Conversations for the Common Good
Pennsylvania Innocence Project
11/12/2026 | 55m 14sVideo has Closed Captions
We explore wrongful convictions, the pursuit of justice, and the fight to free the innocent.
WVIA Public Media and the Pennsylvania Innocence Project present a special edition of Conversations for the Common Good, exploring the human impact of wrongful convictions. Through personal stories, short documentaries, and expert discussions, the program examines the pursuit of justice, the challenges of rebuilding lives, and the resilience of those wrongfully imprisoned.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Conversations for the Common Good is a local public television program presented by WVIA
Conversations for the Common Good
Pennsylvania Innocence Project
11/12/2026 | 55m 14sVideo has Closed Captions
WVIA Public Media and the Pennsylvania Innocence Project present a special edition of Conversations for the Common Good, exploring the human impact of wrongful convictions. Through personal stories, short documentaries, and expert discussions, the program examines the pursuit of justice, the challenges of rebuilding lives, and the resilience of those wrongfully imprisoned.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Conversations for the Common Good
Conversations for the Common Good is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship- Hello, everyone, and welcome to "Conversations for the Common Good: The Pennsylvania Innocence Project".
On any given day, roughly 6% of people incarcerated in Pennsylvania's prisons are serving time for crimes they did not commit.
That amounts to several thousand people, and that's just here in Pennsylvania.
Once convicted of a crime, it can be extraordinarily difficult for an innocent person to clear their name and secure their freedom.
And that is where the Pennsylvania Innocence Project comes in.
Since opening their doors in 2009, they have worked to release at least 40 innocent people from behind bars, people who lost a collective 1,000 years of their lives to wrongful convictions.
Over the next hour, we'll hear from several of those exonerees about their quest for vindication and life after their release.
We'll also hear from the Innocence Project's executive director.
But first, a look at how the Pennsylvania Innocence Project came to be.
- September the 9th, 2005, I remember that.
I'll never forget that day.
(somber music) Them taking me to the Roundhouse and never let me go.
- Being innocent, I'm also a victim.
The culprit to me is actually the system.
- There's a significant history here, which I think starts with the Innocence Project in New York City and some of the early exonerations in the late 1980s and the early 1990s when DNA was finally recognized at the courts as kind of the gold standard.
- And what we learned from the Innocence Project was that they were inundated with applications from Pennsylvania inmates.
- By then, the consciousness had started to change.
- Until that point, there was the assumption that the criminal justice system much more often than not got it right.
- The number of innocent people in prisons ranged anywhere, the experts said from maybe 3% to 8%, which sounds low.
It sounds well the system got it right, you know, but that's thousands of people.
- And if you told people that the mission was to secure freedom and release from incarceration for people imprisoned for crimes they had not committed, it was sort of like a revelation to them.
(bright music) - And everything came together.
We had great support in this community, which is very public interested bar here.
We had law students, many law students from all the area law schools, lawyers who worked pro bono on these cases.
- We opened our doors in April of 2009, but before then the word was already out in the prisons, so we opened up with a stack of mail to get started.
- It was like a moment of clarity when you see how many people really care 'cause when you got so many nights when you just by yourself and you looking over your law work or you just lost, you really trying to hold it together and you praying for help, but you don't know that the help is there.
So it was like, it was like a vindication moment.
- The number one thing that they say, that they have said is never give up.
(inspirational music) (screen whooshing) - When the Pennsylvania Innocence Project opened up, these guys had faith again.
- It was like for a person that's innocent, that's what you looking for.
You really looking for somebody that's like, "All right, well, look, I believe you."
- And I feel brave.
I feel courageous, you know, each day and I'm humble.
- There's nothing more powerful than walking an innocent person out of court.
- Know if you innocent, this is what you can do.
Don't let 'em take your humanity.
Like, when you right, you right.
- People are now where they ought to be, not in prison.
They're home in the community.
And what strikes me is most of the people, most of them, without bitterness.
- You wanna help people, you wanna make a difference.
You see a wrong and you wanna right it.
- It's heartening, gratifying that there are resources to try and right those wrongs.
- I'm going to be okay.
I'm going to be okay.
(inspirational music) - Yahya Moore now works as a paralegal for the Innocence Project and joins us for our conversation.
During his 27-year wrongful incarceration, he studied law and worked to secure his own exoneration as well as those of several wrongly-convicted peers.
He is an author, educator, and passionate advocate for those still working toward their freedom, as well as a practitioner of restorative justice.
Termaine Hicks is a board member of the Pennsylvania Innocence Project after being wrongly incarcerated for 19 years.
