Prairie Pulse
Prairie Pulse: Dr. Michelle Lelwica and Patty Kakac
Season 21 Episode 22 | 26m 58sVideo has Closed Captions
A discussion to mark Women's History Month and music from Patty Kakac.
Women's History Month is marked with an interview with Dr. Michelle Lelwica, Concordia College professor of women's and gender studies and religion, and a musical performance from Patty Kakac.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Prairie Pulse is a local public television program presented by Prairie Public
Prairie Pulse
Prairie Pulse: Dr. Michelle Lelwica and Patty Kakac
Season 21 Episode 22 | 26m 58sVideo has Closed Captions
Women's History Month is marked with an interview with Dr. Michelle Lelwica, Concordia College professor of women's and gender studies and religion, and a musical performance from Patty Kakac.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
How to Watch Prairie Pulse
Prairie Pulse is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship(uplifting music) - Hello and welcome to Prairie Pulse.
Coming up a little bit later in the show, we'll hear music from Patty Kakac.
But first, our guest Joining us now is Dr. Michelle Lelwica, professor of religion, and women's, and gender studies at Concordia College in Moorhead.
Thanks for joining us today.
- Pleasure to be here.
- As we get started, tell the folks a little bit about yourself and maybe your background, and where you're originally from.
- Well, let's start with where I'm originally from.
I grew up in Staples, Minnesota, and I spent first 18 years of my life there.
Then I went to the College of St. Benedict and kind of fell in love with learning and felt like I couldn't stop.
And I went on to graduate school at Harvard Divinity School and did my Master's of Theological Studies there.
And then I was the first student to graduate in a PhD program, focused on religion, gender, and culture.
- Okay, well you're here today to talk a little bit about March, of course is Women's History Month.
So can you talk about some of the classes you teach at Concordia that focus on women's history, and roles in society, and things like that?
- Yeah, probably the course that's most relevant to Women's History Month that I teach is women's religious history.
So religion is my home field and I have an emphasis in gender and women's studies.
And that class is, I say this about all my classes, but it really is one of my favorite classes to teach.
I usually get a handful of men in the class.
It fulfills a requirement, so that helps.
And lots of women, and some in between, students who are non-binary.
And it's just a wonderful class for me to teach because I get to witness students encountering the history of women in a way that they haven't, we don't send students to high school and they learn about the history of women.
They learn about history, which is so often his-story.
It's not really her-story.
So much of what we inherit historically is written by the historical winners.
Men have been in the dominant position.
And so, women don't learn about their own history.
And especially we start that class looking at the history of women in early Christianity.
And many of the students, not all of my students are Christian.
I would say about 50, maybe 60% of them are, but whether or not they're Christian, they're shocked to really find out about women's active role at the beginning of Christianity because that's not a history that we learn about, either in the context religion, usually or more broadly.
So I think one of my favorite things about that class is, students start to really see how specific patterns of gender norms and gender narratives that are historical, continue to echo in their own experiences.
So for example, a lot of the writings we have about women are just that, they're about women, they're not by women, and they're often very demeaning towards women.
The early church fathers talk about how women are not very rational, and they're not very trustworthy, and they're profound sources of temptation, always leading men off the path.
These are narratives that are still alive today.
A lot of women doubt their own intelligence.
They doubt their own ability to lead.
They doubt their own sense of self and the self-doubt that these historical narratives generate about women echoes in my students' experiences, particularly the young women who wanna feel brave and wanna feel confident, but they realize they struggle with self-doubt.
And where does that come from?
They weren't born with it, that's a historical legacy.
- Yeah, and you're almost, you're probably answering part of this question, but why is it important to mark and observe women's history month and maybe not a month, but at least in March in this country?
- Yeah, because if we don't know our history, we don't know our experience, we don't know how we came to be who we are.
And Simone de Beauvoir, she was a groundbreaking feminist in the middle of the 20th century.
She was responsible for saying, "One is not born a woman, one becomes a woman."
In other words, so much of gender is socialization.
Of course there are physiological differences, but so much of what we learn about what it means to be a man and what it means to be a woman, these are social narratives.
That's what it means to say gender is socially constructed.
So, I lost the question, go back to the question.
- Yeah, so why is it important to mark and observe it?
