New Mexico In Focus
Pro-Palestinian Protests at UNM
Season 17 Episode 46 | 56m 41sVideo has Closed Captions
Source New Mexico Editor Shaun Griswold hosts roundtable discussions on the pro-Palestine protests.
This week, Source New Mexico Editor Shaun Griswold hosts a two-part roundtable discussion on the pro-Palestine protests taking place on college campuses in Albuquerque and around the nation. Sophie Leah of Jewish Voice for Peace tells us why her organization wants the University of New Mexico to divest from Israel. Sarah Silva tells us about her work as a community organizer in Las Cruces.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
New Mexico In Focus is a local public television program presented by NMPBS
New Mexico In Focus
Pro-Palestinian Protests at UNM
Season 17 Episode 46 | 56m 41sVideo has Closed Captions
This week, Source New Mexico Editor Shaun Griswold hosts a two-part roundtable discussion on the pro-Palestine protests taking place on college campuses in Albuquerque and around the nation. Sophie Leah of Jewish Voice for Peace tells us why her organization wants the University of New Mexico to divest from Israel. Sarah Silva tells us about her work as a community organizer in Las Cruces.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
How to Watch New Mexico In Focus
New Mexico In Focus is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship>> FUNDING FOR NEW MEXICO IN FOCUS IS PROVIDED BY VIEWERS LIKE YOU.
>> Jeff: THIS WEEK ON NEW MEXICO IN FOCUS, ENCAMPMENTS ON CAMPUS.
A SPECIAL ROUNDTABLE LOOKS BACK AT THE LAST FEW WEEKS OF PRO-PALESTINIAN PROTESTS AT THE UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO.
>> Longa: GO ALONG THIS JOURNEY WITH US.
WE'RE ASKING FOR A DEGREE OF TRANSPARENCY WHICH IS CURRENTLY NOT AVAILABLE ABOUT THEIR INVESTMENTS.
>> Jeff: AND STANDING WITH STUDENTS.
WHY JEWISH VOICE FOR PEACE NEW MEXICO WANTS UNM TO DIVEST FROM ISRAEL.
NEW MEXICO IN FOCUS STARTS NOW.
THANKS FOR JOINING US THIS WEEK, I'M EXECUTIVE PRODUCER JEFF PROCTOR.
ON APRIL 30th, POLICE ARRESTED 16 PRO-PALESTINIAN DEMONSTRATORS AFTER THEY OCCUPIED THE STUDENT UNION BUILDING IN A PROTEST CALLING UPON THE UNIVERSITY TO DIVEST FROM THE STATE OF ISRAEL.
THE MOMENT FOLLOWED MORE THAN A WEEK OF PROTESTS AT UNM'S DUCK POND.
A HOME THAT ORGANIZERS HAVE SINCE RETURNED TO AFTER THOSE EARLY MORNING ARRESTS.
THESE ENCAMPMENTS ARE PART OF A LARGER MOVEMENT, AS SIMILAR DEMONSTRATIONS HAVE TAKEN PLACE AT CAMPUS GROUNDS ACROSS THE COUNTRY.
LEADING TO THOUSANDS OF ARRESTS.
IT'S A COMPLEX TOPIC.
AND WE'VE DEDICATED MOST OF THIS WEEK'S SHOW TO EXPLORING IT.
A LITTLE LATER, WE'LL HEAR FROM SOPHIE LEAH WITH JEWISH VOICE FOR PEACE NEW MEXICO.
AS A RECENT UNM GRADUATE AND NOW UNIVERSITY STAFFER, SOPHIE TALKS ABOUT THE POWER OF STUDENT-LED MOVEMENTS AND THE WELCOMING NATURE OF THIS ONE.
BUT FIRST, SOURCE NEW MEXICO EDITOR SHAUN GRISWOLD HOSTS A ROUNDTABLE DISCUSSION ON THE MATTER WITH UNM LAW SCHOOL PROFESSOR ERNESTO LONGA WHO HELPED DRAFT THE DIVESTMENT RESOLUTION.
CIVIL RIGHTS AND CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEY AHMAD ASSED, AND DAILY LOBO MULTIMEDIA EDITOR PALOMA CHAPA.
>> Shaun: THANKS, JEFF.
ERNESTO, THE COMMON THREAD HEARD FROM PROTESTERS AT COLLEGE CAMPUSES ACROSS THE COUNTRY IS THIS IDEA OF DIVESTMENT.
WHAT ARE UNM'S INVESTMENTS IN THE STATE OF ISRAEL?
WHAT WOULD DIVESTMENT LOOK LIKE?
>> Longa: OKAY, WELL, THIS IS A FAIRLY DIFFICULT QUESTION TO ANSWER.
WE KNOW THAT UNM HAS A SIGNIFICANT ENDOWMENT POOL THAT'S MANAGED BY THE UNM FOUNDATION.
>> Shaun: MILLIONS OF DOLLARS, RIGHT?
>> Longa: YEAH, HUNDREDS MILLIONS OF DOLLARS, I BELIEVE.
UNM'S LAST FINANCIAL AUDIT REPORTED HAVING -- THEIR CONSOLIDATED INVESTMENT POOL CONSISTING OF ABOUT $715 MILLION.
>> Shaun: AND THIS IS ALL IN RESEARCH YOU'VE HAD TO DO INDEPENDENTLY, IS THAT CORRECT?
>> Longa: YES.
SOME OF THIS INFORMATION IS READILY AVAILABLE ON THEIR WEB PAGES, THROUGH FINANCIAL AUDITS.
THE UNM FOUNDATION REPORTS A KIND OF HIGH-LEVEL INFORMATION ABOUT ITS INVESTMENTS IN A SERIES OF FUNDS BASED ON ASSET CATEGORIES AND THINGS OF THAT TYPE.
SO, WE'VE SUBMITTED A SERIES OF PUBLIC RECORD REQUESTS TO TRY TO GATHER SOME ADDITIONAL INFORMATION, BUT ARE REALLY RUNNING INTO A BIT OF A WALL.
>> Shaun: SO, DO WE HAVE AN ACTUAL FIGURE AS TO HOW MUCH UNM IS INVESTING IN THE STATE OF ISRAEL?
>> Longa: NO.
WE DON'T.
BUT WE HAVE BEGUN TO GATHER SOME SENSE OF MAYBE WHAT SOME OF ITS FINANCIAL CONNECTIONS ARE TO ISRAELI COMPANIES, PRIMARILY.
SO, SOME OF THE FUNDS THAT UNM HAS INVESTED IN MAKE PUBLICLY AVAILABLE THEIR HOLDINGS.
SO FOR EXAMPLE, UNM IS INVESTED IN BLACKROCK.
ONE OF BLACKROCK'S INDEX FUNDS.
AND WE KNOW FROM ITS INVESTMENTS IN BLACKROCK THAT IT HAS CONNECTIONS TO COMPANIES THAT PRODUCE MILITARY WEAPONS THAT ARE USED, AND THAT ARE BEING USED IN THE ASSAULT ON GAZA AND SUSTAINING THE ILLEGAL OCCUPATION IN PALESTINE.
>> Shaun: THAT'S DIRECTLY RELATED TO WHAT DIVESTMENT WOULD LOOK LIKE IF UNM WERE TO APPROACH THIS, IS THAT CORRECT?
>> Longa: YES, EXACTLY.
THERE'S SOME GOOD RESOURCES OUT THERE THAT WOULD HELP GUIDE US IN INFORMING WHAT DIVESTMENT WOULD LOOK LIKE FROM WHICH COMPANIES.
THE UN HIGH COMMISSIONER FOR HUMAN RIGHTS, FOR EXAMPLE, HAS IDENTIFIED 112 BUSINESSES, MOSTLY ISRAELI COMPANIES, WHICH PROFIT OFF OF THE ILLEGAL OCCUPATION.
AS A STARTING PLACE, WE COULD CONSULT A LIST OF THAT KIND.
OF COURSE, THERE'S OTHER DIVESTMENT LISTS THAT LOOK AT U.S. INVOLVEMENT AS WELL.
WEAPONS MANUFACTURERS, PRIMARILY.
>> Shaun: GOT IT.
ERNESTO, IT'S VERY FASCINATING TO KNOW THAT JUST THE AUDIT ITSELF, UNDERSTANDING WHAT THAT NUMBER IS, IS PART OF WHAT THE GROUP THAT CREATED THE ENCAMPMENT AT UNM IS LOOKING FOR.
THAT'S ONE OF THE THINGS YOU'RE ASKING THE BOARD OF REGENTS TO BEGIN, CORRECT?
IS THAT AUDIT PROCESS.
>> Longa: NO, I THINK WE'RE ASKING THE BOARD OF REGENTS TO DO IS GO ALONG THIS JOURNEY WITH US.
WE'RE ASKING FOR A DEGREE OF TRANSPARENCY THAT'S CURRENTLY NOT AVAILABLE ABOUT THEIR INVESTMENTS.
>> Shaun: PALOMA, I HAVE TO ASK NOW.
LET'S GO TO THE ENCAMPMENTS AND THE PROTESTS.
YOU WERE ONE OF THE FIRST JOURNALISTS IN NEW MEXICO TO SEE THE ENCAMPMENT AT UNM GET ESTABLISHED.
AND WHEN THE LOBO DID FIRST NOTICE THIS, WHAT WAS UNMPD'S INVOLVEMENT WHEN YOU FIRST STARTED THIS COVERAGE?
>> Chapa: DURING THE DAY, IN THE EARLY PART OF THE AFTERNOON, THERE WAS NO POLICE INVOLVEMENT.
WHEN THEY FIRST STARTED PITCHING THE TENTS.
>> Shaun: THIS IS ON DAY ONE, CORRECT?
>> Chapa: YES.
IT WAS A MONDAY.
>> Shaun: A MONDAY.
>> Chapa: AND IT STARTED OUT WITH A MARCH AND RALLY.
STARTING FROM THE SUB TO THE BOOKSTORE TO THE DUCK POND.
AT THE DUCK POND IS WHEN PEOPLE STARTED BRINGING OUT TENTS AND PITCHING THEM.
AND THERE WAS NO POLICE PRESENCE AT THAT TIME.
UNTIL ABOUT -- WELL AT 6 P.M., THEN THEY PUT THE FIRST NOTICE ON THE TENT THAT THIS IS A VIOLATION OF UNM POLICY.
