PBS Hawaiʻi Presents
The Island in Me
Special | 1h 39m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
Two women return to the atoll where they grew up and find the atoll and themselves forever changed.
Two women who grew up on Pukapuka, a remote atoll in the Cook Islands in the South Pacific, return home decades later to reconnect. Amelia Hokulea Borofsky, the daughter of an anthropologist and Johnny Frisbie, who wrote the first published work by a Pacific Islander at age 15, left the atoll at different times. In returning, they find a sense of belonging with emotion and celebration.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
PBS Hawaiʻi Presents is a local public television program presented by PBS Hawai'i
PBS Hawaiʻi Presents
The Island in Me
Special | 1h 39m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
Two women who grew up on Pukapuka, a remote atoll in the Cook Islands in the South Pacific, return home decades later to reconnect. Amelia Hokulea Borofsky, the daughter of an anthropologist and Johnny Frisbie, who wrote the first published work by a Pacific Islander at age 15, left the atoll at different times. In returning, they find a sense of belonging with emotion and celebration.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch PBS Hawaiʻi Presents
PBS Hawaiʻi Presents is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
[sound of waves] [Music] GEMMA: Amelia left me for an island.
I never knew Pukapuka existed, nor could I place it on the world map.
I thought I would be with Amelia forever.
I could never imagine that this remote Atoll in the Pacific will change my life.
[Music] AMELIA : It is a strange thing memory.
I didn't even believe that Pukapuka was real, more like a dream place.
I was five years old when we left.
It had been 30 years.
[Music] AMELIA: And then one day I picked up Johnny Frisbie’s book, Ms Ulysses from Puka-Puka and literally within three pages, I knew I had to go back to this place of my childhood that she wrote about.
It wasn't a decision… it wasn't a choice… it was a calling.
[Music] JOHNNY: Many of my dreams are of Pukapuka, you know… I guess because just the memories are there all the time.
[Music] JOHNNY: Where I am going to go when I die is Pukapuka … that's where I'm going.
[Music] GEMMA: I never thought I would be making this film.
But I had to embark on this journey to understand the world she had left me for.
[Music] GEMMA: Amelia and I met more than a decade ago in Hawaiʻi, when I was working in another documentary film and she was getting her doctorate degree in psychology.
From the very first conversations we had she told me about her childhood memories in Pukapuka.
I was living with her that Sunday afternoon when she picked up Johnny Frisbie’s book.
She came to the living room and said: “Pukapuka is real.
I need to find a way to get back.” I was so excited for her.
We were in a committed relationship when Amelia went to Pukapuka for the first time.
By then, we had been wanting to start a family, I was older so I would try first.
[Music] GEMMA: But when she came back from Pukapuka everything was different.
She told me she could no longer integrate me into her life.
I was so heartbroken.
[Speaking in Pukapukan] AMELIA: mmm so poetic when you say it.
[Speaking in Pukapukan] JOHNNY: I was afraid of ghosts.
[Speaking in Pukapukan] JOHNNY: That is my father and me.
AMELIA: This one?
JOHNNY: Mm-hmm.
AMELIA: Oh, is he teaching you how to how to write?
JOHNNY: Yeah!
AMELIA: Oh, wow.
You can tell he had that spirit of adventure.
And then you said on the Frisbie’s spirit of adventure riddled with fearlessness.
JOHNNY: Yeah, that's right.
AMELIA: That was your line.
That's your book!
JOHNNY: Yeah.
AMELIA: Wow it was in the Chicago Sunday Tribune front page!
And it looks just like you Johnny.
JOHNNY: It does in a way, I don’t know how they did it.
[Music] ROB: Hello.
NANCY: Hello here we are in Paradise Island.
ROB: Amelia will speak to you in a little while and she's out playing.
NANCY: There's really nothing I need.
There's nothing we need.
There's nothing Amelia needs.
There's nothing Rob needs nor wants.
ROB: Well, I want to be finished with my research but that’s all (LAUGH).
There's nothing really in material objects that we need.
NANCY: Yesterday another boat came and brought us milk biscuits.
[AMELIA speaking in Pukapukan] NANCY: And her M&M’s or candy.
AMELIA: My money moneys.
NANCY: She doesn't know what money money is.
It means candy in English.
AMELIA: You say that pebbles.
NANCY: Pebbles.
But she doesn’t what pebbles are…they are like M&Ms … that's what they call them in America- M&Ms.
[Natural sound] AMELIA: We came to Pukapuka when I was one, but we left when I was four and a half.
My memories of Pukapuka are very visceral, very physical.
I remember the sound of the waves crashing on the reef.
The taste of the roasted bird.
And I remember our house on the beach.
It's like it hits my body first, and then I try to make sense of what the memory is.
There's, just a feeling of trauma and survival and life on the edge and playing and having a great time too but an intense daily life.
