Prairie Pulse
Prairie Pulse: Dr. Nicholas Howard and Jake Ingamar
Season 24 Episode 5 | 26m 53sVideo has Closed Captions
Dr. Nicholas Howard talks about the issues at the center of the 2026 midterm elections.
The 2026 midterm elections are fast approaching and all eyes are on who will take control of Congress. Concordia College Political Science Assistant Professor Dr. Nicholas Howard discusses the issues driving voters to the ballot box. Also, music from Fargo musician Jake Ingamar.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Prairie Pulse is a local public television program presented by Prairie Public
Prairie Pulse
Prairie Pulse: Dr. Nicholas Howard and Jake Ingamar
Season 24 Episode 5 | 26m 53sVideo has Closed Captions
The 2026 midterm elections are fast approaching and all eyes are on who will take control of Congress. Concordia College Political Science Assistant Professor Dr. Nicholas Howard discusses the issues driving voters to the ballot box. Also, music from Fargo musician Jake Ingamar.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Prairie Pulse
Prairie Pulse is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship(upbeat music) (upbeat music ending) - Hello, and welcome to "Prairie Pulse."
Coming up a little bit later in the show, we'll hear music from Jake Ingamar from Fargo, North Dakota.
But first, joining me now is Dr.
Nicholas Howard, a Political Science Professor from Concordia College in Moorhead.
Dr.
Howard, thanks for joining us today.
- Thank you for inviting me.
- Well, you're here today to talk about the upcoming midterm elections, something a lot of people are talking about right now.
But before we get to that, tell us a little about yourself and your background.
- Well, I've been at Concordia since 2023, and before that, I was a Professor at Auburn, and with a PhD from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, and undergraduate degree from here in the state at Carlton College, and I worked in the US Senate for a little while.
- Okay, well, so you know about politics a little bit, don't you?
Well, you're here, as I said, to talk about the upcoming midterm elections, and before we get into the main discussions of the elections for 2026, really define what a midterm election is.
- So midterm election is generally one in which the topmost candidate, in this case, for a national election, the president, does not appear on the ballot.
So when we say a national midterm, it means an even numbered year in which the president is not on the ballot in any capacity.
- Yeah.
So do you think voters approach a midterm election differently than they would sort of the presidential election year?
- Yes, they do.
We see that in turnout numbers, especially among younger voters and voters who have recently moved, their turnout numbers tend to be much higher in presidential years, because the information environment is so much richer, it's so much easier, because the president and their incumbent, or for an open seat is out stumping, out giving interviews, and out essentially ginning up the base, and trying to actually drive turnout in ways that just aren't quite as present in a midterm election when they're not on the ballot.
- Yeah.
Well, you talk about that, but you know, when you think about, an election's an election, you're still voting for representatives that's gonna serve you in DC, and while yes, a presidential election year might have, well, more impact, because the President's on the ballot, really, why do you think that trend happens?
I mean, you talked a little bit about it, but why do people not get out and vote in the midterms?
- So, and this is one where it depends a little bit on kind of what you're talking about in the specific year and stuff.
So let's take this year in contrast to 2024, and then 2022, the last midterm election before this one.
So we're seeing actually relatively even engagement, at least in early election results for early voting in places like Minnesota, places like Texas, that is actually on par with early voting numbers in the 2024 election.
But that we expect that to fade a little bit as we get closer to have a little bit of a lull, and then the pickup of everybody on the actual election day in November.
And a lot of that is the increase in attention that we're seeing relative to what we just talked about with the presidential election year.
We're seeing interest in Texas, interest in Minnesota that is unusual in this kind of an environment, because control of national governing institutions are at stake.
And President Trump is out campaigning on this, his essentially whole administration is out doing the same, and we have the same for the previous presidential administration for their endorsements, both Biden and Obama before him, and essentially their entire cabinet are out stumping for candidates around the country.
So we're seeing actually this particular cycle is actually, we expect to be higher turnout than the 2022 midterm, but it probably won't quite reach the 2024 general election for president.
- Okay, so it might buck the trend, but you don't think it'll reach record numbers of... Anyway, all right.
Well, looking at the 2026 election, what are the key races for the midterms?
- So the key races are the Senate races.
We're seeing, in Minnesota, we're actually neck and neck right now between the candidates, and it's not just for the Senate races, it's also for down ballot races statewide, we're seeing Attorney General like has hotly contested, but outside of that, Texas Senate race, Ohio's Senate race, North Carolina's Senate race, Georgia's Senate race are all essentially hotly contested.
And especially where we're seeing it right now is Texas and Ohio are the two big spenders in terms of where the parties are actually putting their money, their essentially endorsements and their attention.
And we're actually seeing a pickup in Alaska right now, President Trump was just there a week ago, giving essentially a campaign rally in a state that is not known for seeing them.