AND THEN, AT 8 P.M., THERE WAS A RALLY THAT HAPPENED THAT EVENING BECAUSE IT WAS ALSO EARTH DAY.
THE POLICE DID COME AND IT WAS UNM AND STATE POLICE OFFICERS THAT CAME TO THE ENCAMPMENT, AND BROUGHT UP POLICY AGAIN.
THEY TRIED TO MAKE THE PROTESTERS REMOVE THE TENTS THAT WERE THERE.
BUT THEY STARTED -- THEY PICKED UP THE TENTS AND PICKETED WITH THEM.
AND THE OFFICERS PRETTY MUCH JUST STOOD THERE UNTIL, LIKE, LATE AT NIGHT.
AND THEY DIDN'T REALLY DO MUCH EXCEPT FOR STAND THERE.
AND I TALKED TO ONE OF THE UNMPD OFFICERS TO TRY TO GET A STATEMENT FROM THEM, AND I DIDN'T GET ONE.
>> Shaun: WHEN DID YOU FIRST NOTICE NEW MEXICO STATE POLICE SHOW UP ON CAMPUS AROUND THE ENCAMPMENT?
>> Chapa: IT WAS 7:51.
>> Shaun: THAT FIRST NIGHT NEW MEXICO STATE POLICE WERE THERE?
>> Chapa: YEAH.
>> Shaun: LATER THAT NIGHT YOUR REPORTING DID SHOW POLICE DID INTERACT WITH THE PROTESTERS AND CLEAR OUT THE ENCAMPMENT.
LATER INTO THAT WE SAW SOME OF THE SIMILAR PATTERN THROUGHOUT THE WEEK.
NOW, I'M CURIOUS BECAUSE THE DUCK POND IS RIGHT IN THE MIDDLE OF CAMPUS, WHICH MEANS EVERYONE SEES THE ENCAMPMENT, SO WHAT HAVE YOU NOTICED AS A REPORTER AS WELL AS AN UNM STUDENT IN TERMS OF THE WAY FOLKS ON CAMPUS ARE INTERACTING WITH THE PROTEST AND ENCAMPMENT?
>> Chapa: YEAH, I THINK I HAVEN'T REALLY NOTICED MUCH OF LIKE, EXCEPT FOR ONE DAY THERE WAS A COUNTER- PROTESTER WHO CAME IN WITH SIGNS AND STUFF.
OTHERWISE, I HAVEN'T NOTICED MUCH INTERACTION AS FAR AS PEOPLE OPPOSING IT.
I HAVEN'T BEEN THERE 24-7, SO I'M NOT SURE, BUT FROM WHAT I CAN TELL THOSE WHO ARE ENGAGING THE ENCAMPMENT ARE THERE, AND THOSE WHO AREN'T KIND OF JUST WALK BY.
FROM MY OBSERVATION.
>> Shaun: OF COURSE, IT CAN'T BE 24-7 BECAUSE YOU'RE A STUDENT THAT HAS FINALS THIS WEEK.
WE CAN TALK ABOUT WHAT'S THAT BEEN LIKE TO COVER ALL OF THIS WITH FINALS GOING ON, A LITTLE BIT LATER.
AHMAD, I WANT TO ASK YOU, LEGALLY SPEAKING WHAT RIGHTS TO DO STUDENTS HAVE TO PROTEST THE WAY THEY HAVE AT THE DUCK POND?
>> Assed: YOU KNOW, EVERY UNIVERSITY CAMPUS' FUNDAMENTALS OF FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION AND SPEECH ARE VITAL TO THIS DIALOGUE TO LEARNING AND SHARING KNOWLEDGE.
AND IT IS INCUMBENT UPON EVERY UNIVERSITY TO HAVE THAT TYPE OF ENVIRONMENT FOR STUDENTS TO BE ABLE TO EXPRESS AND RATHER THAN FORCIBLY SILENCE THESE FOLKS, MORE DIALOGUE AND MORE SPEECH IS ENCOURAGED.
WITH A WIDE VARIETY OF VIEWS.
SO THE STUDENTS HAVE EVERY RIGHT TO PROTEST, WHETHER THE CONFINES OF THE FIRST AMENDMENTS, AND AS LONG AS THERE ISN'T AN IMPEDIMENT TO THE OPERATION OF THE UNIVERSITY, OR THERE ISN'T PHYSICAL THREATS THAT ARE OCCURRING.
THEY HAVE EVERY RIGHT TO PURSUE THEIR ABILITY TO EXPRESS WHAT IS CHERISHED AND WHAT IS PROTECTED IN OUR CONSTITUTION.
>> Shaun: OKAY.
AND A WEEK AFTER THE ENCAMPMENT WAS SET UP, WE SAW THIS ESCALATE TO THE SITUATION AT THE STUDENT UNION BUILDING.
YOU KNOW THERE'S IMAGES AROUND US THAT SHOW A LOT OF WHAT PALOMA AND HER SISTER AND THEIR DAILY LOBO COLLEAGUE CAUGHT.
I'M CURIOUS FROM YOUR PERSPECTIVE, WHAT'S DIFFERENT FROM A LEGAL PERSPECTIVE?
ONCE THE GROUP DECIDES TO OCCUPY THE STUDENT UNION BUILDING.
>> Assed: I THINK THERE'S A DISTINCTION WITH REGARD TO ADMINISTRATIVE POLICIES VERSUS CRIMINAL ACTS.
AND SO A VERY GENERAL STATEMENT I'D LIKE TO START WITH IS THAT THE FOSTERING OF THE ENVIRONMENT REALLY IS A RESPONSIBILITY OF THE UNIVERSITY.
I LOVE WHAT ERNESTO SAID EARLIER ABOUT WANTING THAT UNIVERSITY TO GO ON THAT JOURNEY THAT HE SPOKE ABOUT.
BECAUSE IT'S ALWAYS SUPPOSED TO BE ABOUT THE FACULTY, THE ADMINISTRATION AND THE STUDENTS AS ONE.
WHEN WE START GOING AT SEPARATING STUDENTS AWAY FROM FACULTY AND ADMINISTRATION IS WHEN THE PROBLEMS START.
I FAULT THE UNIVERSITY FOR NOT HAVING HISTORICALLY BETTER RELATIONSHIPS, UNDERSTANDING STUDENT ORGANIZATIONS, FOSTERING AN ENVIRONMENT FOR MORE DIALOGUE, FOR AN OPPORTUNITY TO HAVE SPEECH.
BUT WITH REGARDS TO SPECIFIC INSTANCES IN TERMS OF THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN BEING AN ENCAMPMENT AND OCCUPYING THE SUB, THERE MAY BE A DISTINCTION.
AND THAT'S GOING TO BE DRAWN BY THE FACTS.
AND HERE'S ULTIMATELY WHERE IT COMES DOWN TO.
IS WHETHER IN FACT THIS ROSE TO THE LEVEL OF SOMETHING THAT IS CONTRARY TO THE POLICIES AND WHETHER THEY WERE ACTING WITHIN THEIR RIGHTS PEACEFULLY TO PROTEST.
AND ALLOW FOR THE STUDENTS FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION.
THAT'S GOING TO BE DICTATED BY A CASE BY CASE BASIS, QUITE FRANKLY.
>> Shaun: WHAT ABOUT THE GENERAL VIEWS OF THE ACT OF CIVIL DISOBEDIENCE?
PALOMA AND I, I WAS ALSO THERE WITH PALOMA COVERING THAT NIGHT AT THE STUDENT UNION BUILDING.
WE WERE THERE WELL INTO THE NEXT MORNING.
THERE WAS A GENERAL CONVERSATION AROUND EVERYBODY THAT THIS WAS AN ACT OF CIVIL DISOBEDIENCE.
YOU MAY HAVE TO EXPECT TO GET ARRESTED.
THERE WAS PREPARATION AROUND ALL OF THAT.
WITH ALL THAT STATED AS FACT TOO, IS THERE ANY ELEMENT REGARDING FREE SPEECH WHEN IT COMES TO CIVIL DISOBEDIENCE ON CAMPUS?
>> Assed: I THINK THAT IT'S ALSO CONTEXTUAL.
IN THE SENSE YOU DO HAVE A RIGHT, UNDERSTANDING THE RESPONSIBILITIES AND THE CONSEQUENCES IT MAY HAVE.
SEVERAL STUDENTS HAVE EXPRESSED THE IDEA THAT EVEN IF WE ARE ARRESTED, IT'S NOTHING COMPARED TO WHAT THE PALESTINIANS IN GAZA HAVE BEEN GOING THROUGH AND THE DEATHS AND THE GENOCIDE THAT IS OCCURRING.
SO THERE IS A SENSE OF CONSEQUENCE THAT HAS BEEN RECOGNIZED BY STUDENTS.
BUT I ALSO THINK THERE IS OPPORTUNITIES FOR THE UNIVERSITY TO FOSTER SOME DE-ESCALATION ON THEIR PART.
THERE'S A RESPONSIBILITY TO ENSURE THAT WE DON'T GO AND CALL IN STATE POLICE AND HAVE A FORCEFUL UPROOTING OF STUDENTS THAT OCCUPY THE STUDENT UNION BUILDING.
I REALLY DO FEEL THAT WAS OVER THE TOP WITH REGARD TO THE REACTIONS BY THE UNIVERSITY.
AND THIS IS, AGAIN, AN ACADEMIC SETTING TO WHERE FREEDOM OF SPEECH IS PRIMARILY WHAT UNIVERSITIES MUST FOSTER, AND ARE KNOWN TO FOSTER.
THIS IS AN EXCHANGE OF AN ACADEMIC ENVIRONMENT WHERE CIVIL DISOBEDIENCE IS PART OF CONVERSATION THAT OCCURS.
AND THIS WORLD HAS MANY ISSUES THAT ARE CONCERNING TO THIS GENERATION OF STUDENTS.
AND THEY'RE FINDING WAYS TO EXPRESS IT.
SO I THINK WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF THEIR RESPONSIBILITIES, AS LONG AS THERE ISN'T AN OUTRIGHT IMPEDIMENT TO THE OPERATION OF THE UNIVERSITY, AS LONG AS THERE ISN'T THIS NOTION OF PHYSICAL THREATS TO OTHER STUDENTS, THEY ARE TO BE PROTECTED.