[Music] AMELIA: Later in my life I began thinking about the need to face that trauma or somehow heal it.
So, I went to see a psychologist.
She said to me, you know what is it that you panic about?
And I said I panic about a cold hungry and on the verge of death… …and she just looked at me and said that was not a panic that's a memory.
[Music] AMELIA: It just hit me that I needed to go back to Pukapuka.
And I just kind of exploded my whole life.
In order to come back I left everything I had known and made this epic journey.
[Music] GEMMA: Once I learned that Johnny Frisbie was living in Hawaiʻi, I knew I needed to meet her.
When she told me about her life it sounded so epic.
And I thought maybe we can make a film together.
Johnny had not been back to Pukapuka in 20 years.
Her brother Charles was still living there and she wanted to see him one last time.
So, she agreed to go with all of us.
I thought then that this journey will be my way to see Pukapuka with my own eyes.
Keep my relationship with Amelia, maybe even repair it, understand why she had taken such a turn and come to terms with it.
[Music] AMELIA: My father's profession as anthropologist.
When he came to Pukapuka with my mother and myself as a one-year-old, there really hadn't been much westernization in the late 1970s.
As a child in Pukapuka you have a hundred playmates, you run free with your playmates.
I mean forget your parents, they're not that important.
I remember that feeling of freedom, of running around going where I pleased when I pleased how I pleased.
I know from my mom that I was gone from dawn to dusk and I remember that feeling of wandering.
NANCY: I’d say Amelia's upbringing was very unconventional.
She chose not to speak English.
She chose to speak Pukapukan and she was much better at Pukapukan than English.
Amelia would walk around with the other kids and after she was used to it her feet were really tough.
You don't have slippers there and it's coral, rough coral, but everybody walked around without shoes and they were just fine.
And their feet were tough.
[Music] AMELIA: I was two.
A boat came.
It was going to Samoa and passengers were invited and then the boat was gonna come back.
My mom was like “hey let's go.” It was only gonna be gone for two weeks and they were gonna come back.
And so, they start gathering their stuff and my mom said: “oh we'll just leave Amelia with the neighbor.” That's what Pukapukans do, they just leave children with other families.
I think they thought they were only gonna be gone for a week or two.
I think it ended up being about three weeks.
I just remember this feeling of being alone, scared, cold, and hungry.
And later my parents said that the woman, the neighbor who took care of me had told me that my parents had died.
So, I never thought they were gonna come back.
But my mom says that when I came back, I wouldn't speak to them.
It was like I had seen ghosts, and my dad said my eyes looked totally hollow.
I didn't look like I was all there and they said it took like at least a month for me to speak to them.
[Music] JOHNNY: My name is Florence Nagtakorua Frisbie, but I'm known as Johnny.
I was born in Papeete, Tahiti 1932.
My mother she was a Pukapukan.
While my mother was in labor my father was celebrating with friends, they were all captains of schooners.
And they were drinking a lot of whiskey and that's how I got my nickname Johnny, Whiskey Johnny.
[Drums] DANGER ISLAND ANCHOR: Lovely Whisky Johnny Frisbie.
Most famous of all hula dancers, born 2,300 miles south of here on a coral atoll.
Her father adventurous Robert Dean Frisbee an American novelist her mother a Polynesian Beauty.
JOHNNY: My father at the time he was the only white man… so growing up was slightly different for us than the rest of the Pukapukan children because of the white man father and Polynesian mother.
My father came to the South Seas as is what's known in those days … very romantic name for these parts of the world in the early 1920s.
He ended up on Pukapuka because he was looking for a place that was isolated from civilization, somewhere quiet, somewhere peaceful, somewhere natural.
And he found Pukapuka.
He applied for a job as a trader looking after a small store.
Got the job and sailed there and liked it and found what he was looking for paradise.
And he began to write.
He wrote six books about Pukapuka, Tahiti, and two novels.
My parents umm, umm, had five children.
Two boys and three girls … yes, Charlie the oldest, me, then Jakey and Elaine and Nga.
The eldest of our family Charles, Charles Mataa Frisbee was born on Rarotonga at the time when my father was away.
And my mother was 17 years old and being cared for by a great aunt Pikipiki.
Her name is Pikipiki.
In Pukapuka you do, you give away your children, your first born, first second third whoever is waiting to have a child from you as a gift.
And so, Charles was born and Pikipiki said: “well he's mine.” And my mother I don't know she may have been in shock, maybe torn between the two cultures, not knowing my father would just not agree to this, but she said “okay.” To her it's fine you know?
We do this, you know?
And that's all Pikipiki took took Charles as her own and when my father returned, he had no son.
She took Charlie in and hidden the bush until my father left the island.
[Drumming] CHARLES: Ah Johnny!
JOHNNY: It has been so long!
So long.