During that time, he developed a passion for creative writing, which became the foundation for his own nonprofit, Step Up, which empowers students to speak out against gun violence and bullying.
Also joining us is Donte Rollins, who was wrongly convicted of participating in a shooting that left a young child paralyzed.
He was sentenced to 62 and a half to 125 years in prison, essentially a life sentence.
It took 10 years, but with the help of the Pennsylvania Innocence Project and the tireless efforts of his mother, Donte was proven innocent and released to start a new chapter of his life.
And finally, the executive director of the Pennsylvania Innocence Project, Zane Memeger.
Zane is a former US attorney for Philadelphia.
Prior to that, as an assistant US Attorney, he investigated and tried cases involving organized crime, public corruption, government fraud, violent crime, and narcotics trafficking.
Before becoming executive director for the Innocence Project, Zane served as an active board member for eight years.
Welcome to you all.
Thank you for being with us.
Zane, I wanna begin with you.
What are some of the factors that lead to wrongful convictions in the first place?
- Yeah, there are a number of factors and they're tracked by the National Registry of Exonerations.
But one of the factors that comes into play is faulty forensic science.
DNA is the gold standard and oftentimes, when you obtain DNA evidence, you might be able to match it to the individual who committed the crime, but that science is evolving over time.
And what we've learned is technology that wasn't available back when a conviction occurred has now advanced to a point where additional testing will demonstrate that the individual who was convicted is now an excluded person, which allows us to go back into court and argue new evidence and that they ought to be released from prison for a crime that they did not commit.
But some other things that happened, for example, in arson cases, forensic science has evolved in arson.
Fire investigators back in the '70s, '80s, and '90s thought that certain burn patterns meant that a fire was set intentionally, or the way glass broke meant that the fire was set intentionally, but science has evolved and those understandings now are that some of those burn patterns were accidental.
Some of the way the glass broke was accidental.
And so you have people in prison for crimes that were, in fact, not crimes.
And so we'll work to try and get those people exonerated.
In cases, you'll have eyewitness identifications.
And what we've learned over time is that eyewitness identifications are not perfect.
People may be under stress, it may be dark out, it may be poor lighting conditions, it may be too far a distance, a whole lot of factors in play.
And one of the changes that's happened in the law is allowing to bring in expert witnesses to testify about eyewitness identifications because they can be fallible and that may be a justification to get a conviction reversed.
False confessions is another issue.
People think that if I were to get picked up, brought to a police station, and asked a series of questions, I would tell the truth, even if it were a prolonged interrogation.
The reality is, a lot of people, when they're put under a lot of stress, they're deprived of sleep, they're deprived of food, they're deprived of water.
The police are allowed to lie and say things that aren't true to see what your reaction is.
People buckle under that mental stress and if you're suffering from mental disabilities or you're a young person, it may be that you admit to something that you clearly did not do, but once you admit it, that is gonna be one of the basis for the government to pursue a criminal prosecution against you.
Other issues involve official misconduct.
Prosecutors have an obligation to seek justice.
They have an obligation to do the right thing.
I served as a prosecutor for 18 years and the rules are very clear in terms of your obligation to disclose information that is exculpatory or beneficial to the defense, you're supposed to turn that information over.
But in a number of the cases that we work on, we find evidence within the case files of statements that witnesses made saying something totally different than what the person was tried for, evidence with regard to test results not being turned over to the defense, a whole list of different things.
And that violates your obligation, that can be misconduct and police officers can engage in misconduct as well.
And sometimes they don't turn over information to the prosecutor that would maybe change the prosecutor's mind about pursuing a certain individual.
And then inadequate defense counsel, that is a significant issue.
Public defense in Pennsylvania is underfunded and your defense lawyer is your shield against the weight of the government coming after you criminally.
And if they don't have the resources and means to investigate your case, look at witnesses, test alibis, test the scientific evidence that's available in your case, it may be that you end up getting wrongfully convicted.
So we spend a lot of time working our cases to find people who are actually innocent based upon the facts.
- You mentioned police misconduct and that leads me to you, Termaine, because in your case, you were accused of sexual assault when, in fact, you were actually trying to help a victim of sexual assault when police arrived.
You were shot by police in that process.
You did time for that.
Can you talk about the role of police misconduct in your case?
- Yes.
Unfortunately for me, a woman was being attacked.
I did not know her and I just responded and I did what I thought anybody would do when they hear a woman screaming.
And by the time I got to the scene, the police had arrived right behind me and they took my hand in my pocket as a threatening gesture when I was just wanting to pull my cell phone out.
But before my hand came out my pocket, they shot me three times in my back and this is where the corruption come in at, you know?
They just covered it up.