AND WE TALK ABOUT THIS NOTION OF PROTECTION, RIGHT?
HAND AND HAND WITH THE ABILITY TO HAVE SPEECH BE PROTECTED, AND THREATS TO BE PROTECTED.
THESE THREATS AND SAFETY OF OTHERS NEED TO BE PROTECTED TO COUNTER, IF YOU WILL, THE COUNTER OPINIONS.
BUT PROTECTIONS ARE ALSO AFFORDED TO PEOPLE THAT WANT TO EXPRESS THEIR POLITICAL OPINIONS ABOUT WHAT'S GOING ON IN THE WORLD, AS HERE.
I THINK THE UNIVERSITY NEEDS TO RECOGNIZE THAT THOSE STUDENTS NEED TO BE PROTECTED.
>> Shaun: THANK YOU FOR THAT.
AND ERNESTO, I WANT TO COME BACK TO YOU AND WRAP UP THIS SEGMENT, HERE.
SOMETHING THAT WAS JUST STATED HERE, SOMETHING WE HEARD CONSISTENTLY FROM PEOPLE AT THE CAMP AND INSIDE THE PROTEST IS, YES, THE SITUATION WE'RE RESPONDING TO IS NOTHING COMPARED TO THE GENOCIDE THAT PEOPLE IN GAZA ARE FACING.
AND THE DAILY ATTACKS.
NOW, I'M CURIOUS ABOUT THE IDEA OF CIVIL DISOBEDIENCE AND THE TACTIC USED TO MAKE THAT A PRIORITY THAT NIGHT.
BUT IN RECOVERY SINCE THEN, WITH THAT ACTION NOW DONE, CAN YOU DISCUSS WHAT THAT SHIFTED IN THE MOOD AND IN TERMS OF HOW DISCUSSIONS FOR TACTICS HAPPEN IN THE ENCAMPMENT FOR STUFF GOING FORWARD?
BECAUSE I IMAGINE THIS IS NOT GOING TO STOP ANY TIME SOON.
IT WILL LIKELY GO INTO NEXT SEMESTER.
NEXT SCHOOL YEAR, EXCUSE ME.
>> Longa: YEAH, I WILL ANTICIPATE THE ENCAMPMENT CONTINUE TO WORK TO BRING PRESSURE ON THE UNIVERSITY TO ADDRESS SOME OF OUR DEMANDS.
I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO REMEMBER AND ALWAYS CENTER WHAT'S HAPPENING IN PALESTINE.
THERE'S A GENOCIDE UNDERWAY THAT IS MOBILIZED STUDENTS WHO HAVE DEEP CONCERNS AND WHO FEEL THAT THEY HAVE A MORAL OBLIGATION TO STAND UP AND SPEAK OUT AGAINST WHAT'S HAPPENING.
AND SO I ANTICIPATE THAT THE DEMANDS TO DISCLOSE OUR FINANCIAL RELATIONSHIPS TO ISRAELI COMPANIES AS WELL AS U.S. COMPANIES THAT ARE SUSTAINING AND PROFITING OFF OF THE ASSAULT ON GAZA AND THE ILLEGAL OCCUPATION TO CONTINUE.
DIVESTMENT IS A KEY TACTIC TO EXPRESS OUR MORAL OUTRAGE ABOUT WHAT'S HAPPENING RIGHT NOW.
>> Shaun: THANK YOU.
AHMAD, REAL QUICKLY TO WRAP UP, CAN YOU DISCUSS WHAT LEGAL ROLE YOU MAY HAVE IN HELPING THE PEOPLE WHO WERE ARRESTED AT THE SUB?
>> Assed: FULL DISCLOSURE, I HAVE COMMITTED MYSELF AND MY OFFICE ASSOCIATES TO REPRESENTING, PRO BONO, ANY OF THE PROTESTERS.
WE HAVE NOT YET CONCRETELY ENTERED AN APPEARANCE ON ANY OF THEM.
I ANTICIPATE THAT WILL PROBABLY HAPPEN.
>> Shaun: OKAY.
AND HAVE YOU HAD -- WHAT CONVERSATIONS WILL YOU OFFER FOR THEM IN TERMS OF REVIEW FOR THE CASE?
WHAT CAN YOU OFFER FOR PEOPLE THAT CONTACT YOU?
>> Assed: WE'LL OFFER THE FULLEST DEFENSE THAT IS POSSIBLE.
WE'RE FIRMLY IN BELIEF THAT THERE ISN'T A PALESTINE EXCEPTION TO THE FIRST AMENDMENT.
AND YOUR RIGHT TO SPEECH, AND FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION.
AND WE'LL AFFORD THEM A VIGOROUS DEFENSE IN THIS REGARD.
I ANTICIPATE ARRAIGNMENTS ARE COMING UP FOR THESE STUDENTS.
>> Shaun: NEXT WEEK, YEAH.
I HAVE TO INTERRUPT YOU.
THAT'S ALL THE TIME WE HAVE FOR NOW.
WE'LL BE RIGHT BACK HERE AT THE TABLE TOWARD THE END OF THE SHOW TO DIG A LITTLE BIT DEEPER.
>> Jeff: IT SEEMS LIKE IT SHOULD BE STRAIGHTFORWARD ENOUGH, BUT ONE OF THE MOST FRAUGHT QUESTIONS IN AMERICAN DISCOURSE AT THE MINUTE INVOLVES THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ANTI-SEMITISM AND ANTI- ZIONISM.
GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS AT THE STATE AND FEDERAL LEVELS HAVE COMPLICATED THE MATTER.
AS YOU'LL HEAR IN MY CONVERSATION WITH SOPHIE LEAH.
SOPHIE IS A MEMBER OF JEWISH VOICE FOR PEACE NEW MEXICO, A RECENT UNM GRADUATE, AND NOW A STAFFER ON CAMPUS.
WE TALKED ABOUT WHY HER ORGANIZATION STANDS WITH THE PALESTINE SOLIDARITY MOVEMENT, AND WHY ITS MOMENT IS NOW.
SOPHIE, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOIN ME THIS WEEK ON NEW MEXICO IN FOCUS.
>> Leah: THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR HAVING ME AND INVITING ME.
>> Jeff: SO HOW DID JEWISH VOICE FOR PEACE NEW MEXICO BECOME INVOLVED WITH THE PALESTINE SOLIDARITY MOVEMENT?
AND WHY?
>> Leah: YEAH, SO JEWISH VOICE FOR PEACE IS AN ORGANIZATION THAT STANDS IN SOLIDARITY WITH PALESTINIANS.
AND HAS FOR A VERY, VERY LONG TIME.
AS I THINK EVERYBODY KNOWS BY NOW, THIS HAS BEEN AN ONGOING ISSUE THAT HAS STARTED LONG, LONG BEFORE OCTOBER 7th.
AND THERE HAVE BEEN ADVOCATES STANDING IN SOLIDARITY WITH PALESTINE LONG, LONG BEFORE OCTOBER 7th.
AND JEWISH VOICE FOR PEACE IS ONE OF THOSE.
SO WHEN A LOT OF ORGANIZATIONS REALLY STARTED STEPPING UP TO STOP THE ONGOING GENOCIDE THAT'S HAPPENING IN PALESTINE, JEWISH VOICES FOR PEACE WAS ONE OF THOSE.
AND SO IT MADE SENSE THAT ALL OF THESE VALUED ALIGNED ORGANIZATIONS WOULD FIND EACH OTHER AND SUPPORT EACH OTHER.
THAT'S HOW JVP BECAME A PARTNER WITH THE SOLIDARITY CAMPS AND THAT KIND OF THING.
>> Jeff: GOTCHA.
I THINK YOU ANSWERED MY NEXT QUESTION.
YOU SAID THE WORD GENOCIDE.
I WAS GOING TO ASK WHAT SPECIFICALLY IN THIS CONTEXT YOUR ORGANIZATION OPPOSES.
SO I'LL ASK THE SECOND PART OF THE QUESTION.
WHAT DOES JEWISH VOICE FOR PEACE WANT THE UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO TO DO?
>> Leah: SO JEWISH VOICE FOR PEACE IS THERE TO SUPPORT WHAT THE STUDENTS WANT.
AND REALLY STAND WITH THE STUDENTS.
WE RECOGNIZE THAT THIS IS A STUDENT-LED MOVEMENT.
AND SO JEWISH VOICE FOR PEACE IS NOT LIKE DICTATING.
LIKE HERE'S SOME TALKING POINTS, HERE'S THINGS THAT YOU'RE PUSHING THEIR OWN AGENDA, BUT ARE REALLY BEING LED BY THE STUDENTS.
WHEN IT COMES TO WHAT THE STUDENTS ARE ASKING FOR, THEY'RE ASKING FOR DIVESTMENT, AND THEY'RE ASKING FOR DISCLOSURE OF THE INVESTMENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY.
AND THERE'S A DIVESTMENT RESOLUTION THAT WAS DRAFTED THAT IS VERY SIMILAR TO THE ONES THAT WERE CREATED IN THE '80s THAT STAND AGAINST SOUTH AFRICAN APARTHEID.
AND REALLY WHAT THEY WANT IS TO PULL MONEY BACK FROM WEAPONS MANUFACTURING COMPANIES, ESPECIALLY AS THEY PERTAIN TO THOSE THAT GIVE WEAPONS TO ISRAEL.
AND SO, YEAH, WE REALLY ARE FOLLOWING THE LEAD OF STUDENTS AND SUPPORTING THEM IN WHATEVER CAPACITIES THEY NEED.
>> Jeff: SO LET'S BACK UP A LITTLE BIT.
FROM YOUR PERSPECTIVE, HOW HAS UNM LEADERSHIP HANDLED THE PALESTINE SOLIDARITY MOVEMENT DURING THE PAST FEW YEARS?
AND DID THAT CHANGE AT ALL AFTER THE HAMAS ATTACK ON ISRAEL ON OCTOBER 7th?
>> Leah: I DON'T KNOW THAT I CAN SPEAK TO, LIKE, THE LENGTH OF HOW THE UNIVERSITY HAS HANDLED IT.
BESIDES THE STATEMENTS THEY HAVE PUT OUT, WHEN IT COMES TO THE SOLIDARITY CAMP, WHICH IN MANY WAYS SPEAK FOR THEMSELVES, I KNOW WHAT A LOT OF STUDENTS ARE REALLY LOOKING FOR IS THAT CONVERSATION AND THAT DIALOGUE TO HAVE WITH ADMINISTRATION.