CHARLES: Yeah.
Been thirty years.
JOHNNY: Maybe yeah oh!
[Natural Sound] JOHNNY: Oh, look at the rundown house yeah there Raro.
Our Papa, our father is buried over there.
CHARLES: Oh yeah, that’s right!
[Sound of singing] JOHNNY: Come come come…yeah papa.
In so many ways you know he wanted me to be an island girl, but for some reason he sensed that I could also learn to write.
When we lived on Pukapuka, we had a house and there was a room which is rare.
He had a little library, a desk for his typewriter and umm carbon paper and a ream of white paper and he used to allow me to enter that room which was a no-no otherwise, cause you know there was all these precious things that are not available anywhere else on Pukapuka.
I thought his library all the books were Bibles you know because there were no books on the island at the time.
If there were, kids didn't know.
I remember him asking me once to get the dictionaries so I said to him “oh the Bible” like correcting him and said no the dictionary.
So, I brought the dictionary.
(LAUGH) Watching him type type type… popopopopo….
turn the character, popopopopo… was fascinating.
And then then he takes a page out and there's there's writing on this page.
There is actually writing.
When we moved to Samoa, he asked me to keep a diary of our life up to that point.
That was in 1945.
And it was quite scary doing it because for the first time I had to something that makes sense, and write it down on paper.
This is a European thing, it is not my thing, but he wanted me to go through that exercise of putting a story together.
He told me about chapters and then eventually the diaries evolved into “Miss Ulysses from Pukapuka.” And it was published before he died.
CHARLES: Cold breeze, right?
Plenty breeze.
JOHNNY: You know Papa was an atheist?
And he wasn’t really happy with the way Christianity was introduced to our people in the early 1800’s.
CHARLES: Yes, yes, yes.
JOHNNY: And he was very angry about that, very upset.
JOHNNY: Ah, you didn’t know Papa.
Did you?
CHARLES: Eh?
JOHNNY: You didn't know him very long?
Papa.
CHARLES: Yeah well.
JOHNNY: I can remember when you first met him?
Charles always had horses, loved horses.
He lived a great life in New Zealand he was successful jockey.
He did work hard he married a Maori woman and had six beautiful children.
He learned many skills.
He's a real survivor.
But there is that element of loss that he carries with him.
He's never known my mother; no he’s never known my mother.
[Music] CHARLES: I was the very favorite son of theirs because first Cook Islander to ride horses, and even if I was riding a donkey that he would put their money on.
(LAUGH) Every time Mama Pikipiki heard about Frisbie coming to our place, she takes me to the taro patch and hide me there.
That's how my mama people he loves me so much and I love her too.
And I think I prefer to stay with her instead of having to go with my father to see the world and go to school to learn and prosper.
JOHNNY: He loved you.
CHARLES: Yeah.
Thank you, Johnny.
JOHNNY: He was very proud of you.
CHARLES: Thank you.
I love you too.
JOHNNY: Oh, these are lilies.
CHARLES: These are lilies.
Yeah!
But these ones out of the weeds see?
Tiririririri.
[Natural sound] NANCY: All right we aren't gonna be returning until probably May 1981.
The reason being is that I'm pregnant now again, unplanned but what are you going to do?
And we're not, I'm not allowed to travel on by ship anyway after six months pregnant ,so we'll just have to stay here.
AMELIA: She ate some fish that was bad, maybe like a day-old fish.
They also didn't have refrigeration, and it made her have contractions early and so she went into labor prematurely.
And because Pukapuka didn't have any equipment really at all, there were no incubators nothing, my mom said it was alive at the time and then it died shortly after.
And they put it in a bucket.
And I was four and a half when this happened, so, I have some vague memories of it.
I remember a lot of blood and crying.
I have an image of children spying and not being able to get rid of them.
A real feeling of helplessness.
She just told my dad she was ready to go so shortly after that we left so we left.
[Music] JOHNNY: And when my mother passed away, I was six and a half I think close to 7, yeah.
Then my mother's family wanted their share of my mother's children, two of the children, which would have meant me and my brother.
And there was a point when they did come to, to our house, and ask and said it's time you give us two children.
And they were entitled to two children and that shook my father.
He decided them to leave.
So, the first boat that came to Pukapuka which was awful awful awful boat we said take us to the nearest island.
We got off the boat and we were on an uninhabited island, Suwarrow.
We learned the art of survival by having to fish and having to learn to grab lobsters and cooking it ourselves and catching tropic birds.
It was just amazing.
And it was all fun!!
(LAUGH) We knew the hurricane was coming, heading straight for Suwarrow.
We gathered in our house on the highest point of the island, which could have been about 20 feet about sea level.
And we were all in there in the dark.
The wind blowing and you can hear trees, you know cracking, breaking and then suddenly a huge wave just crashed into the building, and the water carried all of us to one side of the house and my father said: “get out of here get out of here, just followed me.” My father he had prepared a dinghy.