- So, Simone de Beauvoir said that if we don't know our history, there's a whole piece of self-knowledge that's missing collectively as women.
And so, understanding our history and understanding, not just history from the perspective of what men said about women, but the more we can even dredge up stories that, and self representations that women in history had about themselves and their struggles in what predominantly has been patriarchal cultures, we learn about our own agency.
We learn about other women's agency, we learn about how they challenged social norms in ways that made it possible for us to be on this trajectory, hopefully, I'm hopeful that we continue transforming society towards a more equal future.
- Well, can you talk about maybe how in just our lifetime jobs and roles have changed for women?
- Yeah, well, I see more and more young women being more audacious in the best sense of the word, like brave, courageous in charting their own paths.
But certainly doors have opened to women in jobs that used to be almost exclusively for men.
If you look back in the 1950s and you went into the jobs wanted part of a newspaper, you'd see jobs for women and jobs for men, gender segregated jobs.
That's how you know it used to be.
And now, we don't do that anymore.
Women are getting college degrees at a rate even slightly higher than men.
And so, they're going into jobs that were exclusively male territory or almost exclusively for much of human history and western history.
Think about women becoming doctors, lawyers, teachers.
And at the same time, men are going into fields that have traditionally been relegated to women, nursing, teaching, et cetera.
Still not at the rates where it's 50, 50, but I see young women also going into jobs that involve technology and some of those things that people in my generation have less fluency in.
A lot of young women are very confident with those types of jobs, and I see them being very entrepreneurial about them.
- So it sounds like you believe progress has been made in recent decades for equal pay and opening doors for women to careers that maybe they weren't, but what more can be done in your opinion, in the coming years?
- Yeah, lots more needs to be done.
I don't wanna give the impression that we're there yet.
And when we think about it, think about even women in leadership positions.
In Congress today, we have 28% of Congress is women.
Now that's progress, but is that even close to half?
No, it's not even close to half, so what can be done?
I think we need to first of all understand that there still is a problem.
We've made progress, but there's still a problem of gender inequity, systemic gender inequity.
And when I talk about sexism as something that's systemic, what that means is, it's not a matter of our personal intentions.
It's not that some people don't like women.
There are people who maybe don't like women, but not many.
Most of us have mothers, and sisters, and partners.
But what can be done is we can admit that there still is a problem.
There still is systemic gender inequality.
And once we recognize that problem, we can look for ways in our own daily lives that we cannot be complicit with that.
The same is true with racism.
We're asking these questions, as a white person, I'm trying to understand what are the ways I've been complicit with racism?
One of the ways is, I haven't had to think about it.
You know, I've had the privilege.
Part of white privilege is not having to think about it.
So I think one thing that can be done is, men can join the struggle against sexism and see it as their problem too.
As I'm not just a women's studies professor, I'm a women and gender studies professor.
So the men in my class, we talk about how patriarchy, namely the system of male dominance, is not good for them either.
I had a really interesting conversation two weeks ago with students in my Christianity and Religious diversity course.
And we were reading this book where the author is making the case against sexism, but she's also saying that patriarchy's not good for men.
And I asked the male students in the class, what do you think about this?
And they opened up so beautifully about the struggles of what it's like to be having to live up to this image of manhood that feels really oppressive to them.
And what if they don't fit into that, and think of all the pressure to be successful, and what if you're not successful?
So I think until people who are in the dominant group see the kind of oppression that they're implicated in as their problem too, until white people see racism as their problem, until men see sexism as their problem too, and not just a women's issue, we won't make progress.
But I'm hopeful when I teach, this may be why I teach college students.
They're at a place in their lives where they're open to seeing things change and seeing things differently.
And when we see things differently, then we have a chance to change.
- Okay, talk some about your publications and research.
I understand you've done some on body images for women.
- Yeah, you know, it's funny, it strikes some people as funny that as a religion scholar, my primary focus for the past three decades has been looking at body image and eating disordered behavior among women.
And then I remind people who find that to be peculiar about the story of the second creation myth, the story of Adam and Eve and how sin comes into the world.
Do you remember that story?
How does sin come into the world?
- Adam, I mean, Eve takes a bite of an apple.
- Eve, takes a bite, it's actually a fruit.