They planted the gun and the gun that they said that I had was actually registered to a Philadelphia police officer and was not reported stolen until after they shot me.
They came up with a story that they shot me three times in my chest after they told me to get off the victim and to put my hands up.
One, I don't have any bullet holes in my chest.
They're all in my back.
And two, they said after they shot me that I put this bloody gun back in my pocket before I fell to the ground.
There was no blood inside my pocket.
And, you know, there was a surveillance tape that captured part of the assault unraveling.
You see the victim being accosted by an assailant, you see his clothing.
I didn't even match the description.
However, that surveillance tape disappeared.
Matter of fact, the jury never saw the tape.
The Innocence Project never saw the tape and it just vanished.
And I ultimately wound up going to trial eight days and 20 officers testified against me and I was convicted.
I was convicted of rape, of aggravated assault, of possession of instrument of crime, and terroristic threats and I was sentenced to 12 and a half to 25 years.
Because in PA you have to admit culpability in order to make parole, I did not accept culpability for a crime that I did not commit and the parole board denied me and I wound up sitting and waiting while I was still challenging my conviction.
And this is where the Innocence Project came in and they got behind me and they hired an expert, Dr.
Michael Baden, world renowned forensic pathologist.
And he looked over my medical records, he examined my clothing, and concluded that the police had lied, that they actually shot this guy in the back.
And that prompted the district attorney's office to take a closer look at my case.
And they concluded that obviously if they lied about this, then they lied about everything else leading up to it and that the conviction couldn't stand.
And this started the process and this is how my conviction was ultimately overturned.
And I walked out of the penitentiary almost six years now.
- And Zane, to Termaine's point, once you are convicted, it can be incredibly difficult if you are innocent to prove your innocence and to clear your name.
And I think Termaine hinted at some of the reasons that that happens, but talk about that.
Why does it take 10, 20, 30, 40 years sometimes for someone to clear their name?
- Yeah, so you are given your initial due process.
So you're given a trial.
If you lose at trial, you're entitled to appeal your conviction.
Here in Pennsylvania, you would appeal it to the Superior Court.
And then if the Superior Court denies you relief, you could appeal it to the Supreme Court, which can decide whether or not to take up your case or not.
But if they deny you relief, that is called exhaustion of your direct rights of appeal.
At that point in time, in Pennsylvania, there's the Post-Conviction Relief Act, which is a statute that gives individuals the right to challenge their conviction once their direct appeals is over, but you have to bring your claims within one year and you really have to demonstrate that there was something that occurred during your trial that was unconstitutional or in violation of the criminal rules of procedure.
But once that one year passes, the only way you can really get back into court is if there's some type of new evidence.
And so I talked earlier about, well, new evidence can be new testing results, new forensic science that undermines the conviction, or eyewitnesses who testified at your trial now have come forward and recanted their testimony, that can be considered new testimony as well.
It may be that you learn during the course of looking at a case that the prosecutor failed to comply with their obligations, so you find the statements that were in their possession but not turned over to the defense.
You find the test reports that weren't turned over to the defense and that may give you an avenue to pursue new evidence pursuant to the Post-Conviction Relief Act.
But gathering that evidence is really hard and time consuming.
And oftentimes that evidence doesn't arise until after that one year bar has occurred.
The system likes finality and it believes that it's gotten it right.
And the system works well in certain ways, but in other ways, it doesn't work well.
And I've seen it from both sides and the system gets it wrong.
And I think it's important for people to understand that the system can get it wrong, but more importantly, that prosecutors and judges understand that the system can get it wrong and that they're not infallible and they should be willing to take a look at a case that gives pause or serious concern in terms of the factual evidence that was present that led to a conviction.
- Yahya, you spent 27 years in jail for a murder that you did not commit.
What did it take for you to clear your name?
- For me, it took resilience.
And under resilience is standing in the law library, writing hundreds of letters, just staying in the fight because, you know, you have to be resilient because, you know, this fight, it wears you down.
It wears you down.
And studying the law myself and, you know, I had to go pro se, which is I had to represent myself.
And so putting in petition after petition after petition and knowing that the law is on your side, but you still getting these denials, you still get 'em and you go back and you read the law again, you be like, "Well, why, I'm right."
And then you go to other people like, "This is what it says, right?"
And you still get denied.
And it could wear you down.
It could immobilize you, but it takes resilience.
And another thing it takes is help.
It takes help.
No one could do it by themselves.
I don't care how many times you go in the law library.
I don't care how many letters you write.
It takes help.
It takes organizations like the Pennsylvania Innocence Project.
You know, it takes help.
- Donte, you were accused and convicted in connection with a shooting that left a young child paralyzed.