SO THAT THEY CAN FEEL HEARD AND THEY CAN FEEL LIKE THEY HAVE A VOICE ON CAMPUS, WHICH THEY DON'T FEEL THEY HAVE.
YEAH.
>> Jeff: SOPHIE, DO YOU THINK IT'S FAIR TO SAY THAT THE UNIVERSITY, AT LEAST SINCE YOU REALLY HAVE BEEN INVOLVED HERE, HAS TAKEN SORT OF A PASSIVE OR HANDS-OFF APPROACH?
DOES THAT RING THE TUNING FORK FOR YOU?
>> Leah: YEAH, I THINK WHEN IT COMES TO MANY PUBLIC INSTITUTIONS, INCLUDING THIS UNIVERSITY, THAT THERE'S A SENSE THAT THERE NEEDS TO BE A KIND OF NEUTRALITY.
AND ONE OF THE BIG FRUSTRATIONS IS THAT WHEN IT COMES TO SOME OF THE REALLY EXTREME IMAGES WE'RE SEEING THAT ARE COMING OUT OF THE GENOCIDE THAT'S HAPPENING IN PALESTINE, THAT THERE CANNOT BE A NEUTRAL STANCE.
AND THAT MAKING NO STATEMENT IS ACTUALLY A VERY HEAVY STATEMENT IN ITSELF.
AND SO THAT'S REALLY WHERE THE FRUSTRATION IS COMING FROM.
WHERE A NEUTRAL STANCE ISN'T DOING IT FOR A LOT OF THE STUDENTS.
THEY WANT MORE THAN THAT.
AND ARE DEMANDING THAT.
>> Jeff: SORT OF NEUTRALITY IN AND OF ITSELF IS AN AFFIRMATIVE CHOICE, RIGHT?
>> Leah: YEAH, YEAH.
IN MANY WAYS. YEAH.
>> Jeff: GOTCHA.
LET'S DIG A LITTLE BIT DEEPER INTO THIS.
TWO YEARS AGO GOVERNOR LUJAN GRISHAM SIGNED AN EXECUTIVE ORDER ADOPTING THE INTERNATIONAL HOLOCAUST REMEMBRANCE ALLIANCE'S DEFINITION OF ANTI-SEMITISM FOR THE STATE OF NEW MEXICO.
THE U.S. HOUSE RECENTLY PASSED A RESOLUTION DOING THE SAME AT THE FEDERAL LEVEL.
WHAT DO YOU KNOW ABOUT THAT DEFINITION, AND DO YOU SEE ANY POTENTIAL PROBLEMS OR PITFALLS WITH ITS USE THIS WAY BY GOVERNMENT ENTITIES?
>> Leah: I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO NOTE LIKE THE DEFINITIONS OF ANTI-SEMITISM WHICH KIND OF CONFLATE ANTI- ZIONISM, AGAIN, ARE LIKE REALLY A RED HERRING TO THE ISSUE AT HAND.
AND IN MANY WAYS -- NOT ALL JEWS ARE A MONOLITH.
AND CERTAINLY IT DOESN'T SPEAK TO THE JEWS I KNOW WHO FEEL -- WHO HAVE EXPERIENCED ANTI-SEMITISM.
I'VE CERTAINLY EXPERIENCED ANTI-SEMITISM.
AND REALLY, IT'S SO FAR FROM THE ACTUAL ISSUE AT HAND, WHICH IS THE GENOCIDE OF PALESTINIANS AND INVESTMENTS IN WEAPONS MANUFACTURING.
SO REALLY WHEN IT COMES TO DEFINITIONS AND THAT KIND OF THING, IT'S SO FAR FROM THE ISSUE THAT IS BEING DISCUSSED AT THE ENCAMPMENT.
THE ENCAMPMENT HAS BECOME SUCH A PLACE OF LEARNING, ESPECIALLY FOR THE STUDENTS.
THEY'VE HAD TEACH-INS, CLASSES HAVE BEEN HELD THERE.
THEY'RE LEARNING TO DRAFT LANGUAGE AND THAT KIND OF THING.
TO ARTICULATE DIVESTMENT AND THEY'RE LEARNING ABOUT PAST MOVEMENTS.
AND SO THE DISCUSSION OF LIKE IS IT ANTI-SEMITISM SEEMS SO DETACHED FROM WHAT THEY'RE DOING.
AND REALLY, ALL OF THE DEBATE AND THINGS THAT HAVE BEEN GOING THROUGH CONGRESS AND THAT KIND OF THING TO DEFINE ANTI-SEMITISM IN RELATION TO ARE VERY MUCH SEEMING TO BE A DISTRACTION.
>> Jeff: I APPRECIATE YOU ANSWERING THAT QUESTION, TOO, IN THAT WAY.
SO YOU GRADUATED FROM UNM IN 2023, AND YOU NOW WORK AT THE UNIVERSITY.
I WANT TO MAKE CLEAR, FOR PURPOSES OF THIS CONVERSATION, THAT YOU ARE SPEAKING AS A MEMBER OF JVP, AND AS A MEMBER OF OUR CAMPUS COMMUNITY, NOT SPEAKING FOR THE UNIVERSITY OR THE PARTICULAR DEPARTMENT YOU WORK IN.
BUT I WANT TO ASK, WHAT HAS YOUR EXPERIENCE BEEN LIKE ON CAMPUS AS A FORMER STUDENT AND NOW AS A STAFFER WHO IS JEWISH?
>> Leah: YEAH, I FEEL LIKE A VERY WELCOMING ENVIRONMENT FROM THE OTHER STUDENTS ON CAMPUS, FROM THE PEOPLE I WORK WITH.
YEAH, I DON'T FEEL ANY ANIMOSITY OR THAT KIND OF THING.
I THINK THERE IS A SORT OF NERVOUSNESS THAT PEOPLE APPROACH THIS TOPIC WITH.
BECAUSE THERE IS NO -- THEY DON'T HAVE THE LANGUAGE TO TAKE INTO THESE CONVERSATIONS.
AND SO THERE IS LIKE A HESITANCY THAT I'M SEEING FROM A LOT OF PEOPLE ON CAMPUS WHO ARE KIND OF NERVOUS TO LIKE APPROACH THE ENCAMPMENT, AND THAT KIND OF THING.
BECAUSE THEY DON'T KNOW, LIKE, AM I GOING TO BE ASSOCIATED WITH SOMETHING REALLY WRONG, AM I GOING TO BE ACCUSED OF ANTI-SEMITISM AND ALL THAT KIND OF THING.
SO, I THINK SOMETIMES THERE IS A WALKING-ON-NEEDLES KIND OF THING.
BUT THE GENERAL ENERGY THAT I GET FROM THE STUDENTS IS REALLY WANTING A DISCUSSION.
REALLY WANTING TO BE ENGAGED IN THEIR CAMPUS.
BE ENGAGED IN THE PROCESSES OF THE UNIVERSITY, AND TO WANT THEIR VOICES REPRESENTED BY THE VOICES OF THE UNIVERSITY.
>> Jeff: SOPHIE, THIS IS MY LAST QUESTION, AND I'M NOT GOING TO ASK YOU TO TRY TO ANSWER IT GLOBALLY.
BUT FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF OUR CAMPUS COMMUNITY HERE AT UNM, WHY IS ALL OF THIS BLOWING UP THE WAY THAT IT IS NOW?
WHY THIS MOMENT?
>> Leah: I REALLY THINK IT HAS REACHED SUCH A BREAKING POINT FOR MANY PEOPLE.
WE'VE BEEN IN THIS HEIGHTENED STATE FOR LIKE SEVEN MONTHS NOW, REALLY.
SINCE LIKE OCTOBER 7th.
PEOPLE HAVE BEEN GOING THROUGH THE PHASES OF GRIEF OVER AND OVER, I THINK.
WITH ANGER AND SADNESS AND THIS DEPRESSION.
IT'S DIFFICULT TO SEE THE IMAGES COMING OUT OF PALESTINE EVERY SINGLE DAY.
AND IT WEARS ON PEOPLE.
AND I THINK WHAT WE'RE SEEING NOW IS A CULMINATION OF THAT EMOTION AND THAT FRUSTRATION MANIFESTING ITSELF WITH YOUNG PEOPLE WHO ARE REALLY INCLINED TOWARD SOCIAL CHANGE.
WHO ARE REALLY -- HAVE BEEN HISTORICALLY LIKE THE FORBEARERS OF PROGRESS, YOUNG PEOPLE ARE AT THE FRONT OF LIKE ALMOST EVERY HISTORICAL MOVEMENT.
I THINK WHAT WE'RE SEEING NOW IS A CULMINATION OF BEING WORN DOWN BY JUST A GROWING FRUSTRATION WITH LEADERSHIP.
AND WANTING TO BE A PART OF THAT LEADERSHIP.
WANTING THEIR VOICES HEARD.
>> Jeff: SOPHIE, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING ME.
I REALLY APPRECIATE THE CONVERSATION.
>> Leah: YEAH, THANK YOU, AGAIN SO MUCH FOR HAVING ME.
>> Jeff: WEEKS BEFORE COPS IN RIOT GEAR STORMED INTO THE STUDENT UNION, I SPOKE WITH SARAH SILVA, A COMMUNITY ORGANIZER BASED IN LAS CRUCES.
SARAH HAS BEEN IN THE TRENCHES ON COUNTLESS THORNY ISSUES FOR TWO DECADES.
AS WE PREPARED FOR THIS WEEK'S SHOW WE KNEW SILVA'S EXPERIENCE RALLYING OTHERS FOR POLITICAL AND SYSTEMIC CHANGE WOULD ADD IMPORTANT CONTEXT.
IT'S AN ELECTION YEAR, AND SARAH'S LINE OF WORK HAS HAD A BAD RAP IN THE RUN-UP TO AMERICANS HEADING TO THE POLLS SINCE BARACK OBAMA ARRIVED ON THE SCENE IN 2008.
OUR CONVERSATION BEGINS THERE.
SARAH SILVA, WELCOME TO NEW MEXICO IN FOCUS.
>> Silva: HI, THANKS FOR HAVING ME.
>> Jeff: ABSOLUTELY.