- Okay.
Well, you've mentioned Minnesota here with the Senate race, definitely, but also the governor race is one.
Can you talk a little bit about that one?
- Of course.
So one of the things that we're seeing a lot in the Senate race is similarities and differences between the candidates.
So some similarities, both candidates, Klobuchar and Demuth have come out in favor of the Independent Office of Inspector General, they are both talking about like investigations and governmental oversight and reform.
So there are some similarities between what the candidates are talking about and what the race is about.
Given kind of what we've seen in Minnesota over the last couple of years, that's not unexpected, but we're seeing some pretty big differences in the substance of what they're talking about for those things outside of creating the Office of Inspector General.
We're seeing essentially much more sort of social aspects of one and much more law enforcement aspects of the other.
Again, not unexpected, but we're seeing even where they're talking about the same issues, they're talking about them very differently.
- Yeah.
Well, you're talking issues.
Give us an overview of what are some of the biggest issues and topics going into the midterms overall.
- So in Minnesota, it's gonna be investigations for fraud and oversight of government administration, and that's gonna mean essentially interaction with and separation from the federal government as we saw recently with ICE.
And so that's gonna be a lot of it is how does this new administration, whichever candidate wins, actually interact with the federal government, and the federal government's actions in the state is gonna be a hot topic as we go into the home stretch of this race.
- Mm-hmm.
What are some of the other issues for other states that people are looking at?
- So similar issues actually have popped up in Texas and Ohio, and not so much in states like Georgia and North Carolina.
But outside of that, one of the things we're actually seeing a lot of in these states is immigration as a touchtone issue for what those races are actually defined by, both for the individual states, and in relevance to like national immigration policy, and again, how we interact as states with the federal government and their policy priorities.
- You know, a key issue we keep hearing about is dealt with mail-in voting, and whether or not citizens should provide proof of citizenship.
Can you talk about why that topic is such an issue during this midterm election?
- So it's an issue perennially in almost every election cycle and for good reason.
We wanna talk about election security and making sure that the ballots actually are representative of who they're talking about, and thus who wins as actually representing the populace that they are elected to represent.
And those are fundamental issues in any democracy that we talk about, not just the US.
We're seeing it in France right now for like those issues surrounding French protests.
So it's not just us that are concerned with these questions.
Now, the other side of that is essentially for people who say that we shouldn't spend quite so much attention and especially resources on it, is that voting by non-citizens is incredibly rare.
The Heritage Foundation investigated, and they found only about 77 instances over a 20-year span, so roughly three per election cycle, so it is exceedingly rare and the penalties are stiff.
There are heavy monetary fines and in most cases, deportation if you vote as a non-citizen in our elections.
So it's justified concern, absolutely, but in terms of actual instances of it, historically, it's pretty rare.
- Yeah.
But what role does mail-in voting or absentee voting play, especially in rural areas, like North Dakota and Northwest Minnesota?
- So one of the things to think about when we talk about voting and turnout is what does it actually cost a voter to participate, and sure, money is part of this, so gas money to get to election, polling places, but it's not just that, it's also the cost of acquiring information, the time it takes, and what else you could be doing with that time.
And mail-in voting and absentee ballot voting dramatically decrease those costs, because for mail-in voting, like the ballot comes to you, you don't have to invest time and opportunity for what else you could be doing, and you have the ballot with a little bit of time sitting in front of you to actually make your choice.
And for absentee balloting, that's the case.
For early voting, you can actually then pick the time that works for you, so you're not giving up quite so much of what else you could be doing in that given time slot, and so that's why we see like this surge, especially right now in rural areas for the usage of these tactics for both trying to actually promote them from the parties themselves to actually encourage voters to use them, so that they can actually participate in advance and actually get their vote registered outside of the individual election day is because it does lower these costs.
- Do you have any kind of numbers that you could tell us about you know, absentee and mail-in voting, you know, percentage-wise of overall voting or what impact it has there?
- It's highly on the state.
It's a great question.
So North Dakota has high variance historically on what this pattern looks like, and this is one where midterms actually have a pretty big swing in terms of like the usage in Minnesota and North Dakota, because the information environment is a lot different.
So essentially, mail-in voting and absentee voting tends to be higher in presidential election years, because people can make up their mind a little bit earlier, because the President is on the top of the ticket.
Now, this is one where we're seeing a little bit of difference from that for this election cycle.
I'll take Texas as an example, which for like the most populous counties in Texas, so Dallas County in Texas, we're actually seeing participation for absentee and early voting on par with the 2024 election at this point, which is rare for a midterm election.
And so we're seeing these, and it's not just Texas, we're seeing a little bit of it in Minnesota, so it turns out that we may be seeing a little bit of a difference in the trend for this, because the information environment is so much richer now with the advent of social media, and the attention being paid to this cycle that is unusual for midterms.
