Homegoings: A righteous space for art and race
The woman who won’t age quietly: Meet Karen Arthur
Season 4 Episode 6 | 29m 52sVideo has Closed Captions
A long-overdue conversation about the intersectionality of racism, aging and menopause.
U.K. based Karen Arthur refuses to become invisible as she ages. On the contrary, she's brighter, bolder and more vibrant than ever. And she wants that confidence for other women who are aging — especially Black women. So, as host and founder of the podcast “Menopause Whilst Black” Karen is opening up a long-overdue conversation about the intersectionality of racism, aging and menopause.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Homegoings: A righteous space for art and race is a local public television program presented by Vermont Public
Homegoings: A righteous space for art and race
The woman who won’t age quietly: Meet Karen Arthur
Season 4 Episode 6 | 29m 52sVideo has Closed Captions
U.K. based Karen Arthur refuses to become invisible as she ages. On the contrary, she's brighter, bolder and more vibrant than ever. And she wants that confidence for other women who are aging — especially Black women. So, as host and founder of the podcast “Menopause Whilst Black” Karen is opening up a long-overdue conversation about the intersectionality of racism, aging and menopause.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
How to Watch Homegoings: A righteous space for art and race
Homegoings: A righteous space for art and race is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship-I'm an ex teacher, so I did a -!worksheet, gave them all pens.
-PowerPoint presentation, -and I, you know, ask them a -question, go round, you know, -!and what's the best thing about -!age and what's the worst thing -!about aging?
And what I noticed -!was that all of us had different -!symptoms.
Some had night sweats.
-!I never had night sweats.
Some -had hot flushes.
Some people -didn't have hot flushes.
-Somebody had really aching -joints.
I was fine, but we -started the conversations.
-!Age is a funny thing, or rather, -we are funny about it.
Some -!people straight up lie about how -old they are.
Some people -!whisper about it in rooms where -!only a few others are in earshot -!like it's a dirty little secret.
-But if you're lucky, aging is -something you face the Karen -Arthur way, are you 61 years -old?
Do I have that correct?
-!Oh, 63 baby.
Don't take my years -away.
-UK based, Karen Arthur -wears a lot of hats.
She's a -mother, a school teacher, a -fashion model.
She also hosts -Joy retreats for women.
She's -!written a children's book, and -!through it all, she's never been -in the business of hiding her -age or really anything about -!herself anymore.
And there's one -topic, one touchy topic for a -lot of women and people with -!ovaries that Karen faces pretty -!head on through her work, little -!did everyone know soon you would -!be talking about vaginal dryness -!and hot lashes and night sweats -to the whole world, they have -that to look forward to -learning.
-!Yeah, it's funny.
My mum still -!doesn't know what I do, and it's -fine.
In fact, when I talk to -her about what she calls the -change, -!she just thinks it's funny that -change we're talking about is -!menopause.
I haven't entered my -menopause era yet, but it's -!coming for me soon enough.
And -!friends of mine have described -!it as such a drastic change to -!their bodies that it feels like -!a whole other puberty of sorts.
-!And black friends of mine have -gone as far as to call it the -grand erasure, a time in your -!life when you go from a person -!who already isn't fully seen by -!society, by the medical field, -by the Eurocentric gaze of -!beauty to nearly invisible.
But -!Karen sees it as so much more.
-She sees it as a catalyst for -!deeper conversations about the -ways we generalize and -!experience aging.
So on top of -!everything else, She's the host -of her own podcast called -!menopause.
Whilst black on her -show, she's opening up a long -overdue and frankly often -!ignored conversation about the -intersectionality of racism, -aging and menopause, -!people love to overlook racism.
-!Like when you Google the stress -!there's a stress measurement or -something.
It's like you get -points for if you've moved -!house, or you've had a death in -the family, or you've had a -!divorce, nowhere on that.
Does -it say racism?
Well, -!from Vermont public this is home -!goings, a show that invites you -to eavesdrop on candid -conversations with people who -!will challenge what you think.