And even though you were miles away from the crime at the time that it happened, besides being misidentified by a relative of the victim, you had a defense attorney who did not present key evidence that could have exonerated you probably fairly quickly, and then a judge who refused to dismiss the charges repeatedly.
What effect did your time in prison have on you, especially being wrongfully convicted, and what kept you going during those years?
- Well, just wanting to be home, not wanting to be the end of my story, and knowing that I was, like, innocent.
My mom, you know, she was able to obtain evidence to help me receive my freedom and (Donte clearing throat) you don't have no other choice but to keep going.
For real it was like, it's either that or just die in jail and that wasn't, like, an option for me.
- So it was just knowing that that was not the end of your story, that your mom was working for your release and others, and that's kind of how you got through all those years behind bars?
- Yeah, for sure.
- Yeah.
Eduardo Ramirez was 19 years old when he was convicted of a crime he did not commit.
He spent the next 27 years in jail.
He says he survived with the help of mentors, the Innocence Project, and his paintbrush.
(bright music) - At the end of the day, I thought the truth would win out.
I didn't know what was coming.
I spent all of my 20s, all of my 30s, and most of my 40s, a total of 27 and a half years in prison for something I didn't do.
I carry that with me every day.
What I have discovered about prisons in general is where there is a will, there is a way, that you can make much out of little if you're determined enough.
(bright music) (car honking) You have a million and one distractions out here.
You got bills, you got kids, you got work, you got family, you got all that.
I only had one problem and that was being in prison.
I couldn't think about that 24 hours a day, so I was able to think about a lot of other things.
Who is Eddie?
How does Eddie sort of, like, move forward in the world that best represents what Eddie is about?
And I spent the better part of 27 and a half years kind of sitting with that.
I met older individuals who were like, "The next step is freedom."
(bright music continues) And so they really mentored me and put me on a path with education and community work and artwork.
I have a background as a, like I like to say, a vandal in the city of Philadelphia.
I was a graffiti artist.
If the name Jerk has ever appeared on your property, I apologize.
I know that people wanna say I'm an artist, and again, I balk at labels.
I'm just a person who uses art to enroll people in a different conversation.
People have said to me, "Maybe, you know, there's a reason for what happened to you.
Maybe if you hadn't gone to prison, you wouldn't have discovered this part of yourself."
And I like to say, "Well, maybe if I hadn't gone to prison, I would have discovered another part of myself.
I would have been, you know, Bill Gates."
You know, the what if isn't really what I'm involved in, it's the what is.
All these things happen, but the Innocence Project in particular came on board in 2016 and didn't leave my side.
- They write to us.
It's their family.
It's their resilience.
Eddie's the one that really does the work.
- Nilam met me at the front gate as I was leaving the prison.
- It's so joyous to see one of our clients, like Eddie says, you know, really become like family, walk out those doors.
But then when I drive away that night, I'm always remembering how many of our clients are still there.
- It's less about me.
I'm just a small part of this, right?
I'm one individual.
It's about the thousands, like, literally thousands, maybe tens of thousands of innocent people in the United States of America who are sitting in jails and prisons for something they did not do, and that is a tragedy.
(bright music continues) - Zane, when a wrongly-convicted person is exonerated and released, what compensation do they receive from the state?
- Yeah, in Pennsylvania, you receive no compensation from the state and you receive no services.
Essentially, you're exonerated, the prison door opens, you walk out, and the prison officials say, "Good luck."
We are one of a handful of states now that doesn't have compensation laws on the book where individuals are compensated for each year wrongful confinement.
Oftentimes it ranges between 50 and $75,000 per year of wrongful conviction.
We're in the process of trying to get a bill passed in Pennsylvania to deal with that compensation piece.
One avenue that individuals have is that they can try to sue the state or the municipality or county that wrongfully convicted them and led them to prison, but those are hard lawsuits to pursue.
They're hard lawsuits to win because you end up in litigation again following your exoneration and you may end up in a re-trial over the facts and you may end up not getting anything as a result of suing the Commonwealth.
But the reality is their lives are being stripped away and nothing being provided when they walk out the door.
And in terms of services, one of the things that we do at the Innocence Project is deal with re-entry and we deal with the individual coming home and getting their driver's licenses and the necessary paperwork in order.
We help them find housing.
We help them deal with getting health benefits, dealing with social security, help them get education and job training, help them find employment, help them deal with perhaps substance abuse issues if they're present or dealing with mental health issues if they're present.
Being incarcerated leads to additional trauma.
And when you add on top of that, that an innocent person is in prison for something that they didn't do, you can only imagine what that trauma is that they have to work through every single day.
