The Darr Mine Disaster
The Darr Mine Disaster
12/19/2007 | 28m 1sVideo has Closed Captions
Pennsylvania’s 1907 Darr Mine disaster spurred safety reform and a fight to preserve its history.
In 1907, an explosion at the Darr Mine in Westmoreland County killed 239 men and boys—the worst mining disaster in Pennsylvania history. This documentary recounts the tragedy and the community’s determination, led by Ann Toth of Bobtown, to honor the victims and preserve the story that reshaped mining safety.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
The Darr Mine Disaster is a local public television program presented by WQED
The Darr Mine Disaster
The Darr Mine Disaster
12/19/2007 | 28m 1sVideo has Closed Captions
In 1907, an explosion at the Darr Mine in Westmoreland County killed 239 men and boys—the worst mining disaster in Pennsylvania history. This documentary recounts the tragedy and the community’s determination, led by Ann Toth of Bobtown, to honor the victims and preserve the story that reshaped mining safety.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
How to Watch The Darr Mine Disaster
The Darr Mine Disaster is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipMost of it's covered up right now, but I think we can still see it.
There is something in the woods here.
This is where the, one pit mouth was.
Not many people know it's there.
According to the mine map that I have.
Just off the Youghiogheny bike trail on a hill above the river is a lon forgotten doorway to our past.
But it has been a long time.
100 years.
A simple hole in the hillside.
The timbers are gone.
It's all cave down.
So caved in.
It's hard to believe this opening used to be 20 times bigger.
And you could just about see down it here now.
Hard to believe.
Hundreds of men went to work here every day.
They don't really know how many bodies was in that mine.
This is what's left of the Darr.
Mine.
This is the story of what happened here.
The whole York Valley shook.
People many, many miles away could feel it.
The darr mine exploded on December 19th, 1907.
240 men went to wor that day, and 239 were killed.
It remains the worst mining disaster in Pennsylvania history, yet very few people know much about it.
Most of this history has been forgotten about.
That's why a small but dedicated group of people is working to change that, by reminding others of how the explosion affected so many lives.
To our family, the dark tragedy meant a lot.
How it changed safety laws and how what many call a religious miracle kept the tragedy from being much worse.
We see thousands of people alive today because their father and grandfathers went to church that day with all that intrigue and a 100 year anniversary.
Historians are showin new interest in the darr mine, and when they start their research, they start in a most unlikely place.
These are the listings of some of the men.
The living room of a 78 year old woman in Bobtown Pennsylvania.
I'm from the land, the hungry and I am hungry.
Magyarorszag and Toth is proud of her heritage.
Oh, yeah.
I love the traditions, you know, and her family heirlooms.
The Hungarian owner of the house.
She's telling the neighbor lady to go home and mind your own business.
And don't come here with her gossip.
I have a picture of my father playing his violin.
The picture of her dad is fading.
But.
Anna can still hear the music.
And she still has his violin.
I am passionate about my Hungarian music.
It's her passion for the darr mine, though, that keeps and going.
She's gathered the world's largest collection of darr images and artifacts.
She's fought hard to restore a cemetery where the miners are buried.
Like Anna's family, most of the miners were Hungarian.
And she has a personal connection to the disaster.
I've got coal dust running in my blood, you know, in my veins.
Yes.
But more than that, this coal miner's daughte and coal miner's granddaughter has respect for the people whose lives revolved around the Dar and the other mines of that era.
Both sides of the family.
And always living in the coal mining patches.
Anna's family settled in those patch towns of the Youghiogheny River valley in 1903.
Her grandparents had left Budapest to make a better life and once here the family grew, with most of the men finding work in these mines.
30 miles southeast of Pittsburgh.
Religion was important.
So was family and community life.
The men would gather sometimes underneath the old great barbers.
They would talk and discuss what was going on in the mine.
The wives also kne what was going on in the mines if there was a dangerous situation.
So when they hung the clothes out on the clotheslines, they talked to one another.
Everybody knew what was going on.
It was roughly 185 when miners dug the first coal out of the Darr.
The mine tunneled into the Youghiogheny River hillside and Rostravo Township, Westmoreland County.
Some of the miners and their families lived next door in the village of Van Meter.
Many more lived on the other side of the river in Jacob's Creek.
A cable car, long gone now shuttled them across the York to the Darr mine and home again after a long shift.
Those men back then.
Did their work.
They worked hard.
They would work 12 and 14 hours.
You only got $0.50 a day for a wagon of coal.
And that was a lot of coal.
And those wagons.
Let me tell you, to feed and clothe their families.
The miners were obligated to buy from the company store.
That's where you got your supplies from.
