER A REMOVAL OF THE CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO AN ABORTION.
WITH ROE OFFICIALLY OVERTURNED, STATES NOW HAVE MORE ROOM TO APPLY THE LAW AS THEY SEE FIT, WHICH HAS RESULTED IN GREATER RESTRICTIONS AND BANS ACROSS THE COUNTRY.
BUT WHAT DOES THIS MEAN FOR NEW YORK?
WHAT DO ABORTION LAWS LOOK LIKE IN OUR STATE?
[ JAZZ MUSIC PLAYING ] THE RIGHT TO AN ABORTION WAS LEGALIZED IN NEW YORK IN 1970 AND THEN REINFORCED BY THE REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH ACT, WHICH PASSED IN 2019.
AS IT CURRENTLY STANDS, PEOPLE IN NEW YORK HAD THE RIGHT TO AN ABORTION WITHIN THE FIRST 24 WEEKS OF PREGNANCY.
ABORTION PROCEDURES ARE ALLOWED OUTSIDE THE 24 -- WEEK WINDOW IF THE FETUS IS NO LONGER VIABLE OR IF THE PATIENT'S HEALTH IS AT RISK.
THIS LAW APPLIES TO BOTH NEW YORK RESIDENTS AND VISITORS.
SO THE PROTECTIONS ARE PRETTY STRAIGHT FORWARD.
WE HAVE LAWS ON THE BOOKS THAT ALLOW PEOPLE TO GET ABORTION PROCEDURES WITH CERTAIN RESTRICTIONS IN PLACE.
BUT THERE'S A GROWING MOVEMENT TO FURTHER ADVANCE THESE PROTECTIONS WHICH WOULD BE DONE BY ENSHRINING THE EQUAL RIGHTS AMENDMENT INTO THE STATE CONSTITUTION.
THE EQUAL RIGHTS AMENDMENT, OR THE ERA, WOULD EXPAND A VARIETY OF ANTI-DISCRIMINATORY SAFEGUARDS AND CONSTITUTIONALLY PROTECT THE RIGHT TO AN ABORTION IN NEW YORK.
BUT WHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A RIGHT THAT IS CODIFIED BY LAW VERSUS A RIGHT THAT IS PROTECTED BY THE STATE CONSTITUTION?
WE ASKED KATHARINE BODDE AND JENNA LAUTER, TWO LEGAL EXPERTS FROM THE NEW YORK'S CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION.
WELL, WE SAY THAT THE RIGHT TO ABORTION IS CODIFIED IN STATE LAW, WHAT WE MEAN IS THAT NEW YORK STATE'S OWN STATUTES PROVIDE AN ALTERNATIVE SOURCE OF THE RIGHT TO AN ABORTION.
SO NEW YORK LAW, THROUGH STATE STATUTE, PROVIDES THAT ABORTION IS LEGAL HERE IN NEW YORK STATE AND NOT ONLY LEGAL BUT PROTECTED AS WELL.
IN ORDER TO AMEND THE NEW YORK STATE CONSTITUTION, YOU HAVE TO GO THROUGH ESSENTIALLY THREE-FOLD PROCESS, SO THE LEGISLATURE HAS TO PASS THE AMENDMENT IN TWO CONSECUTIVE LEGISLATIVE SESSIONS AND THEN THE AMENDMENT GOES ON THE ACTUAL BALLOT BEFORE THE PEOPLE FOR A REFERENDUM VOTE.
THE CONSTITUTION IS MORE DIFFICULT TO CHANGE.
IT IS LESS SUBJECT TO POLITICAL WINDS AND CERTAINLY WE HAVE SEEN STRONG WINDS OVER THE PAST DECADE OR SO.
SUPPORTERS WANT ABORTION RIGHTS ENSHRINED IN THE STATE CONSTITUTION BECAUSE IT WOULD THEN BECOME MORE DIFFICULT TO REMOVE THEM, BUT OPPONENTS DON'T WANT THAT FOR THE SAME REASON.
WHERE DOES THE ERA CURRENTLY STAND IN THE LEGAL PROCESS?
WITH RESPECT TO THE ERA, THAT HAS NOW PASSED THE LEGISLATURE IN TWO CONSECUTIVE SESSIONS AND THE NEXT STEP IS FOR IT TO GO BEFORE THE PEOPLE FOR A VOTE.
IF YOU ARE A NEW YORKER, YOU WILL BE ABLE TO VOTE FOR OR AGAINST THE EQUAL RIGHTS AMENDMENT IN THE NOVEMBER 2024 ELECTION.
SO KEEP THAT IN MIND.
[ JAZZ MUSIC PLAYS ] SO WE KNOW WHAT THE ABORTION SITUATION IS AT THE STATE LEVEL AND WE KNOW WHERE THE SUPREME COURT STANDS ON THE ISSUE, BUT IS IT POSSIBLE FOR ABORTION TO BECOME ILLEGAL IN NEW YORK EVEN THOUGH THERE ARE STATE LAWS SAYING OTHERWISE?
WE ASKED KATHARINE BODDE FROM NYCLU.