-You know, I'm Myra Flynn, and -!today a conversation with Karen -Arthur, a former teacher, -!author, mother, podcaster, and a -woman who is aging loudly as -you'll hear today, there is -nothing invisible about Karen -now, though it wasn't always -that way.
She's overcome -domestic abuse, mental health -!issues and generational cycles -!of trauma to arrive where she is -!today, 63 black in the midst of -!menopause and fabulous.
This is -her journey, and this is -!homegoings.
We're a proud member -of the NPR Network.
Welcome -home.
-Here in the States, we say so -!often as black women, like, oh, -!like, we cannot meet this, like, -!Eurocentric beauty standard.
And -we call it the Eurocentric -beauty standard, but you're -!actually, like, over in Europe, -!just wondering, like, as a black -!woman, like, when did you when -!did you figure out, well, damn, -like I'm beautiful.
-!Oh gosh, there's a lot of layers -to the question.
I've always -!loved fashion, and I've always -loved style, and I've always -!been told I was beautiful, but -!believing it is another thing i.
-!Actually, I didn't really come -!into my own until my early 50s -!and maybe mid 50s, and it's been -!a long journey getting here, I -!would say, because even I'm so -!confident now, whereas before, -my confidence was on the -outside.
So in a sense, -clothing, wearing clothing, -choosing fashionable, stylish -!clothes, form fitting clothes, -you know, power suits, heels, -!all the things, was an outward -representation, but it didn't -touch the sides of how I was -!feeling inside, whereas when I -!had to go down to come up, you -know?
So I it's been a long -!journey.
Yeah, it's been, it's -been a very long journey, and -!it's not been linear.
And in in -the grand scheme of things, -there's an assumption that I, -!I've always been this way, and I -absolutely have not.
-I think about other women who -are in their 60s that I know -!that don't necessarily feel, you -know, as beautiful or as as -visible, and as you as you do -!and and so, yeah, we were going -!to dive into some of that secret -!sauce.
But before we, before we -go there, I'm, curious about -!your life.
I guess I know that -it hasn't always been fashion -shows and story books and you -!know, life by the sea.
So what -happened when your life was -!looking like very conventional -and what was that life like?
-!I was with my ex partner for 20 -years.
Exactly 20 years, -actually, we had to beautify, -have two beautiful children, -!daughters.
We had a nice house -!in in the capital, you know, in -!London, I had a good job.
He had -!a good job.
We had a couple of -!holidays a year, two cars, all -the things, you know, looked -!good, you know, in the pictures, -!but the behind closed doors, it -!was a very different story.
And -I feel that his insecurities -!were taken out on me.
I suppose -it's interesting.
I I've been -!little bit irky, because abuse -is abuse, and I, whilst it -!wasn't physical abuse, the man -never laid hands on me.
The -!other side to that is that kept -me with him for longer than -maybe needed be.
Everything -!happens the way it's supposed to -happen.
I understand all of -!that, but my reasoning was, he -doesn't hit me, and therefore -!everything's okay.
And I didn't -actually own I found it very -difficult to see myself as a -!person who's an abuse survivor, -!and it's a conversation I've had -!with my daughters as well.
You -know that, yeah, I need it -wasn't until I realized, oh, -!that's what was going on, that I -!started to heal, actually, and -started to, you know, took -!myself to therapy and stuff like -!that.
But I dismissed a lot of -stuff because of the outward, -the outward persona of our -!relationship.
We looked great we -you know, if you saw us in a -!restaurant, or you saw us on a -!ski slope or, you know, wherever -we were, we looked like the -!perfect couple, but it was more.
-It was, um, mental abuse.
It -!wasn't even verbal.
I would say -!it was, well, it was verbal in -!the sense that he would put me -down, and I didn't realize he -!was but he would make jokes at -!my expense, bring me right back -!down to earth, and I never felt -!I could celebrate my many gifts -!and talents and strengths, and -it wasn't a friend of mine -described my persona when he -!walked in the room as dimming my -!light just dimmed, and I'm not -about to do that anymore.