That's how you were kept going.
The Pittsburgh Coal Company owned the store, and the Darr mine most of what the men earned.
Went right back to the boss.
They didn't care.
Back then, the coal companies of that era were considered cavalier and ruthless, overlooking human safety.
Disciplining men who didn't watch out for the mines.
Expensive horses and mules.
But the men got hurt.
Hey, there's another bunc of honkies coming over through Ellis Island.
Caverns and explosions were common.
On December 1st, 1907, just ten miles from the Darr, the Naomi mine exploded, killing 34 men.
The Naomi mine closed.
Those who survived were out of a job.
So many of the Naomi miners went looking for work.
They found it and what they hoped would b a better future at the Darr mine They should have never sent those men in.
My job is to look out and protect the miner that work in our commonwealth.
The most important thing we can do as an industry is to make sure that every man and woma that goes to work in our lives goes home at the end of each day.
That's what Joseph Baffoni did in the summer of 2002, when nine miners were trapped in the Quecreek mine in Somerset County.
If I was responsible for all of my terminus coal mines.
So when Quecreek occurred, I was one of the first ones to be notified and involved right from the beginning.
Throughout the entire operation.
So we know somebody was there and they were alive.
We had nine miners that were able to be returne to their families here at Darr.
The things that were permitted back then just, were not adequate and, not acceptable.
As director of the Bureau of Mines Safety with the Department of Environmental Protection.
And as a former miner, I started to mine in 1970.
Joe knows about goo and bad conditions underground, and he knows the history of mining in this region.
And it was commonplace in the industry at that time to have methane ignitions and explosions and, large losses of life.
December of the seventh i known as the darkest month in, in mining history in the country.
The dreaded month i what mining families called it.
There had never been as many mining deaths before.
There haven't been as many since December 1907.
On the first day of that month, the Naomi disaster left 34 dead in Fayette County, Pennsylvania.
It made national headlines.
Coffin were shipped to the Naomi site to prepare for the burials.
Five days later, massive explosions collapsed the Monongah mine in West Virginia, killing 362 men.
The single greatest mine disaster in American history.
But it wasn't over.
An explosio killed as many as 90 in Yolande, Alabama, on December 16th and it was just about that time.
Miners back in Pennsylvani were complaining about too much methane gas in the Darr mine, and not enough ventilation.
They had some air shafts, but they didn't have all that they needed.
So there were a lot of things that went on bac then that, you know, we wouldn't even think of letting going on today.
Papa needed help in the mines.
So the kids a lot of times were snuck into the mine.
The kids would help Papa loa the coal into the coal wagons, and the little water boys would come around, too.
Some of them were only five, six years old.
Sometimes even the women would sneak in and help their husbands.
They dress up in boys clothing and they would go in.
That's why there's no way of knowing exactly how many people were in the mine.
On December 19th, 1907, the official records show it was 240.
The whole Youghiogheny Valley shot.
Tremblewhen that went off.
A mine explosion of that type magnitude Pretty, pretty violent.
And very improbable that anybody would survive.
I did not know at that time how famous my grandfather was, because they did not talk about those things then.
And Toth remembers sitting on the porch steps with her grandfather.
She remembers the stories of what he did the day the Dar exploded.
Istvan Toth was working at the nearby Whitsett mine when everyone heard the blast.
He asked his supervisor about sending a rescue team to the Dar.
So my grandfather says, are you going to send any help up?
The answer was no.
He said that the mine superintendent.
If you're not sending anybody up, Im going.
And he did.
He went.
He ran up those tracks three miles.
But the would be rescue team would serve only as a recovery team.
After 24 hours, an exhausted Istvan Toth went home to his wife and collapsed on the floor.
And he says to her mindem hi, mindem hiaba mid cout, what he meant was all in vain, all in vain.
They all died.
They found a piece of head over here, an arm over here, maybe a leg there.
That's how those bodies came out.
It had the hunt.
You had the hunt on him.
What actually occurred here was a methane dust explosion.
When that would occur, it would put all the dust into suspension, and then the dus would continue.
The explosion.
It would just propagate throughout the mine.
It would be very violent.
The result of an inquiry int the explosion surprised no one.
The Pittsburgh Coal Company was cleared.
At the time, miners were hats with open flames.
It was presumed one of them sparked the blast by entering an off-limits area, a gassy tunnel that had been fenced off by a supervisor.
Critics said the miners shouldn't have been in the dark at all.
They didn't need to let those men go in there.
That was it.
All they had to do was hold the the production up for a couple of days and get that gas out of there instead of blaming it on the men.
Despite the anger and grief, there was work to be done.
The mine was deep and intricate.