- Fruit.
- It's described as a fruit.
But the artistic tradition makes us all believe it's an apple.
Anyway, it could have been, who knows?
It is a story.
Religion scholars see this as a myth, not as something that really happened.
But yeah, she eats, she eats.
So sin, and shame, and death come into the world through a woman's disobedient appetite.
This goes back to the first question.
If we don't really study the way that these historical narratives continue into today, we're missing something important.
And so my interest in women's eating issues comes from my own experience having an adolescent eating disorder.
And, but I started studying when I was at Harvard Divinity School, what many of the religious authorities who were male were saying about women's bodies and about women's appetites.
And the constant narrative kept going back to Eve and women couldn't control their appetites.
And women were outta control, and their bodies were unruly, and they needed to contain their bodies, and they needed to contain their hunger.
And I was like, this is so interesting connecting the dots between this, one of the most influential myths in western culture is the creation myth.
And at the heart of that myth is sin and shame being associated with women's bodies and in particular their bodily appetites.
And so, when I started doing research on this, it was so clear to me that that shame, that legacy of shame still is alive.
I talk to my students about this all the time.
It's one of my favorite topics is, you know, are you still all struggling with body image stuff?
Oh yeah, oh yeah, they are.
Even though they know it's toxic, even though they know that they've been fed a bed of lies about their bodies, they still really struggle.
And now with social media, of course that isn't helping the situation because they're exposed to all kinds of curated, edited, perfected images and they struggle with shame.
- Do you feel teachers, counselors, and others are better now than in past decades at spotting eating disorders and eating issues among women and young girls?
- Yeah, to some extent maybe.
But also, one of the most prominent eating disorder is binge eating disorder.
And that's often done in secret, and so that's hard to spot.
My own experience as an adolescent started off with a lot of self starving, but then I became bulimic, and that's pretty easy to hide.
So I went for three years with nobody knowing what was going on, for me.
And I think it's hard to spot certain eating disordered behavior, especially in a culture where eating disorders, we have on the extreme part of the continuum.
But then we also celebrate diet culture and weight loss.
We compliment a woman who has lost weight until she's gone too far and then we pathologize her.
So to some extent I think we've gotten better, but I also think it's hard to spot disordered eating in a culture that's already got so much disordered eating.
- Who are some of your heroes as we celebrate Women's History Month?
- I think about Sojourner Truth, are you familiar with her?
A mid 19th century former slave who was, her slave name was Isabella, but she didn't like her slave name 'cause that was not a name that she gave herself.
And so she chose the symbolic name of Sojourner Truth, Pursuing Truth.
And she went up and down the coast lecturing about the brutalities of slavery.
And at a famous convention in 1851, there were some Christian ministers there, it was a women's rights convention and she was one of the few Black women there.
And these ministers were talking about how women shouldn't have rights because Jesus was a male, and women weren't smart enough, and Eve caused the whole downfall of humanity.
So those are the reasons.
And in the context of that conference, Sojourner Truth stood up and said, basically, "I hear a bunch of people talking about women's rights, but am I even included in that as a Black woman?"
And I think we're still struggling with that today, right?
But then she went on and gave these brilliant responses to the ministers saying, "You are saying women can't have rights because Jesus was a man.
Well, where did Jesus come from?"
Jesus came from a woman.
So, and then she says about the argument against women's intelligence, she says, she makes a clever argument against what the ministers are saying.
And finally she's arguing against their claim that women can't have rights because of what Eve did.
And she says, "You know, if Eve was powerful enough to bring down the whole of humanity, she must be pretty powerful.
And I think she has the power and women have the power to flip it and make it right again."
So she's a hero of mine because she's brilliant, she's audacious, and her legacy I think lives on in women who are willing to be brave and audacious today against those kinds of ridiculous arguments that want to contain us.
- You know, what are some of the shocking things young women who attend your classes learn about, things that women couldn't do not that long ago?
I mean you back up 100 years ago, the right to vote, but even a bank account or having their name on a credit card.
- Yeah, you know, women were not able to have a bank account in their own name until like 1950.
Think about credit cards, it was 1974, a woman could have a credit card in her own name.
And this goes back to the legacy of women basically being property.
And it's not that long ago that these things were happening.