-!No, you're not.
There's nothing, -!nothing dim about your light now -you -!we all know that mental health -!doesn't it doesn't go away, it -!doesn't get better on its own.
-!You have to do something about -it.
And so seven years later, -!that came and bit me in the bum.
-You know, literally what -!happened a couple of years after -!we split up, I had a really bad -!toothache, and the toothache, I -!now realize, estrogen, even your -!body, perimenopause, can have a -!detrimental effect on your gum -!health.
Off.
I didn't know this -at the time.
I -didn't even know that either, -right?
It's true.
Look after -!your teeth.
Guys floss.
And I, I -!ended up at the dentist with the -abscess and had a tooth taken -!out and what?
So I had time off -!work, of course.
And then when -!the painkillers started to wear -!off and I was due to go back to -!work.
I was in so much pain, I -!ended up, ending up going to the -!doctors, and the doctor signed -!me off for a week.
So that was -the first time that I thought -something's not quite right.
-!Five years later, it came back -!with full force.
I remember 2014 -!September so that we've all gone -!back to school.
The girls have -!gone to uni.
My eldest is gone -back after a sabbatical.
My -!youngest has started.
I've got -the house to myself now.
-!First time you're on your own in -your home by yourself.
-Yeah, I got, I'm, I think I'm -!gonna love it, you know?
I can -run around naked.
I'll know -!where everything is, all the all -!my clothes will be in the right -place, you know?
And I -absolutely hated it after two -!days, I was like, the house is -really quiet.
I do not like -this.
It's getting colder and -darker, and my boiler breaks.
-And the for the first time I -!have to look at my life, because -!I've got nothing else to do.
You -!know, I get up, I go to work, I -work, I work, I work, I come -!home, I do some more work, I go -to bed, I go up and do it all -!over again.
And I looked at my -life and I was like, I don't -!like this.
If I get run over by -a bus tomorrow, I'm gonna die -unhappy, but I couldn't see a -way out.
-I'm just curious what was -!officially going on, like, how -!do you name it?
Was it a mental -breakdown?
Was it was, -!I call it a breakthrough, but it -!was, you know, on paper, it's a -breakdown.
At that point, I -hadn't I didn't have a -!diagnosis, but I knew something -wasn't quite right.
I wasn't -!given, offered any medication or -anything like that.
I also, I -!also knew that I was having hot -!flushes.
I knew that my periods -!had stopped.
So in the back of -my head, I know something's -!going on with menopause, but I'm -more worried about the fact I -can't do my job.
I've been -!forgetting to go to meetings.
My -!brain is, you know, foggy, and -!the job that I could had always -!been able to do I couldn't do, -you know, so all of those -!things, I wasn't looking after -myself.
I didn't care for the -!way that I looked.
I didn't care -!for I'd lost my creative spark.
-!I stopped sewing, which is huge.
-I was existing.
I was simply -existing.
-!I told people, some people that -!I was going to be interviewing -you, and so many women had -!questions about like, what does -!menopause feel like?
I'm putting -two and two together while -talking to you this breakdown -!breakthrough also had menopause -!written all over it.
And so when -you talk about like the brain -!fog and the depression and the -!lack of Spark and creativity, is -!this some of the stuff and your -teeth?
Is your teeth -!deteriorating?
Is this some of -the stuff that comes with -!perimenopause, with the onset of -menopause.
-!I always say because people ask -!me this a lot.
How do you know -!you're in perimenopause?
How do -!you know it's starting?
All of -my information about my own -perimenopause and menopause -journey is, in retrospect, I -didn't know what was going on -whilst it was happening, -!perimenopause wasn't a word I'd -ever heard of.
I now realize -!that, you know, perimenopause, -!estrogen starts to decline, and -estrogen affects every single -part of your body.
And one of -!the things that's important to -pay attention to is not just -your gum health, but skin -changes, changes in your gut -!health, your periods go berserk.