Most of the victims were about a mile and a half inside, and the stench of scorched men and mules was terrible.
Wagons that normally carried coal from the mine now carried human remains to a temporary morgue set up in a tent near the company store.
If a piece of a body came out new, it happened to be your husband's pants or long underwear or part of a shirt.
Maybe that's how you identified a piece of a body.
No single cemetery was able to handle that many bodies.
So the darr miners were buried throughout the region.
Connellsville, McKeesport.
71 of the bodies, unidentified or from poor families, were buried at the Olive Branch Cemetery.
A few miles from the Darr.
They're in a mass grave.
This faded photo show the coffins lined up in the hole with Christmas wreaths on the caskets.
And that's probably what really is the sad story of the tragedy here at are that, you know when that occurred in December, people were getting ready for the holidays.
And now you have this disaster.
The community did respond.
This rare book catalogs the names of many people and organizations that gave to the Dar mine relief effort.
It even makes note of one swindle in which a man organized a charity concert for the families, and then kept the money.
He was sent to jail.
Records also sho that the Pittsburgh Coal Company donated $20,000 to the relief fund, and spent $12 for each casket.
There was no welfare, nothing in them days.
As for those left without a family income, many had to move on.
Their idea was to come to the New World, make money.
But that didn't happen.
The streets were not paved with gold.
Some of the women had no choice but to take their children, leave town, and hopefully find a new husband.
Other widows and parents went back to the old country, taking with them memories of lost husbands and sons.
Martha Paul, age 45, wife and children in Italy, the only recor of their existence in America.
The Daraa mine casualty list.
Paul Brazy Bolo Steve, age 25, wife at Jacob's Creek.
Butcher.
All those names of dead men.
People could barely comprehend it.
But just as unbelievable.
The story of a man who got out.
And there is someone still alive who knew him.
I'd like to remember at the age of 96.
Esther Budd still checks her mailbox every day.
She uses a walker to get around.
She's still in her own home.
I've lived in this house since 1918, and I can remember.
A lot of things.
Esther remembers quite well the man most people believe is the Darr mines only survivor.
That was my uncle Tom.
He was married.
The mother's sister.
And he was the only man that got out of the explosion alive.
Tom Williams was a Dilly Rider, a term for a miner who tends the wagons of coal.
A Connersville newspaper reported how he'd just stepped away from his car when the mine blew.
He was just practically at the entrance, and he thought he heard a rumbling and he got on out.
He did get clear out.
Despite the notoriety, Tom rarely talked about the dark explosion that was a no no subject.
Esther says her uncle led a good and optimistic life.
He was a very loving person and he loved me.
He did go back to being a coal miner again, and she still has some of Tom's belongings from the mine.
That was his lunch box.
Along with her memories of a dar Tom Williams.
Thank goodness he got out alive.
But.
Oh, what about the other people that didn't get out?
Walter Shepard was our grandfather.
And he was only 24.
Arlene Thompson and Pamela Simpson only know their grandfather's face through his only photograph.
He looks intelligent.
I think typically English staunch.
He looks and he's handsome.
In fact, the sisters are among just a handful of people who have photos of anyone who died in the disaster.
This 24 year old, probably planning for Christmas with his wife and the babies, thinking about making enough money to maybe buy him something.
And he goes into this mine with all of these other men.
And she's at home with the little ones.
And they hear that loud earth rumble love of her life, 24 years old, and he's not there anymore.
And the babies have no dad.
One of those babies.
And there's our dad.
What a sweet baby.
Did grow up to be a coal miner himself.
John Sheppard the father of these two women.
Daddy used to come home and all you saw were his eyes, the whites of his eyes.
It was important to him, and he wanted his father to be remembered.
Here's Walter's name.
Walter Sheppard, badge number 508.
And he was 24 years old.
Oh, look at the detail.
And he had two children.
In recent years, the sisters learned that they also had a step great grandfather in the Darr.
The mine foreman, William Campbell.
Mr.
Campbell, you can't see him very well, but he also perished in the mine, too.
William Campbell's body was among the first brought out by the recovery team.
There is still some question as to what happened to the remains of Walter Sheppard.
Our grandfather's body was never found.
I say it's in the mine.
I hope that he's not in an unmarked grave somewhere.
That someone can take flowers.
I hope that he died with his friends.
Saint Nichola Orthodox Church is not so big, but it's just about the right size for the tiny village of Jacob's Creek, where most of the Dar miners lived.
Right here on our rest, our Lord, to the souls of your adopted servants.
They also lost their lives in the mine and make their memory eternal and so today, on this day, the people here pray for the miners souls and reflect on another reason to remember the Da disaster.