SO WE'RE GOING TO TALK ABOUT COMMUNITY ORGANIZING TODAY, OF COURSE.
AND THERE'S A LOT TO GET TO.
INCLUDING SOME OF THE WORK THAT YOU HAVE BEEN DOING IN THAT SPACE IN SOUTHERN NEW MEXICO, FOR MANY YEARS.
BUT I WANT TO START WITH KIND OF A BASIC DEFINITION.
COMMUNITY ORGANIZER HAS BECOME SOMETHING OF A CUDGEL.
MANY VIEWERS WILL REMEMBER JOHN MCCAIN'S CAMPAIGN USING IT AS A WAY TO PAINT BARACK OBAMA AS SOME KIND OF SUBVERSIVE EVILDOER DURING THE 2008 ELECTION CYCLE.
WHAT IS A COMMUNITY ORGANIZER?
>> Silva: THAT'S A GREAT WAY TO START.
SO COMMUNITY ORGANIZER IS SOMEONE WHO DEVELOPS AND EQUIPS PEOPLE IN COMMUNITIES TO ARTICULATE, SEEK, AND NEGOTIATE THEIR GOALS AND PURPOSES IN PUBLIC LIFE.
SO THAT'S A FANCY WAY OF SAYING MY JOB AS AN ORGANIZER IS THE ABILITY TO MOVE PEOPLE TOGETHER CONSISTENTLY TO REPRESENT THEIR BROADER COMMUNITY NEEDS TO COMPEL PEOPLE IN POWER.
OVER AND OVER AGAIN.
>> Jeff: AND WE'LL GET TO SOME OF THE HEAD-IMPACTING -THE-WALL NATURE OF YOUR WORK IN A BIT.
I REALIZE THIS WORK CAN TEND TO BE ISSUE-SPECIFIC.
AND WE'LL TALK ABOUT THAT SOME IN A MOMENT, AS WELL.
BUT BROADLY SPEAKING, WHAT IS THE PURPOSE OF COMMUNITY ORGANIZING?
WHAT DOES IT OR WHAT SHOULD IT AIM TO ACCOMPLISH?
>> Silva: WELL, WHEN I STARTED ORGANIZING -- SO I STARTED ORGANIZING IN 2004.
AND I ALWAYS THOUGHT THAT MY LIFE GROWING UP WOULD HAVE BEEN VERY DIFFERENT IF A COMMUNITY ORGANIZER HAD KNOCKED ON MY FAMILY'S DOOR WHEN I WAS A KID GROWING UP IN SOUTHERN DONA ANA COUNTY.
AND LIKE PART OF ORGANIZING IS LOOKING AROUND AND SEEING WHAT ARE THE PROBLEMS THAT ARE FACING OUR FAMILIES, DAY TO DAY, AND WHAT ARE THE WAYS WE CAN MAKE A DIFFERENCE.
THAT CAN BE LIKE RAISING THE MINIMUM WAGE, FOR EXAMPLE.
OR GETTING AS LOCAL AS LIKE GETTING A CROSSWALK INSTALLED TO SLOW DOWN TRAFFIC DURING SCHOOL HOURS.
IT'S THE THINGS THAT ARE MOST IMPORTANT TO THE FOLKS THAT ARE ACTUALLY ORGANIZING.
AND THEN THERE'S THESE LARGER MOVEMENTS THAT WE CAN SEE ACROSS THE COUNTRY.
BUT REALLY, IT'S LIKE ALL ORGANIZING IS LOCAL.
IT'S LIKE LOOK AROUND, WHAT ARE THE ISSUES AND THE PROBLEMS YOU SEE AND IS THERE A COMMUNITY THAT CAN HELP COMPEL SOME CHANGE AROUND THOSE THINGS.
>> Jeff: LET'S FINISH WITH THE DEFINITIONAL STUFF, BRIEFLY, IF WE COULD.
HOW DOES YOUR WORK IN COMMUNITY ORGANIZING DIFFER FROM, SAY, ACTIVISM OR ADVOCACY, AS PEOPLE TEND TO UNDERSTAND THOSE TERMS?
>> Silva: YEAH, SO THE DIFFERENCE IS THE ORGANIZING AND ORGANIZER WE'RE CALLED TO BE STUDENTS OF POWER AND STUDY POWER DYNAMICS.
AND THAT MEANS THE ADVOCACY DOESN'T STOP -- THE ADVOCACY MEANS ME GOING ON BEHALF OF SOMEBODY ELSE AND SAYING GO HELP THOSE PEOPLE OVER THERE.
THAT'S ADVOCACY.
LIKE I'M SPEAKING ON BEHALF OF SOMEBODY.
AND MOBILIZING IS ALMOST LIKE A ONE-AND-DONE FLASH MOVEMENT.
AND OFTEN YOU CAN SEE THAT.
AND THAT'S AN ELEMENT OF ORGANIZING.
BUT IT'S NOT THE ONLY THING THAT IS THE WAY THAT WE EXERCISE POWER.
ORGANIZING IS ABOUT CREATING DURABLE, LASTING RELATIONSHIPS AND MOVEMENTS SO THE COMMUNITY CAN REPRESENT ITSELF IN LIKE THE WAYS IN WHICH POWER DECISIONS MOVE IN THOSE COMMUNITIES.
ORGANIZING IS CONNECTED TO DURABLE AND ACCOUNTABLE COMMUNITIES AND CONSTITUENCIES.
AS AN ORGANIZER I'M GOING, SAY, TO A BUNCH OF CONGREGATIONS OR SCHOOLS OR NEIGHBORHOODS, AND I'M GETTING TO KNOW PEOPLE AND THEIR ISSUES AND WHAT THEY'RE STRUGGLING WITH.
AND I'M NOT LIKE, OKAY, LET ME GO AND ADVOCATE FOR YOU.
BUT WE SAY WHAT DO WE DO TOGETHER, AND WHAT DO YOU WANT TO DO ABOUT IT.
AND I'M OFFERING THE TOOLS, SUPPORT AND PATHWAYS TO HELP PEOPLE ACHIEVE THEIR OWN GOALS.
AND SOMETIMES THAT CAN TURN INTO A PROTEST, BUT OFTEN IT CAN TURN INTO LOBBYING AT THE CITY, STATE, COUNTY, NATIONAL LEVEL.
OR THAT CAN LOOK LIKE BIG, PUBLIC ACTIONS AGAINST A LANDLORD.
SO IT CAN MANIFEST IN A LOT OF DIFFERENT WAYS.
>> Jeff: GOTCHA.
IT'S SORT OF THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A LOCALLY-BASED JOURNALIST AND WHAT WE CALL A PARACHUTE JOURNALIST.
SOMEBODY THAT POPS IN FOR A QUICK SECOND.
>> Silva: EXACTLY.
WE HAVE TO WATCH OUT FOR THOSE CARPETBAGGERS THAT COME INTO OUR COMMUNITY.
JOURNALISTS OR ORGANIZERS.
>> Jeff: THANK YOU FOR USING THE C-WORD.
THAT MEANS I DON'T HAVE TO.
SO HOW HAS THIS WORK CHANGED OVER THE 20 YEARS THAT YOU'VE BEEN DOING IT?
AND WHAT HAVE BEEN SOME OF THE PRIMARY DRIVERS OF THAT CHANGE?
>> Silva: I'M GOING TO SPEAK -- I'M NOT GOING TO GET EVERYTHING.
RIGHT, BECAUSE A LOT HAS HAPPENED IN 20 YEARS.
BUT WHEN I STARTED ORGANIZING, NO ONE KNEW WHAT AN ORGANIZER WAS.
LIKE I WOULD SAY I'M AN ORGANIZER, AND PEOPLE WOULD SAY DO YOU GO TO PEOPLE'S HOUSES AND CLEAN THEIR CLOSETS.
>> Jeff: LIKE YOU'RE A TRAPPER KEEPER OR SOMETHING?
>> Silva: YEAH.
AND THAT WAS AT THE TIME THAT OBAMA HAD JUST STARTED HIS CAMPAIGN FOR PRESIDENCY.
HE WAS JUST BEGINNING TO COME ON THE SCENE.
AND SO NO ONE HAD A REFERENCE POINT TO ORGANIZERS AND THE REFERENCE POINT BECAME PRESIDENT OBAMA.
AND THEN IT SNOWBALLED INTO THAT.
SO WHAT HAS HAPPENED SINCE THEN, A LOT OF DIFFERENT THINGS HAVE SHIFTED.
ONE, I WOULD LOOK AT THE FINANCIAL CRISIS IN 2008 THAT DROVE SO MANY FAMILIES INTO LOSING THEIR GENERATIONAL WEALTH, AND THEIR HOMES.
THAT WAS A HUGE DENT THAT MANY ORGANIZERS WERE DEALING WITH.
AT THE SAME TIME, LIKE A FEW YEARS BEFORE ACORN WAS BASICALLY TARGETING FOR REGISTERING MILLIONS OF LOW INCOME AND BROWN AND BLACK PEOPLE TO VOTE.
AND THROUGH A COUPLE OF THEIR OWN BAD DECISIONS BUT ALSO THROUGH TARGETING, THAT ORGANIZATION CEASED TO EXIST AS WE KNEW IT.
BECAUSE THEY WERE EXERCISING POWER THAT WAS SCARING THE STATUS QUO.
SO WE'VE SEEN THAT OVER AND IN DIFFERENT PARTS OF THE COUNTRY WHERE PEOPLE'S CAPITAL AND SELF-INTERESTS GET THREATENED AND THE ORGANIZERS GET TARGETED FOR THAT.
I THINK WE'VE ALSO SEEN ALL THE WORK ON THE PALESTINIAN MOVEMENT AND WORKING ON FREE PALESTINE AND GAZA AND CALLING FOR A CEASE FIRE.
WE'VE SEEN A NUMBER OF PEOPLE COMING OUT AND ORGANIZING AROUND THAT.
CONSISTENTLY AND REPEATEDLY.
AND THAT'S NEVER HAPPENED BEFORE.
NOT IN THE U.S.
SO I THINK THAT IS BEGINNING TO SHIFT.
AND THAT'S JUST MORE RECENT.
AND THEN THE PANDEMIC, I THINK THE PANDEMIC HAS ALSO CREATED A LOT OF CONDITIONS FOR HOW PEOPLE ORGANIZE.