And while individuals may look fine from the outside, there's a lot still going on that none of us will ever understand unless we've been there, but we help them try to navigate that piece and those are resources that aren't provided by the state at the present time.
- I wanna revisit a couple of things that you just mentioned, but it is stunning to think that people could spend years, if not decades, of their lives in prison wrongfully convicted and then come out and there is nothing for them, at least not yet.
In fact, LaFaye Gaskins is among those who received no state compensation for the 34 years he spent in jail on a wrongful conviction.
He was sent to jail in large part on false testimony and poor legal representation and in spite of a complete lack of evidence.
(gentle music) - 34.
34 years I've been in prison.
I was wrongly convicted of a crime that I didn't commit.
- [Edward] He'd been convicted based on the testimony of somebody who was high on crack, who said she saw him from behind from a couple hundred yards.
- He was given a court-appointed lawyer who did not put on a defense case at all.
- It was pretty obvious that there wasn't a single shred of evidence that LaFaye had done this.
- That's when I started learning how to get myself out.
So I had a typewriter, I had paper, and we start doing it, writing the hundreds of letters to the lawyers, writing to everybody.
When you're trying to prove your innocence, you're going to have sleepless nights and you want people to help you and you want people to believe you.
(gentle music continues) Dan, the reporter, wrote the story about me.
That's when I had the highest hope because now I got one person to believe in me.
Now I know I can get other people to believe in me.
- He was very committed to trying to prove his innocence.
He was fighting for himself.
- And I got that letter saying, "Hey, we gonna take on your case."
That was my moment of true hope.
(gentle music swells) - What the public doesn't know is the Innocence Project is not just looking for cases.
People apply and extensive research that goes into this before the project is willing to put their name behind it.
- Innocent Project did they investigation, did they research, did they interviews, and they said they was willing to take my case.
That was the best thing that ever happened to me because I'm here.
What kept me going in there was my daughter.
All the things that she was doing made me say, "Hey, you know, I need to keep on going."
- LaFaye had never seen his daughter outside of prison.
Them getting to be together, that's what it meant to me was seeing LaFaye's mom get to hug him and bring him home.
- Nothing went more emotional in my entire career to see him walk out the door and hug his mother after the 35 years in prison.
- My release date was the day I retained my freedom to be whoever I can be.
- [Edward] LaFaye is home.
He'd been in since he was in his early 20s and he now has a chance at a good life.
- My homecoming was seeing the people that really genuinely cared for me.
That was my homecoming and that was my mom and my daughter.
So that's what I'm grateful for and I'm happy even today.
(gentle music continues) - Termaine, most of us cannot imagine the trauma that comes with being wrongfully incarcerated, and Zane mentioned it just a moment ago.
And the fact that the trauma doesn't always end when you walk out the door of the prison.
Can you talk about how those years impacted you and how the trauma doesn't always end when your release day comes around?
- Right.
I mean, so we all suffer and endure the trauma differently.
You know, for me, once I woke up in the hospital when I was alive, you know, I had to do some type of reality check, right, to figure this out.
And how am I get, you know, myself back together, but more importantly, my freedom and get back to my family.
And just the trauma of being incarcerated for something that you did not do is immeasurable.
You know, you fighting the boogieman, for real.
And some of your punches, or most of your punches ain't landing.
You swinging and they not landing.
And then you have just the prison life.
You know, there's never a silent night in prison, never.
Somebody yelling on their gate from they cell 24/7.
So, you know, you learn how to block out certain things and you learn how to just forge on, to go through it.
And, you know, Yahya mentioned it, it's resilience, right?
And all you're doing while you're incarcerated wrongfully is you're suppressing it.
You're not necessarily dealing with it because you're dealing with the issue of trying to get the hell out of jail.
So you suppressing this, you know, traumatic situation that happened to you, these physical and emotional scars that you're dealing with for decades, you know, for decades.
And then, you know, you get the fortunate letter or the jubilant phone call saying that one, that an organization like the Innocence Project has accepted your case.
(Termaine laughing) It still took them 12 years to get me out, right?
But then two, you get that phone call saying you're going home and you're happy.
But when you get there, you know, you're taking that all in and it is a great place.
It's probably the best feeling that I ever experienced in my life, but so much comes with it.
When I went to prison, my only child, my son was four years old.
The day that I walked out of prison, my grandson was four.
So, you know, you try to wrap your head around that and be excited in that moment for yourself and for your family, but then you still thinking about the men that you left behind.
You know, you thinking about the problems of tomorrow.
In Eddie's piece, he talk about how out here in the free world, you have all these problems, bills, jobs, family, raising your kids.
In prison, when you're innocent, you have one and that's how you're gonna get out.