IF CONGRESS PASSED AND THE PRESIDENT SIGNED A LAW THAT MADE ABORTION ILLEGAL ACROSS THE COUNTRY, THEN OUR RULE OF FEDERALISM, WHERE FEDERAL LAW IS SUPREME TO STATE LAW WOULD GOVERN.
FEDERALISM IS WHEN A TERRITORY IS PRESIDED OVER BY MULTIPLE LEVELS OF GOVERNMENT.
FOR EXAMPLE, ROCHESTER, NEW YORK, HAS ITS OWN CITY GOVERNMENT, WHICH IS SUBJECT TO THE LAWS OF NEW YORK STATE'S GOVERNMENT, WHICH IS SUBJECT TO THE LAWS OF THE U.S. GOVERNMENT, AND THE TOP OF THE FOOD CHAIN HAS FINAL SAY WITH CERTAIN EXCEPTIONS GIVEN BY THE U.S. CONSTITUTION.
THIS IS ALL TO SAY A FEDERAL ABORTION BAN OR RESTRICTION WOULD SUPERSEDE STATE LAW.
SO AT THE RISK OF BEING TOO SPECULATIVE, WHAT WOULD HAPPEN IN THAT CASE?
I THINK, YOU KNOW, IT'S PROBABLY RELATIVELY SAFE TO ASSUME THAT WHATEVER FEDERAL ADMINISTRATION PASSES A NATIONWIDE ABORTION BAN IS ALSO GOING TO BE FAIRLY INVESTED IN ENFORCING THAT AT THE FEDERAL LEVEL.
THAT SAID, THERE MAY BE AVENUES FOR NEW YORK STATE TO LIMIT THE EXTENT TO WHICH IT CONTRIBUTES TO AND SUPPORTS PROSECUTION UNDER FEDERAL LAW.
SO FOR INSTANCE, NEW YORK MIGHT UNDER THIS SCENARIO, EXPLORE WAYS THAT IT COULD PROHIBIT LAW ENFORCEMENT PROSECUTORS FROM FACILITATING FEDERAL GOVERNMENT EFFORTS TO ARREST OR INVESTIGATE PEOPLE WHO ARE INVOLVED IN ABORTION CARE IN NEW YORK AND COULD DIRECT STATE-LEVEL PROSECUTORS NOT TO SEEK PROSECUTION UNDER FEDERAL ANTIABORTION CHARGES.
THERE'S ALSO ANOTHER ASTERISK TO CONSIDER WHEN LOOKING AT NEW YORK'S ABORTION LAWS.
THE LAWS OF OTHER STATES.
ONE STATE'S LAWS DO NOT SUPERSEDE ANOTHER'S.
IF DELAWARE DECIDED THAT NOBODY COULD LEAVE THEIR HOUSE UNLESS THEY WERE WEARING A SPARKLY FANNY PACK, WE IN NEW YORK WOULDN'T HAVE TO WORRY ABOUT IT, UNLESS WE WANTED TO VISIT DELAWARE IN WHICH CASE YOU'D NEED TO STRAP UP.
IF SOMEBODY WAS VISITING NEW YORK TO GET ABORTION PILLS AND WAS FROM A STATE WHERE ABORTION IS BANNED, THEY WOULD NEED TO GO THROUGH THE ENTIRE PROCESS AND HANDLE ANY AFTERCARE OR COMPLICATIONS IN NEW YORK BEFORE RETURNING TO THEIR HOME STATE IN ORDER TO MINIMIZE THE RISK OF LITIGATION OR PROSECUTION.
THERE'S A LOT TO TAKE AWAY FROM ALL THIS.
THE ESTABLISHMENT OF FEDERAL AND STATE LAWS AND THE WAY THEY ARE ENFORCED IS IN A FREQUENT STATE OF FLUX.
THE LEGAL BATTLE AROUND THE RIGHT TO AN ABORTION SHOWS NO SIGN OF SLOWING DOWN.
THOUGH THROUGH THE FOG, THERE'S ONE CONSTANT, THE MAJORITY OF AMERICAN PEOPLE HAVE SUPPORTED THE RIGHT TO AN ABORTION IN SOME CAPACITY FOR DECADES.
THANKS FOR TAPPING IN.
UNTIL NEXT TIME, BE WELL, BE GOOD AND STAY INFORMED.
[ THEME MUSIC ] AND YOU CAN FIND MORE FROM OUR CIVIC SERIES ON OUR WEBSITE.
AS ALWAYS, THAT'S AT NYNOW.ORG.
WE'LL SEE YOU NEXT WEEK.
THANKS FOR WATCHING THIS WEEK'S "NEW YORK NOW."
HAVE A GREAT WEEK AND BE WELL.
[ THEME MUSIC ] ANNOUNCER: FUNDING FOR "NEW YORK NOW" IS PROVIDED BY WNET.
- News and Public Affairs
Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.
- News and Public Affairs
FRONTLINE is investigative journalism that questions, explains and changes our world.
Support for PBS provided by:
New York NOW is a local public television program presented by WMHT
Support for New York NOW is provided by WNET/Thirteen.