He tied it to a tree.
We got into the dinghy, another wave came and just turned the dinghy over.
We knew what to do, you know we had been on tipped canoes before.
When it tips over you know you just dive down deeper and come out and don't come out there.
So, we all did we were popping air, coconuts passing and debris passing through us.
There was so much lightening you could actually see everything.
And so, my father would say just crawl crawl.
Crawl to the tamanu tree and we crawl to the tree and he helped us climb up to the tree.
He tied us to the trees.
We survived aha…and those three trees were the only tamanu trees that withstood the force of the hurricane.
We're not scared you know?
We didn't feel threatened.
I sometimes wonder if it's because of my father because he was so strong.
GEMMA: Hey Croc?
Hey, I'm Gemma Cubero, I am the filmmaker.
CROC: I can go across her panels that she has in the calves GEMMA: Mm-hmm.
Mm-hmm.
CROC: Jellyfish for protection.
GEMMA: Yeah, that’s beautiful.
CROC: The patterns are reflection you know, of many aspects of living in isolated islands, Polynesian life.
They’ve passed down through generations and of course they adapt to different living and different meanings, you know?
They mutate, they grow.
But the foundation of the designs are cultural patterns they run very deep.
[Tattoo natural sound] AMELIA: Thanks guys.
[Tattoo natural sound] CROC: Well done woman.
Love you!
That’s good!
[Natural sound] PUKAPUKAN WOMAN: I'm proud.
You know, when I saw it, the paper.
That was a couple of months ago I kept it and I am taking it to New Zealand.
JOHNNY: Yeah, this is for the Pukapukans when they come to to Rarotonga.
They stay here for a while to get used to the change, before they move on to New Zealand, yeah.
And it's a very good place for for that to happen right here, because there's so many helpers, so many, the old people giving them you know, some good advice.
Even though they have never been to New Zealand they give them comfort, emotional comfort.
It is a good place.
It’s a haven.
[Natural sound] JOHNNY: So, when my father died, I moved in with with the manager of the airstrip in Rarotonga.
Yeah, I moved here to do domestic work for them.
We were all separated.
Then I met up with the Engles, Peter Engle was friends of my fathers and he was a movie actor by the name of Peter Whitney, he came from Hawaiʻi.
And they were sailing the Pacific and I said I would only come if I am a part of the family not a servant.
Because at the time, all the girls my age in the Cook Islands were being sent to New Zealand to work as a maid.
Once I moved there, I was determined to bring my sisters to Hawaiʻi.
And it was a challenge to meet so many haoles, you know so many Europeans.
At the time I still was not comfortable speaking in English.
So, in 1950 I was 18.
But I'd started school in eighteen because of not having the formal education to back me up.
But I did good.
I really did good.
I received all A's which then allowed me a scholarship to Punahou, a private school.
I had difficulties with the discipline, was so different from how our father taught us.
It didn't prepare us.
I almost gave up but no I stayed on then managed to graduate not with high marks but I graduated.
[Drumming] JOHNNY: I danced on Sunday every luau at a nightclub in Waikīkī.
Now and again my sisters would join me and eventually my sister took over my place.
And she built this most fantastic show called the Pukapuka Otea.
She brought dancers from other islands and trained them.
And she had drummers and guitar players, ʻukulele players, singers.
And that went on for years and years at the at the Queen’s Surf, which no longer exists in Waikīkī.
[Pukapukan Drumming Music] GEMMA: Johnny!!
Johnny!!!
How was that?
We have been waiting in the capital of the Cook Islands, Rarotonga for transport to get to Pukapuka.
The only way to reach the atoll is by chartering a very expensive private plane or to go by sea, which takes six days.
There are no hotels or supermarkets on Pukapuka, so we're now getting all the food we need for the weeks we will be filming.
Awesome!
AMELIA: Country soft red, what is that?
SUPERMARKET PERSON: That's the wine.
The red wine.
AMELIA: Oh yeah one of those.
Okay, umm, onions, 20 kilo bag of onions.
JOHNNY: The island is going to sink.
(LAUGHING) [Natural sound] [SINGING IN PUKAPUKAN WITH PUKAPUKAN ʻUKULELE] [Music] CARLA: Mama what was with us such a short time.
All that I can remember of her are those things that cannot be forgotten.
She had the purest kindest and most beautiful heart of any woman I have known.
No one could love a person more than I did my ma.
This book is The Frisbees of the South Seas, my mother's autobiography, her second book.
I feel very much the same about my mother.
She is pure she's kind, ahh gentle all those wonderful things.
When I was young, when I saw my mother crying one night and I asked my father what's what's the matter?
He said oh she's crying because she misses her mother.
Pukapuka is her mother.