AND I COULD KEEP GOING.
I WANT TO TALK ABOUT HOW THE DIFFERENCES OF ORGANIZING HAVE SHIFTED AS WE'RE TALKING, TOO.
BECAUSE THERE'S JUST SO MANY WAYS TO LOOK AT HOW ORGANIZING AND PEOPLE WHO HAVE -- LIKE ORGANIZERS ON THE GROUND ARE CHANGING THE WAY WE LOOK AT POLICING, AT ABOLITION.
ALL OF THESE THINGS ARE CONVERGING IN SEVERAL COMMUNITIES ACROSS THE COUNTRY SIMULTANEOUSLY.
>> Jeff: I WANT TO TALK JUST BRIEFLY TO FOLLOW UP THERE ABOUT WHAT I OFTEN REFER TO AS THE DEMOCRATIZATION OF INFORMATION.
RIGHT, LIKE I GREW UP IN THE NEWSPAPER TRADITION WHERE WHAT WE DID WAS SENT A BUNCH OF PEOPLE OUT TO GATHER AS MUCH NEWS AS WE COULD IN A GIVEN DAY, WE PUT THAT ALL ON A BUNCH OF DEAD TREES AND THREW IT IN OUR DRIVEWAY IN THE MORNING.
AND THE INTERNET CAME ALONG AND SAID, NO, NO, NO, NO.
WE'RE GOING TO FLATTEN THIS.
SO I WONDER HOW DIGITAL PLATFORMS AND SOCIAL MEDIA, IN PARTICULAR, HAVE CHANGED THE WORK THAT YOU DO AND THE WAY THAT PEOPLE PERCEIVE THAT WORK?
>> Silva: YEAH, DIGITAL ORGANIZING HAS BECOME A REALLY HUGE TOOL AND WAY TO GET ORGANIZING OUT INTO THE COMMUNITIES RELATIVELY QUICKLY.
AND LIKE REALLY BROADLY.
AND IT'S NOT A SUBSTITUTE FOR GETTING ON THE GROUND AND BUILDING REAL, SUSTAINABLE RELATIONSHIPS.
SO I THINK ONE THING THAT HAS SHAFTED IS DIGITAL ORGANIZING IS ENOUGH OR JUST GIVING PEOPLE INFORMATION WILL THEN CREATE A DIFFERENT OUTCOME.
OR PEOPLE WILL THEN MAKE A DIFFERENT, OR RIGHT CHOICE, IF WE JUST GIVE PEOPLE INFORMATION.
THAT'S NOT NECESSARILY THE CASE.
SO THAT'S LIKE ONE WAY THAT I THINK THE INTERNET AND ONLINE INFORMATION HAS SHIFTED ORGANIZING.
AND THE OTHER IS WE CAN ACTUALLY GET OUR STORIES OUT AND NOT WAIT ON A LOCAL NEWSPAPER TO FIND A HOOK FOR OUR ISSUE.
THAT WE CAN ACTUALLY JUST CREATE A PLATFORM OURSELVES.
AND PUT OUR STORIES OUT THERE AND PUT OUR DEMANDS OUT THERE.
AND IT'S NOT ENOUGH.
SO I WOULD SAY DIGITAL ORGANIZING CAN LOOK A LOT LIKE ASTROTURF.
IT LOOKS LIKE OH, IT LOOKS LIKE PEOPLE HAVE A LOT OF POWER OR PEOPLE BEHIND THEM, WHEN IT'S ACTUALLY VERY THIN ENGAGEMENT.
AND THAT IS NOT SUSTAINABLE FOR ACTUAL MATERIAL CHANGE IN COMMUNITY.
>> Jeff: THANKS AGAIN TO SARAH.
YOU CAN CATCH THE SECOND HALF OF THAT DISCUSSION NEXT WEEK WHEN WE GET INTO THE CHALLENGES COMMUNITY ORGANIZING HAS FACED OVER THE LAST 20 YEARS.
NOW, LET'S GET BACK TO THE CAMPUS PROTEST MOVEMENT WITH SHAUN AND HIS GUESTS AT THE ROUNDTABLE.
>> Shaun: ALL RIGHT.
AND THANK YOU ALL, AGAIN, FOR RETURNING FOR ONE LAST DISCUSSION.
WE LEFT THE TABLE THE LAST TIME TALKING ABOUT SOME OF WHERE THE LEGAL ISSUE WAS GOING TO GO IN PROCESS FOR THE PEOPLE ARRESTED AT THE STUDENT UNION BUILDING.
AHMAD, WE KNOW NEXT WEEK THERE'S GOING TO BE AN ARRAIGNMENT.
WE KNOW THE UNM POLICE DEPARTMENT ARE THE ONES INVESTIGATING THIS CASE, WHILE STATE POLICE WERE THE RIOT POLICE THAT ARRIVED.
THEY WERE ACTING IN ASSISTANCE WITH THE UNM POLICE.
THE UNM POLICE WILL COMPLETE THEIR INVESTIGATION.
WHAT HAPPENS NEXT?
>> Assed: SO AT ARRAIGNMENT THEY ENTER PLEAS OF NOT GUILTY.
AND THERE'S GOING TO BE OFFICER PROSECUTION.
THEY'RE GOING TO BE PROSECUTED BY OFFICERS.
THE D.A.
's -- >> Shaun: UNM POLICE OFFICERS?
>> Assed: YES, IT WILL BE UNM POLICE OFFICERS, POSSIBLY WITH THE ASSISTANCE OF STATE POLICE.
DEPENDENT ON THEIR ROLE HERE, THEY MAY BE WITNESSES, AS WELL.
SO BOTTOM LINE IS THE D.A.
's OFFICE ESSENTIALLY WILL NOT BE PROSECUTING THESE MISDEMEANOR CASES.
AND WHAT WILL HAPPEN IS A DECISION TO PROCEED FORWARD WITH PROSECUTIONS WILL BE MADE.
ULTIMATELY, I THINK THAT'S A CALL FOR UNM THROUGH DICTATING THEIR POSITION TO UNMPD AS TO WHAT THE FUTURE OF THIS PROSECUTION IS GOING TO LOOK LIKE.
ARE THEY WILLING TO DISMISS THESE CASES?
ARE THEY GOING TO WORK OUT ARRANGEMENTS TO ALLOW FOR THESE STUDENTS TO PLEAD TO LOWER CHARGES OR MAYBE SOME FORM OF DISPOSITION THAT WILL NOT BE ON THEIR RECORD?
THESE ARE THINGS THAT WILL COME ABOUT AFTER THE INVESTIGATION IN THE COURSE OF THE NATURAL LIFELINE OF THE CASE.
>> Shaun: THANK YOU FOR HELPING US WHAT WE CAN UNDERSTAND NEXT ON THAT PROCESS.
I ALWAYS LIKE TO BRING THIS BACK ABOUT WHY WE WERE HERE.
WHY THE PEOPLE EVEN PUT THEMSELVES IN THAT POSITION TO BE ARRESTED AND WHY THEY'RE DOING THIS.
AND IT'S BACK TO DIVESTMENT.
THEY FOUND A WAY TO DO SOMETHING TO IMPACT THE INTERNATIONAL INCIDENT AND A GENOCIDE ACTIVELY HAPPENING, TO FIND A LOCAL WAY TO AFFECT THAT CHANGE.
THERE'S HISTORY WITH UNM DIVESTING.
ERNESTO, CAN YOU DESCRIBE WHAT THAT HISTORY IS A LITTLE BIT?
>> Longa: YEAH, INDEED.
THE UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO COMMITTED TO A FULL DIVESTMENT FROM APARTHEID SOUTH AFRICA IN 1985.
THIS WAS A PROCESS THAT WAS SUPPORTED BY THE UNM PRESIDENT AT THE TIME, TOM FARER, WHO WAS A HUMAN RIGHTS ATTORNEY AND SERVED ON THE INTER-AMERICAN COMMISSION ON HUMAN RIGHTS.
HE BASICALLY, YOU KNOW, PROPOSED A STANDARD THAT MIGHT BE INCORPORATED INTO A UNIVERSITY INVESTMENT POLICY.
AND WHAT HE SUGGESTED IS FOR THE UNIVERSITY TO ASK ITSELF, YOU KNOW, DO OUR INVESTMENTS FOSTER VIOLATIONS OF FUNDAMENTAL HUMAN RIGHTS, OR VIOLATIONS OF INTERNATIONAL LAW AND ALSO DO OUR INVESTMENTS SUPPORT REGIMES THAT PRACTICE APARTHEID OR COMMIT GENOCIDE.
THESE ARE THINGS THAT WE SHOULD BE CONSIDERING AND WEIGHING WHEN WE MAKE DECISIONS ABOUT INVESTMENT.
I'LL JUST SAY ONE THING ABOUT THIS.
THE ADMINISTRATION OF THE UNIVERSITY HAS BEEN MESSAGING STUDENTS IN THE ENCAMPMENT THAT THEY DON'T HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO THE AFFECT DIVESTMENT.
I WANT TO JUST EMPHASIZE HOW SHOCKING THIS IS TO ASSERT.
YOU KNOW, THE BOARD OF REGENTS BY THE NEW MEXICO CONSTITUTION HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO CONTROL AND MANAGE THE UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO.
IF IN FACT THEY DO NOT HAVE CURRENTLY CONTROL OF UNM'S FINANCES, EVERYONE NEEDS TO KNOW ABOUT THAT.
THAT IS REALLY QUITE INCREDIBLE.
>> Shaun: I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO NOTE THE BOARD OF REGENTS ARE PICKED BY THE GOVERNOR'S ADMINISTRATION AND APPROVED IN PART BY THE LEGISLATURE.
THEY'RE ALSO THERE IN PART FOR THE TAXPAYERS OF NEW MEXICO.
I THINK THAT'S A VERY IMPORTANT ELEMENT TO UNDERSTAND.
LIKE THOSE ARE PEOPLE DIRECTLY THAT SHOULD BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE.
IS THAT HOW Y'ALL VIEW IT?
>> Longa: YEAH, ABSOLUTELY.
ONE THING I WANT TO EMPHASIZE HERE IS THAT THE DIVESTMENT FROM APARTHEID SOUTH AFRICA WAS REALLY A DEMONSTRATION OF TRUE LEADERSHIP AT THE UNIVERSITY.