-!You know, you might be someone -who's always had really light -periods, and then they decide -you can start flooding.
It's, -!it's, you know.
So I always tell -!people, you'll have, you know, a -!six week cycle than a two week -cycle.
This is the thing.
We -don't pay attention enough to -!what is going on with our body.
-So we self medicate.
So we -!think, Oh, it must be, I don't -!know.
We we make things better -!by shopping, drinking, you know, -!but we actually know what needs -to happen.
Just that we don't -we.
We've lost the ability to -trust our intuition and trust -!ourselves, and we have all the -answers in our head, in the -!sense that we know that we need -to go to the doctors, but we -don't have time to go to the -!doctors, because we've got to do -this for somebody else, and -!we've got to do work.
And do you -see what I mean?
So we'd pull -!that stuff off.
So for me, mine -started at 39 and it was the -year before my 40th birthday, -and I thought I was having an -existential crisis.
And -actually, I just felt out of -!sorts, and I thought it was me.
-!In fact, I thought I was being -!ungrateful, because, for what?
-!Because I've got a nice house, -!I've got a car, I've got a good -job, I've got a roof over my -!head.
I don't have to think of, -you know, I've got beautiful -!children, I'm intelligent, I've -!got all the things.
How dare I -!feel out of sorts.
That's how I -felt.
And so I didn't do -anything.
I just, I'm in the -middle of that.
My partner is -!doing what he's doing, and I'm, -!I think it's me.
I need to buy -!some sexy lingerie, and I need -!to spice it up in the bedroom.
-You know, I put it all on me.
-It's exhausting.
I don't know -!how, honestly, I was exhausted -trying to think of that, but -!that's what happened.
And so you -fight that.
You fight that -feeling by working harder, -!taking yourself on a little spa -!break, getting your nails done, -!you know.
But actually what you -need, and what I needed, was -time to re evaluate.
And what -depression did was it lit me -!down, so I didn't have a choice.
-Do you see?
What is it?
Not -here?
You must feel the body -keeps school.
All of those -things hit me at 5152 -wow, you know.
And it was -necessary, -absolutely necessary.
-!Hello and welcome to menopause.
-Was black the podcast.
We are -!the podcast that is committed to -sharing the stories of black -people in any stage of -menopause.
Your -podcast is called menopause -!whilst black.
I'm very curious -!about the black aspect of this -because you know, you scroll -!through your phone to call for -!help and you didn't want to talk -to your mom about going to -therapy or this breakdown, I -!don't know.
I just feel such a -sense of having to keep it -together all the time.
As a -!black woman, I just wonder, is -!there something different going -on for black women with this -onset of menopause, 100% -it's so layered, I don't know -where to start that.
I mean, -when I realized I was going -!through the menopause, I started -!to Google my symptoms.
I don't -recommend that to anybody, -!especially at three o'clock in -the morning when you're -!desperate.
One thing, I noticed -what there were so many so I -thought I was dying.
And -secondly, that I didn't see -anybody who looked like me -!talking about menopause, so all -the people talking about -menopause, or all the images -were of old women, old white -!women.
This is very important, -!with blonde, gray hair in a bob, -slightly longer than mine, -!wearing beige this is important -!with their heads in their hands, -wow.
And so subliminally, I'm -like, oh.
And I've spoken to -black women who said they -thought menopause was a white -!women's disease, because we, and -we, we buy into that.
What's -!that awful phrase, Black don't -!crack, which is just rubbish, I -you know, and that is about -esthetically.
But there's -!something about that phrase that -!is also well, you can't have a -breakdown.
You cannot not be -!strong.
The strong black woman -!trope does not serve us because, -!listen, I was brought up by my -!mother, single mother four kids.
-I'm the oldest of four, and I -!have always been the person who -!does all the things looked after -!the kids.
Went to uni.
I'm a bit -!of a I just do it.
I just get on -!with it, you know.