It was where her mother was born, where her mother died, and where she lived.
Those years that she had with her mother, they all happened at that place that is why she has yearned for it as she yearned for her mother.
AMELIA: It’s that little, little, little, little, little.
JOHNNY: Yeah!
AMELIA: Right there.
JOHNNY: Oh, there it is!!!
[Music] GEMMA: Johnny always told me that if we were going to go on this trip, it would be a spiritual journey.
I wonder what I will find.
[Music] CHARLES: Hello brother!
PUKAPUKAN MAN: Hello, Johnny.
Welcome home!
AMELIA: You look good!
MAMA LUI: Am I?
Getting old and older?
AMELIA: No.
JOHNNY: It’s good to be back.
It’s really good to be back.
I just feel like I am going to explode!
[Johnny speaks Pukapukan] JOHNNY: If I keep going I may cry so, yeah.
[Music- PUKAPUKAN SINGING] AMELIA: We left Pukapuka when I was four and a half years old and got to Hawaiʻi and I had never seen a toilet before.
I had never seen streetlights.
I had never seen a car.
I had never seen a dog.
My mom likes to tell a story of how I saw all the street lamps and I said many moons.
I can still remember the first time I saw toilet and flushed the toilet and being terrified that the water would suck me in.
NANCY: Transitioning into Hawaiʻi and the pace of life, even though Hawaiʻi is a slower pace than the mainland, was still really fast for us.
In Hawaiʻi I had to spend a lot more time with Amelia because before she would be taken care of by everybody, and now I had to watch her and make sure she was okay and not wandering around.
And in America you’re supposed to know where your child is at every moment.
I left Amelia with my parents at a picnic grounds and we went walked off somewhere and I was supposed to say “I am going over here for an hour will you watch the children?” And I didn't do that so this was a faux pas.
I got scoldings.
It was different to get used to the expectations here and child rearing is very different.
AMELIA: In kindergarten you got to match words and pictures, so I could read the word dog for example, D-O-G, but I'd never seen a dog so I couldn't match the word with the picture.
So they thought I was really slow, and put me in special education for a while.
You know, all my memories up to five are of Pukapuka and we didn't have any mirrors.
Obviously, I looked at my parents and they weren't brown, but I really think that I thought racially I was brown.
So when we got to Hawaiʻi I suddenly became white or haole and I was confused by it because I really saw myself as brown or as Polynesian.
And I really, really felt lonely.
[Music] AMELIA: I never felt like I belonged.
I ended up going to Punahou, which is a fancy private prep school in seventh grade.
Nancy who is one of the popular girls saying to me Amelia you're like an alien that just landed from outer space.
And that's something that stayed with me my whole life.
[Natural sound] AMELIA: This is the same house and same spot.
Every Pukapukan I would say has a dream of going on the outside getting money coming back and rebuilding the family house.
So, it became a dream of mine after a while to rebuild the family house.
[Natural sound] AMELIA: Me rebuilding the house was about recapturing the past.
Rebuilding the house was about trying to recapture my memories.
I think there was a part of me that thought if I saw it and I sat here something would come back.
Rebuilding the family house was about belonging.
You know?
That if I had a house here I belonged to the land.
[Music] AMELIA WITH PUKAPUKAN GIRL: Hey I have your presents from Hawaiʻi.
[AMELIA SPEAKS IN PUKAPUKAN] AMELIA: Okay.
It's a gift-giving culture so presents are really important.
Presents are more important than money.
And it’s about what you give not what you have.
WHOOHOO!
WOMAN GETTING GIFT: Thank you very much.
For Mama Peka.
[Singing in Pukapukan] AMELIA: Wooooo!
Look at that!
Wow!
Viti Ongo.
MAMA LUI IN PUKAPUKAN: Viti Ongo!
AMELIA: Palu Palu MAMA LUI: Praise the lord!
AMELIA: Praise the lord!
MAMA LUI: Praise the Lord.
Halleluiah!
AMELIA: Halleluiah!
[Singing in Pukapukan] AMELIA: You know, women in Pukapuka are really really strong.
The taro patch is passed from one woman to another all the way back to the ancestors.
We have a really strong sense of owning part of the land and half the food and there's a division of labor but it's also really empowering to, I find to know what my role is.
I don't have to do everything I just have to go to the uwi.
[Natural sound] JOHNNY: This is an abnormal coconut you know?
It didn't turn round oval, and as as little girls we adopted these as dolls.
So, these were our dolls.
We put little coconut leaf skirt around them, we put them to bed and sometime we'll take them for swim and just throw them in the lagoon, and they float around.
I will swim and rescue them before they disappear.
But they were dolls.
And this other one you bend it like this.
Now I'm going to go to the dance tonight.
[Drumming] CARL KINIPOPO: Wow.
Johnny if you still have your breath could we ask you a few questions?