AGAIN, THIS WAS A PROCESS THAT WAS KIND OF INITIATED BY THE PRESIDENT AT THE TIME, BUT WITH THE SUPPORT OF A COALITION OF BOTH STUDENT AND COMMUNITY ORGANIZATIONS.
THE BLACK STUDENT UNION, THE ASSOCIATED STUDENTS OF UNM, THE NEW MEXICO RAINBOW COALITION WERE ALL INVOLVED.
ACTUALLY, THE GOVERNOR OF NEW MEXICO AT THE TIME, TONEY ANAYA, WAS SUPPORTIVE OF DIVESTMENT AS WELL.
THEY ATTEMPTED TO HAVE THE STATE DIVEST AND FAILED IN DOING SO.
BUT YOU KNOW, WE NEED THIS KIND OF LEADERSHIP RIGHT NOW.
WE NEED THIS KIND OF LEADERSHIP TO BE WILLING TO INVESTIGATE WHAT OUR FINANCIAL RELATIONS ARE TO A STATE THAT HAS BEEN DECLARED TO BE PRACTICING APARTHEID BY AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL AND HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH.
AND THE INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE HAS DETERMINED IS PLAUSIBLY ENGAGED IN A GENOCIDE.
THIS IS SERIOUS STUFF THAT WE NEED TO, AS A UNIVERSITY COMMUNITY, COMMIT TO INVESTIGATING THE EXTENT TO WHICH WE HAVE FINANCIAL CONNECTIONS WITH THESE CRIMES.
AND TO CONTEMPLATE AND CONSIDER DIVESTMENT.
>> Shaun: THANK YOU FOR SHARING THAT.
NOW, PALOMA, I WANT TO GO TO YOU BECAUSE YOU'RE ATTACHED TO ANOTHER LEVEL OF HISTORY IN ALL OF THIS.
IN JOURNALISM.
I THINK IT'S FASCINATING TO FIRST UNDERSTAND THAT YOUR MOTHER WAS A BROADCAST JOURNALIST AND IN FACT HAD COVERED OCCUPATION OF A UNM STUDENT BUILDING, THIS WAS IN THE '80s, RIGHT?
YOU HAVE THAT BACKGROUND, YOUR SISTER IS WITH YOU, SO NOW THERE'S THREE JOURNALISTS IN YOUR HOUSEHOLD.
BUT YOU'RE ALSO STUDYING FINALS.
YOU'RE A STUDENT AT UNM.
WHY IS IT IMPORTANT FOR YOU TO COVER THIS EVERY DAY AND AS YOU HAVE WHILE YOU HAVE THE OBLIGATIONS OF A STUDENT, WHY WAS IT IMPORTANT FOR YOU TO BE THERE?
>> Chapa: MY SISTER AND I INTENDED TO GO SHOOT VIDEO AND ELLA WAS GOING TO TAKE PICTURES.
ELLA IS MY OTHER REPORTER AT THE DAILY LOBO.
THE TWO OF US WERE GOING TO TAKE PICTURES BUT WE ENDED UP SPENDING A LOT OF TIME THERE AND JUST GOT TASKED WITH REPORTING IT, AS WELL.
AND THAT'S HOW WE FELT OBLIGATED BECAUSE WE WERE THERE FROM THE START.
AND THE THREE OF US WANTED TO STAY THERE INTO THE NIGHT AS WELL.
AND COME BACK EVERY DAY.
>> Shaun: DO YOU HAVE ANY EXPERIENCE COVERING PROTESTS OR INTERACTING WITH POLICE IN THE WAY YOU HAVE OVER THE PAST COUPLE OF WEEKS?
>> Chapa: NO.
THIS IS ALL A NEW EXPERIENCE.
>> Shaun: WHAT ARE YOU AT THE LOBO DOING TOGETHER, AND MAYBE THIS IS SOMETHING YOUR MOM IS OFFERING ADVICE ON.
WHAT ARE YOU DOING TO SORT OF NAVIGATE HOW TO COVER THIS WHILE MANAGING THE EMOTIONS AND FEELINGS THAT COMES FORWARD WITH IT?
AND ALSO BEING A STUDENT.
>> Chapa: AT THE TIME WE'RE IN TRANSITION OF EDITOR-IN- -CHIEF.
SO THE INCOMING AND OUTGOING EDITOR-IN-CHIEF WERE REALLY SUPPORTIVE.
LILLY AND MADDIE HAD GOOD CONVERSATIONS WITH US AND EVEN GAVE US RIOT GEAR IF WE NEEDED IT.
AND THEY WERE REALLY LIKE SUPPORTIVE IN MAKING SURE OUR MENTAL HEALTH IS THE TOP PRIORITY.
THEY SAID IF YOU DON'T WANT TO COVER THIS, YOU DON'T HAVE TO.
BUT WE DID IT, AND IT WAS A GROUP EFFORT.
>> Shaun: YOUR TWIN SISTER TOOK THIS PHOTO.
RIGHT?
AND THIS IS IN THE MIDDLE OF ALL THE CHAOS.
WHEN STATE POLICE ARRIVED.
WHEN YOU SAW HER STEP UP AS CLOSE AS SHE COULD TO GET TO THAT PLACE, WHAT ARE YOU THINKING IN YOUR HEAD?
>> Chapa: I WAS SCARED FOR HER.
BECAUSE SHE TOOK THE PICTURE, BUT SHE ALSO TOOK VIDEO AND SHE HAD THE CAMERA RIGHT IN THEIR FACES.
I CAME UP TO HER AND I WAS LIKE, BE MINDFUL OF THE FACT THAT THEY HAVE BATONS, AND THEY COULD CHARGE AT ANY MOMENT.
BUT SHE GOT RIGHT IN THEIR SHOES IN FRONT OF THE PROTESTERS.
I WAS JUST LIKE, WOW.
>> Shaun: AND YOU KNOW, YOU WERE ALSO DOING EDITING ON MULTIMEDIA WORK.
YOU'RE ALSO EDITING PACKAGE ALL THE VIDEO THAT YOU REVIEW AFTER EVERYTHING THAT HAPPENED AND OCCURRED.
AND WATCHING THAT VIDEO, DID YOU NOTICE, OR DID YOU EXPERIENCE ANY INSTANCES WHERE POLICE MIGHT HAVE STOPPED YOU AND PREVENTED YOU FROM DOING YOUR JOB?
>> Chapa: YES.
I FEEL LIKE WE DID.
I WAS KIND OF SHOUTING TO LET US RECORD A CERTAIN INSTANCE OF THREE COPS TACKLING ONE STUDENT.
AND IN THAT MOMENT A COP RAN TO ME AND KIND OF GRABBED MY ARM AND SAID, OUT THE DOOR.
YOU HEAR HIS VOICE IN THE VIDEO.
HE PULLED ME OUT THE DOOR AND HE DID THE SAME THING WITH MY SISTER WHILE SHE WAS RECORDING.
HE GRABBED HER BY THE BACKPACK AND JUST PUSHED US OUT THE DOOR.
AND THEY WERE MAKING LOT OF PEOPLE GO OUT THE DOOR, BUT THIS IS ALSO RIGHT IN THE MIDDLE OF US RECORDING A BIG MOMENT.
SO, I MEAN -- >> Shaun: THANKS FOR SHARING THAT.
AHMAD, THIS IS THE FIRST TIME YOU'RE HEARING THIS.
I'M CURIOUS WHAT ARE YOUR THOUGHTS ON THEIR ACCOUNT?
>> Assed: I HAVE TO TELL YOU, FIRST I'M VERY INSPIRED BY PALOMA AND ELENA.
THANK YOU FOR WHAT YOU DO.
>> Shaun: ELLA, EXCUSE ME.
>> Assed: I'M SORRY, PARDON ME.
YES.
SO IT'S A SCARY PROSPECT TO RELIVE THROUGH THEIR EYES THE FEAR OF BEING A STUDENT AND HAVING TO FACE EXTRAORDINARY, HEAVY-HANDED APPROACH BY LAW ENFORCEMENT ON A UNM CAMPUS.
A CAMPUS THAT SHOULD BE FREE FROM THE FORCIBLE SILENCING OF FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION.
IT IS AN EXTREMELY TOUCHING, IF YOU WILL, IN SOME RESPECT, NARRATIVE ABOUT THE VIEW FROM THIS SIDE.
I THINK IT WOULD BE VERY IMPORTANT FOR UNM, PRESIDENT STOKES, AND THE UNIVERSITY, FACULTY, ADMINISTRATION TO HEAR OUT THIS PARTICULAR EXPERIENCE AND UNDERSTAND WHAT CHAOS HAS BEEN BROUGHT ABOUT AT THE UNIVERSITY.
INSTEAD OF AN APPROACH THAT INVOLVED DE-ESCALATION AND ALLOWING FOR FREEDOM OF SPEECH.
PROTECTING IT IN PUTTING IN MEASURES FOR MORE CONDUCIVE, PRODUCTIVE, POSITIVE AREA OF SHARING KNOWLEDGE AS ERNESTO TALKED ABOUT HISTORICALLY, FOR EXAMPLE, WHEN DIVESTMENT OF APARTHEID SOUTH AFRICA WAS IN PLACE.
AND THE ADMINISTRATION WAS PART OF THE INSPIRATION MOVEMENT IN THAT REGARD.
>> Shaun: HE MENTIONED THE GOVERNOR AT THE TIME OF THE STATE OF NEW MEXICO WAS INVOLVED.
YEAH, THERE'S HISTORY HERE NOW.
WE'RE GETTING CLOSE TO WRAPPING AFTER THIS CONVERSATION UP.
CLEARLY, WE'RE GOING TO CONTINUE ALL OF THIS.
I REALLY ALSO WANT TO UNDERSTAND SORT OF HOW WE'RE VIEWING THIS AND WHY WE'RE HERE.
THERE'S ALL KINDS OF MANNERS OF HORRORS HAPPENING IN THE WORLD, HAPPENING OUTSIDE OF OUR HOMES IN NEW MEXICO.
RIGHT NOW, WHY WITHIN THIS GROUP OF PEOPLE THAT YOU'RE ALL WORKING WITH IN DIFFERENT SPACES, THIS GENERATION, WHY ARE WE CHOOSING THIS ISSUE RIGHT NOW TO TAKE ON THE RISKS OF FOLLOWING AND COVERING IT?