But I watched -!my mum get on with it, and she -!watched her mum get on with it.
-!So where is the, you know, where -!is the, I don't know, the trope -!that says you can be soft, you -can be easeful, you can -!surrender.
You can let somebody -!else go on there.
And this is a -problem for me these days, -!because I find it really hard to -ask for help.
I.
It's got the -!differences.
I recognize it at -!this point, I'm still at work, -and I'm still trying to get -!better, to go back to work, and -I think that bit's important, -!because I wasn't trying to get -better.
It was all about the -grind.
Yeah, get back to -work, right, right?
Because -!what else am I going to do?
How -!else am I going to look after my -kids like there's no choice -here?
I now know that I'm the -!kind of person if you don't give -me a choice, I come out -!fighting.
You know, if I feel I -!don't have a choice, or if you -!tell me I have to do something -!these days, I'm not going to do -it unless you give me a very -!good reason.
But in those days, -I felt I had no choice, you -know?
So I started in my -!research, and I find out, I read -!the swan report, which says that -!black women in the Global North -!start our menopause 8.5 months -!and up to two years earlier than -!our white counterparts.
And I'm -like, I'm sorry, what -I read that as well.
I was -checking that out ahead of -talking to you, and I had no -idea.
And I'm, yeah, super -!curious.
There seemed to be so -!many theories about why that is, -yeah, -and no one knows, because the -!research hasn't been done.
The -!research for menopause is in its -!infancy, and people still don't -know black women still don't -!know this.
Now my own theories -are around, you know, racial -weathering, the you know, -!allostatic load, and how living -!in a racist, white supremacist -!society has a negative effect on -!our physical outcomes.
All you -have to do is put, put into -!Google or your, you know, chosen -!search engine, black women and -!and what comes up, Alzheimer's, -!mental health outcome, all the -!outcomes ours are worse or black -!people and, and so it incensed -me that, at the same time, I -!didn't start the podcast.
Then, -you know, I started to talk -about it to my black friends, -girlfriends.
I invited them -around to sit in my kitchen -!table and talk about, you know, -menopause, and I'm an ex -!teacher.
So I did a worksheet, -gave -!them all, of course, PowerPoint -presentation, and -I, you know, ask them a -question, go round, you know, -!and what's the best thing about -!age, and what's the worst thing -!about aging?
And what I noticed -!was that all of us had different -!symptoms.
Some had night sweats.
-!I never had night sweats.
Some -had hot flushes.
Some people -didn't have hot flushes.
-Somebody had really aching -joints.
I was fine, you know, -but we started the -!conversations, and I guess that -was the prerequisite for the -podcast.
The podcast came in -2020 when George Floyd was -murdered and Amy Cooper -!weaponized her white tears, I'm -!being threatened by a man in the -ramble.
Please send the cards -immediately.
And that was the -point.
The other point that -!flipped everything on its head -!was like, Oh, well, I can't be -!quiet.
So I did a survey asking -black British women to share -!their experiences in menopause.
-And I remember there was no -!research about that at all.
The -reason so many people, I -!believe, filled in my survey was -that they were thrilled to be -asked.
And that is reflected.
-!It's like no one's asked me this -before.
We are overlooked or -assumed, you know.
And the -research needs to be nuanced, -!because black women, South Asian -women, people from different -parts of the world experience -!menopause in different ways.
And -!you cannot lump us all together, -you know.
And I have to say, -!people love to overlook racism, -!like when you google this, the -stress, there's a stress -!measurement or something.
It's -!like, um, you get points for if -you've moved house, or you've -had a death in the family, or -!you've had a divorce.
Nowhere on -that.
Does it say racism?
-Because that's the overlying -thing.
You know, it's -the biggest stress, it's the -!biggest loss, it's the biggest, -yeah, it's the biggest death.
-Sometimes that can go on -!internally, right?
Absolutely.
-!And this is affecting, you know, -how we are able to live, how -long we are able to live, the -!quality of our life.
It's, it's -!huge.