Then when you get out, you have all of that, it just hits you as an adult man or a woman.
You have no bank account, you know?
You have no place to lay your head, you know?
You have no job.
You have no medical history, you know?
You got to figure all this out.
And yes, it's a great thing to be out here.
It's a great thing to be out of that bondage, out of that, you know, insanity that you was locked in of no fault of your own.
And then you just got to figure out how to, you know, navigate through life out here.
And then the Innocence Projects, they help you refine therapy, you know?
I see a therapist.
I still do, nearly the six years that I've been home.
And this is no easy task.
And unfortunately, I know of so many exonerees, they fall off on the deep end and get caught up in addiction, whether it's drugs, whether it's alcohol or whatever the case may be 'cause it's hard.
You know, but the fight don't stop.
The fight continues 'cause now you got to fight to make sense of being out here where you supposed to been at all along.
And you didn't have those pitfalls, those learning experience as you would growing into it.
- Donte, what was the most difficult thing for you when you were released?
What was the hardest part once you got your freedom back?
- Just readapting to society.
Like, being in prison, that's a different world.
And then for me, I didn't have no time to prepare.
Like, my appeal happened overnight and I just came home.
So, like, you don't have no jobs, like, there's no avenues for us.
Like, if someone was found guilty and come home, they have, like, avenues and stuff to help them get through the next day.
But for wrongfully-convicted people, when we come home, we don't have nothing.
Like I said, Innocence Project, they have put things in place for us to try to help us get through the next day, but that took time and that wasn't always available, but it's available now and I'm grateful for it.
But when you first get out of prison, it's nothing.
You just have to take every day at, like, take every day at a time to, that's to maintain and not do nothing stupid.
- Of course, not everyone who claims to be innocent of a crime actually is, and that's why the Innocence Project goes to great lengths to ensure that the people they represent truly are wrongly incarcerated.
(calm music) - We have a four-stage review process.
Stage one is simply we receive a letter from the person applying from the incarcerated individual.
It's really important that we hear from that person directly and not through a liaison 'cause we want to acknowledge their agency and make sure that they want our help.
Stage two, we have volunteer attorneys just look at an overview of the case to see if there is a plausible claim of innocence.
Stage three, we're reviewing every piece of paper, every shred of video, every shred of evidence we can find on the case.
- A significant lengthy review to determine whether we can help, whether the person is, in fact, innocent, and that really is the kind of foundation of the work.
- Then we present the case to a case review committee.
We do that to check ourselves, have a neutral board and make sure that there are, you know, past prosecutors or current prosecutors on that to look at it from that angle.
And if it makes it through that process, then we look at taking on that incarcerated person as a represented client with our organization and look at the various ways that we may be able to litigate the case or bring a legal remedy of some nature to that person.
(gentle music) Besides trying to exonerate wrongfully-convicted folks is that we also do policy work and education.
- How can we make the situation better not just for our clients, but for everyone and try to reform the criminal legal system more broadly?
(bright music) - [Meghan] We deal with cases in every one of the 60-some-odd counties that are in Pennsylvania.
There's no barrier as far as what county somebody may be incarcerated in or what county someone was convicted in.
- We're a tiny organization.
We've gotten over 8,000 letters asking for help since we started.
- We cannot do this work without our volunteer attorneys and without our volunteer law students, interns.
- Most of them have no idea how much more difficult it is to get post-conviction release in Pennsylvania.
We have a Right to Know Act, which is the state version of the Freedom of Information Act that specifically exempts criminal investigation records from disclosure.
So in most states, if you're trying to get police reports related to your case, you could file a request for an open records request, something like that.
Here, all of that is specifically blocked.
So it's really challenging to even get the information we need to review the cases and work on them, much less bring forward new evidence of someone's innocence.
- And I think the students remind you that every person is, this is, you know, a fresh case that deserves a fresh perspective and reminding everybody of the person's individual humanity.
(bright music continues) - Yahya, talk to us about your re-entry experience.
27 years in jail, what was it like coming back out?
- Wow.
Well, re-entry has phases.
Initially when I get home, I'm happy and I could do what I wanna do and I could eat what I wanna eat and things like this.
And then reality kicks in.
When I was inside, I had these ideas about freedom and how it would be and everything was like a fantasy, right?
I hadn't even factor in any speed bumps.
Everything that I fantasized about being home, there were no roadblocks in these fantasies.
And so when I get home, it was shocking.
It was shocking that it was hard to find employment.
So I had acquired a lot of skills while inside.
I studied the law.
I did a lot of other different things.
I was a facilitator of restorative justice and all these other little programs and writing books and all these different things.
And so I wanted to come home and put this to work, right?
