
Bizarre spinning toys
Season 1 Episode 24 | 4m 56sVideo has Closed Captions
Spinning toys and tops have unusual behaviors.
Spinning toys and tops have unusual behaviors. The famous tippe top flips itself over and spins on its stem. The PhiTOP stands up on its end, which you can also do with a hard-boiled egg. These behaviors all have to do with torque and angular momentum, like a bicycle wheel precessing around a rope due to gyroscopic behavior.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback

Bizarre spinning toys
Season 1 Episode 24 | 4m 56sVideo has Closed Captions
Spinning toys and tops have unusual behaviors. The famous tippe top flips itself over and spins on its stem. The PhiTOP stands up on its end, which you can also do with a hard-boiled egg. These behaviors all have to do with torque and angular momentum, like a bicycle wheel precessing around a rope due to gyroscopic behavior.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
How to Watch Physics Girl
Physics Girl is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship[music playing] So I got this fancy top called a PhiTOP, which is just an oblong piece of metal.
But watch what happens when you spin it lying down.
It stands up.
That is, if you start it spinning along its minor axis, it will rise up and spin along its major axis.
Now, this toy is shiny and pretty, but that physics trick at the end, you could make a hard boiled egg stand up like that.
Check it out.
It will even stand up on its smaller end and the best part, you can spin it and color it with markers.
Perfect way to decorate your Easter eggs.
So it's nothing fancy about this particular toy, although it does look pretty fancy.
But in both of these spinning behaviors, the center of mass, that is, the point that pretty much tells you where the average of the mass is, the point that's supposed to stay as low to the ground as possible because of gravity, that point rises up.
It looks like it's not obeying gravity.
So weird.
Almost as weird as this demo.
It seems like the wheel here should just fall straight down since it's just hanging on the rope.
But it stays sideways.
But still, you ain't seen nothing.
This is the famous Tippe Top.
Not only does the center of mass rise up, but the whole thing flips over.
If your mind is blown, you're in good company-- well, me.
But also here are two Nobel Prize winners and quantum physics pioneers playing with the Tippe Top.
Back in the 1950s, there was actually a craze among physicists to figure out how this toy works.
All these papers just for analyzing these toys, because their behavior is super complex.
As one scientist put it, "even the most simplified model for the rolling and gliding TT is a nonintegrable dynamical system with at least 6 degrees of freedom."
So why are these toys so weird?
Let's take a crack at the egg.
First, how is energy conserved when it stands up?
Because energy has got to be conserved.
So the rising center of mass means that gravitational potential energy increases.
Where did that energy come from?
Well, the egg actually slows down a bit, so kinetic or motion energy is converted into potential energy.
The egg then also speeds up as it stands up because of the changing moment of inertia, but that doesn't affect the energy transfer.
So overall, energy is conserved if you ignore heat losses to friction, which physicists like to do.
Now, how does the egg stand up?
First, a little physics vocabulary.
When something rotates, it has angular momentum, which physicists like to define with the right hand rule.
As along the axis it's rotating about, curl your fingers with the direction of the spin, and your thumb points along the angular momentum vector.
Angular momentum is just like regular linear momentum.
Something that's moving wants to keep moving unless there's a force stopping it like friction.
In the same way, this wheel wants to keep spinning with its angular momentum vector pointing in the same direction unless there's a torque stopping it like my hand.
When you apply a torque to something, that is a force some distance away from whatever you're going to rotate that thing about, it can make it spin faster or slower or change the direction it's spinning.
Put simply, torque wants to increase angular momentum in the direction of that torque.
Watch this.
Gravity is applying a force here.
Now, this is where it gets confusing, because just like angular momentum is defined as not really in the direction that the wheel is spinning, but out of the spinning plane, torque is defined as r cross F which, by the right hand rule, is also in a third direction.
So torque on the wheel like this would increase momentum in that direction.
Torque this way, like that due to gravity, would make the angular momentum vector want to rotate that way.
And the gyroscope will turn, what we call gyroscopic precession.
Now, back to the egg.
It works similar to the wheel's procession.
In fact, the egg processes.
In order for the egg to stand up, its angular momentum has to change due to a torque.
When the egg starts spinning, it slides around a bit, which means there's friction that opposes the sliding.
Friction provides some of the torque needed to stand the egg up.
Now, we can test that.
If we spin these on a surface that has little to no friction, they shouldn't behave the same.
Yeah.
It doesn't work the same.
Nope.
You can also try spinning a raw egg, which doesn't work because the fluid on the inside doesn't move with the shell.
So it turns out, tops and rotational physics is pretty complicated.
But you get the coolest phenomena.
Thank you so much for watching this episode of "Physics Girl," and happy physicsing.
- Science and Nature
A series about fails in history that have resulted in major discoveries and inventions.
Support for PBS provided by: