
The Case for College
10/26/2026 | 31m 4sVideo has Closed Captions
Radio Atlantic host Adam Harris sits down with leaders of public and private universities.
Radio Atlantic host Adam Harris sits down with leaders of public and private universities to discuss how higher education can adapt to meet the needs of today’s students and create new pathways to opportunity.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
The Atlantic Festival is a local public television program presented by WETA

The Case for College
10/26/2026 | 31m 4sVideo has Closed Captions
Radio Atlantic host Adam Harris sits down with leaders of public and private universities to discuss how higher education can adapt to meet the needs of today’s students and create new pathways to opportunity.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch The Atlantic Festival
The Atlantic Festival is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipHere to discuss the Case for College.
Please welcome President of Mount Holyoke College, Danielle R. Holley, President of the University of California, James B. Milliken and the President of Columbia University, Jennifer L. Mnookin, with Radio Atlantic host Adam Harris.
How are we doing today?
I love it, great to hear it.
You all, thank you so much for joining me.
I'm really excited for this conversation.
I think we have a lot to talk about, as you can imagine.
I want to start with you, President Milliken.
I was thinking about the concerns that were coming out about artificial intelligence from some of the CEOs over the last couple of weeks, and I was looking into all that and saw that you all just recent had your AI steering committee give an update on sort of what you were thinking and how you were sort of implementing AI in the university and considering implementing AI and your university.
What have you all learned so far about the implementation and what is is necessary to to ensure that the the, the fundamentals of the university stay intact as we move into a new era?
When you use words like no and ensure, I'm getting a little nervous on this subject.
But we did just have a report from from an AI system wide AI steering committee.
The theme of the committee is AI for Humans and Humanity, and they have set a series of work streams with subcommittees that cross campus with faculty and students and staff on health and AI, on AI and learning, AI and discovery, protecting humans and AI for the public good.
And we're hosting these sessions across the state of California in combination with our campuses over the next few months.
It's our view that places like the University of California, especially one that contributed so much to the evolution of of AI over the years, needs to be in a leadership position, needs to be in this space, helping to define how it's used in our classrooms, laboratories, hospitals, but also what are the ethics around using, what are the guardrails around using it?
And we can't leave that to someone else to decide for us.
Yeah, it makes sense.
And I've been thinking about sort of that use of the sort of ethics of it and how you how you build out the ethics of it.
And Daniela want to go to you with this one because there is something that you learned in higher education.
I know a lot of people have been reading Stoner by John Williams recently.
Kind of there's this intangible thing about about higher ed that you get.
And George Washington explained it as such when they were thinking about creating a national university, right?
He said that there's nothing that better deserves your patronage then the arts and sciences, because knowledge in every country is the surest basis of public happiness.
And so much of that, they argued, grew out of college.
It grew out of the liberal arts.
Can you talk about the value of a liberal arts education, the value of those, those fundamentals in this AI age?
Yeah, I think as much as people want to do direct us and we do have to be leaders in the AI space.
I find that one of the most compelling things to me is that as I walk around my campus, a 2100 small liberal arts college, the very first of the Seven Sisters Colleges, founded in 1837.
When you walk across the campus at Mount Holyoke, it feels probably very much as it did in terms of commitment to the liberal arts as it did 100 years ago.
And so for us, the space is really about what makes us inherently human.
What are the things that we can do that AI might not be able to do?
And I think also in terms of women's colleges, HBCUs, MSIs, my previous institution is Howard University.
One of my biggest concerns is that if we don't lean into the liberal arts, lean into the humanities, the groups in our country that are most left behind, most underrepresented, most marginalized, will not have the opportunity to participate in the way that they have in the past.
And so that leaning into the liberal arts, when we're seeing a challenge as big as AI and an opportunity in some ways I think is more important than ever.
So walking into the studio art classroom, walking into an english classroom, I teach still as president of the college, I teach a seminar on the Supreme Court.
I feel like those are the things being face to face... If you saw University of Chicago unveiled a lot of their AI work, and a lot of it was around learning goals, what are the learning goals of the liberal arts and are we still committed to those learning goals?
And I have to say, at the small liberal arts colleges, including Mount Holyoke, we are deeply committed to the liberal arts and to the humanities, not just because, as George Washington said, there is nothing better to patronize, but also because we believe that those are still the building blocks of foundation of democracy.
President Mnookin the... sort of in thinking about that and you hear the arguments for the liberal arts, but you also hear students now and their families saying that we want something a little bit more tangible, right?
Like if we're going to spend this money on our college education, we have to get something on the back end.
And ROI is sort of like the overarching idea behind that.
How are you balancing that desire to, sort of anticipate what's coming next?
Because we can't really know what's going to happen in the job market for for the institution, but sort of thinking about sort of being at Columbia, sort of formerly being at the University of Wisconsin.
How do you how do you balance those two ideas of, we're trying to prepare you with these fundamentals while we know that you're expecting to be prepared for a workforce that, functionally tangible, intangible.
No, thank you for the question.
It's I think I would actually echo some of what I've already heard about a liberal arts education, actually being able to be thoughtful preparation for a complicated world.
I think that we can't ignore that one of the reasons why students go to college is to grow their opportunity set.
And that includes their professional opportunity set.
It also includes forms of flourishing in their later lives that are not simply about economic return.
But we can't ignore economic return as one of the things that they that they legitimately care about.
But I actually think that one of the things that that that the AI disruption moment is showing us is that a narrow focus on workforce skills may turn out to be higher risk, because the, the those particular skills might become outmoded or outdated.
And I hope that when students come to Columbia that what they'll actually get, they'll get some spaces where they are learning to think and write and interpret in device free ways.
And in fact, our core curriculum, which is a very important part of our undergraduate experience, has just decided in certain very critical classes to go device free across the core curriculum.
And I think that's a wonderful decision.
At the same time, I think it's incredibly important for our students to be ready to thrive, inhabit and lead a world where AI is likely to have a disruptive and transformative force in their jobs and roles, and so we should be exposing them to that and making sure that they are ready, ready for that world as well.
So I think it's a yes and, not an either or.
And I, I don't at all think that we should ignore ROI or our students being ready to, to be able to have very successful and flourishing lives, including careers.
But I think that to narrow a workforce frame for that might be missing the point.
Considering what institutions are trying to build, right?
And building out that curriculum.
I think we've seen over the last several years pressure not only internally but also externally, right?
Pressure from the federal government, pressure from state and state governments, and, and this desire to ensure that institution is maintaining its academic freedom while they are also dealing with those pressures.
I know that you've said previously that you wouldn't have taken this job if you didn't believe that the institution still had its academic freedom and was able to ensure its integrity.
But how are you thinking about that preservation of academic freedom and the integrity of the university and of universities in response to state, sort of, broadly speaking, state and federal government pressures?
Absolutely.
We're definitely in a moment where there's been many efforts to engage in relatively direct and more aggressive forms of, of, of direction and control.
This, the federal government's obviously one example, but but state governments across this country are doing this in many ways and many new ways as well.
And so it's important to recognize the breadth and complexity of, of, of this, of the set of dynamics.
I think that it's incredibly important that universities are able to choose who is teaching, what they're teaching, and that we maintain reasonable institutional autonomy.
Columbia did make make an arrangement with the federal government after, you know, hundreds of millions of dollars of research funding were being withheld.
And we, but under the terms of that agreement, we still hold all of the powers to make those decisions.
It's important to recognize that universities, especially research universities, like the ones that JB leads and ones like Columbia, have a lot of engagement and interaction with the federal government.
This goes all the way back to World War II.
There's been a partnership between the federal government and science funding here in the United States.
I think it's been an incredibly productive partnership, extraordinary amounts of high quality research, of medical research that has produced new cures of engineering research, that has produced new technologies.
This has happened because of this partnership.
But it also means that we are deeply entwined.
We're deeply entwined as a regulatory matter.
We're deeply entwined as a fiscal matter.
And that partnership has survived lots of ebbs and flows in in the political world.
But the last several years have put more pressure on that partnership than we've seen ever before.
And I worry that that has long term implications for American competitiveness, for our ability to train the next generation of extraordinary, of extraordinary researchers in the sciences, but not only.
And so I think that's something that needs to concern all of us.
President Holley, considering the that sort of dynamic, that federal dynamic, and also the institutions idea of ensuring their long term stability, right?
You don't want to run too far afoul of the federal government.
You don't want to run afoul of the state government because that's you don't want to buy, you know, bite the hand that feeds you in a certain sense.
But there is there is an argument that institutions are going to far in advance of anything practically being implemented.
Right.
The law says one thing and institutions are doing another.
How when you are processing all of the developments over the last decade in higher education, because really this started in state governments about a decade ago.
How are you thinking about about that, about sort of the elimination of these programs and the necessity of the programs?
Yeah, I think strongly about, obviously the partnership between the federal government and our higher ed institutions is very important.
But I think something that I've been thinking about and really focusing on the last few years is the importance of the respect of institutional independence, right?
Because that is at the core of academic freedom.. Yes, we think of academic freedom as being about being able to determine your own curriculum, being able to hire your own professors.
But there is also something to a university or college in the United States saying, we value diversity, equity and inclusion, and we value it strongly as a part of our core mission and values.
So at Mount Holyoke, we are a women's college.
We are gender diverse women's college.
We believe strongly that we have been here for 190 years, and we have the right to determine our own institutional independence.
And so when the federal government tells or tries to convince institutions that it is illegal to engage in diversity, equity and inclusion actions that are well covered by the law.
That to me is extremely, extremely worrisome because it is attempting to restructure the ability, especially, I think, of private institutions.
So that's also the contrast between my institution and the two that are here.
When we talk about our private institutions, it is also important for the government to respect what private institutions do and our ability to carry our missions forward.
And I think without that, what we will see is the government, for example, trying to put us all in the same box.
So when it comes to return on investment or what they're calling the earnings regulations, they do not recognize that women are still structurally underpaid in the United States, people of color, Black and LatinA people are structurally underpaid.
In our job market.
There is no accounting for many of those inequalities.
And I think when we see the federal government attempting to engage with our higher ed institutions, it must be in a way that respects institutional independence and also takes into account structural inequality, because without those two things, they cannot be seen as a legitimate broker in the space of higher ed.
[applause] President Milliken, I was actually the beneficiary of one of those programs at UC Irvine when I was in undergrad.
There was the summer undergraduate research fellowship, where I studied with a professor in the Department of Political science.
And it's I have a similar question for you, right?
Sort of leading that large university system, how how are you sort of balancing that relationship with the sort of federal government, state government and and ensuring that you're you're sort of institutions have continued to, you know, value those things that you have historically valued?
Yeah.
Well, I'm spending a lot more money on lawyers, >>I can tell you.
>>There will be lawyers.
So I've been at the University of California now for a little over a year.
The first week that I started, the administration froze $580 million of NIH grants at your former campus.
At the end of that week, we got a voluntary resolution agreement that suggested we should pay $1 billion to have the funds released.
Fortunately, they were and we have said from day one we get $19 billion a year from the federal government, whether it's Medicaid, Medicare, or whether it's 5 billion for research at the University of California.
And no matter which administration it is, we have an obligation.
We're audited by them.
We always have had investigations, no matter who was in Washington.
So our views always been that, of course, we'll talk to the federal government.
They are necessary partners and as Jennifer said, have been since very strong partners since the Second World War.
It doesn't mean that we will give up on our independence, that we will give up on our governance, that we will sacrifice academic freedom or the other kinds of decisions that have made universities great.
And you look at the stream you started with George Washington.
So I'll start a little later, like 1862.
You look at the at the Morrel Act, then you look at the GI Bill, then you look at the Civil Rights Acts.
And each of those were important expansions of higher education in this country.
And since the 1960s, we have based much of our federal policy on higher education around supporting the cost of higher education across the board, because the one thing we know, thanks to Raj Chetty and his colleagues and some others, is that opportunities, universal or talent is universal.
Sorry, but opportunitys not in higher education, as you have often said, is the way that you bridge that talent and opportunity.
So we're going to continue to do everything we can to keep that partnership strong and keep the support for people across the University of California, so that the 300,000 students there can thrive.
Yeah.
You mentioned, you mentioned the Morrel Act, right?
1862 the federal government doles out something like 17 million acres of land, expropriated from some like 250 indigenous tribes that state that states can sell in order to fund fund institutions.
And that sort of gave us the baseline for our higher education system today.
But it was a sort of development, right?
It was higher education was for a certain subset of people.
And then the first Morrill Act says, we have places to train men in the art of man slaying.
We have places to create lawyers and doctors, but we don't have places for to to clothe and feed the great brotherhood of mankind, right?
It's Justin Morrill.
So when you were thinking about the next development in higher education, kind of who the current iteration of students, who your institutions are serving, right, including that like traditional 18 to 24, but also the adult student now.
How are you thinking about wrapping this new iteration of students into, and this kind of goes for each of you to, into your into your system and and providing for them the services that are necessary to be successful?
So, so in 1960, one of my predecessors, Clark Kerr, was credited as being the principal author of the California master plan, which sort of set the standard for how higher education is organized around the country.
14 million people in the state.
Now, there are over 40 million people in the state.
Much more demand on our institution.
UCLA got 198,000 applications for its freshman class last year.
So there's much more demand.
We are not going to satisfy that in the traditional model, even as big as our campuses are.