And so it felt like all the jobs that were offered to me were jobs of labor.
It felt like, "Oh, you could work in the Walmart."
Now don't get me wrong.
If I needed to work in a Walmart, then that's where I would have been.
In Walmart, I've been a good, I would stock the shelves very well.
But I felt like stocking the shelf for me wouldn't have helped anyone.
The things that I require and things I learned, no one would benefit from me stocking a shelf.
And that was hard.
It was hard because it felt like the world was trying to tell me that I'm not who I had become, you know?
And so that was the hard part.
And so I had to get these ideas about what freedom is, these unrealistic expectations and things like this.
I had to get rid of that idea and get down to what freedom is now, initially, right, and take it day by day and deal with it how it comes and things like this.
And so eventually, I landed the job with the Pennsylvania Innocence Project, thankfully, the best job I ever had.
- Well, and along those lines, Zane, when a wrongfully-convicted person is released, is their record automatically expunged or is that something that sometimes they have to carry around for a while?
- It's not automatically expunged and oftentimes, they have to carry it around with them.
And there are some mechanisms to eventually get your record expunged, but in today's world, what happens now is gonna really follow you forever.
We're now in a world of social media, of constant newspaper reporting.
All that information is gonna be available for eternity.
And so there's information out there that ultimately is gonna follow you around the rest of your life.
And so when the system gets it wrong, the impact is forever, in my view.
And that's why it's so important that we work to get a system that makes sure that it gets it right.
- And Zane, we would be remiss if we did not acknowledge the role of race when it comes to wrongful incarceration.
Talk about that if you would and why, overwhelmingly, we see Black men typically or people of color who are in this category.
- Yeah, so I think if you look at and you study our criminal justice system, historically, since really reconstruction, the criminal law has focused in on persons of color in terms of prosecution and enforcement.
And depending on the community makeup, law enforcement may target certain communities more than others.
And as a result, persons of color may be subject to more contact with police, which leads to more arrest, which leads to criminal charges, which leads to convictions.
And so you end up with a prison population that is predominantly persons of color and then you extrapolate that out to the idea of wrongful convictions.
You can only assume and then it's proven that the individuals who are being exonerated for a vast majority of the crimes are persons of color.
And that's something that the criminal justice system really needs to address in terms of how it engages with the community and how it enforces the laws, because it ought to be fair across the board.
- And though most of the Innocence Projects clients are men, they do work with women as well.
Women like Letitia Smallwood who spent 42 years behind bars accused of setting a fatal fire in Carlisle, PA in 1972.
(gentle music) - There are fewer women in prison than men, and so we get fewer requests for help, but we have exonerated two women and are currently working with another client.
With women in wrongful convictions, oftentimes they are convicted of crimes that didn't even happen.
One of our clients, Letitia Smallwood, was convicted of setting fire (sirens wailing) to an apartment building in Carlisle, Pennsylvania in the early '70s.
Teri was 20 years old at the time.
She was home from college for the summer.
The alleged motive was that she was dating a guy who lived in the building with another woman.
They were both dating him at the same time.
And that was really the case against Teri.
And it was almost immediately concluded by a Pennsylvania state trooper who was acting as a fire marshal that this was an arson.
It was an intentionally set fire.
She wrote to hundreds of people for help over the next 40 years.
We got a letter from her right when we opened in 2009.
At the time of Teri's trial, any fire investigator probably would've said that was an arson.
And so being open-minded to the understanding that science evolves, for example, that new evidence may come out.
We asked a fire expert to look at Teri's case and he opined that indeed this should never have been determined to be an incendiary fire.
This was likely an accidental fire, so there was no crime at all.
Teri was eventually able to come home based on that new fire science after serving almost 43 years.
These cases become very sensationalized in the media, and what I would hope that people would do is, especially now with so many podcasts, so many high profile trials being covered minute by minute, just see where the facts go, because I think people are still surprised that something could go horribly wrong and someone could be convicted of a crime they didn't commit.
(gentle music continues) - And Zane, you mentioned legislation in the works that would address the compensation issue, but what else is being done legislatively to reduce or prevent the likelihood of wrongful incarceration in the first place?
- Yeah, so one of our major advocacy efforts right now is trying to get a bill passed that would deal with interrogations, a law that would require that in any interrogation questioning involving violent-crime-type offenses, that it would have to be video recorded so that you would get the best evidence.
And so you would see from beginning to the end what transpired in the questioning room and juries could look at that and decide whether or not it's voluntary, whether or not the person actually confessed to something that they did, in fact, do, but they could also see any improper behavior by law enforcement that could have coerced statements that were not true.