So we're gonna see a little bit of a higher participation for these alternative non-election day voting methods.
- You know, of course, we're talking about midterm elections and an issue that I understand been brought up on both the state and national levels is sort of the aging demographic of Congress, and how do age and term limits become a factor in, well, any election, but midterm elections as we're talking about.
- So it's a great question.
I'll take term limits first, because term limits, you actually have to change the Constitution if you want term limits on Congress, because Congress sets the rules for its membership in Article One.
So you would have to amend the text of Article One through the new amendment, and so that is tall order with any constitutional amendment, that's a tall order.
Now, that said, states can set term limits for their individual state legislatures, North Dakota has done so recently, other states before them, but on a national level, we're talking amending the Constitution itself.
For the aging demographic, we've actually seen high discussion of that in the parties.
There was a lot of pushback against that in Democratic primaries for this 2026 cycle, and it's not new where we talk about Republicans pushing out incumbents in the 2022 midterm election, and Democrats pushing out older incumbents in this 2026 midterm during the primaries.
Now, that's not a universal cycle, because for example, Ed Markey, the Senator from Massachusetts, won his primary against, I'll go with a much younger incumbent, by 42 years, by about 35%.
So it's not a universal cycle, but we see like this midterm cycle is when kind of this age conversation tends to come up a lot more.
- Yeah.
Do you have any breakdown for demographics along party lines at all?
- So most of the... We have... Sorry.
We have an aging demographic in Congress, like members of Congress on average are older than they have been.
And this is especially true for the Senate.
We see essentially a lot less turnover than we used to in the Senate, we're gonna see a little bit more.
So Joni Ernst in Iowa, for example, is a younger member on, well, relative to her colleagues, but is retiring this cycle and not running for reelection, Tina Smith retired, not young overall for the population, but young compared to her colleagues.
But we also see on the other hand, Mitch McConnell, Chuck Grassley still in office, and so on average, Democrats tend to be a little bit younger, but there's a less difference than you might think.
- Sure.
Well, let's change and go.
When it comes to international conflicts, like the war in Ukraine or the Middle East, how much weight do voters put on that in the elections?
- So the direct contribution to this is probably gonna be relatively low, but for this cycle, we're actually seeing them play out in economic policy, so gas prices, inflation, and so for this cycle, we're actually gonna see a lot more attention to it, both directly for the conflict in Iran, and especially as we talk about the price of fuel, the price of energy, more generally, the price of consumer goods as a high diesel price is witnessed.
So this cycle, we're actually gonna see a lot of attention to it, maybe not directly for the war in Iran, but indirectly whenever we talk about inflation and prices, members and their challengers are going to bring up, like these conflicts in the Middle East as fits their cycle.
- Yeah.
Well, a recent poll from October 16th, a majority of Americans expect the Democrats to take control of the US House.
I think history shows a sitting president's party loses seats in the House normally, if I'm right on that.
- Yes.
- How reliable are these studies and surveys when it comes to forecasting elections?
- So you ask a great question.
Any forecasting is fraught with concerns, but for this House race, especially given kind of the redistricting that we've seen in several states this cycle, it's the margin of errors on these forecasts tend to be a little tighter than what we're normally used to, because state legislatures actually changed districts midstream.
We saw this in Texas, we saw this in California, and a few other states, New York, for example, but we're seeing kind of the downside of this for some races in Texas, where Republicans thought that they would actually get tighter races for their party, and we're actually seeing more competition in some of these seats than they may have expected, which increases Democrats' essentially relief that they will take the majority, and what it's gonna come down to is races that are these contested races in Texas, these contested races in, for example, Marcy Captor in Ohio that was the subject of some redistricting in hers, like the California 40th that's pitting two incumbent Republicans against each other.
It's gonna come down to these races for how much and if the Democrats actually control the House.
But they're feeling pretty good at this point right now.
- Yeah.
How has the political landscape changed or shifted from the last election?
- So relative to 2024, we're talking about a much more unpopular incumbent President, depending upon the poll, President Trump's approval rating is between 39 out of the high and 31 at the low percent, which is gonna have a huge effect, especially on these hotly contested races in places like the Texas Senate race.
President Trump is actually contributing a lot of money to this race, and a lot of his time and attention, Alaska is the same thing.
And it's actually pulling on these incumbent Republican candidates in some cases, or for the open seat for Paxton in Texas, it's pulling on him a little bit, and we're seeing this in Minnesota, where Tafoya is actually being really careful about how and where she includes national politics in her campaign.
- You know, how would you say news coverage of the election cycle is playing into voters' decisions?
- A lot, and this is especially true with the advent of social media.
So social media is a pretty big component of especially younger and new voters for acquiring information, because they have more readily available access to it, and essentially lives in their pockets.