JOHNNY: Yes.
CARL KINIPOPO: Where were you born?
JOHNNY: Papeete Tahiti but I didn't live there all the time.
CARL KINIPOPO: No, I thought not.
You speak English very well JOHNNY: Oh (LAUGHER) CARL KINIPOPO: Where elsewhere else have you well lived Johnny besides Papeete?
JOHNNY: On the atoll of Pukapuka mm-hmm which is only a mile long and half a mile wide.
CARL KINIPOPO: Well, what did you find to do in that atoll that was enough to write a book about?
JOHNNY: Oh, play hide and seek, fish… CARL KINIPOPO: Hide and go seek eh?
Well that that sounds like interesting… CARLA: My father was very very popular and very well-known, and she was well known in her own right.
At that point because she had her and dance show in Waikīkī with her sisters.
She met my father who had been going out with her sister, Ngatokorua, but that broke up and so my mother took over.
Ngatokorua went to marry Batman, Adam West.
My mother married my father.
And he is charismatic very charismatic, funny.
I think she saw some elements of her father there too and he and loved her for her Pacific nature.
JOHNNY: I had four children.
They all grew up in New Zealand, went to school in New Zealand.
Because we wanted to take them away from the American influence.
I couldn't think of anything else more meaningful, though I wasn't vegetating.
I wasn't giving up everything else and you know music dancing the things that interested me to help me develop into a fuller woman, a fuller of human being.
But my children and they alone where my total focus total focus in life so.
CARLA: She was tireless in her giving to the community.
Supporting people, supporting people from the Pacific who came to New Zealand and found a very different place.
She was eventually awarded a Queen's Service medal for her community work.
She was on a television program for ten years called “Beauty and the Beast.” [Theme music] HOST: I'm 20.
My boyfriend's 21 we've been together for nearly a year.
He's soon to go away for two months and I'm afraid he might play around with some other girl?
WOMAN IN THE SHOW: Now if you really love this guy then you can trust him and he can trust you.
HOST: Johnny?
JOHNNY: I think it's very well to trust someone, but it's still difficult to say that you know?
“I trust that person no matter what.
It's still in the back of your mind, but I suggest since you've already conjured up this you know this image of your boyfriend away having a great time you should stick to that.
And you think of how you know think what a wonderful time he's gonna have playing around in your at home staying you know?
Sitting there by yourself, and just enjoy yourself by these thoughts.
CARLA: My mother's advice was always very different.
Basically, she's saying to people just chill out a bit you know it's okay you know you don't need to angst so much.
[Music] AMELIA: How come there aren’t as many fish here in Pukapuka?
There used to be more in the old days?
IOTAMA: Yeah.
Before we would go fishing, it takes only a few hours to get fish.
Not now.
AMELIA: How come?
IOTAMA: Maybe, climate change.
(SPEAKING IN PUKAPUKAN) JOHNNY: The people of Pukapuka now are realizing something strange is happening, because the land is getting smaller.
Many of them are leaving moving to New Zealand.
Many of the old people refuse to move, they don't want to move.
They're going to be there in and disappear with the land as far as they're concerned.
GEMMA: Now I see how islands are not isolated but connected by water.
I’m so moved by the deep sense of order here.
How there is always time to work hard, to play hard and pray.
Time is circular here.
[PUKAPUKAN MUSIC] JOHNNY: There is a lot of freedom.
Children have lots of freedom.
And then we were left to figure it out and not be so closely guarded and watched.
[PUKAPUKAN SINGING] You grow up being a survivor, fully respecting nature the wave, the seas.
Children the rules are of the land.
Life just flowed.
Look at this one here.
Look at that.
I just went to the beach and walked and swam and fed some little fishes with coconut.
Chewed up coconuts.
Took my clothes off, shh.
There was nobody around (LAUGH) CHARLES: This is what you call it husking coconuts.
JOHNNY: It took me back to my childhood and it was nice.
You know, you don't often have the opportunity in life to reach that state where you can actually pretend you're a kid again.
CHARLES: That’s my three daughters.
That’s my son over there with his wife.
JOHNNY: Who’s that?
CHARLES: Oh Paty and I. Pi Pi Pi.
That's her daughter JOHNNY: That’s all Pukapukan.
Oh no this is Papua New Guinea?
CHARLES: That’s Papua New Guinea yeah.
JOHNNY: Whoa.
CHARLES: That's where I was in Papua New Guinea, Panguna.
JOHNNY: Oh!
CHARLES: Yeah, I was in Panguna, Papua New Guinea, welding, Pola making… Yeah!
We built all those ships.
JOHNNY: Oh, put it together, glue it together?
CHARLES: No, we didn’t glue it together… [LAUGHER} With chewing gum, yeah…[LAUGHER} CHARLES: There's my girlfriend see!