I'm sure it's a miracle.
They call it the miracle of Saint Nicholas because December 19th, 1907 was a religious holiday the feast day of Saint Nicholas.
Christina de Renko is an Orthodox Christian and a founder of the Carpathia Gruesome Society.
Saint Nicholas would be the main saint.
The carpet the Russian would pray to for intercession, and they would pray for his him to watch over them for him to protect them, for him to assist them.
And many believe that is what happened when about 200 men did not go inside the mine that day because they went to church.
It was the one day every yea they would take off the carpet.
The Russians would take off to go to church, on the Greek Catholic Orthodox old calendar date of December 19th.
Father Alexander Zuby traveled to Jacob's Creek to offer a Divine Liturgy in Saint Nicholas memory, and during that liturgy is at the time whe the ground shook beneath them.
The explosion occurred that killed all the men that were in the mine at the time.
They said that when the mine exploded, it blew fire clear across the river into Jacob's Creek from the mouth of the mine, and everyone ran to see what could be done to help the miners that were stuck in the mine.
It's very emotional for me to hear this story.
Emotional because some of thes parishioners wouldn't be alive today, had it?
Not been for a church service 100 years earlier.
Mother told me her daddy and my uncle, that's her brother, was spared their life because they stayed home and went to church.
Ironically the Monongah mine had exploded 13 days earlier, on December 6th, the feast day of Saint Nichola and the Roman Catholic Church.
60 miners in West Virginia had stayed home.
Two descendants of the monongah and Darr churchgoers still talk about it today.
And you wouldn't be here today with us telling the story.
Isn't that the truth?
Because you wouldn't be alone and that wonderful people are here.
I always remember, as I'm walking in the doors, that the building here was constructed by unemployed and retired coal miners from their bare hands.
We do believe that Saint Nicholas saved them that day, telling us it's our responsibility in this generation to work to preserve the history of this miracle, as well as the sacrifices of the coal miners and steel workers of that period.
If we don't preserve it, it will be lost for future generations.
This old mining town is no longer a destination for most people, and there's something still in the air around the place.
Watch your step.
The energy of the men who were here.
There's a lot of stories.
And these hills are out here.
Stories?
Yes, but very little else to show how coal once meant.
Life in the Youghiogheny River Valley.
There are some ruins, like what used to be one of the banning mined buildings.
It's just a shell now right next to the Youghiogheny bike trail at the site of the Darr explosio You have to look hard to find a few rail tracks, concrete foundations and what's left of the entrance in the temple would have been right on this here.
These men all have mining in their past, and they're among those doing what they can to preserve this history.
This is timber.
Raymond A. Washlaski started a coal mine website that include extensive research on the Darr.
Dave Hamilton is a trai volunteer who tells his stories the old fashioned way to bikers and hikers he meets along the trail.
There' a lot of history along the trail here, and our min is a very important part of it.
Dave is a former miner who grew up in this area.
As a child if I was up that area at night time, I'd run down pastor, believe me, and I was told by my father, never go in that hole.
I think my dad all the time.
And to look down here to see what he collected on and off, is a coal miner's son who inherited his father's impressive collection of coal mining memorabilia from the open flame hats the miners used to wear to this cage, with the actual remains of a canary that died of gas poisoning in a coal mine.
Canary would die inside the cage.
That was a sign get out of the mine.
Don's working to get a museum in rust River to house his dad's collection.
I think Papp needs a museum.
And to formally recogniz the Darr disaster in the townshi where it happened.
And now, our fellow worker, we pay the last sad right and tribute of respect.
The last one we can pay you in this world.
And of course there is.
Anna Toth the coal miner's granddaughter who's been the hear and soul of the Darr mine group.
Now, what happens when I die?
I don't know, because I don't think anybody else has the passion that I have about it.
She keeps the story alive and still keeps up the cemeteries where the Dar miners rest.
But sometimes if I'm down in the cemeteries by myself and my dear grandfather.
I feel that little brush on my shoulder.
After the Dar and other disasters of the era, a public outcry led to tougher mining laws and the creation of the U.S.
Bureau of Mines.
Testing and research into dust explosion helped prevent future tragedies, and there never again was another dreaded month like December 1907, when more than 700 men and boys died in American coal mines.
I don't think they died in vain.
Names and faces remembered by a few who left behind more than many people might know.
I think that the people that work in the mines toda owe a lot to those individuals that paid the ultimate sacrifice, many, many years ago.
So I hope that the explosion saved somebodys life down the road.
Support for PBS provided by:
The Darr Mine Disaster is a local public television program presented by WQED















