
The threat to academic freedom featuring Todd Wolfson
Clip: 11/3/2026 | 14m 7sVideo has Closed Captions
The threat to academic freedom featuring Todd Wolfson
Steve Adubato speaks with Todd Wolfson, President of the American Association of University Professors, Professor of Media Studies at Rutgers University, and National Vice President of the American Federation of Teachers, about threats to academic freedom and its impact on higher education.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Think Tank with Steve Adubato is a local public television program presented by NJ PBS

The threat to academic freedom featuring Todd Wolfson
Clip: 11/3/2026 | 14m 7sVideo has Closed Captions
Steve Adubato speaks with Todd Wolfson, President of the American Association of University Professors, Professor of Media Studies at Rutgers University, and National Vice President of the American Federation of Teachers, about threats to academic freedom and its impact on higher education.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Think Tank with Steve Adubato
Think Tank with Steve Adubato is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship- Hey everyone, Steve Adubato.
We kick off the program with Todd Wolfson, who's the President of the American Association of University Professors, acronym AAUP.
As a former member, I will disclose that, when I was at Rutgers as a professor early on in my career.
Hey, Todd, tell everyone what the organization is.
We'll put up the website right now.
- Yeah, we're like a 110-year-old organization, even a little bit older than that, founded by John Dewey.
First, it was founded to be a voice for professors in universities as an advocate organization.
And for the first 50 years, that's really what it did.
In the '70s, it started also unionizing faculty in higher education.
And so from that time forward, we started building local unions and giving collective bargaining, fighting for collective bargaining rights like at Rutgers.
And so today, we hold both of those histories.
So one level, we advocate for all faculty.
At another level, we have 60,000 dues paying members across 600 campuses.
100 of those campuses have collective bargaining rights and 500 are just advocacy chapters where they're faculty that don't have collective bargaining rights.
- All right, let's get into this.
- Let's do it.
- Word association.
Okay, Todd?
- All right.
- I say academic freedom, you say?
- Under threat.
- Make the case.
- I'll make the case.
We actually just released a report today about this.
Under the Trump administration 2.0, we have never seen this kind of attack on the academic freedom of faculty in the history of the country, and that's including the McCarthy period.
And so in the McCarthy.
- You're talking about the late Senator Joe McCarthy, there's a communist everywhere.
Why would you connect what's going on now to the Red Scare McCarthy era?
- I'll tell you why, because in that era, the federal government through a series of different committees, including HUAC, and I forget what it stands for.
- It's the House Un-American Activities Committee.
- Yeah, thank you for that, Steve.
Thank you for the assist.
- That's what happens when you're old and you know this crap, but go ahead.
- I'm impressed.
So they dragged over a hundred faculty in front of it during that time and many lost their jobs.
- Are you a communist?
Do you know of a communist?
This isn't that, respectfully, I'm playing devil's advocate, but be serious.
It's not like that.
Todd, it's not that.
- Can I tell you, Steve?
- Please, go ahead.
- The week after Charlie Kirk was assassinated, 50 faculty lost their jobs, which is almost as many as lost their jobs during the red scare with no due process.
- What does that have to do with Charlie Kirk?
- So a faculty member in X state said, "I didn't like him.
"I don't feel bad for him."
And the university would come and fire that tenured faculty for saying something that they said was out of political bounds.
So look, the red scare and the claims around communism look different, but the impact is the same.
And I wanna tell you why I think it's worse than the McCarthy period, because during that period, it was individual faculty members losing their job.
Now the Trump administration is writing demand letters to universities telling them that if they don't change what they teach, who teaches, they will, exactly, they will lose $500 million in federal funding for research on cancer and Alzheimer's and diabetes.
And so in the McCarthy period, it was an attack on individual faculty.
This time around, it's an attack on individual faculty, and it's an attack on universities writ large.
- Todd, more devil's advocate.
- Do it.
- There are millions of Americans, at least a couple million hoping watching right now, who are going you know what?
Universities too far left, a close family friend of ours, our daughter's a couple years away from college, we're looking at colleges.