And so I just felt angry -!and perplexed that people didn't -know -!that the wonderful thing about -!menopause was black.
It provides -a safe.
Base for people black -people who are socialized as -!women, to feel seen and heard, -and I and that's hugely -important, and I caused it.
I -called it menopause whilst -black, because I was going -through menopause.
And I'm -black, and I'm so apologetic -!about that, and I have had white -!women say, Can I listen?
Which I -think is the most stupid -!question ever.
Like, I own the -flipping airwaves, like, calm -down, but the flip that over.
-!What do I ever say to, you know, -!to podcast with two white women?
-Oh, can I listen?
No, -you just because that's the -!standard of everything we listen -to and watch, yeah, -!this is my life, my dear, this -!is my life.
It's so hard being -!fabulous.
Yes, no, yeah, that's, -!that's a strange question.
But -!like, but like, do they listen -white women, yeah, yeah.
-!Why?
They're learning something, -you know, and I think that's -important we, we, yes, it's -important for black people, -!socializes, you know, women, but -it's also important for -!everybody.
Diversity is not this -thing where only one, only a -!certain person, can listen to a -certain thing or do a certain -thing.
You know, diversity -!benefits everyone, which is why -!the political situation we're in -!now, where you are and where I -!am, just feels wild, because the -!short sightedness, you know is, -is it baffles me.
It really -doesn't baffle me.
I know -exactly what's going on.
-Yeah, right, but I see what -you're saying.
Like, you're -!like, Yeah, I think that's the -thing a diverse world, and -especially one where black -people feel safe, who are -!historically treated the worst -!in the world, means everybody's -!being heard, everybody's being -treated better, everybody's -having more opportunity.
This -thing about us starting -menopause earlier and not -knowing why.
Well, I tell you -!what I would like my message to -all women, but particularly -!women of color, black women, is -!we need to look after ourselves -first, earlier.
The reason my -!menopause hit me the way it did -!is because I did not look after -myself.
I did not think I was -worthy.
I put all my energies -into looking after everybody -!else, particularly my children, -when when I split from my -partner, but having the -!opportunity, because that's what -depression was.
That's what -menopause was.
As awful as it -was the opportunity to really -!sit down, sit my backside down, -and get very, very quiet, -everything literally flipped -!upside down.
But I had no choice -!but to go quiet, because, yeah, -!I didn't have a choice.
I didn't -!have a job.
I was fun, employed, -!you know, I didn't love my life.
-!Whatever I'd been doing before -!wasn't working, so I had to flip -everything on its head.
And I -vowed to myself that if I was -!going to live for another 3040, -maybe 50 years that I would -curate my life, doing things -!that I love, and I've stuck to -!that.
And it doesn't mean that -!every day is a, you know, fairy -!tale day.
Far from it.
I still -have to send emails.
I still -!have to cook for myself.
Someone -come cook for me, please.
-!However, my I do the things that -!align with my values.
I go where -!the joy is as much as I can, and -I let go of that feeling of -!scarcity because I lean into a -!feeling of what is for me, will -!not pass me by, and everything -!is temporary.
This what you're -!worrying about now you're going -!to laugh about in a year's time.
-!I hope.
You know, I think, as we -!age, people who are socialized -as women are encouraged to go -!very quiet and become invisible.
-!And we, we lose because we we're -!not seen as conventionally sexy, -or we can't have kids.
People -think that we just need to -!disappear.
You know, don't have -!an opinion.
Well, I'm older and -I'm wiser and I'm louder and -have more knowledge and more -!experience, I am not going to be -quiet.
-!Thanks so much for joining us.
-!If you want to continue to be a -!part of the homegoings family, -!stay in touch@homegoings.co and -subscribe to the homegoings -podcast wherever you listen, -take good care you.
- Arts and Music
How the greatest artworks of all time were born of an era of war, rivalry and bloodshed.
Support for PBS provided by:
Homegoings: A righteous space for art and race is a local public television program presented by Vermont Public