JOHNNY: Another one, which one?
CHARLES: I was very popular.
JOHNNY: Is that number 50?
CHARLES: How many times have I been married?
Well only two.
JOHNNY: That you can remember…[LAUGHTER] CHARLES: That I can remember.
JOHNNY: Yeah, only two.
AMELIA: Wait, Papa Charlie.
Hold on a second, I want to smell your breath.
Oh Papa Charlie, are you ok to drive?
CHARLES: Yes of course.
[Natural sound] CHARLES: In Pukapuka, everyone is kind to you.
You know, you can go to any house you might receive some food or something like that or someone bring you a coconut.
But not in Rarotonga.
In Rarotonga, there's too many tourists I suppose.
You have to buy it.
You have to have enough money.
But over here in Pukapuka you just help yourself.
Uto I know that.
No one will tell you, eh leave that uto, that’s mine.
You can live good life in Pukapuka.
JOHNNY: He came here and he saw that he could be a Pukapukan, and by being a Pukapukan then he is his mother’s son.
It is his way of finding his identity and he’s been here for a long time.
We are nothing else but Pukapukans.
[Music] AMELIA: I've been kind of desperately wanting a kid for about 10 years now.
And being with Gemma we tried a few times with her.
It didn't happen.
For some reason I really got stubborn about wanting to connect somehow to the place by having a Pukapukan child.
So, I thought about adopting a Pukapukan child and all sorts of things.
Finally decided to try and got pregnant with a Pukapukan.
I did and then I had a miscarriage.
That was really painful.
It felt like a really big loss.
[Bells & singing in Pukapukan] AMELIA: The first time I came to Pukapuka I felt like I had to abandon one to have the other.
I didn’t know how to be both with women and with men, how to be both white, Jewish and Pukapukan.
It felt like almost nothing on the outside was relevant anymore in Pukapuka.
Not my doctorate.
Not my relationships.
And there was a feeling of somehow I couldn't integrate who I'd been.
When I came back to Pukapuka, everyone was telling me this is where your baby brother was buried, right here.
And it just made me feel… yeah, I have a connection to this land.
People were saying you know hey Amelia are you gonna be buried here?
Are you gonna be buried in Pukapuka?
And I think they were asking me are you for real?
Like, are you committed to this place?
You would say how many children have you had?
And they would say six, two died.
Had a strong sense of place born and laid to rest.
[Natural sound] Ohhhhh!
AMELIA: There we go who wants a glass?
CHARLES: Where is the glass?
[Sound of glass breaking] GEMMA: While shooting Papa Charlie’s birthday, my left leg collapsed.
I had to stop filming.
[Rain] GEMMA: I laid on a mattress not realizing that I would not be able to walk for weeks.
When this happened the community completely mobilize to help me.
For months, Moko, the taunga, or the healer, came every single day to work on my body.
And he said to me: “you do your jobs and I do my job.” He never asked for anything in returned.
I know now that my injury was more than physical, and that it was through Moko I was able to release the emotional pain I was holding.
This was a transformative experience for me.
[Music] JOHNNY: I was on Rarotonga in 1994.
The Pukapukan people on Rarotonga of the Democratic Party approached me and asked me if I would stand for the seat of Pukapuka.
But I thought okay if they want me to I'll go, and maybe I might make a difference.
[MAMA LAKELA IN PUKAPUKAN]: (JOHNNY LAUGHS) JOHNNY: Soon after I arrived, I learned the political party system had somehow just damaged the community.
Families were split.
You know, one group join the Cook Islands party the other that Democratic party and they just weren't speaking to each other.
It was awful, awful, awful.
But at the same time, I was doing really well.
The opposition party sent for the prime minister of the Cook Islands to come to Pukapuka right away, and he brought cartons of slippers to give away and rum to buy votes.
Once he distributed all these gifts I knew then I didn't have a chance.
[MAMA LAKELA & JOHNNY SPEAKING IN PUKAPUKAN]: JOHNNY: Pukapukans are very very political people but in a different way.
The villages compete with each other in sports and fishing in chanting in composing.
It has a lot of humor in it.
They make fun of each other and people laugh.
[Cheering] [Singing in Pukapukan] AMELIA: If we don’t have children here, they call you anacole, someone useless or not worth being fed.
So, everyone was teasing me and calling me useless basically for not having kids.
To be given a child would be truly being accepted as being part of the family.
I mean you only give children away as a special gift to people.
For me to have a Pukapukan child it would mean a deeper sense of belonging.
PILA: I've got seven.
And I've got four boys and three girls.
And I had a miscarriage you know in 2009.
And I teach grade one and they are five and six years old children.
[Drumming] PILA: I love Amelia.
She’s my sister.
She's also a member of my family too.
My third child was a baby girl.
She was adopted by my auntie Tamo and my uncle Nick.