This close family friend said to my wife, Just make sure she doesn't wanna go to one of those really liberal colleges.
There are millions of Americans who believe that universities, college universities across the board, across the country have leaned too far left.
Too many of the faculty are too far left, are Democrats or progressives or socialists, communists, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
There's not enough balance.
By any reasonable standard, the statistics would bear that out, politically, ideologically.
But why do you say that's not an issue that people should be concerned about?
- Well, all right.
First of all, I represent 60,000 people.
- Got it.
- The majority of the people I represent are dreaming about a black hole or they're trying to figure out how to create a therapy for your mother when she goes to the doctor and has Alzheimer's or they're trying to figure out how to build the best bridge.
They are not political roles.
They are just people trying to train the next generation of nurses, engineers.
- Take them off the table 'cause they're doing God's work, doing important work.
- Well, that's 90% of what we're talking about when we talk about faculty.
- Is it?
- By far, there are more STEM faculty than faculties in American studies, which is one of their favorite hit jobs.
This whole argument about woke-ism and leftist.
- About DEI, about woke-ism.
- All that.
It is a produced argument.
I mean, look, I'll say this.
I will admit this first.
There's maybe a tilt to the left.
Sure.
The more people are educated in any study, the more they vote Democrat, for instance.
- That's like saying people who are smarter wind up voting more Democratic.
- Come one.
- No, but that's a, well, it's a proven fact, and it's written in Project 2025.
You can go look at it, right?
And so what this is really about is about undermining higher education because it's a threat to some political agendas.
- How?
What's the threat?
- What's the threat?
- Yeah.
- Well, every single time you have.
- What's the threat to those who you argue want to financially, I don't wanna use the word I was thinking of, but basically make it clear to universities and to professors that if you advocate certain policies around woke-ism, DEI, et cetera, et cetera, anti-Trump, anti-Charlie Kirk, who was God forbid assassinated, we're gonna use financial wherewithal to stop you.
What are they threatened by?
- They're threatened by an independent institution.
So every time there's regimes that lean authoritarian, I'm not saying that's what they are, but lean in that direction, there is a playbook, and there's three parts of society that always come under threat.
One is the courts, the second is the free press, and the third is a public higher education system.
And the reason why the public higher education system always comes under threat is because it's an independent sector of society that helps develop ideology and is independently able to challenge political positions because people do research on politics, on history, on society.
And so that's threatening to a government that doesn't want to be challenged.
- Go ahead, finish your point, I apologize.
- For the same reason that the press comes under threat.
- Oh yeah, we know.
Those of us in public broadcasting know a little bit about that.
- I know you do, and it's for the same reason, because it's an independent voice that offers a counterbalance to a very strong government at times.
Higher ed is the exact same way.
So the argument that we're woke, DEI, all trying to teach our kids about Marxism is like it's a red herring because what they really wanna do is undermine a system they can't control.
- How difficult is it for faculty members outside of the research you were talking about that's largely scientific, health oriented, medical, et cetera?
How difficult?
I was actually, our daughter was looking at Columbia University in New York, and you couldn't get onto the campus.
The security there is intense.
How difficult is it in this environment to talk and teach about the Middle East, Israel, and Gaza?
- I'm gonna answer that, but I just also wanna just mark how ridiculous some of this is.
I have a faculty member who's an ornithologist.
She's studying the diversity of the bird genome in a species in the Southwest.
Her research was cut because the title had diversity in it.
They keyword search and cut research.
Another research project was cut, they wanted to understand the difference between literacy rates in urban settings and in suburban settings.
And that was coded as DEI research or infant mortality in urban settings versus suburban settings, again, coded as DEI.
And so those research projects were cut.
I wanna flag that.
But to get to your important question - By the way, before you go to the Gaza-Israel thing, we're starting a family foundation, the Adubato Center for Media Leadership as a 5019(c)3 which is a tax code for a nonprofit.
We did all the paperwork, and then we got some word from the IRS.
Yeah, we wanna make sure that you're a nonprofit.
And we're like what?
And we're a media organization.
Nobody's making money.
And I'm not putting our dirty laundry out there.