So they're basically two things I would say about this and what the 21st century master plan looks like to me.
It's how we extend the incredibly high quality programs of the University of California outside of our campuses to more people throughout the state who would benefit.
And then I think, equally important, it's how do we do it for a lifetime?
People are going to need to be educated.
We've always talked about lifelong learning.
It's an imperative now.
We don't know what the world's going to look like in a few years and we know that our graduates are going to need opportunities to keep learning, reskilling, retooling.
And so those are the two ways I think we need to think about how we expand what we've traditionally done.
And President Holley, how does that look on a traditionally like residential campus?
Yeah, it's one of the biggest challenges to is to think about how can we make a residential college campus model still available, available and affordable in this in this era?
And it is a real challenge.
I think on the opposite side from not all of us are lucky enough to get 198,000 applications every year.
We make a lot of enemies.
Exactly, exactly.
And I think what's happening is that we're really seeing the demographic, cliff.
The smaller numbers of students who are graduating from high school.
And it will have a major impact on the 2800 plus colleges and universities.
So often when we think about colleges and universities, we think about the ones that are on the stage right here.
But we know that our regional campuses are struggling in the state system.
We see the closure and merger of many higher ed institutions, including ones in our own backyard, like Hampshire College in Western Massachusetts and many others.
And I think what we're seeing is the need to partner in a much, much more thoughtful way.
So, for example, community colleges partnering with residential small liberal arts colleges to say, yes, you may do two years at a community college and then come over and have a traditional residential experience at a place like Mount Holyoke or a place like Smith, right?
But that need to really understand in the higher ed ecosystem, how are our universities, how are our colleges connected, and then what do people need?
Many people, and we know that there are a huge number of Americans who have not been able to fully benefit from their college degree because they have college credits and no degree, right?
So one of the things I'm most interested in is how we get those students to the finish line, right?
How do we take students who have some college credits and help them to get their degrees?
Because we know that people with a bachelor's degree that's worth about $2.8 million over your lifetime, and people with bachelor's degrees earn about 84% more over the course of their lifetime.
We need to be focused on many of the populations in the United States who have not been able to fully take advantage of the bachelor's degree, and how do we use our higher ed, higher ed ecosystem to help make that possible?
I think that idea of partnerships is really interesting.
And President Mnookin I want to come to you with this one in part because, right?
If you were and I promise, I don't just have like stats at hand, these stories that I've written in the past.
So if you're a Black student going to a public college in North Carolina, something like 22% of them go to one of the 12 predominantly white institutions, around 25% go to one of the five, one of the five historically black colleges, and the rest of them go to community colleges.
And so, like, if you're thinking about that sort of idea of access and getting people to the next step, to get to the next step, it is important to factor community colleges into that equation.
How are you all at Columbia sort of thinking about those partnerships with even the local institutions in in New York?
Yes.
And similarly, when you were at Wisconsin, right?
How were you thinking about those as well?
Yes, well, so I, we we actually have a brand new program with a couple of community colleges in Manhattan that is a transfer program into our undergraduate general studies program.
We also have a 2+2+2 program, two years in community college, two years with an undergraduate degree with us, and then a public health degree.
And I think thinking about expanding partnerships like that is is a valuable and really important thing.
I think Columbia does need to look at how can we grow even more our engagement with this city, and what does that look like?
I'll do a shout out for JB here, because the UC system has had long in that master plan a lot of emphasis on transfer from community college to the UCs.
And there's a general point here, which is, I think, important across the ecosystem and needs to be said, which is that one of the glories of the American higher education system has been its variety, and also that there are lots of ways to have on ramps and off ramps.
And we need to protect that and even grow the ability that people can with some college or come to college later.
At Columbia, our general studies program, which has been around for many decades, is a very important space for that framing, for educational opportunity.
And it's something that I'm proud of and excited about.
I've also I didn't know this until until I began to look at this opportunity.
But, you know, Columbia has more more vets than the rest of the Ivy League put together.
And so thinking about different kinds of on ramps and opportunities and not making what was available to somebody at 18 or 19 or 20, the end story of what might be possible is something that I think we all should be attending to across the ecosystem, whether we're a four year residential college, whether we're a school like Columbia, whether we're a, you know, the UC system or whether we're a regional comprehensive, as there were a dozen of in my former state.
You know, you talk about the hallmarks of our education system, one of them, right?
One of the things that made American higher education a sort of jewel of the world in higher education is the sort of that idea of access not only for students in the United States, but also the international students who would come over and study.