I gave it to them because they you don't have any children.
Because it’s something that I gave them from my heart.
I trust them and I believe them they will they are going to look after her well.
[PUKAPUKAN CHILDREN SIGNING PUKAPUKAN ANTHEM] PILA: When I look at Amelia, it, I fell for her.
I wanted to give one of my child to to Amelia.
I talked about it too with my partner, we had a discussion about it.
Then it was again again it was hard.
It was hard it was very hard for me to make my decision.
JAMES KATOA: Rib but how many ribs are there?
Yes, why don’t you repeat.
Ribs.
Yes, ribs okay.
Tala come you had a good try.
Your turn.
Next.
AMELIA: Atela.
Kneecap.
Kneecap.
I am volunteering to teach English at the school and I had a blast.
[Speaking in Pukapukan] This is Dental Practitioner.
4 o clock, eh?
Because her grandfather used to work in New Zealand from 4, 4 in the morning until 4 in the afternoon, no?
So that is why she is name 4 o’clock.
This is Teatua.
I started writing articles for the Cook Islands News.
I just felt like I really had a space and a sense of purpose as a teacher and as a writer.
It was part of the magic of being back here and was being seen and giving a gift back to the place.
Umm, I felt useful.
I just fell in love with the children and the school and with my own little vulnerable traumatized self and with the community and with the old people.
I just fell in love with it all.
I was charged with starting the tertiary program.
This program brings villagers into the school and has them teach how to live off the land.
TIM: Nowadays in Pukapuka we've got mobile phones, so they've got no time for weaving and all the traditional stuff, but whereas in when Amelia came and started the program she we've kind of revived those things.
AMELIA: My students started jokingly calling it the University of Pukapuka and so that name stuck.
LINDA: I was one of the persons who supported program.
But there wasn't not enough youth who wanted to attend, maybe that's one of the difficulties that she faced.
AMELIA: The youth were really busy, the girls had cooking to do there was politics going on.
So, I just did not understand the government bureaucracy.
[Music] GEMMA: This way?
Walking thru the villages in Pukapuka, I felt like I was in my father’s hometown of San Pablo de la Moraleja, a small Castilian village in Spain.
And believe I don’t come from the Pacific, but there was something so familiar about living in this tight-knit community, about the people and this rural way of life.
Being able to come here and make this film has made me understand Amelia more, and come to peace with the fact that our relationship had to end.
Pukapuka is not a mystery for me anymore.
[Singing in Pukapukan] [Natural sound] JOHNNY: We buried some our toys in here for her.
It was so long ago and yet it's just you know?
It's painful.
I don’t know how to get over these things.
Yeah, I wish I could come here too.
Nice.
[Natural sound, drumming] JOHNNY: Oh!
look at that.
AMELIA: Yay!
JOHNNY: Let’s eat.
There is a lot of juice in this nice, rich oily like butter-melted butter.
[Natural sound] JOHNNY: These are plates.
[Natural sound] AMELIA: Oh my god.
This is insane.
Oh my god.
[Natural sound] JOHNNY: Seventh heaven.
Oh, it was delicious.
Yeah, it certainly is food for the gods.
Coconut crab is.
You are limited to how many you can have.
From what I heard there was a two-year ban on catching the crabs and there was so much when they finally harvested it a little while ago there was enough, they caught over a thousand, they trapped over a thousand coconut crabs enough for to each person to have two.
Well, that's that's that's what we must do just protect these delicacies so we can have them forever and ever.
I am very glad I came.
Very happy.
Yeah, it makes you wonder why I ever left?
[Natural sound] JOHNNY: What a huge leg!
(Laughing) [SPEAKING IN PUKAPUKAN]: [Music] GEMMA: The making of this film has made me understand the deep imprint that Pukapuka has made on Amelia and Johnny’s life.
And Johnny was right, Pukapuka has been a spiritual journey for me.
[Natural sound] AMELIA: My whole life had been a story of not belonging, and so to come back here and and find a story of belonging, and to find some positive memories of this place was really healing.
GEMMA: Thank you!
AMELIA: I have found something so deep and so important that at the end I just had to connect by myself on my own terms, not through a partner, not through a child.
[Music] AMELIA: Bye bye Pukapuka!!
JOHNNY: I was just so grateful we had time to be together, to be with my brother Charles, so very very grateful.
And you know it's just a gift that this happened.
I feel like my mother and father were with me, and I'm taking them with me.
And I think that result maybe it would rid me of my loneliness for them.
AMELIA: I mean there's no doubt in my mind that I'll come back to Pukapuka.
No matter where I go in the world, I will still always have Pukapuka, so that I can leave and I still have this place deep inside of me.
[Music]
Support for PBS provided by:
PBS Hawaiʻi Presents is a local public television program presented by PBS Hawai'i