What I'm telling you is we were like where's that coming from?
Why would the IRS be looking, 'cause the word media is in there, media leadership, media literacy.
I don't know what the rationale is, but odd, to say the least, pick up your point about Gaza and the Middle East and teaching for your professors, your members in this environment.
- Yeah, I will.
Look, it's the most difficult thing I've ever, I've been in higher education since 2001 when I started my PhD.
And so over the last 25 years or so, I have never seen anything like this.
And I'll say, look, it's hard for our Jewish faculty.
It's hard for Israelis who are in this country, but the people who have been suffering the most have been people who are teaching or speaking out on Palestine.
That doesn't mean, and I'm Jewish.
I wanna be really clear.
But when I look at the faculty who are losing their jobs, losing their livelihoods, students who are getting kicked out, for the most part, it's happening to people who are speaking up on Gaza.
And so it's a real problem.
We need to work together to figure out a way to have a higher ed system that can deal with difficult, difficult, heartbreaking issues like the Middle East and move forward and fight through and think through these issues without the kind of outcomes we're having, which is deep, deep distrust, and people losing their jobs, and people being fearful to come to campus because they feel like they're being persecuted.
And so it's a really difficult.
And across the board, but certainly New York City has been one of the places where it's been the hardest.
- Do you believe that's doable?
You believe that, see, I don't wanna go down a rabbit hole here.
You've been talking about the Trump administration.
- Sure.
- And what their policies as you perceive them, right?
- Yes.
- Do you believe that all of a sudden there's a different president, another Republican or a Democrat, but not Donald Trump because he can't serve again last time I checked the Constitution, that this goes away, that academic freedom just comes back in higher ed, and professors, your members don't have to worry about this anymore?
- No, we have a lot of pieces to put back together.
Our biomedical research infrastructure has been really destroyed and there's a lot to rebuild, but also the trust has been really- - You're talking about funding to NIH.
You're talking about all kinds of programs.
- I'm talking about, yeah, cancer labs that were doing critical research that have been shut down and shuttered.
And like that cancer lab may have produced the next critical therapy that would've come to market in 2026, and now won't come to market till 2028, and it might not be in time for your father, brother, sister, mother, friend, neighbor.
So yeah, that's been completely dismantled.
- I can't believe that that's what the Trump administration has wanted through this.
- Well, I don't know either, but sometimes.
- Do you believe it's an unintended consequence?
- Well, have you not seen them bite off their nose to spite their face a few times on a bunch of different types of issues?
So who knows what they're thinking?
It's hard to get inside of such an erratic leadership, but what I can say is that it will have devastating impact to Americans.
- Wow.
Todd Wolfson is the President of the American Association of University Professors.
How many members again?
- 60,000.
- Faculty members.
- And growing.
- And growing, faculty members across the country.
Todd, thank you.
We'll continue, I promise we'll have you back.
There's so much more to talk about, but wish you and your members all the best.
- Thank you, Steve.
Anytime you wanna talk, I'm here.
- You got it.
Stay with us, we'll be right back.
- [Narrator] Think Tank with Steve Adubato is a production of the Caucus Educational Corporation.
Funding has been provided by The Adubato Center for Media Leadership.
New Jersey Sharing Network.
Hackensack Meridian Health.
Community FoodBank of New Jersey.
The Adler Aphasia Center.
PSE&G.
The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey.
NJM Insurance Group.
And by The Fund for New Jersey.
Promotional support provided by NJ.Com.
And by Insider NJ.
- NJM Insurance Group has been serving New Jersey businesses for over a century.
As part of the Garden State, we help companies keep their vehicles on the road, employees on the job and projects on track, working to protect employees from illness and injury, to keep goods and services moving across the state.
We're proud to be part of New Jersey.
NJM, we've got New Jersey covered.
Liver and kidney recipient shares life-saving donation story
Video has Closed Captions
Liver and kidney recipient shares life-saving donation story (12m 21s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Today's top journalists discuss Washington's current political events and public affairs.


New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
New Episode
Support for PBS provided by:
Think Tank with Steve Adubato is a local public television program presented by NJ PBS