It would also protect law enforcement officers from allegations of misconduct during the interrogation process because you would have the best evidence available.
In 2025, the proposed bill that's in the house got out of judiciary committee and sent to the floor for a vote.
But before the floor voted, the chiefs of police voiced their opposition and as a result of their opposition, the bill wasn't brought to the floor because not enough people on both sides of the aisle were willing to vote for the bill.
We're in the process of trying to gather additional evidence that would hopefully push it back into a bill that individual representatives would wanna support and have made into law because it just really makes sense.
And we're operating in a world now where the vast majority of police departments are already wearing body cameras and they're recording everything.
And this is not an additional ask.
It's just basically asking you to record when you're talking to people, what they say so that we have the best evidence available.
And so hopefully, we'll get across the finish line at some point, but that would make it better in terms of making sure that false confessions aren't part of the wrongful conviction process.
- Yahya, what did you miss the most during your 27 years?
- I missed the family, just being around them when I wanted to.
Yeah.
- What about you, Termaine?
- Family, my son, my son.
- Donte, what did you miss the most?
- Just being able to do what I want when I felt like it.
That's just it.
- I'm curious to know what each of you would want people to know about what happens to someone when they are wrongfully incarcerated, as briefly as possible, but I'm curious to hear, like, what do you want people to know that they don't know about what it's like?
Yahya?
- It's hard to get out.
Oh, man, it's so hard to get out.
You're going to have to fight, hands down.
- Termaine?
- I did a quick self-inventory, and just echoing what Yahya just said, you know, you got to fight or give in and just be there.
So resilient, you really got to believe in yourself, not so much the system, but believe in yourself, believe in God and that one day something different will happen.
- Donte?
- Getting out is just the beginning of a new chapter, of a new fight and let's take a day at a time.
- I wonder if for any of you, the experience has changed the way that you think about trust, trust in institutions, trust in people based on what you have been through.
Termaine?
- I don't trust nobody but the people that help me.
- Same way.
- Yahya, what do you say?
- I trust a little bit more.
- Yeah?
- Yeah.
So I know that the law is, I always say this, the law is made by human beings.
It's practiced and it's enforced by human beings.
And so it's only gonna be as fair and as just as we are as human beings.
And so I got help after sitting in 27 years, it was feeling grim, it was feeling so bad, but eventually I got help and that took people, it took human beings to help me.
So I trust that human beings, we will find a way.
I trust that.
I have to.
- Zane, you were a prosecutor.
Now you're working on the other side of things.
How have your views evolved since your days as a prosecutor?
- Yeah, so my guiding principle has always been do the right thing and justice.
And even when I was a federal prosecutor, you could be hard charging and moving forward with investigations, but at the end of the day, you need to make the right call and make sure that justice being served by people who don't deserve to be punished aren't being punished.
And that's what you should strive for.
And in the context of being a federal prosecutor, I also had the luxury of being able to turn down cases in terms of the way the federal and state system operated and were.
The federal system, we could adopt cases from the state and pursue them or we could decide we're not going to pursue those cases.
And there were a number of cases that I saw coming across my desk where the witness statements didn't make sense, the information that was being provided by the law enforcement officers didn't make sense.
And from my perspective, that is not a case that we ought to be wasting our resources on and pursuing.
That doesn't necessarily stop state prosecutors from moving forward with those cases.
And state prosecutors are overwhelmed with the number of cases that they need to deal with because most crimes are handled at the state level, not the federal level.
And you also have law enforcement officers who are doing work in their communities and bringing these cases to prosecutors and just trying to get the cases done.
And then you got public defenders trying to represent individuals and their resources are stretched.
And so it's just a recipe for bad things to happen within a system that is not perfect by any stretch of the imagination.
And so taking on this role, having that perspective allows me to operate in the Pennsylvania Innocence Project supported team that's working very hard to right some really serious wrongs in terms of overturning wrongful convictions.
But at the end of the day, just making sure that justice is served.
It may be delayed, but our goal is to make sure that justice is served and wrongfully-convicted people aren't sitting in prison.
- And on that note, we will bring our conversation to an end.
Yahya Moore, Termaine Hicks, Donte Rollins, Zane Memeger, thank you all for a most enlightening and eye-opening conversation and for the work that you're doing to give innocent people their lives back.
You can find more information on the Pennsylvania Innocence Project at painnocence.org.
I'm Tracey Matisak.
Thanks for watching.
(audience applauding)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.

- News and Public Affairs

Today's top journalists discuss Washington's current political events and public affairs.




New Episode

New Episode


New Episode
Support for PBS provided by:
Conversations for the Common Good is a local public television program presented by WVIA