I was saying I was about 10 years old when women could get a credit card in their own name.
So that's during my lifetime.
I think it was not until, this, I wanna bring in intersectionality, which is a way of talking about the way you can never talk about gender in isolation from talking about race, and class, and sexuality, and other ways that we create identities in our culture.
And Black women were not even allowed to be in the Miss America pageant until the late '60s because Black was not considered beautiful.
And that to me, again, bespeaks the power of Sojourner Truth's legacy, this power of claiming herself in that category of woman as a Black woman in saying, we belong here too.
- So many things are changing or have changed in, well a short period of time.
You talk '74 for a credit card and things, but we are running out of time.
So if people are interested in getting more information, where can they go, who can they contact?
- Well, Concordia has a wonderful women and gender studies program.
In fact, we have a number of women and gender studies minors and they connect their minors with whatever their major is.
Our director is currently on sabbatical.
So I'm happy to field any questions or have more discussions about these conversations, and I'm just on the website at Concordia College.
- All right, well thank you so much for joining us today.
- My pleasure.
- Stay tuned for more.
(uplifting music) Patty Kakac from Evansville, Minnesota has spent nearly 40 years performing as a solo artist and with groups in the upper Midwest.
She performs original songs on instruments including guitar, Autoharp, and harmonica.
♪ Come oh, come hear me now ♪ ♪ Hear my story I'll tell ♪ ♪ Take care of land or it will be gone ♪ ♪ This land we love so well ♪ ♪ I've been a farmer all my life ♪ ♪ Now my life's nearly over ♪ ♪ So my children I leave it to you ♪ ♪ This land it's beauty and lure ♪ ♪ So come oh, come hear me now ♪ ♪ Hear my story I'll tell ♪ ♪ Take care of the land or it will be gone ♪ ♪ This land we live so well ♪ ♪ But now they come to take it away ♪ ♪ After working so hard all these years ♪ ♪ Heedless what it means to me, heedless of all my tears ♪ ♪ So come oh, come hear me now ♪ ♪ Hear my story I tell ♪ ♪ Take care of the lang or it will be gone ♪ ♪ This land we love so well ♪ ♪ You may be a doctor, you may be a lawyer ♪ ♪ Maybe a carpenter too ♪ ♪ But somewhere back in your family tree ♪ ♪ You were a farmer too ♪ ♪ For from earth we all began, back to earth we return ♪ ♪ To survive we must take care of our roots ♪ ♪ This lesson we all must learn ♪ ♪ So come oh, come hear me now ♪ ♪ Hear my story I'll tell ♪ ♪ Take care of the land or it will be gone ♪ ♪ This land we love so well ♪ ♪ This land we love so well ♪ ♪ Seven sisters of the prairie ♪ ♪ I will lay me down to rest ♪ ♪ Watch the sun traverse across the sky ♪ ♪ From east to the west ♪ ♪ Leave your burdens on the top of this old hill ♪ ♪ Screams of Red tail in the distance ♪ ♪ Then all is quiet, all is still ♪ ♪ Seven sisters of the prairie ♪ ♪ I have come to you at last ♪ ♪ Come to share your stories, stories of the past ♪ ♪ For need we remember all the souls that went before ♪ ♪ Their broken bodies lie along long Christina shore ♪ ♪ Sisters of the prairie I see you walking still ♪ ♪ Your proud shoulders carry all your strength ♪ ♪ And all your will ♪ ♪ The grasses rise to touch your hands as if to say goodbye ♪ ♪ The sisters weep for you, but still you cannot cry ♪ ♪ Seven sisters of prairie ♪ ♪ I will leave you with your moons ♪ ♪ To tend these hills so gently ♪ ♪ Heal the ancient wounds ♪ ♪ From all careless hatred and all the endless wars ♪ ♪ I hear the sisters calling peace forevermore ♪ - Well, that's all we have on Prairie Pulse for this week.
And as always, thanks for watching (uplifting music) - [Narrator] Funded by the Minnesota Arts and Cultural Heritage Fund with money from the vote of the people of Minnesota on November 4th, 2008, and by the members of Prairie Public.
Support for PBS provided by:
Prairie Pulse is a local public television program presented by Prairie Public