And there have been a lot of policy changes as they relate to international students.
How are you all... President Milliken, I'll go to you first, especially in thinking about the UC system, thinking about the researchers that are coming through the UC system.
How are you balancing sort of protecting both the professors now who are at the institution, but also thinking about the students who might be able to benefit, who are no longer able to benefit thanks to the policy?
So I mentioned my first week at the University of California, which was not a high for me, but two months in Nobel Prizes were announced, and of the six American Nobel Prize winners, five were from the University of California.
Three were born in other countries.
Three were born in other countries.
And the United States has been the greatest beneficiary of the global migration of talent in the history of the world.
[applause] So this is, this is an unforced error to cut off and do things that are restricting that supply of talent that we have benefited so enormously from.
So these these two pieces, as Jennifer mentioned, The Vannevar Bushs “Science, the New Frontier,” the partnership between higher education and the federal government since World War II, the support we would build the buildings, we hire talented faculty and graduate students, admit them, and the federal government supports it with research grants.
Similarly being open to talent all over the world for our science, and technology, and engineering, and medicine has has made this country the envy of the world.
And we need to preserve those two things.
Absolutely.
I've spoken with a lot of sort of higher education historians over the last several years, including John Thelin, who wrote the “History of American Higher Education.”
If you haven't read it, it's a great book and kind of gives you the full overview of kind of how we got to where we are now.
And when I asked him a couple of years ago, is this moment, like, genuinely different than what we have experienced before?
And he said, “yes, I think what right now, between the state and the federal policies, we are undergoing a transformation that will affect the next generation of of higher education and affect the students for the next generation.”
So I guess for for all three of you, you know, we've all had versions of like the future of higher education kind of conversations.
But if it's 2036, right, a decade from now undergoing all of the changes that we've seen now, what do you think that conversation looks like ten years from now?
Where do you actually see American higher education and a decade and President Mnookin, I'll start with you and we can... Oh, good.
Thank you, thank you.
You know, ten years is actually sort of a blink of an eye in some ways.
What I hope is that some of the that we're having today about trust and trust in higher ed and trust in institutions, I hope that those are less front and center.
I hope that across the political spectrum, we have found our way back to recognizing that universities and colleges may not be perfect.
We may not get everything right.
We may need to engage in some look, some forms of self-examination.
We certainly need to worry about affordability.
We need to worry about access.
We need to worry about structural inequality.
But I hope we're in a place where we recognize that knowledge and learning and knowledge production are good for our country, good for the world, and good for our communities, and that we're working together to try to figure out more ways to offer those opportunities to people who are seeking them, in ways to help them build a better life.
And then we could be in a more constructive place rather than a dart throwing place, or a place where sometimes it feels like we're taking lovely, flawed but but lovely crystal balls and throwing them onto the ground and shattering them.
So I hope we can be in a place where where trust is reemerging and we are working together for the benefit of future generations in our nation in a very challenging times.
I completely agree with that.
I think one additional thing I would add is that I would hope that as higher education institutions, we have been able to make the case in a much more affirmative way about what is it that we actually do in our institutions.
I think we have gotten on the defensive and are trying to defend.
Are we places that indoctrinate students?
Are we places that are unaffordable?
Are we places that we are not able to interest students in all of the incredible learning that there is the production of knowledge?
I hope that we have made a much more affirmative statement about why is higher ed not just important for the individuals that attend our institutions, but why is it important for the democracy itself?
And I think unless we are willing to make that articulation the same that we did after World War II, we will see our institutions continue to crumble.
First, if we're here ten years later to talk about what higher education looks like, that means that the 10% chance that well all be killed in a couple of years by AI... Didn't happen.
Didn't happen.
So that's that's great.
Second, higher ed is going to be around and it's going to be strong.
As my newest member of my Board of Regents, Scott Galloway, told me, the only people who say you shouldn't go to college have graduate degrees from Stanford.
>>Right.
>>Yes.
>>So... >>Yes.
Absolutely.
We are going to be here, but we we have work to do.
We have work to do to try to get back to the sort of the trust, the commitment that the American people have and that their government has in higher education, and to acknowledge how it has been a partner in building the strength of this country.
And that's what I hope we will have been successful at.
All right.
Well, President Millikin, president Holley, President Mnookin, and thank you so much for your time.
>>Thank you.
>>Thank you.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.

- News and Public Affairs

Today's top journalists discuss Washington's current political events and public affairs.




New Episode


New Episode


Support for PBS provided by:
The Atlantic Festival is a local public television program presented by WETA