FIRST, ERNESTO, I WANT TO ASK YOU THIS QUESTION.
WHY?
>> Longa: WELL, GENOCIDE CONCERNS ALL OF HUMANITY.
REALLY.
YOU KNOW, RAPHAEL LEMKIN, WHO COINED THE TERM GENOCIDE AND CAMPAIGNED FOR THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE GENOCIDE CONVENTION, REFERRED TO GENOCIDE AS THE CRIME OF ALL CRIMES.
IN DECEMBER, THE INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE FOUND IT PLAUSIBLE THAT ISRAEL WAS COMMITTING ACTS IN GAZA THAT VIOLATE THE GENOCIDE CONVENTION.
FRANCESCA ALBANESE, THE SPECIAL RAPPORTEUR ON THE SITUATION OF HUMAN RIGHTS IN THE PALESTINIAN TERRITORIES, CONCLUDED THERE ARE REASONABLE GROUNDS TO BELIEVE THAT THE THRESHOLD INDICATING ISRAEL'S COMMISSION OF GENOCIDE HAS BEEN MET.
AND IN A RECENT FEDERAL CASE REGARDING U.S. COMPLICITY IN ISRAEL'S GENOCIDE, THE U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE JEFFREY WHITE STATED, QUOTE, "AS THE ICJ HAS FOUND IT IS PLAUSIBLE THAT ISRAEL'S CONDUCT IN GAZA AMOUNTS TO GENOCIDE.
IT'S NOW EVERY INDIVIDUAL'S OBLIGATION TO CONFRONT THE CURRENT SIEGE IN GAZA."
IN OTHER WORDS, ALL OF HUMANITY INCLUDING NEW MEXICANS HAVE A MORAL OBLIGATION TO STAND UP AND SPEAK OUT AGAINST GENOCIDE.
AND SPECIFICALLY OUR GOVERNMENT'S COMPLICITY IN THAT GENOCIDE.
THE U.S. GOVERNMENT HAS FUNDED AND FINANCED THIS GENOCIDE THROUGH BILLIONS OF DOLLARS OF AID, BUT BY PROVIDING DIPLOMATIC COVER IN THE U.N. SECURITY COUNCIL.
FOR A PERIOD OF TIME DEFUNDING RELIEF AGENCIES IN GAZA.
WE'RE DIRECTLY IMPLICATED AT THE MOMENT IN THESE CRIMES.
AND IT'S ALL OF OUR RESPONSIBILITIES TO STAND UP AND TO SPEAK OUT AGAINST GENOCIDE.
>> Shaun: THANK YOU FOR SHARING THAT.
PALOMA, YOU ANSWERED THIS A LITTLE BIT EARLIER.
I'M CURIOUS FROM WHAT YOU'RE HEARING IN YOUR REPORTING FROM STUDENTS, FROM PEOPLE AT THE CAMP, WHY ARE PEOPLE TAKING THE RISK TO PARTICIPATE IN THIS?
>> Chapa: WELL, A CONVERSATION THAT WE HAD AT THE SUB WAS LIKE EXCHANGING ARE YOU SCARED TONIGHT, LIKE ARE YOU SCARED OF GETTING ARRESTED.
A LOT OF PEOPLE TOLD US THIS IS AN ISSUE THAT IS BIGGER THAN THEMSELVES AT THIS POINT.
AND THEY'RE WILLING TO RISK LEGAL REPERCUSSIONS.
THEY SAID, I MEAN, KIDS ARE BEING BOMBED IN GAZA AND I'LL FACE ECONOMIC AND LEGAL REPERCUSSIONS.
I CAN FIX THAT.
THIS IS A BIGGER ISSUE.
SO THAT'S WHY WE'RE WILLING TO BE OUT HERE AND THAT'S WHAT A LOT OF STUDENTS TOLD US THAT NIGHT WHEN WE TALKED TO THEM.
AND ELLA ASKED THEM THAT QUESTION.
LIKE WHY ARE HERE YOU WILLING TO RISK?
ESPECIALLY AT THIS HOUR.
IT'S A SCARY ENVIRONMENT, BUT THAT WAS AN ANSWER FROM A LOT OF PEOPLE.
>> Shaun: OKAY, AHMAD WE'VE GOT 90 SECONDS.
FROM YOUR VIEWPOINT AS A CITIZEN OF NEW MEXICO, AS A TAXPAYER, NOT FROM A LEGAL PERSPECTIVE.
I'M CURIOUS WHY YOU'RE PAYING ATTENTION TO THIS?
>> Assed: I WANT TO COMMENT ON THE GENERATION THAT ARE INSPIRING.
I THINK SOCIAL MEDIA HAS A LOT TO DO WITH SHOWCASING ATROCITIES AROUND THE WORLD.
WHERE WE DIDN'T HAVE THAT IN OUR GENERATION.
WE HAD A NARRATIVE THAT WAS DICTATED BY THE MEDIA THAT WAS ESSENTIALLY HAD ONE PARTICULAR NARRATIVE.
AND NOW THIS GENERATION IS SEEING THE ATROCITIES FIRSTHAND.
THEY KNOW THE POLITICAL NARRATIVE.
THEY'RE SMARTER THAN THOSE THAT ARE ESPOUSING HATE.
THEY ARE TRULY AFTER JUSTICE FOR ALL PEOPLE.
WHETHER THAT HAPPENS TO BE IN GAZA, OR ANYWHERE ELSE IN THE WORLD.
AND I THINK AS A NEW MEXICAN, ESPECIALLY, WE'RE A STATE THAT HAS A VERY WARM AND INSPIRING COMMUNITY.
FROM THE NATIVE-AMERICAN COMMUNITIES, THE HISPANIC COMMUNITIES.
THOSE COMMUNITIES THAT HAVE ALWAYS SOUGHT JUSTICE AND MAY HAVE FACED INJUSTICE IN THEIR OWN WAY, HISTORICALLY, WANT TO COME TO THE TABLE AND FIGHT FOR JUSTICE EVERYWHERE.
I APPLAUD THIS GENERATION.
THEY HAVE PUT PALESTINE BACK ON THE MAP.
AND THEY ARE SPEAKING THE TRUTH BECAUSE THEY SEE IT.
BECAUSE SOCIAL MEDIA HAS ALLOWED FOR THAT TO HAPPEN.
>> Shaun: I REALLY DO APPRECIATE ALL THE CONVERSATION THAT WE HAVE HERE.
AND WHILE WE HAVE TO STOP HERE, WE KNOW THIS IS GOING TO BE ONGOING.
WE'RE GOING TO BE FOLLOWING THIS AS IT DEVELOPS INTERNATIONALLY WITH HOW THE UNITED STATES AND ISRAEL -- AND WHEN AND IF THEY STOP THEIR CEASE FIRE.
BUT THE SAME TIME WE'RE GOING TO BE TRACKING ALL THIS LOCALLY.
THERE'S A LOT OF WORK THAT'S GOING TO BE HAPPENING ON THIS FRONT.
PALOMA IS GOING TO DO A LOT OF WORK ON THAT AND WE'RE GOING TO SEE WHERE THAT GOES.
IT WILL BE AN INTERESTING YEAR AS WE TRACK THE REST OF THIS.
THANK YOU, ALL, FOR THIS.
AND THANK YOU, ALL, FOR WATCHING.
WE APPRECIATE IT.
>> Assed: THANK YOU.
>> Chapa: THANK YOU.
>> Jeff: WE WANTED TO INCLUDE UNM'S PERSPECTIVE IN THIS WEEK'S SHOW.
WE ASKED TO INTERVIEW PRESIDENT GARNETT STOKES.
THE UNIVERSITY DECLINED TO MAKE HER AVAILABLE.
NEXT, WE SENT A LIST OF EMAILED QUESTIONS TO STOKES THROUGH HER SPOKESPERSON, CINNAMON BLAIR, WHO IS ALSO CHAIR OF THE KNME BOARD OF DIRECTORS.
WE ASKED WHY STOKES CHOSE TO CALL STATE POLICE INTO THE STUDENT UNION BUILDING ON APRIL 30th.
HERE WAS THE RESPONSE.
QUOTE, "GIVEN THE SIZE OF UNMPD AND ITS LIMITED ABILITY TO MANAGE EVENTS WITH LARGE CROWDS WHILE STILL MEETING THE EVERYDAY NEEDS OF THE CAMPUS COMMUNITY, NMSP HAS BEEN CONSISTENTLY CALLED UPON TO SUPPORT OUR OFFICERS AND MANAGING THE ENFORCEMENT OF OUR POLICIES AND THE LAW, ESPECIALLY WHEN THERE IS A REPEATED FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH UNMPD DIRECTIVES."
END QUOTE.
WE ALSO WANTED TO KNOW WHERE STOKES STANDS ON THE DIVESTMENT RESOLUTION.
IT'S COMPLICATED, CAME THE RESPONSE.
SO STOKES AND OTHER UNIVERSITY LEADERS HAVE BEEN SPEAKING WITH VARIOUS PEOPLE IN GROUPS ON CAMPUS TO EXAMINE THE, QUOTE, "POTENTIAL CULTURAL, GEOPOLITICAL AND FINANCIAL IMPACTS."
END QUOTE, OF DIVESTMENT SO FAR STOKES SAYS THERE'S NO CAMPUS-WIDE CONSENSUS.
SO, QUOTE, "ADDITIONAL ENGAGEMENT IS REQUIRED."
END QUOTE.
LASTLY, WE ASKED WHAT PRINCIPLES AND ADVISORS STOKES CONSULTS WHEN TRYING TO BALANCE THE FIRST AMENDMENT WITH THE SAFETY AND ACADEMIC INTERESTS OF THE WHOLE CAMPUS COMMUNITY.
SHE REFERRED US TO UNM'S RESPECTFUL CAMPUS POLICY, WHICH THE UNIVERSITY ADOPTED IN 2011.
THANKS FOR WATCHING.
WE'LL SEE YOU NEXT WEEK.
>> FUNDING FOR NEW MEXICO IN FOCUS IS PROVIDED BY VIEWERS LIKE YOU.

- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.

- News and Public Affairs

FRONTLINE is investigative journalism that questions, explains and changes our world.












Support for PBS provided by:
New Mexico In Focus is a local public television program presented by NMPBS