And so what we're seeing here is these kinds of candidates actually try to promote social media as part of their campaign.
Both candidates for Governor and Senate in Minnesota are doing it, we're seeing James Talarico in Texas really lean into it, we're seeing Sherrod Brown embrace it in a way that he did not when he lost his election six years ago, and so we're seeing these kinds of media environments change under our feet now.
However, for more traditional outlets, television, newspapers still play a huge role in setting what the story is, even if they're not reaching directly these younger voters.
- Yeah.
Let's go back to elections and you know, what are considered threats to the voting systems out there, cyber attacks or things like this?
- It's a huge concern.
It's one of those where we actually, for the first time in not our elections, but in Venezuela's elections, we actually saw verifiable evidence of foreign interference in an election in South America's elections last time, and so it is a huge concern, and it's something that we spend a lot of time, and information, resources actually combating, from Russia, China, and other states.
So it's one of those where we are and should rightfully be concerned about what this looks like and those things.
But it's part of the reason why we're talking about like absentee direct ballots, why we're talking about direct ballots in terms of mail-in, because those things are harder to get their hands on from actually interfering with the election itself, and so we're seeing a lot of the resources of government and private entities be directed at information security.
- You know, are there factors that play into an election and voter turnout besides political issues and who's on the ballot and things and such as maybe the state of the economy or can you talk about that a little bit?
- Absolutely.
It's one of those where the economy is gonna be front and center, and it is in almost every race in the country.
And if we're not talking about the economy directly, we're talking about affordability, we're talking about inflation, all of which are the price of goods and how much money stays in your pocket when you go shopping, when you fill, put gas in your car, all of those things.
So yes, the economy is front and center.
And so we're seeing candidates have to answer hard questions on both sides, Democrat and Republican, about kind of their past votes for incumbent members on things, like supporting tariff policies, supporting economic spending under the Biden Administration for Democrats.
We're seeing a lot of candidates have to answer hard questions about these things.
And so yes.
- Well, we are about to run out of time, but can you talk quickly about the importance of voting for a citizen?
- So voting is the most fundamental aspect of democratic life.
It is how we decide who actually represents us, what we actually get, and the policies that we actually get to see made.
And that's true not just at the national level, not just at the statewide level, all the way down to mayor and city councils.
It is the most fundamental responsibility, joy, and duty of a democratic citizen to vote.
- Thank you for that, but we're out of time, if people want more information, where can they go?
- Always start with your Secretary of State website, and generally, find your local news or statewide newspapers and they have great information.
- Thank you so much for joining us today.
- Thank you.
- Stay tuned for more.
(upbeat music) Indie folk musician, Jake Ingamar, from Fargo, North Dakota was deeply impacted by a rock and roll concert at the Fargo Dome at the age of five.
But it wasn't until his teenage years that he began playing guitar and writing music.
Today, he strives for perfection as he crafts his original tunes through analog and digital recordings for a transparent 3D sound experience.
(gentle guitar music) ♪ City leaves and city streets ♪ ♪ Emma walks so cautiously ♪ ♪ And no one knows there's no one there ♪ ♪ Stuck behind a broken stare ♪ ♪ Coming down like midnight hail ♪ ♪ Something waiting to derail ♪ (gentle guitar music) ♪ Back and forth behind the gate ♪ ♪ The nothing men petrol the state ♪ ♪ The city mourns a fallen king ♪ ♪ While the arson lights another sting ♪ ♪ Then it hits you when you sleep ♪ ♪ Like a bomb going off in me ♪ (gentle guitar music) (guitar music) ♪ Burning nights that boil you alive ♪ ♪ Well I'd rather drown ♪ ♪ Distance couldn't shake you from my heart ♪ ♪ Well, since I'm older I better be smarter then before ♪ ♪ Never thought I'd be so ready to start ♪ (guitar music) ♪ I guess I'm on my way to become ♪ ♪ The one and only better man ♪ ♪ But it's so hard when you're riding on a carousel ♪ (guitar music) ♪ Seems unlikely that we could start somewhere ♪ ♪ But I can see it anyhow ♪ ♪ Levitating across the clouds ♪ ♪ It's the end of nothing anyhow ♪ ♪ It's the end of nothing anyhow ♪ ♪ It's the end of nothing anyhow ♪ ♪ It's the end of nothing anyhow ♪ (guitar music) ♪ Ooh ♪ ♪ Ooh ♪ ♪ Ooh ♪ ♪ Ooh ♪ (guitar music ending) Well, that's all we have on "Prairie Post" for this week, and as always, thanks for watching.
(gentle upbeat music) - [Announcer] Funded by the North Dakota Council on the Arts and by the members of Prairie Public.
(gentle upbeat music ending)
Support for PBS provided by:
Prairie Pulse is a local public television program presented by Prairie Public













